DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

A Study on Qianhuang(錢潢)'s Shanghansuyuanji(傷寒溯源集)

전황(錢潢)의 『상한소원집(傷寒溯源集)』에 대한 고찰(考察)

  • Ahn, Jin-hee (Dept. of Korean Medicine, Graduate School, Kyunghee University) ;
  • Jeong, Chang-hyun (Dept. of Korean Medical Classics, College of Korean Medicine, Kyunghee University) ;
  • Baik, You-sang (Dept. of Korean Medical Classics, College of Korean Medicine, Kyunghee University) ;
  • Jang, Woo-chan (Dept. of Korean Medical Classics, College of Korean Medicine, Kyunghee University)
  • 안진희 (경희대학교 일반대학원 기초한의과학과) ;
  • 정창현 (경희대학교 한의과대학 원전학교실) ;
  • 백유상 (경희대학교 한의과대학 원전학교실) ;
  • 장우창 (경희대학교 한의과대학 원전학교실)
  • Received : 2017.01.31
  • Accepted : 2017.02.16
  • Published : 2017.02.25

Abstract

Objectives : The purpose of this paper is to study the form, contents and special features found in Qianhuang's life, books, his relationship with his disciples and Shanghansuyuanji's edition and its pass-ons. Methods : The best version among Shanghansuyuanji's copies was selected. Based on this, Qianhuang's life, books and his relationship with his disciples were studied, and Shanghansuyuanji's edition and its pass-ons, form and contents were analyzed. Results & Conclusions: Through study, first I see that Qianhuang was born in the early period of Qing Dynasty and died after the publication of Shanghansuyuanji, Suwen's annotation book probably had not been published yet, his mentor were Fangyouzhi and Yujiayan. Second, I see that he organized Shanghanlun sentences from his own perspective of cause of a disease and cure method. Third, I see that he viewed the diseases of six meridians with the perspective of yinyang and explained the concept of three yins and three yangs in relation to yinyang's ups and downs, and his Yuggyeongjasu theory made possible various interpretations of disease mechanism. Fourth, I see that he held critical views towards the Shanghanlun sentences through the Error Discrimination. Fifth, I see that he viewed disease mechaniam in interdependent relationships or from the point of view of the School of Warming and Tonifying through the Meaning of Herbal Formula. Sixth, I see that he sometimes quoted Neijing in proper ways that fit the disease mechanism in Shanghanlun. On the other hand, he quoted Neijing solely for the reason that identical words are used, but some of these were not proper. Additionally, he criticized the aforementioned annotators for improper quoting Neijing. Consequentially, for reasons mentioned above Qianhuang's Shanghansuyuanji has great importance as a Shanghanlun annotation book.

