• 제목/요약/키워드: critique

검색결과 206건 처리시간 0.027초

미셸 푸코와 건축의 근대성(I): - 말과 사물, 말과 건축 - (Michel Foucault and Modern Architecture(I) - Words and Things, Words and Architecture -)

  • 배형민
    • 건축역사연구
    • /
    • 제7권3호
    • /
    • pp.87-105
    • /
    • 1998
  • Surveying the literature of architecture since the nineteenth century, one can identify two dominant but problematic attitudes, among several, that pursue the task of defining what modern architecture is and should be. The first is the search for meaning and the second is the pursuit of form. This study, following Michel Foucault, asserts that the dual formation of meaning and form is a historical product of modernity and belies architecture's uncritical dependence on language since the nineteenth century. This study is a critique and historical analysis of this pernicious reliance, and constitutes a first step towards thinking of alternative relations between 'words and architecture' in the modern world. In reconstructing this problematic, the paper has called on Foucault's seminal The Order of Things. The study follows his construction of the Renaissance, the Classical and the Modern episteme, and in brief fashion, reconstructs the relation between language and architecture in each episteme. In analysing the Modern, the study focuses on Hegel's Lectures on Aesthetics. Hegel placed architecture in a genre hierarchy within which architecture, because of its material basis, was fundamentally limited in its ability to express the Spirit. For Hegel it was, among the arts, poetic language, and beyond art, the language of philosophy, through which the Absolute Spirit could be atttained. Much of post-nineteenth century architecture has remained within the shadow of Hegel, where architecture's materiality is perceived to be a burden, and in order to secure its relevance in modern society, architecture was deemed to pursue the role of language. As the most recent and sophisticated example of architecture's pursuit of form, the paper analyses the work of Peter Eisenman. Though Eisenman's theoretical writings are replete with post-Hegelian rhetoric, his architecture remains dependent upon the model of language, albeit a structuralist one. The paper concludes that ultimately, the pursuit of meaning and form is unable to face the crucial issue of value in modernity. While the former decides to easily what it is, the latter evades the issue itself. The second installment of this ongoing study will pursue a third possibility alluded to by Foucault, where language remains silent, pointing only to its 'ponderous' material existence.

  • PDF

Team 10의 CIAM 탈퇴가 오늘 우리에게 주는 역사적(歷史的) 교훈(敎訓) (The Historical Lesson of the Team 10's Break Away from the CIAM)

  • 이희봉
    • 건축역사연구
    • /
    • 제7권3호
    • /
    • pp.137-149
    • /
    • 1998
  • The purpose of this study is to learn from a lesson of the historical fact, the Team 10's break away from the CIAM, which is selected as the most important event in the whole 20th century architecture by author as a historian. The CIAM, organized in 1928 by leading European architects in order to propose new architecture in the industrial era, expanded to the world, met almost annually with an idea of economic efficiency, new functional order, and industrial production for thirty years. Young architects had conflicted with old established group from 6th congress, and after 10th congress they met independently in 1959; the CIAM was disappeared and the Team 10 was born. Main issue of the break-away was human aspect. The Team 10 started from real man, concept of 'human contact', 'sense of community', and 'belonging' instead of abstract functional order. Although CIAM did not suggest inhumane architecture, their biological criteria with sunlight, air, sufficient site became physical determinism. Critique against the Team 10, unsuccess for making humane architecture leads to underestimation like a generational hegemony struggle. However, architect is not specialist of life but form. Historical reevaluation for Team 10 should be that they are the first group to raise an human issue in architecture. Success or not to solve the problem belongs to another domain. After 1960, modern architecture was attacked from the common people, not clients but 'users'. Academic circle tried to solve the problem with behavioral approach through a clear process, 'design method' and with phenomenological approach on real human experience. However practice became reactionary tendency, to make form a little complex, they became post-modern and deconstruction form. Failure of the Team 10's form proved that a complex form does not necessarily make a good life of people. In the Korean historic situation of colony ruling, confusion of liberation, and the War, we did not know the existence of both CIAM and Team 10. After 1970s' economic development, we have just copied Western form from Modern via Post-Modern to Deconstruction. If we make architecture people mattered, we should start from the basic, learning from the Team's break-away, instead of copying.

