Journal of the Korean Society for Railway (한국철도학회논문집)

The Korean Society for Railway (한국철도학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

A Study of Appropriate Amounts and Applicable Ranges of the Travel Time Values of Goods in Korea

우리나라 화물 시간가치의 적정 크기와 적용 가능 범위 연구

  • Choi, Changho (Department of Logistics and Transportation, Chonnam National University) ;
  • Park, Dongjoo (Department of Transportation, The University of Seoul)
  • Received : 2013.08.12
  • Accepted : 2013.09.30
  • Published : 2013.10.31
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This study assesses the appropriate amounts and applicable ranges of travel time values for freight transport modes in Korea. The findings suggest that it is possible to determine appropriate sizes and applicable ranges of travel time values of goods set for road transport mode (i.e. truck), whereas those for railway, inland waterway, marine, and air transport modes are not as easily estimated. The adequate travel time value for trucks is 20,000won/vehicle hour, and the application range of travel time value of trucks is 17,000~23,000won/vehicle hour considering other variables. The most adequate estimation method of determining the travel time value for road transport is the wage rate method, whereas the marginal rate of substitution method is more rational for railway, inland waterway, marine, and air transport modes considering the application purpose and characteristics of the goods transported.

본 연구는 우리나라에서 화물의 운송수단별로 통행시간가치가 어느 정도 크기로 수렴되는 것이 적정한 지를 평가해보고, 아울러 시간가치를 어느 정도의 범위 안에서 적용하는 것이 합리적인지를 강구하였다. 연구의 결과 화물차를 이용한 도로운송은 적정 시간가치의 크기와 범위의 도출이 가능하나, 철도와 내륙수로 해운, 항공운송 등은 도출에 한계가 있었다. 도로운송 화물의 적정 시간가치 크기는 20,000원/대 시간이며, 가변적 요소까지를 감안하였을 때 적용 가능한 범위의 분포는 17,000~23,000원/대 시간이다. 아울러 시간가치의 산정 방법은 도로운송의 경우 임금율법이 적정하나 철도, 내륙수로, 해운, 항공 운송 등은 적용 목적과 대상 화물의 특성을 반영하여 한계대체율법을 사용하는 방안이 합리적임을 제시하였다.