Keywords

References

  1. Qian H. Shanghansuyuanji. Shanghai. Shanghaiweishengchubanshe. 1957. 錢潢 著. 傷寒溯源集. 上海. 上海衛生出版社. 1957.
  2. Qian H. Zhou XB, Chen JW annot.. Shanghansuyuanji. Beijing. Xueyuanchubanshe. 2009. 錢潢 著. 周憲賓, 陳居偉 校注. 傷寒溯源集. 北京. 學苑出版社. 2009.
  3. Xuxiusikuquanshu Bianzuanweiyuanhui ed., Gu TL chiefly ed.. Chongbianzhangzhongjing shanghanlunzhengzhifamingsuyuanji (Xuxiusikuquanshu v.986.). Shanghai. Shanghaigujichubanshe. 2002. 顧廷龍 主编. 重編張仲景傷寒論證治發明溯源 集(續修四庫全書 v.986.). 上海. 上海古籍出版 社. 2002.
  4. Xuxiusikuquanshu Bianzuanweiyuanhui ed., Gu TL chiefly ed.. Chongbianzhangzhongjing shanghanlunzhengzhifamingsuyuanji (Xuxiusikuquanshu v.987.). Shanghai. Shanghaigujichubanshe. 2002. 顧廷龍 主编. 重編張仲景傷寒論證治發明溯源集(續修四庫全書 v.987.). 上海. 上海古籍出版社. 2002.
  5. Chen DS, Ceng Y, Huang ZD ed.. Maeng UJ, et al. trans.. Theories of Different Schools. Seoul. Daesung Publishing Company. 2001. 陳大舜, 曾勇, 黃政德 編. 孟雄在 외 9人 譯. 各家學說. 서울. 대성의학사. 2001.
  6. Yin CL ed. and trans.. Theories of Different Schools of Korean and Chinese Medicine. Daejeon. Jumin. 2006. 尹暢烈 編譯. 韓中醫學各家學說. 대전. 주민출판사. 2006.
  7. Yin XM. ShanghanWenbing Brief History. Daejeon. Jumin. 2007. 殷晳玟 著. 傷寒溫病學史略. 대전. 주민출판사. 2007.
  8. Wang Q ed.. Shanghanlunyanjiu. Guangzhou. Guangdonggaodengjiaoyuchubanshe. 1988. 王琦 主編. 傷寒論硏究. 廣州. 廣東高等敎育出版社. 1988.
  9. Zhongguoyijidacidian Bianzuanweiyuanhui ed.. Zhongguoyijidacidian. Shanghai. Shanghaikexuejishuchubanshe. 2002. 中國醫籍大辭典 編纂委員會 編. 中國醫籍大辭典. 上海. 上海科學技術出版社. 2002.
  10. Yan SY ed.. Zhongguoyijitongkao. Shanghai. Shanghaizhongyixueyuanchubanshe. 1992. 嚴世芸 主編. 中國醫籍通考. 上海. 上海中醫學院出版社. 1992.
  11. Hong WS. Jeonggyohwangjenaegyeong somun. Seoul. Publisher of Institute of Oriental Medicine. 1985. 洪元植. 精校黃帝內經素問. 서울. 東洋醫學硏究院出版部. 1985.
  12. Liu A original work. Gao Y annot.. Huainanzizhu(Zhuzijicheng 7). Shanghai. Shanghaishudianchubanshe. 1986. 劉安 著, 高誘 注. 淮南子 注(諸子集成 7). 上海. 上海書店出版社. 1986.
  13. Zhang ZJ. Zhujieshanghanlun. Beijing. People's Medical Publishing House. 1994. 張仲景 著. 注解傷寒論. 北京. 人民衛生出版社. 1994.
  14. Fang YZ ed.. Chen JW annot.. Shanghanluntiaobian. Beijing. Xueyuanchubanshe. 2009. 方有執 編著. 陳居偉 校注. 傷寒論條辨. 北京. 學苑出版社. 2009.
  15. Shen MN. Assessment of Academic Thought of Shanghansuyuanji. Zhongyizazhi. 1981. 11. 沈敏南. 試評 傷寒溯源集 的學術思想. 中醫雜誌. 1981. 11.
  16. Xie ZL, et al.. Debate on Shanghansuyuanji Several Problem. Zhongyixuebao. 2014. 29(191). 謝忠禮 外 4人. 傷寒溯源集 若干問題探討. 中醫學報. 2014. 29(191).
  17. Wan XG. A Brief History of Shanghan Academic Development. Guangzhou zhongyiyaodaxue. Doctoral dissertation. 2001. 萬曉剛. 傷寒學術發展史略. 廣州中醫藥大學博士學位論文. 2001.
  18. Ma JJ. Discuss Yushan school in Ming and Qing Dynasty. Zhongguozhongyijichuyixuezazhi. 2015. 21(11). 馬俊杰. 論明清時期虞山醫派. 中國中醫基礎醫學雜誌. 2015. 21(11).
  19. Huang YJ. A Stydy on School of doctors in Wumen. Master's thesis in Nanjingzhongyiyaodaxue. 2012. 黃亞俊. 吳門醫家學術流派硏究. 南京中醫藥大學 碩士學位論文. 2012.
  20. Kim IS. Review of literatures on Chuan Bian of 6-Jing disease. Master's thesis in Graduate School of Kyunghee University. 1992. 金仁碩. 六經病의 傳變에 關한 文獻的 연구. 慶熙大學校大學院 碩士學位論文. 1992.
  21. Qian H. Chongbianzhangzhongjing shanghanlunzhengzhifamingsuyuanji. Kyoto. 1803. [cited 2017 Jan 15] Available from: URL: https://www.library.pref.osaka.jp/licsxp-opac/WOpacTifTilListToTifTilDetailAction.do?urlNotFlag=1 錢潢. 重編張仲景傷寒論證治發明溯源集. 京都. 1803. 大阪府立図書館 검색.