Journal of the Health Care and Life Science (보건의료생명과학 논문지)

The Korean Society of Medical Informatics Education (한국의료정보교육협회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Analysis of Research Trends and Measurement Tools for Clinical Practicum Satisfaction : A Study among Nursing Students in South Korea

임상실습만족도에 대한 주요 연구동향 및 측정도구 분석 : 국내 간호대학생 대상으로

  • Su-mi Baek (Dept. of Nursing, Jungwon University) ;
  • Su-jung Park (Dept. of Nursing, Jungwon University) ;
  • Ji-Seon Kim (Dept. of Nursing, Jungwon University) ;
  • Sue-yoen Lee (Dept. of Nursing, Jungwon University)
  • 백수미 (중원대학교 간호학과) ;
  • 박수정 (중원대학교 간호학과) ;
  • 김지선 (중원대학교 간호학과) ;
  • 이수연 (중원대학교 간호학과)
  • Received : 2023.10.20
  • Accepted : 2023.11.20
  • Published : 2023.12.31
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This study examines research trends and measurement tools related to clinical practicum satisfaction among nursing students, with the goal of offering insights for future research directions A search was conducted using combinations of the keywords 'nursing college students,' 'clinical practice satisfaction,' 'practice satisfaction,' and 'practice' from 1985 to 2022 in three domestic databases. After applying selection/exclusion criteria, a final analysis was performed on 91 studies. The papers analyzed in this study consisted of 91 quantitative studies (100%), and 75 studies(82.4%) lacked IRB approval. Furthermore, the research tools used in these studies often lacked reliability and validity verification. Additionally, a significant proportion of the variables related to clinical practice satisfaction focused on individual students, with 35 types associated with individual competency and emotional characteristics. These findings indicate the need for various efforts in nursing professional development to improve students' satisfaction with clinical practice.

본 연구는 국내 간호대학생을 대상으로 임상실습만족도에 대한 주요 연구동향 및 측정도구를 분석함으로써 향후 간호대학생의 임상실습만족도의 연구방향을 제시하기 위해 수행되었다. 국내 데이터베이스에서 1985년부터 2022년까지 학술지에 게재된 논문을 대상으로 '간호대학생', '임상실습만족도', '실습만족도', '임상실습', '실습만족', '실습'의 주제어로 검색하여 선정 및 제외기준에 따라 최종 91편의 논문을 분석하였다. 분석결과 선정된 논문은 양적연구가 91편(100%), IRB 미승인 연구 75편(82.4%), 연구도구는 신뢰도·타당도 검증이 부족하였다. 또한 임상실습만족도 관련 변수는 학생 개인 측면의 변수가 대부분이었으며, 그 중 개인역량·정서적 특성과 관련된 변수가 35종이었다. 향후 간호 전문직 발달 측면에서 학생의 임상실습만족도를 향상하기 위한 제도적, 정책적 노력이 필요하다.

