'Probable Errors' as an EIA Method to Define Project Impact Area - Focusing on the Preparation of 'Howitzer' Fire Training Site -

공산오차를 적용한 환경영향평가 대상지역 설정 기준에 관한 연구 - 곡사화기 사격장 조성사업을 중심으로 -

  • Received : 2007.10.15
  • Accepted : 2007.12.06
  • Published : 2007.12.30

Abstract

In Korea, military authorities have neglected to consider impacts of military projects on local communities and natural environment. Moreover, local communities have had difficulties in dealing with the Ministry of National Defense (MND), which was stubborn enough not to implement environmental assessment on their projects. In this situation, recent case, "EIA of Baekgol Division's Howitzer Fire Training Site" in the Supreme Court-in which judges upheld the Higher Court's decision that the division violated the Environmental Impact Assessment law by ignoring to implement EIA-reveals that military projects can no longer forgo environmental assessment. The decision has serious ramifications on the future of Environmental Impact Assessment in military-led projects. This paper examines the proper scope of EIA in military-led projects and, more specifically, fire training site and searches for how to improve it through 'probable error,' a military training method that is applied to real 'howitzer' fire training. Probable error of the artillery field manual is nothing more than an error that exceeded as often as it is not exceeded and its scientific method was demonstrated through real fire tests in the US. Army. If it is applied to improve assessment methods about the proper scope of EIA in military 'howitzer' fire training site, 'probable error' will improve effect prediction, mitigation and reliability.

Keywords

References

  1. 김구한,2001. 6., 공산오차를 이용한 간접화기 사격효과 향상방안에 관한 연구,배재대학교 석사학위논문
  2. 뉴시스,2006. 7. 3., 환경평가 무시 군사시설 '무효' 대법 첫확정
  3. 대법원,2006. 6. 30., 국방군사시설사업실시계획 승인처분무효확인 선고 2005두14363
  4. 육군본부, 1996. 1. 26., 교참 310-30 표준훈련장
  5. 육군본부,1999. 5. 25., 야전교범 23-40 81밀리박격포(KM187)
  6. 육군본부,2004,야전교범 32-3 포병포술(사격지휘)
  7. 최준규 . 강재구,2006,국방 . 군사시설에 대한 환경영향평가 개선 방향 -군사훈련장 사업을중심으로一,KEI
  8. 한겨레신문,2005. 7. 25. , 군은 골프로 체력단련하나
  9. 한겨레신문,2007. 6. 14., 해병대,박격포탄 오폭사고
  10. 환경부,2006. 7. 5., 환경영향평가제도 혁신포럼 2006 구성 . 운영 최종보고서
  11. 환경영향평가법시핸령,1993. 12. 11., 대통령령 제14018호
  12. U.S. Army and Marine Corp, 1996, FM 6-40 Tactics, Technicues, And Procedures For Field Artillery Manual Cannon Gunnery