KDI Journal of Economic Policy

Korea Development Institute (한국개발연구원)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Treasury Stock Sales and Management Rights Protection: Conflicts of Interest between an Owner-manager and Small Shareholders

  • Received : 2017.06.16
  • Published : 2017.08.31
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This paper investigates the sales process of treasury stocks, while most previous research studies treasury stock repurchases. The sales of treasury stocks are an important measure to protect management rights only in Korea, as Korea's laws and systems allow treasury stock sales according to the board's resolution and not by the decisions made at the general shareholders' meetings. The board's resolution, which considers the owner-manager's interest on management rights, can cause damages to small shareholders. Considering (i) the economic characteristics of treasury stocks, (ii) other countries' institutions and experiences, (iii) a theoretical assessment of the possibility of small shareholder losses, and (iv) lessons from Korea's actual instances, Korea's present system should be corrected at least in the mid and long term. Even in the short-term, rules pertaining to sales enacted by the board's resolution inducing small shareholder losses should be overhauled. The autonomous discipline by various stakeholders could be an ideal measure by which to monitor ownermanager's decisions. In addition, temporary intervention measures, such as government examinations, could be implemented to protect small shareholders.

Keywords

References

  1. An, Sung Po. 2011. "The Legal Issues in Accordance with Accepted Acquisition of Treasury Stock." Commercial Law Review 30 (2): 73-104 (in Korean).
  2. Bagnoli, Mark, Roger Gordon, and Barton L. Lipman. 1989. "Stock Repurchase as a Takeover Defense." Review of Financial Studies 2 (3): 423-443. https://doi.org/10.1093/rfs/2.3.423
  3. Bajaj, Mukesh and Anand M. Vijh. 1990. "Dividend Clienteles and the Information Content of Dividend Changes." Journal of Financial Economics 26 (2): 193-219. https://doi.org/10.1016/0304-405X(90)90003-I
  4. Byun, Jin Ho and Min Kyo Pyo. 2006. "Majority Shareholders Selling Behavior after the Repurchasing Announcement: Signaling or Managerial Opportunism?" Korean Management Review 35 (3): 695-716 (in Korean).
  5. Comment, Robert and Gregg A. Jarrell. 1991. "The Relative Signaling Power of Dutch-auction and Fixed-price Self Tender Offers and Open-market Share Repurchases." Journal of Finance 46 (4): 1243-1271. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1991.tb04617.x
  6. Chae, Dong-Heon. 2007. "Legal Validity in the Case that the Dominant Stockholder Takes His Company's Treasury Shares to Protect His Management Right." KLCA Monthly Journal August Issue: 126-140 (in Korean).
  7. Cho, Sung Ick. 2017. "The Sale of Treasury Stocks and Protection of Management Rights." KDI Focus 82.
  8. Cho, Sung Ick and Yong Hyeon Yang. 2016. A New Discipline for the Inter-Corporate Shareholding. KDI Research Monograph 2016-05 (in Korean).
  9. Choi, Junesun. 2016. "Should the Treasury Stock Disposal Be Regulated?" KERI Column 2016-07-15 (in Korean).
  10. Chung, Chan-Hyung. 2015. "Legal Problems in Connection with Acquisition, Disposal and Amortization of its Own Shares by a Company under 2011 Revised Korean Commercial Code." Review of Law and Firms 5 (2): 3-32 (in Korean).
  11. Dittmar, Amy K. 2000. "Why Do Firms Repurchase Stock?" Journal of Business 73 (3): 331-355. https://doi.org/10.1086/209646
  12. Do, Jae-Moon. 2006. "A Comparative Study on the Reacquisition-restriction of its own Shares of a Corporation." Journal of Business Administration & Law 16: 129-163 (in Korean).
  13. Fried, Jesse M. 2001. "Open Market Repurchases: Signalling or Managerial Opportunism?" Theoretical Inquiries in Law 2 (2): 865-894.
  14. Harris, Milton and Artur Raviv. 1988. "Corporate Control Contests and Capital Structure." Journal of Financial Economics 20: 55-86. https://doi.org/10.1016/0304-405X(88)90040-2
  15. Jensen, Michael C. 1986. "Agency Costs of Free Cash Flow, Corporate Finance, and Takeovers." American Economic Review 76 (2): 323-329.