Keywords

References

  1. E. Simpson and M. Courtney, 'Critical thinking in nursing education: Literature review', International journal of nursing practice, Vol.8, no.2, pp.89-98, 2002.
  2. M. Fukada, 'Nursing competency: Definition, structure and development', Yonago acta medica, Vol.61, no.1, pp.001-007, 2018.
  3. Korean Accreditation Board of Nursing Education, 'A manual for universities for the evaluation of nursing education certification in the first and second half of the 2023 school year', 2022.
  4. M. Kachaturoff, M. Caboral-Stevens, M. Gee and V. M. Lan, 'Effects of peer-mentoring on stress and anxiety levels of undergraduate nursing students: An integrative review', Journal of Professional Nursing, Vol.36, no.4, pp.223-228, 2020.
  5. F. A. Ahmed, N. Alrashidi, R. A. Mohamed, A. Asiri, A. A. Ali, K. H. Aly, Khaled, W. G. Nough, N. A. Demerdash, S. A. Marzouk, A. M. Omar, M. M. Marzouk, S. H. Alkalash, S. M. Moursy, D. E. Fadila, S. S. Eldin and A. A. Almowafy, 'Satisfaction and anxiety level during clinical training among nursing students', BMC Nursing, Vol.22, no.1, 2023.
  6. S-J. Shin, Y-R. Tak, R-Y. Song, S-H. Kwon, J-A. Song and J-S. Kim, 'Improvement Strategies for Clinical Nursing Education to Strengthen Clinical Competencies of Nursing Students: A Focus Group Interview Study', Journal of Qualitative Research, Vol.23, no.2, pp.104-116, 2022.
  7. B. Arkan, Y. Ordin and D. Yilmaz, 'Undergraduate nursing students' experience related to their clinical learning environment and factors affecting to their clinical learning process', Nurse Educ Pract, Vol.29, pp.127-132, 2018.
  8. E-H. Gil, 'Affecting Factors on Satisfaction of Clinical Practice in Nursing Students', Korean J Health Commun, Vol.13, no.1, pp.43-51, 2018.
  9. K-H. Yang, S-J. Park and G-Y. Choi, 'Reflection on the Development and Operation of the Nursing Department Curriculum', The Journal of Korean Nursing Research, Vol.5, no.4, pp.69-78, 2021.
  10. H-S. Yu, 'Relationship among Stress of Clinical Practice, Practice Satisfaction and Clinical Competence in Nursing Students', Journal of The Korean Data Analysis Society, Vol.17, no.2, pp.1129-1144, 2015.
  11. M-S. Kim and J-A. Park, 'Effects of incivility experienced nursing student, clinical practice satisfaction, burnout on stress of clinical practice', The Journal of Learner-Centered Curriculum and Instruction, Vol.18, no.10, pp.811-828, 2018.
  12. G-Y. Kim, 'The Convergence Influence of Clinical Performance Ability, Clinical Practice Satisfaction, and Emotional Intelligence on Nursing Professionalism of Nursing Students', Journal of Convergence for Information Technology, Vol.12, no.2, pp.63-71, 2022.
  13. S-G. Kim and E-S Do, 'Affect of Emotional intelligence Caring efficacy and Resilience on Satisfaction on Clinical Practice in Nursing Students', Journal of Korea Academia-Industrial cooperation Society, Vol.20, no.8, pp.231-239, 2019.
  14. D-W. Kwon, H-S. Park and S-H. Y, 'Experiences of Clinical Career Recognition of Nursing Students After Clinical Practice', The Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences 21, Vol.9, no.2, pp.449-462, 2018.
  15. K-J. Cho and H-S. Kang, 'Study on Self-Concept and Satisfaction of Clinical Practice', Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing, Vol.14, no.2, pp.63-74, 1984.
  16. Y-H. Kim, 'Relationship of Self Efficacy, Self-Directedness and Practice Satisfaction to Clinical Practice Education in Nursing Students', Journal of Korean Academy of Fundamentals of Nursing, Vol.16, no.3, pp.307-315, 2009.
  17. W-J. Park and J-Y. Han, 'The Effect of Ego-resilience, Stress Coping Styles, Teaching, Effectiveness, and Family Support on Satisfaction of Clinical Practice in Nursing Students by AMOS Structural Equation Model', The Journal of Korean Academic Society of Nursing Education, Vol.17, no.3, pp.365-375, 2011.
  18. S-H. Jeong and S-H. Park, 'Relationship among Stress, Depression, and Satisfaction to Clinical Practice among Nursing Students', The Korean Journal of Rehabilitation Nursing, Vol.16, no.1, pp.47-54, 2013.
  19. J-Y. Cho and I-H. Chun, 'The Effects of Clinical Practice Stress and Teaching Effectiveness on Clinical Practice Satisfaction of Nursing Students', The Korean Society For Multicultural Health, Vol.9, no.1, pp.29-39, 2019.