  • PDF

데스크톱 다큐멘터리와 데이터베이스 내러티브 (Desktop Documentary & Database Narrative)

  • 차민철;이상훈
    • 문화기술의 융합
    • /
    • 제4권3호
    • /
    • pp.75-86
    • /
    • 2018
  • 데스크톱 다큐멘터리는 카메라로 촬영하는 대신 인터넷 오픈 아카이브에서 검색하고 선택한 멀티미디어 콘텐츠를 재료로 컴퓨터 인터페이스 상에서 그것을 재조합하는 창작자의 멀티태스킹 과정 자체를 스크린 캡쳐 기술을 사용해 녹화하여 완성하는 새로운 다큐멘터리 양식이다. 본 논문에서는 뉴 미디어 환경에서 잠재적 아카이브를 데이터 베이스 내러티브로 전환하고, 영화적 미장센을 컴퓨터 미장인터페이스로 바꾸며, 의식의 흐름을 통한 큐레이션으로서의 창작 메커니즘을 통해 창작과 비평의 경계를 오가는 메타-시네마이자 뉴 미디어 아트의 실험적 시도로서, 주류 호러 영화의 새로운 혼성 장르적 시도로서, 극영화 창작의 새로운 방식으로서, 새로운 모큐멘터리적 시도로서, 그리고 창작과 비평의 경계를 오가는 비디오 에세이와 비평 영화의 새로운 양식으로서 2010년대를 기점으로 부상하고 있는 데스크톱 다큐멘터리의 개념과 유형 및 특성을 연구한다.

인터넷 수용자의 참여방식과 문화적 생산 -<여인천하> 게시판 분석- (How Does the Internet Audience Participate in Cyber Spare and Constitute Cyber Culture?)

  • 주창윤
    • 한국언론정보학보
    • /
    • 제19권
    • /
    • pp.265-294
    • /
    • 2002
  • 이 연구의 목적은 <여인천하> 시청자 게시론 분석을 통해서 인터넷 수용자가 어떻게 사이버 공간에 참여해서 그들만의 사이버 문화공간을 만들어나가는가를 분석하는 데 있다. 인터넷게시판 수용자는 '드라마 공동체의 참여', '평가와 해석적 참여', '개인적 참여', '방송사에 대한 비판', '공동작가의 참여' 방식을 통해서 사이버 공동체를 형성해나가고 있었다. 사이버 공동체는 보편적 의미공유보다 국면적 의미공유를 향하는 의미공동체를 지향하고 있었다. 게시판의 참여자들은 소속감이나 동질감이 약하고, 글쓰기의 즐거움이나 타자와의 커뮤니케이션을 하는 재미 등과 같은 정서적 욕구에 지나치게 기대어 있었다. 동시에 방송사에 대한 비판이나 공동 작가적 참여를 통해서 적극적으로 운영방식이나 프로그램에 참여하고 있었다. 이것은 게시판 공간이 개인적이면서 공적이고 참여적이면서도 소극적인 이중적 사이버 공간이라는 것을 의미한다.

  • PDF

근대화시기 주거공간을 통해 본 아동관과 아동공간의 고찰 - 1920년대~1960년대까지 - (Attitudes toward Children and Spaces for Children During Korea's Modernization Period as Explored through Housing Cultures and Floor Plans : From the 1920s to the 1960s.)

  • 은난순
    • 가정과삶의질연구
    • /
    • 제23권5호
    • /
    • pp.63-77
    • /
    • 2005
  • The purpose of this study was to examine the changes and the characteristics of the attitudes toward children and spaces provided for them. by analyzing people's daily lives in housing spaces and architects' floor plans between the 1920s and the 1960s. Different kinds of data were obtained from a variety of early literature, research reports, newspaper articles, historical documents, and magazines from the period. Findings of this study are as follows: 1. Before modernization in Korea, children had been regarded as immature persons. Confucian ideas of children viewed them as 'small adults' or 'immature adults.' Thus spaces for children's daily lives were neither differentiated from those of the adults' nor deemed important. However, since the Western invasions and colonization by Japan, a remarkable change in the attitudes toward children took place. Children began to be considered a hope for the future as well as members of modem families. In addition, the introduction of the new word, 'eorini (children),' by Mr. Bang Jeonghwan, brought about a significant change in social consciousness of children. 2. The appearance of 'adongshil (children's room)' on architects' floor plans, which was a result of the social critique against androcentrism during the l930s and 1940s, was highly meaningful. The new floor plans not only emphasized rationalization of the space but also upgraded the children's status in the family. 3. Since the liberation (1945), children's space was differentiated from parental spare by the introduction of private rooms and shared spaces. The privacy of each generation was expressed by the division, and the generations were considered equal in this space distribution. In conclusion, the appearance of children's rooms required conflict-laden changes of social ideals and of the family system. It also was a symbol of modernization.

