A Study on Kiosk Satisfaction Level Improvement: Focusing on Kano, Timko, and PCSI Methodology

키오스크 소비자의 만족수준 연구: Kano, Timko, PCSI 방법론을 중심으로

  • Choi, Jaehoon (Kyungpook National University, School of Business Administration) ;
  • Kim, Pansoo (Kyungpook National University, School of Business Administration)
  • Received : 2022.05.09
  • Accepted : 2022.08.17
  • Published : 2022.08.30

Abstract

This study analyzed the degree of influence of measurement and improvement of customer satisfaction level targeting kiosk users. In modern times, due to the development of technology and the improvement of the online environment, the probability that simple labor tasks will disappear after 10 years is close to 90%. Even in domestic research, it is predicted that 'simple labor jobs' will disappear due to the influence of advanced technology with a probability of about 36%. there is. In particular, as the demand for non-face-to-face services increases due to the Corona 19 virus, which is recently spreading globally, the trend of introducing kiosks has accelerated, and the global market will grow to 83.5 billion won in 2021, showing an average annual growth rate of 8.9%. there is. However, due to the unmanned nature of these kiosks, some consumers still have difficulties in using them, and consumers who are not familiar with the use of these technologies have a negative attitude towards service co-producers due to rejection of non-face-to-face services and anxiety about service errors. Lack of understanding leads to role conflicts between sales clerks and consumers, or inequality is being created in terms of service provision and generations accustomed to using technology. In addition, since kiosk is a representative technology-based self-service industry, if the user feels uncomfortable or requires additional labor, the overall service value decreases and the growth of the kiosk industry itself can be suppressed. It is important. Therefore, interviews were conducted on the main points of direct use with actual users centered on display color scheme, text size, device design, device size, internal UI (interface), amount of information, recognition sensor (barcode, NFC, etc.), Display brightness, self-event, and reaction speed items were extracted. Afterwards, using the questionnaire, the Kano model quality attribute classification of each expected evaluation item was carried out, and Timko's customer satisfaction coefficient, which can be calculated with accurate numerical values The PCSI Index analysis was additionally performed to determine the improvement priorities by finally classifying the improvement impact of the kiosk expected evaluation items through research. As a result, the impact of improvement appears in the order of internal UI (interface), text size, recognition sensor (barcode, NFC, etc.), reaction speed, self-event, display brightness, amount of information, device size, device design, and display color scheme. Through this, we intend to contribute to a comprehensive comparison of kiosk-based research in each field and to set the direction for improvement in the venture industry.

본 연구는 키오스크 사용자를 대상으로 소비자 만족 수준 측정 및 개선의 영향력 정도를 분석하였다. 현대에 이르러 기술의 발전과 온라인 환경의 개선으로 인해 단순노동 업무는 10여 년 후 사라질 확률이 90%가 임박한다. 국내 연구에서도 단순 노무 직종'이 약 36%의 확률로 진보된 기술에 영향을 받아 사라질 것으로 예측되며 기업으로서도 인력 구인과 인건비 등의 문제로 인해 점차 무인화를 진행하며 그 대체재로써 키오스크를 선호하고 있다. 특히 최근 전 세계적으로 큰 유행으로 번지고 있는 코로나19 바이러스로 인해 비대면 서비스에 대한 수요가 높아지며 키오스크 도입 경향은 더욱 가속화되어 세계시장에서 2021년 835억 원 규모로 성장하며 연평균 8.9%의 성장세를 보여주고 있다. 하지만, 이러한 키오스크의 무인이라는 특성으로 인해 일부 소비자는 여전히 사용에 어려움을 겪고 있으며 이러한 기술 사용이 익숙지 않은 소비자들을 중심으로 비대면 서비스 자체에 대한 거부감과 서비스 오류에 대한 불안감 등으로 서비스 공동 생산자에 대한 이해가 부족해 점원과 소비자 간의 역할 갈등을 유발하거나 기술 사용이 익숙한 세대와 서비스 제공 측면에서 불평등이 이루어지고 있다. 또한, 키오스크는 대표적인 기술 기반 셀프서비스 산업이기에 사용자가 불편함을 느끼거나 추가적인 노동을 한다고 여기면 전체적인 서비스 가치 하락을 경험하여 키오스크 산업 자체의 성장세를 억제할 수 있다는 점에서 소비자 중심의 키오스크 개선 방향성 연구는 중요하다. 이에 실제 사용자들을 중심으로 직접 사용함에서 중점 사항에 대한 인터뷰를 진행하여 디스플레이 배색, 글자 크기, 기기의 디자인, 기기의 크기, 내부 UI(인터페이스), 정보의 양, 인식 센서(바코드, NFC 등), 디스플레이 밝기, 자체 이벤트, 반응속도 항목을 추출하였다. 이후 설문을 활용하여 각 기대 평가 항목의 Kano 모델 품질 속성 분류를 진행하였으며 최빈값만을 고려하여 차순위의 통계적 의미가 무시된다는 Kano 모델의 단점을 보완하기 위하여 이를 정확한 수치로 계산할 수 있는 Timko의 고객 만족 계수를 활용하였으며 연구를 통해 키오스크 기대 평가 항목들의 개선 영향력을 최종적으로 분별하여 개선 우선순위를 도출하기 위하여 PCSI Index 분석을 추가로 진행하였다. 그 결과 개선의 영향력은 내부 UI(인터페이스), 글자 크기, 인식 센서(바코드, NFC 등), 반응속도, 자체 이벤트, 디스플레이 밝기, 정보의 양, 기기의 크기, 기기의 디자인, 디스플레이 배색 순으로 나타났으며 이를 통해 키오스크 기반 분야별 연구의 종합적인 비교 및 벤처 산업의 개선 방향성 설정에 이바지하고자 한다.