Keywords

References

  1. K.M. Gwilliam (1997) The Value of Time in Economic Evaluation of Transport Projects: Lessons from Recent Research, The World Bank, Transport No. OT-5.
  2. K. Kawamura (1999) Commercial Vehicle Value of Time and Perceived benefit of Congestion Pricing, Ph.D Dissertation, University of California, Berkeley.
  3. J.G. Lee (1992) Estimation Method of Value of Time in Japan, Transportation Information, Korea Institute of Transportation.
  4. C.H. Choi (1998) Development of the Behavioral Mode Choice Models for Domestic Intercity Road Goods Movement, Ph.D Dissertation, Seoul National University.
  5. C. Winston (1981) A Disaggregate Model of the Demand for Intercity Freight Transportation, Econometrica, 49, pp. 981-1006. https://doi.org/10.2307/1912514
  6. C. Ogwude (1993) The Value of Transit Time in Industrial Freight Transportation in Nigeria, International Journal of Transport Economics, 20(3), pp. 325-331.
  7. S. Bolis, R. Maggi (2003) Logistics Strategy and Transport Service Choice: An Adaptive Stated Preference Experiment, Growth and Change, 34(4), pp. 490-504. https://doi.org/10.1046/j.0017-4815.2003.00232.x
  8. A.S. Fowkes, T. Whiteing (2006) The Value of Freight Travel Time Saving and Reliability Improvements-Recent Evidence from Great Britain, Association for European Transport and Contributors.
  9. C.H. Choi (2002) Value of travel-time savings in metropolitan road freight transportation with freight classification code, Journal of Korean Society of Transportation, 20(7), pp. 167-175.
  10. J.W. Joo, H.K. Ha (2009) Estimating value of time for freight transportation in freight items using logit model, Journal of Korean Society of Transportation, 27(5), pp. 163-168.
  11. A.H. Halse, H. Samstad, M. Killi, S. Flugel (2010) Valuation of transport time and reliability in freight transport, TOI-Report 1083/2010.
  12. Austroid (2003) Economic Evaluation of Road Investment Proposals, Valuing Travel Time Savings for Freight.
  13. C.H. Choi (2002) Value of freight travel-time savings for road investment evaluation, Journal of Korean Society of Transportation, 20(3), pp. 41-52.
  14. KEC (1999) A Study on Economic Feasibility Test for Road, Korea Expressway Corporation.
  15. KDI (2008) A Manual for Preliminary Economic Feasibility Test for Road and Railway (Version 5), Korea Development Institute.
  16. KRIHS (1992) A Study on Economic Feasibility Test for Expressway Construction, Korea Research Institute for Human Settlements.
  17. KOTI (1992a) A Study on Economic Feasibility Test for Urban Expressway Construction of Gwangju Province, The Korea Transport Institute.
  18. KOTI (1992b) A Predictive Study for Traffic Congestion Costs, The Korea Transport Institute.
  19. KRIHS (1996) A Study on the Effectiveness of Road Investment for Logistics Activity, Korea Research Institute for Human Settlements.
  20. Hanyang University (1999) Preliminary Economic Feasibility Test for Mokpo-Gwangyang Expressway.
  21. W.S. Lee (1999) A Study for Socio-economic Effectiveness on the Location of Urban Logistics Facilities, Seoul Development Institute.
  22. KDI (2004) A Manual for Preliminary Economic Feasibility Test for Road and Railway(Version 4), Korea Development Institute.
  23. I.Y. Chung (1999) The effect of road investment on logistics cost in manufacturing industry, Journal of Korean Society of Transportation, 17(1), pp. 41-52.
  24. H.Y Oh (1999) A Study on the Time Value of Freight Transport, Master's Thesis, Hanyang University.
  25. C.H. Choi (2004) A study on estimating the value of travel time of freight transportation for toll roads investment evaluation, The Korea Spatial Planning Review, 43, pp. 109-125.
  26. KST (2006) A Study of Manual on Economic Feasibility Test for Railway Investment, Korea Society of Transportation.
  27. KR (2007) Railway Facility Improvement method for Improving Effectiveness of the Korea Railway Express, Korea Rail Network Authority.
  28. C.H. Choi, S.J. Shin, D.J. Park, H.S. Kim, J.W. Jin (2008) Mode choice characteristics of rail freight transportation, Journal of the Korean Society for Railway, 11(6), pp. 588-595.