조선조 활자주조 및 문헌간행의 종합적 평가 (Le bilan synthetique de la typagraphie careenne pendant la dynastie de Chason)

  • 이희재
    • 한국문헌정보학회지
    • /
    • 제9권
    • /
    • pp.53-74
    • /
    • 1982
  • On admet Jusqu'ici que le XVe siecle est une $\acute{e}poque$ phare de l'histoire de l'imprimerie avec l'apparition de la typographie en Orient et en Occident, $c'est-\acute{a}-dire$ en $Cor\acute{e}e$ sur le Rhim. Cependant, $l'\acute{e}poque$ de l'invention typographique en $Cor\acute{e}e$ doit $\hat{e}tre$ $devanc\acute{e}e$ encore d'un ou deux siecle. Outre cette question, il est $\acute{a}$ noter ici que les caracteres mobiles $m\acute{e}talliques$ Kyemi, fondus en 1403, ont $jou\acute{e}$ un $r\hat{o}le$ $tr\acute{e}s$ important dans l'histoire de la typographie mondiale et que les $caract\acute{e}res$ kabin qui leur $succ\acute{e}derent$ en 1434 menerent la typographie $cor\acute{e}enne$ a son $apog\acute{e}e$. Or, les recherches $cor\acute{e}ennes$ se satifait de la primaute de l'invention en Coree des caracteres mobiles metalliques, mais n'adoptent pas une attitude suffisament critique. Aussi, l'auteur a-toil voulu s'interroger sur la veritable valeur de la typographie de la dynastie de Choson tant au point de vue de l'histoire de l'imprimerie mondiale. En premier lieu, on etudie, comme une chronique, les caracteres mobiles metalliques importants tout au long de la dynastie de Choson sans donner une interpretation nouvelle. C'est dans deux derniers, qu'on essaie de developper ses idees sur la typographie en Coree notamment la question technologique qui devrait etre le fond des recherches. Aussi, on y etudie, la technique de la typographie ancienne en Coree interpretee selon une methode scientifique et moderne et, enfin, le bilan synthetique en cherchant les raisons qui freinerent son developpement en Coree malgre la performance de ses debuts. A l'issue de ces recherches, on ne peut s'empecher d'eprouver une certaine insatisfaction a cause de l'ambiguite des explications que l'on trouve dans des documents fondamentaux. Avec ce difficulte on a voulu, au moins, exposer des points discutatables qui devraient etre les recherches a futur.

  • PDF

예비교사와 경력교사의 과학 수업 관점 비교 (A Comparison of Viewpoints on the Science Lesson between Pre-service Teachers and Experienced Teachers)

  • 전영석;정하나
    • 한국초등과학교육학회지:초등과학교육
    • /
    • 제36권1호
    • /
    • pp.95-112
    • /
    • 2017
  • The competence of teachers, comes out through their lesson, is one of the key factors of school education. The purpose of this study is comparing the viewpoints on the science lessons in the elementary classrooms between pre-service teachers and highly experienced teachers in order to draw implications on pre-service teacher educating system. The participants of the study are 14 junior students in a university of education and 9 elementary school teachers who are highly educated and have much career experience. Each student participant observed one video clip with science lesson of their classmate. The total number of the video subject to observation is 4. Meanwhile experienced teachers observed 1 or 2 videos which are the same to those the students watched. The participants made a class criticism according to the General Standards for Class Critique made by KICE. The in-depth analysis of the criticism yielded the following conclusions; First, pre-service teachers had narrow views on the science class mainly limited in the practical part of class, but experienced teachers had wide views covered to class-knowledge, plan, and practice. Second, most experienced teachers thought that learning is the process by which students acquire knowledge or concepts by themselves, and the main purpose of the class is to help students' learning. Meanwhile, there were many pre-service teachers who thought that conveying knowledge or concepts to students was the main purpose of the class. Third, experienced teachers thought that a good science class should maintain consistency around the learning goals from the planning, implementation, and evaluation. However, many pre-service teachers did not take the learning objectives so seriously.