Keywords

References

  1. Frey, C. B., & Osborne, M. A.(2017). The future of employment: How susceptible are jobs to computerisation?. Technological Forecasting and Social Change, 114, 254-280. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2016.08.019
  2. Ha, J. H., & Kim, S. I.(2021). A study on the increase of kiosk user experience in Non-face-to-face Era for the Elderly: Focused on the McDonald Kiosk. Journal of Digital Convergence, 19(8), 285-292. https://doi.org/10.14400/JDC.2021.19.8.285
  3. Han, A. R., & Yeon, M. H.(2010). Discussion for interactive kiosk design in public environment. Proceedings of the International Conference of the Korean Design Society. Korea Design Society.
  4. Herzberg, F.(1968). One more time, how do you motivate employee?. Boston: Harvard Business Review.
  5. Hwang J. Y., Kim C. B., & Park S. M.(2021). Car maintenance service quality evaluation using Kano model and PCSI Index. Management Education Research, 36(5), 1-24.
  6. Jang, H. J., Han, S. G., Jang, J. H., Yoon, H. J., & Lee, M. W.(2017). A study on job indicators for customized employment support 2017. Sejong City: Korea Vocational Competency Development Institute.
  7. Jeong, S. K., & Yang, J. H.(2013). Effects of Perceived Relational Benefit of Kiosk Service Users on Satisfaction and Loyalty: Focusing on the Moderating Effect of Consumer Innovation and Rationality. Marketing Management Research, 18(2), 47-72.
  8. Jeong, Y. J., & Kang, N. J.(2013). A Study on the Classification and Management of Logistics Service Quality Using the Kano Model. Trade Research, 9(1), 195-215.
  9. Jung, J. I., Lee, J. Y., & Han, J. H.(2021). A study of material control quality characteristics using the Kano model and Timko's coefficients. Journal of the Korean Society of Management Engineering, 26(3), 87-91. https://doi.org/10.35373/KMES.26.3.6
  10. Kano, N., Seraku, N., & Takahashi, F.(1984). Attractive quality and must be quality. The Journal of the Japanese Society for Quality Control, 14(2), 39-48.
  11. Kang, J. H.(2018). A study on consumer acceptance intention of restaurant companies' unmanned order payment system: Focusing on chatbots and digital kiosks. Tourism Research Journal, 32(1), 153-168.
  12. Kang, Y. T., & Jung, G. S.(2018). Customer Satisfaction Analysis of Smart Car Features Using the Kano Model: in Control Effect of the Ccomprehension or Experience of Emerging Technologies. Asia-Pacific Journal of Business Venturing and Entrepreneurship, 13(4), 155-168. https://doi.org/10.16972/apjbve.13.4.201808.155
  13. Kim, H. J.(2021). Kiosk Service Failure: An Exploratory Study on Seniors' Struggles with Kiosk Service. Journal of Consumer Studies, 32(4), 135-158 https://doi.org/10.35736/JCS.32.4.6
  14. Kim, H. J., & Hyun, S. H.(2015). A study on the service quality of airport restaurants using the Kano model and Timko's customer satisfaction coefficient. Food Service Management Study, 18(2), 7-26.
  15. Kim, H. S., Lee, M. S., & Park, J. H.(2020). Effect of information system quality of restaurant kiosk on perceived usefulness, ease of use, and attitude of consumers. Journal of the Korean IT Policy Management Association, 12(6), 2127-2138.
  16. Kim, M. K.(2019). The Effect of Kiosk Quality Characteristics of Foodservice Companies on Experience Value, Satisfaction, and Behavioral Intention. Journal of Tourism Research, 33(9), 71-86.
  17. Kim, S. C.(2010). A study on service quality improvement through Kano model and weighted PCSI. Distribution Science Research, 8(4), 17-23.