  29. W.I. Ha, K.C. Nam (1996) Mode choice models for freight transportation using SP data, Journal of Korean Society of Transportation, 14(1), pp. 81-99.
  30. C.S. Kim, J.Y. Lee, K.H. Jung (2008), A Study on Intercity Freight Mode Choice Modeling, The Korea Transport Institute.
  31. S.B. Jung (2011) Analysis of the effects of transshipment in railway freight transportation, Korean Journal of Logistics, 19(1), pp. 159-168. https://doi.org/10.15735/kls.2011.19.1.008
  32. KEC (1977) A Study on Tolling for Expressway, Korea Expressway Corporation.
  33. C.H. Choi, K.W. Lim (1999) The value of time in intercity freight transportation, Journal of Korean Society of Transportation, 17(5), pp. 43-55.
  34. KOTI (1986) A Study on Improving Method for Freight Transportation System, The Korea Transport Institute.
  35. S.Y. Han (2008) Estimation of value of time by road freight transportation and economic feasibility analysis: using factor cost analysis and contingent Choice Method, Economics Studies, 29(2), pp. 75-107.
  36. McKinsey (1986) Afrekenen met files, McKinsey & Company, Amsterdam.
  37. NEA (1991) Filekosten op het Nederlandse hoofdwegennet in 1990, Report 910072/12515, NEA, Rijswijk.
  38. SMG (2004) California Life-Cycle Benefit/Cost Analysis Model (Cal-B/C): Technical Supplement to User's Guide, System Metrics Group, Inc.
  39. Transek (1990) Godskunders Värderingar, Banverker Rapport 9 1990:2, Transek, Solna.
  40. Transek (1992) Godskunders Transportsmedelsval, VV 1992: 25, Transek, Solna.
  41. A.S. Fowkes, C.A. Nash, G. Tweddle (1991) Investigating the market for inter-modal freight technologies, Transportation Research A, 25(4), pp. 161-172. https://doi.org/10.1016/0191-2607(91)90002-8
  42. HCG (1992) De reistijd-waardering in het goederenvervoer, Rapport Hoofdonderzoek, Report 142-1 for Rijkswaterstaat, Dienst Verkeerskunde, Hague Consulting Group, Rotterdam Transport Centre and NIPO.
  43. S. Widlert, M. Bradley (1992) Preferences for freight services in Sweden.
  44. L. Fridstrom, A. Madslien (1995) Engrosbedrigters valg av transportosning, TOI report 299/1995, Oslo.
  45. Accent and HCG (1995) The value of travel time on UK roads -1994, Final report for the Department of Transport, Accent and Hague Consulting Group , London/The Hague.
  46. M. Fosgerau (1996) Freight traffic on the Storebælt fixed link, Proceedings of the Annual Meeting of the European Transport Forum, PTRC, London.
  47. Fehmarn Belt Traffic Consortium (1999) Fehmarn Belt traffic demand study; Final report, Report for the Danish and German Ministries of Transport, FTC, Copenhagen.
  48. K.A. Small, R.B. Noland, X. Chu, D. Lewis (1999) Valuation of travel time savings and predictability in congested conditions for highway user-cost estimation, Report 431, National Cooperative Highway Research Program, Washington, D.C.
  49. J. Kurri, A. Sirkiä, J. Mikola (2000) Value of time in freight transport, Transportation Research Record, 1725, pp. 26-30.
  50. M. Wigan, N. Rockliffe, T. Thoresen, D. Tsolakes (2000) Valuing Long-Haul and metropolitan freight Travel Time and reliability, Journal of Transportation and Statistics, 3(3), pp.83-89.
  51. G.C. de Jong, C. Vellay, M. Houée (2001) A joint SP/RP model of freight shipments from the region Nord-Pas-de-Calais, Proceedings of the European Transport Conference 2001, Cambridge.
  52. A.S. Fowkes, P.E. Firmin, A.E. Whiteing, G. Tweddle (2001) Freight road user valuations of three different aspects of delay, Proceedings of the European Transport Conference 2001, Cambridge.
  53. Inregia (2001) Tidsvarden och transportkvalitet, Inregia's studie av tidsvärden och transportkvalitet for godstransporter 1999, Background report of SAMPLAN 2001:1, Stockholm.
  54. FHWA (2001) US/Mexico Border Transportation Planning-Truck Transportation, U.S. Department of transportation, Federal Highway Association.
  55. Protrans (2002) The value of time in goods traffic, Achieved at www.transport-research.info.
  56. Rand Europe, SEO and Veldkamp/NIPO (2004) Hoofdonderzoek naar de reistijdwaardering in het goederenvervoer, report for AVV; RAND Europe, Leiden.