  20. M-R. Lee and M-J. Kim, 'The Influences of College Adaptation, Satisfaction of Major and Clinical Practice on Vocational Identity in Nursing Students', Journal of Korea Academia-Industrial cooperation Society, Vol.19, no.6, pp.197-208, 2018.
  21. E-J. Lee, H-J. Kim, E-B. Park, J-W. Park, M-J. Jung and J-H. Jeong, 'The Effect of Clinical Practice Satisfaction, Career Search Efficacy, and Major Satisfaction on Career Preparation Behavior in Nursing Students', The Journal of Learner-Centered Curriculum and Instruction, Vol.18, no.1, pp.263-278, 2018.
  22. Y-S. Seo, C-Y. Jeong and B-H. Kang, 'Influence of Satisfaction with Clinical Practice on Nursing Professionalism of Nursing Students : Influence of Satisfaction with Clinical Practice on Nursing Professionalism of Nursing Students', The Korean Society of Clinical Health Science, Vol.7, no.2, pp.1257-1265, 2019.
  23. D. Moher, A. Liberati, J. Tetzlaff and D. G. Altman, 'Preferred reporting items for systematic reviews and meta-analyses: The PRISMA statement', PLoS Medicine, Vol.6, no.7, 2002.
  24. S-J. Lee, 'Level Satisfaction on Clinical Practice of Baccalaureate Nursing Students', The Journal of Nurses Academic Society, Vol.10, no.2, pp.41-52, 1980.
  25. K-J. Cho and H-S. Kang, 'Study on Self-Concept and Satisfaction of Clinical Practice', Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing, Vol.14, no.2, pp.63-74, 1984.
  26. S-E. Lee, 'A Study on Satisfaction and Experience of Clinical Practice & Direction for Clinical Education', The Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing Education, Vol.7, no.2, pp.333-348, 2001.
  27. S-H. Lee, 'The Effect of Clinical Practice Stress and Satisfaction on Nursing College Students and Their Nursing Professionalism', Chungang University, 2016
  28. S-H. Lee, S-Y. Kim and J-A. Kim, 'Nursing students' image of nurse and satisfaction with clinical practice', Journal of Korean Academy of Nursing Administration, Vol.10, no.2 .pp.219-231, 2004.
  29. D. Fernandez-Garcia , M. C. Gimenez-Espert, P. C. Hernandez and V. J. Prado-Gasco, 'Do organizational variables influence satisfaction with nursing student practices?', Studies in Educational Evaluation, Vol.71, 2021.
  30. I-S. Jeong, Y-R. Um and K-S. Kim, 'Ethical Requirements for the Protection of Human Subjectsin the Publication Guidelines of Nursing Journals', Korean Journal of Medical Ethics, Vol.11, no.1, pp.63-71, 2008.
  31. S-Y. Shin and S-Y. Kwon, 'A Study on the Development and Validity Verification of a Measurement Tool for Educational Satisfaction in University', Journal of Educational Studies, Vol.44, no.3, pp.107-132, 2013.
  32. S-J. Shin, E-B. Yang, E-H. Hwang, K-H. Kim, Y-J. Kim and D-Y. Jung, 'Current Status and Future Direction of Nursing Education for Clinical Practice', Korean Medical Education Review, Vol.19, no.2, pp.76-82, 2017.
  33. S. Lamont, S. Brunero and K. P. Woods, 'Satisfaction with clinical placement-The perspective of nursing students from multiple universities'. Collegian, Vol.22, no.1, pp.125-133, 2015.
  34. M. C. Rodriguez-Garcia, L. Gutierrez-Puertas, G. Granados-Gamez, G. Aguilera-Manrique and V. V. Marquez-Hernandez, 'The connection of the clinical learning environment and supervision of nursing students with student satisfaction and future intention to work in clinical placement hospitals', J Clin Nurs, Vol.30, pp.7-8, 2021.
  35. E. P. Inocian, M. B. Hill, R. F. D. Felicilda-Reynaldo, S. H. Kelly, E. D. Paragas and M. T. Turk, 'Factors in the clinical learning environment that influence caring behaviors of undergraduate nursing students: An integrative review', Nurse Educ Pract, 2022.
  36. D. S. K. Chan, 'Validation of the clinical learning environment inventory', Western Journal of Nursing Research, Vol.25, no.5, pp.519-532, 2003.
  37. K. F. Phillips, Mathew L, Aktan N and Catano L, 'Clinical education and student satisfaction: an integrative literature review', International journal of nursing sciences, Vol.4, no.2, pp.205-213, 2017.
  38. M. Ekstedt, M. Lindblad and A. Lofmark, 'Nursing students' perception of the clinical learning environment and supervision in relation to two different supervision models-a comparative cross-sectional study', BMC nursing, Vol.18, no.1, pp.1-12, 2019.