  18. Kim, Y. J., & Kim, C. H.(2019). A study on the performance measurement of venture companies in the era of the 4th industrial revolution: focusing on the measurement of efficiency of software venture companies. Entrepreneurship and Venture Research, 22(3), 1-12.
  19. Lee, D. M., & Kim, M. J.(2021). Influence of Fast-Food Kiosk Quality on User Intention of Reuse. International Journal of Contents, 21(11), 350-360.
  20. Lim, H. S., Ryu, D. J., & Park, D. H.(2020). Kiosk Industry Analysis: Introduction Effects and Market Prospects. Korea Business Review, 24(1), 21-48.
  21. Lim, S. W., & Park, Y. T.(2010). Potential customer satisfaction improvement index based on Kano model. Journal of Quality Management, 38(2), 248-260.
  22. Maeng, B. K., Park, G. S., & Oh, S. W.(2017). The moderating effect of technology readiness, user characteristics, and situational factors on technology-based self-service usage attitude and intention to use. Journal of Service Management, 18(3), 69-104.
  23. Nam, Y. H., & Kim, W. M.(1998). Analysis of the success potential of venture companies by growth stage: through case studies of technology-intensive venture companies. Entrepreneurship and Venture Research, 1(1), 35-69.
  24. Park, N. G., Lee, S. B., & Jang S. J.(2009). Proposal of new product development process using Kano quality characteristics and Timko customer satisfaction coefficient. Proceedings of the Korean Venture Entrepreneurship Conference. Seoul: Korea Venture Entrepreneurship Association.
  25. Park, S. C., Lee, W. G., Go, J., & Ryu, S. Y.(2020). A study on the identification of shadow labor mechanisms in the digital technology environment. Business Administration Studies, 49(1), 31-50.
  26. Seok, J. H., & Moon, S. H.(2016). Deduction of priorities for service quality improvement in domestic golf courses using Kano model and PCSI index. Management Education Research, 31(1), 233-252.
  27. Shin, J. H., Lee, M. J., & Lee, W. S.(2020). Kiosk design guidelines for the underprivileged: Focusing on cases of fast food restaurants. PROCEEDINGS OF HCI KOREA 2020 Conference Proceedings Proceedings, Korean HCI Society Conference, Gangwon-do: Korean HCI Society.
  28. Song, J. W.(2020). A study on service quality of restaurant kiosk using Kano model: targeting middle-aged and older adults. Hotel and Resort Research, 19(6), 283-304.
  29. Song, Y. S., Jung S. H., & Park, H. S.(2020). A study on the attributes and strategies of courier service quality using the Kano-AHP convergence model. Korean Society of Logistics, 30(6), 37-48. https://doi.org/10.17825/klr.2020.30.6.37
  30. Sung, Y. J., Lee, W. W., Seo G. H., Im, J. S., Jeon, S. W., & Yang, Y. A.(2019). Correlation between cognitive function and ability to use kiosk in the elderly over 65 years of age. Journal of the Korean Society for Aging-Friendly Industry, 11(2), 135-142.
  31. Timko, M.(1993). An experiment in continuous analysis, Center for Quality of Management Journal, 2(4), 17-20.
  32. Woo, C., & Kim, Y. H.(2020). The effect of characteristics and quality of hotel technology-based self-service (TBSS) on customer satisfaction in China: Focusing on the moderating effect of interaction needs. Tourism Research, 45(2), 283-307. https://doi.org/10.32780/KTIDOI.2020.45.2.283
  33. Yoo, M. Y., Kim, H. E., & Kim, S. I.(2014). Evaluating the usability of the kiosk service considering regional characteristics. (G) Korea Digital Design Council, 2014(5), 337-340.