Abstract
To minimize CT examination for Hip FAI diagnosis and operation plan. also, whether the MRI 3D images can replace Hip Clock face image was evaluated when performing Hip FAI MRI by using additional 3D image. This study analyzed Hip MRI and 3D Hip CT images of 31 patients in this hospital. For the purpose of evaluating the images, one orthopedic surgeon and one radiology specialist reconstructed Clock face, at MR and CT modality, by superior 12 o'clock, labrum front 3 o'clock, and the other side 9 o'clock, centering on Hip joint articular transverse ligament 6 o'clock. Afterwards, by the Likert Scale 5 point scale (independent t-test p<0.005), this study evaluated the check-up of A. retinacular vessel, B. head neck junction at 11 o'clock, A. Epiphyseal line, B. Cam lesion at 12 o'clock, and Cam lesion, Posterior Cam lesion at 1,2,3 and 4 o'clock. As for the verification of reliability among observers, this study verified coincidence by Cohen's weighted Kappa verification. As a result of Likert scale for the purpose of qualitative evaluation about the image, 11 o'clock A. retinacular vessel MR average was $3.69{\pm}1.0$ and CT average was $2.8{\pm}0.78$. B. head neck juncton didn't have a difference between two observers (p <0.416). 12 o'clock A. Epiphyseal line MR average was $3.54{\pm}1.00$ and CT average was $4.5{\pm}0.62$(p<0.000). B. Cam lesion didn't have a difference between two observers (p <0.532). 1,2,3,4 Cam lesion and Posterior Cam lesion were not statistically significant (p <0.656, p <0.658). As a result of weighted Kappa verification, 11 o'clock A.retinacular vessel CT K value was 0.663 and the lowest conformity. As a result of coincidence evaluation on respective item, a very high result was drawn, and two observers showed high reliability.
Hip FAI 진단과 수술 계획 시 Hip FAI MRI 검사시 3D 영상을 추가로 활용하여 CT 영상으로 이루어지는 Hip Clock face 영상을 MRI 3D 영상으로 대체할 수 있는지 비교 평가 하였다. Hip 자기공명 영상검사(MRI)와 3D Hip 컴퓨터 단층 촬영(CT)을 동시 시행한 환자 31명 (남: 21명 평균연령: 35세 여: 10명 평균연령: 40.3세)을 대상으로 분석하였으며, 영상평가는 정형외과 전문의 1명과 영상의학과 전문의 1명이 MR과 CT modality에서 Hip joint articular transverse ligament의 6 o'clock을 중심으로 Superior을 12 o'clock, Labrum의 전면을 3 o'clock, 반대쪽을 9 o'clock로 기술하는 Clock face을 재구성 한 후 11 o'clock에서 A. retinacular vessel, B. head neck junction, 12 o'clock A. Epiphyseal line, B. Cam lesion, 1,2,3,4 o'clock의 Cam lesion, Posterior Cam lesion확인 여부를 리커트(Likert scale) 5점 척도로 평가하였다(Independent t-test p<0.05). 리커드 척도 결과 11 o'clock A. retinacular vessel MR 평균 값 $3.69{\pm}1.0$, CT 평균값 $2.8{\pm}0.78$이며 통계적으로 유의하였다(p<0.001). B. head neck junction은 두 평가자간 차이가 없었다(p<0.416). 12 o'clock A. Epiphyseal line MR 평균값 $3.54{\pm}1.00$, CT 평균값 $4.5{\pm}0.62$이었다(p<0.000). B. Cam lesion은 두 평가자간 차이가 없었다(p<0.532). 1,2,3,4 o'clock 의 Cam lesion과 Posterior Cam lesion은 통계적으로 유의하지 않았다(p<0.656, p<0.658). weighted Kappa 검증 결과 11 o'clock A.retinacular vessel CT K값이 0.663으로 가장 낮은 일치도였으며, 각각의 평가 항목의 일치도 평가 결과 매우 높은 결과로 두 평가자간 높은 신뢰도를 보여주었다.