근대성과 관련한 Adolf Loos의 사상과 주거건축에 관한 연구 (A Study on Adolf Loos's thought about Modernity and his Works of Houses)

  • 김경호
    • 한국실내디자인학회논문집
    • /
    • 제15권5호
    • /
    • pp.36-43
    • /
    • 2006
  • Architecture is the product of a way of thinking. If the problems of architecture are to be traced to their roots, then attention needs to be focused on the thinking and considerations that inform its production. Adolf Loos occupies a truly exceptional place in the history of architecture. Adolf Loos's ideas and attitudes disagree with the notion that modernity is possible to develop a harmonious culture within the bounds of a modernizing society. Loos chronologically precedes the modern movement, but his ideas contain the seeds of what will be worked out later as a complex critique of the movement's notions about architecture and modernity. Loos holds the view that modernity provokes an inevitable rupture with tradition that has as a consequence the disintegration of one's experience of life. This evolution, he think, obliges architecture to display a number of languages corresponding to a multitude of different experiences. Through the discussion of Loos's opinions on dwelling and architecture, it explores the true features of position of Loos in modern architecture. Loos thinks that the rejection of the deliberate creation of a new style was a correct response to the diagnosis of life as being rootless and fragmented. Ornament is that which people use to attempt to relate different aspects of life and to join inner and outer worlds in a coherent whole. By getting rid of ornament the illusion is destroyed that a harmonious unity of this sort is still possible. One can only remain true to tradition if one acknowledges that its continuity is not an unbroken one. Dwelling can only be saved by separating it from other aspects of life.

알도 반 아이크 건축에서 "사이 영역" 개념에 관한 연구 -1945년부터 1959년 사이의 전후(戰後) CIAM을 중심으로- (A Study on the concept of "In-Between" in Aldo van Eyck's Architecture -Focus on the postwar CIAM, 1945-1959-)

  • 오광석;안웅희;전영훈
    • 한국실내디자인학회논문집
    • /
    • 제17권1호
    • /
    • pp.19-29
    • /
    • 2008
  • The purpose of this study is to reveal that the concept of relation in the postwar CIAM's debate was the hot issue which leaded to the collapse of CIAM, and that Aldo van Eyck developed it into the concept of "in-between". The postwar CIAM's young members voiced a critique of the universalizing attitude toward dwelling that CIAM had pursued since 1928 and looked for a new approach that would take into account the relation around dwelling. So, this study reviews the concepts of relation which were proposed by the postwar CIAM's young members. As a result, it is revealed that Aldo van Eyck extended the concept of "in-between" not to have the polarities, such as inside/outside, close/open, part/whole, neutralize or cancel one another out, but to attune them in such a way that they reinforce each other by mutual contrast, while the other young CIAM's members limited it to transition or connection. And, this paper analyzes the Municipal Orphanage in Amsterdam which was presented in CIAM 10. Through the analysis, it is revealed that the building presents many polarities simultaneously such as those; indoor and out door realms, dynamics and immutability, part and whole, and so on. In conclusion, it is possible to recognize that the concept of "in-between" is the fundamental binary-compound relation that lies at the root of Aldo van Eyck's architectural thought and bears on an interaction on a reciprocal relation between the inhabitant and the built environment.

한국 독립애니메이션의 국제적 평가와 창작 지원정책에 관한 연구 (A Study on International Critique and Creative Support-Policies of Korean Independent Animation)

  • 염동철
    • 만화애니메이션 연구
    • /
    • 통권11호
    • /
    • pp.121-136
    • /
    • 2007
  • 최근, 한국의 독립애니메이션 작품들이 세계로 진출하는 사례가 점차적으로 늘어나고 있으며, 국제 유명 애니메이션 영화제에서 다수의 작품이 그랑프리를 수상함으로서 국내 독립애니메이션의 성장가능성과 경쟁력이 확인되고 있다. 이러한 국내 독립애니메이션이 지속적으로 안정적인 성장과 국제경쟁력의 확보를 위해서는 정부의 정책지원이 확보되어야 한다. 그러나 현재 애니메이션 산업에 대한 정부의 정책지원이 극장용 창작 애니메이션 분야에 투자 편중되거나, 각종 지원정책들이 수립되고 집행되었음에도 불구하고 아직까지는 독립 애니메이션 분야에 대해서는 여전히 자금압박에 시달리는 실정이다. 현 시점에서, 한국 독립애니메이션의 국제적인 위상을 검토하고 정부의 지원정책이 어떻게 진행되고 있으며 어떠한 정책성과를 발생하고 있는지에 대해 논의할 필요가 있다. 그러므로 본 연구는 국내 독립애니메이션의 현황과 국제적 평가를 검토하고, 현재 시행되고 있는 지원정책을 조사 분석하여 한국 독립애니메이션의 육성을 위한 정부차원에서의 정책적 방향을 제시하고자 한다.

  • PDF