  57. G.C. de Jong, RAND Europe and ITS Leeds, S. Bakker and M. Pieters (2004) New Values of Time and Reliability in Freight Transportation in the Netherland, Achieved at www.significance.nl.
  58. B. Smalkoski, D. Levinson (2004) Value of Time for Commercial Vehicle Operators in Minnesota, TRB 2005 Annual meeting CD-Rom.
  59. R, Maggi, R. Rudel (2005) Evaluation of Quality Attributes in the Freight Transport Market: Stated Preference Experiments in Switzerland, 5th Swiss Transport Research Conference, Ascona, March 9-11, Switzerland, pp.52-60.
  60. B. Smalkoski, D. Levinson (2005) Value of time for commercial vehicle operators, Journal of Transportation Research Forum, 44(1), pp. 89-102.
  61. Significance, VU University Amsterdam and John Bate Service (2012) Value of Time and Reliability in Passenger and Freight Transport in the Netherlands, Project 08064 Final Version.
  62. L. Fridstrom, A. Madslien (1994) Own account or hire freight: a stated preference analysis, IATBR, Valle Nevado, Chile.
  63. E. Bergkvist, P. Johannson (1997) Weighted derivative estimation of quintal response models: simulation and applications to choice of truck freight carrier, Working paper, Department of Economics, Umea University.
  64. K. Kawamura (2000) Perceived value of time for truck operators, Transportation Research Record, 1725, pp. 31-36.
  65. E. Bergkvist, L. Westin (2000) Regional valuation of infrastructure and transport attributes in Swedish road freight Working paper, Umea Economic Studies No. 546, Umea University.
  66. E. Bergkvist (2001) Freight transportation: validation of time and forecasting of flows, Umea Economic Studies No. 549, Umea University.
  67. L.F.M. Viera (1992) The value of service in freight transportation, Ph.D Dissertation, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
  68. G. Blauwens, E. van de Voorde (1988) The valuation of time savings in commodity transport, International Journal of Transport Economics, 15, pp. 77-87.
  69. J. Zhang, T. Kawasaki, S. Hanaoka (2010) Freight Transport Value of Time Estimation for Border Crossing Route - Case Study of Tianjin Port-Ulan Bator Route, Achieved at www.old.ide.titech.ac.jp.
  70. P.P. Roberts (1981) The translog shipper cost model, Center for Transportation Studies, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, Cambridge, Massachusetts.
  71. Department for Transport (2004) Economic Assessment of Road Schemes: The COBA Manual.
  72. MLIT (2008) Cost-Benefit Analysis Manual, Ministry of Land, Infrastructure, Transport and Tourism, Japan.
  73. C.H. Choi, D.J. Park (2007) A Comparative Study on Value of Truck Travel Time between Korea and Other Nations, Seoul Studies, 8(4), pp. 89-105.
  74. C.H. Choi (2006) Literature Review and Suggestion of VOT Study on Freight Transportation, Transportation and Logistics Studies, 1(1), pp.127-146.
  75. K.M. Gwilliam (1997) The Value of Time in Economic Evaluation of Transport Projects: Lessons from Recent Research, The World Bank, Transport No. OT-5, January 1997.
  76. M. Wardman (1998) A Review of British Evidence on the Valuations of Time and Service Quality, Draft Final Report, Department of the Environment, Transport and Regions, April 1998.
  77. The World Bank (2005) Transport Notes: Notes on the Economic Evaluation of Transport Projects, Transport Notes No.15.
  78. EUNET (1998) Deliverable D9, Measurement and Valuation of the Impact of Transport Initiatives.
  79. DOT (2012) Revised Departmental Guidance on Valuation of Travel Time in Economic Analysis, U.S. Department of Transportation.
  80. Land Transport New Zealand (2005) Project Evaluation Manual, Vol.1.
  81. FHWA (2002) HERS-ST v2.0, Highway Economic Requirements System-State Version, Technical Report, U.S. Department of transportation, Federal Highway Association.
  82. L. Zanparini and A. Reggiani (2007) Freight Transport and the Value of Travel Time Savings: A meta-analysis of Empirical Studies, Transport Review, 27(5), pp. 621-636. https://doi.org/10.1080/01441640701322834
  83. G.C. de Jong (2000) Value of Freight Travel Time Saving, Handbook of Transport Modeling, edited by D.A. Hensher and K.J. Button, pp. 553-564.
  84. Achieved at www.imf.org.