  16. Jung, Sung Chang and Young Hwan Kim. 2013. "Anti-takeover Provisions and Stock Repurchases in Korea." Korean Management Review 42 (3): 767-803 (in Korean).
  17. Kim, Seon Gu, Jin Hwa Cha, and Jae Gwon Jeong. 2012. "A Study on the Factor of Making a Decision of Purchasing Our Company Stocks." Journal of Business Education 26 (2): 219-243 (in Korean).
  18. Kim, Soon-Suk. 2006. "Corporate Dividend and Stock Repurchase in the United States." Journal of Comparative Private Law 13 (2): 251-283 (in Korean).
  19. Kim, Soon-Suk. 2010. "Stock Repurchase and Cancellation of Shares under 2008 Revision Draft to the Korean Commercial Code." Ilkam Law Review 18: 135-190 (in Korean).
  20. Kim, Woojin and Jieun Lim. 2017. "An Empirical Study on Resale and Retirement of Treasury Shares: Evidence from Korea." Korean Journal of Financial Studies 46 (1): 35-60 (in Korean). https://doi.org/10.26845/KJFS.2017.02.46.1.35
  21. Lee, Chul Song. 2006. "The Legal Effects of the Unfair Transaction of a Company's its Own Shares." Korean Journal of Securities Law 7 (2): 1-25 (in Korean).
  22. Lee, Chul Song. 2016. "Legal Terminologies for Repurchased Stocks II: Debates on the Fairness of Sales of Treasury Stocks." Shin & Kim Legal Update (in Korean).
  23. Lee, Ik-Gyu and Sang-Lyong Joo. 2005. "Studies on Repurchase Motives." Korean Journal of Financial Studies 11 (1): 243-273 (in Korean).
  24. Lee, Ik-Gyu and Han-Soo Lee. 2006. "The Korean Firms' Stock Repurchase Motives." Korean Journal of Accounting Research 11 (1): 187-208 (in Korean).
  25. Lim, Youngjae and Sung In Jun. 2009. Circular Shareholdings in Large Business Groups: The Roles of Market and Authoritative Disciplines. KDI Policy Study Series 2009-01 (in Korean).
  26. Masulis, Ronald W. 1980. "Stock Repurchase by Tender Offer: An Analysis of the Causes of Common Stock Price Changes." Journal of Finance 35 (2): 305-319. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1980.tb02159.x
  27. Nohel, Tom and Vefa Tarhan. 1998. "Share Repurchases and Firm Performance: New Evidence on the Agency Costs of Free Cash Flow." Journal of Financial Economics 49 (2): 187-222. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0304-405X(98)00022-1
  28. Ofer, Aharon R. and Anjan V. Thakor. 1987. "A Theory of Stock Price Responses to Alternative Corporate Cash Disbursement Methods: Stock Repurchases and Dividends." Journal of Finance 42 (2): 365-394. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1540-6261.1987.tb02572.x
  29. Shin, Min-Sik and Soo-Eun Kim. 2010. "The Relationship between Ownership Structure and Stock Repurchase of Firms." Korean Journal of Business Administration 23 (2): 649-673 (in Korean).
  30. Song, Ok-Rial. 2014. "Economic Analysis of Share Buybacks." Korean Journal of Law and Economics 11 (1): 53-72 (in Korean).
  31. Stulz, Rene M. 1998. "Managerial Control of Voting Rights: Financial Policies and the Market for Corporate Control." Journal of Financial Economics 20: 25-54.
  32. Wang, Jeo Ya, Joon Hyup Song, and Jin S. Kim. 2014. "The Effect of Stock Repurchases on Ownership Concentration." Paper Collections for Spring Conference of Korea Association of Business Education 1-16 (in Korean).
  33. Yang, Yong Hyeon and Sung Ick Cho. 2014. "Policy Objectives on Circular Ownership Structure." In Corporate Governance of Large Business Groups: Empirical Assessments and Policy Implications, edited by Wonhyuk Lim, Chapter 4. KDI Research Monograph 2014-09 (in Korean).
  34. Yoo, Jinsoo. 2014. "Spin-off into a Holding Company, Stock Share and Stock Price." Korean Journal of Industrial Organization 22 (2): 73-95 (in Korean).
  35. Yoon, Seong Min, Joung Hee Kim, and Mi Jung Lee. 2004. "Motives for Stock Repurchases." Review of Social & Economic Studies 23: 85-120 (in Korean).
  36. Yoon, Seung-Young. 2015a. "Dispute on Management Rights and Designated Sales of Treasury Shares." CGS Report 5 (5): 2-5 (in Korean).
  37. Yoon, Seung-Young. 2015b. "Handling Treasury Shares in Equity Spinoff." CGS Report 5 (6): 2-4 (in Korean).
  38. Youn, Taehoon. 2005. "Analysis on Protection of Management Rights and Possession of Treasury Stocks." In Studies on Management Rights, edited by Taehoon Youn, Chapter 7 (in Korean).