A Study of the Physical Properties of Sungnyemun Tile

숭례문 기와의 물리적 특성 연구

  • Chung, Kwang-Yong (Dept. of Conservation Science, The National University of Cultural Heritage)
  • 정광용 (한국전통문화학교 보존과학과)
  • Received : 2010.09.29
  • Accepted : 2010.12.31
  • Published : 2011.02.28

Abstract

The Sungnyemun roofing tiles were twice disassembled for maintenance work, in 1963 and 1997, and modern tiles were applied in 1997. However, besides differing in visual appearance, the modern tiles had distinctly different physical properties. A study has been carried out on 22 different tiles, including original Sungnyemun tiles, modern tiles applied during maintenance, traditional tiles made by tile-makers, and others, to examine their physical properties, such as bending strength, frost resistance, absorption, whole-rock magnetic susceptibility, chromaticity, differential thermal analysis, and other characteristics. Since the method of making modern tiles involves compressing clay in a vacuum, modern tiles showed relatively greater bending strength and specific gravity, while Sungnyemun tiles and those made by tile-makers, in comparison, demonstrated less bending strength and specific gravity owing to their production method of 'treading,' in which clay is mixed by having someone tread upon it repeatedly. Over time, the absorption rate of the original tile used for Sungyemun gradually decreased from 21% to 14.7%; traditional tiles from tile-makers showed absorption rates of 17%, while the absorption rate of modern tiles was just 1%, which is significantly low. As for frost resistance, Sungnyemun tiles and traditional tiles from tile-makers showed cracking and exfoliation after being subjected to testing 4 or 5 times, while slight cracking was seen on the surface for modern tiles after 1ngy, or 3 times. In other words, no significant difference from influence by frost was found. According to the results of differential thermal analysis, the plastic temperature was shown to have been no less than 1, $on^{\circ}C$ for all types of tile, and cristobalite was measuredthrough XRD analysis from a Sungnyemun female tile applied during maintenance in 1963, which appeared to have been plasticized at between $1,200^{\circ}C{\sim}1,300^{\circ}C$. Based on these research results on the physical properties of tiles from the Sungnyemun roof, a fundamental production method for tiles to be applied in the restoration of Sungnyemun has been identified.

Keywords

References

  1. 국립문화재연구소, 숭례문 화재 피해현황 및 수습보고서, 숭례문, 국립문화재연 구소, 2008, pp.13-15
  2. 김왕직.김석순, 기와의 보존과 활용 건축, Vol. 49, No. 12, 대한건축학회, 2005.
  3. 김성구, 옛기와, 대원사, 1992.
  4. 최맹식, 朝鮮時代기와製作, 고궁 건물막새 등 문양조사, 문화재청, 2000.
  5. 양동윤.김주룡.한창균, 고구려 기와의 화학분석과 강도측정을 통한 제작기법 고찰, 고구려연구, Vol. 9, 2000, pp.13-16.
  6. 고민정.김규호, 경기도 포천시 길명리 가마터 출토 흑유자기와 백자에 대한 특성분석, 보존과학회지, Vol. 22, 2008, p.47.
  7. 한민수, 해저인양 고려청자의 산지추정에 관한 과학적 기법연구, 중앙대학교 대학원 박사학위논문, 2006.
  8. 정광용.김명진, 중성자 방사화 분석에 의한 고려후기 기와의 산지 연구, 한국분석과학회, Vol. 14, 2001, pp.476-477.
  9. 김수경, 천안 백석동 고재미골유적 출토 무문토기의 고고과학적 특성 및 재현실험, 공주대학교 대학원 석사논문, 2008, p.22
  10. 장성윤 外3, 공주 단지리 유적 출토 백제 기와의 고고과학적 특성, 보존과학회지22, 2008, pp.15-30.
  11. 김재현, 기와의 기계적 성질에 미치는 미세구조의 영향, 순천대학교 대학원 석사논문, 2000, pp.3-14.
  12. 김성수, 인공풍화실험을 이용한 석재의 공학적 내구성 평가, 석사학위논문, 서울대학교 대학원, 1999.
  13. 송무근, 인공풍화를 이용한 암종별 골재의 물성변화에 관한 평가, 석사학위논문, 서울산업대학교 산업대학원, 2009.
  14. 장성윤 外3, 공주 단지리 유적 출토 백제 기와의 고고과학적 특성, 보존과학회지, 제22호, 2008, pp.15-30.