DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Correlative Comparison of the Basilica Church of Europe with the Buddhist Chaitya Cave of India

서양 중세 바실리카 교회와 인도 불교 석굴 차이탸와의 연관성 비교 고찰

  • Received : 2012.10.04
  • Published : 2012.12.25

Abstract

This paper demonstrates the Christian basilica church of Europe is remarkably similar with the Buddhist cave chaitya of India: longitudinal access of rectangular plan, semicircular apse at the deepest sanctuary end, high nave and low aisle divided by two rows of columns, and rib arch vault ceiling, etc. Although architectural history of the East and the West has been studied independently and separatedly, the paper suggests a possibility that the similarity between two forms is not coincidence but results from influence of the Indian Buddhist cave to the church basilica. The Indian Buddhist caves of basilica type had already been developed for five hundred years when the Christian church basilica were built officially after permission by Emperor Constantinus in A.D.313. Western architecture historians were not successful in tracing an origin of the Christian church basilica as a firm architectural type from the Roman basilica, for the Roman basilica has diverse forms of which original meaning is covered hall with colonnade aisle adjacent to forum. This paper suggests that the Christian church basilica is more similar with pagan religious temple of the Neopithagoras and the Mithras from archeological excavation than the Roman basilica by producing evidence of relation between two the Western pagan religions and the Indian religion.

Keywords

References

  1. Rapson, Edward J. ed. Ancient India, The Cambridge History of India, vol. 1. Cambridge, 1922
  2. Brown, Percy. Indian Architecture, Buddhist and Hindu. Taraporevala. 1942/1971.
  3. Fletcher, Banister. A History of Architecture. Butterworth. 1896/1987
  4. Vitruvius. The Ten Books on Architecture. Dover. 1960
  5. Brown, Baldwin. From Schola to Cathedral- Early Christian Architecture and Its Relation to the Life of the Church, 1886.
  6. Reber, von Franz. History of Mediaeval Art. Harper & Bros. 1897
  7. Pevsner, Nikolaus. An Outline of European Architecture. Pelican. 1962
  8. Soma Thera. The Contribution of Buddhism to World Culture. Buddhist Pub. 2012
  9. Kahn, Ashiraf. Gandara. Ashiq Hussein Chaudhry. 2006
  10. Kostoff, Spiro. A History of Architecture. Oxford, 1985
  11. 이희봉, 인도 불교 석굴사원의 시원과 전개 , 건축역사연구 , 2008.08.
  12. 이희봉, 탑의 원조 인도 스투파 형태 해석 , 건축역사연구 2009.12
  13. 이희봉, 동양/서양의 이분대립으로 본 건축 논문에 대한 반증 , 건축역사연구 2007.10
  14. Mead, G.R.S. "Appolonius of Tyana" The Gnostic Society Library, www.gnosis.org/library.
  15. ko.wikipedia.or.kr "Mithraic Mysteries".
  16. ko.wikipedia.or.kr "신피타고라스학파"
  17. www.newadvant.org. "Mithraism" in Catholic Encyclopedia.
  18. Argan, Gillo Carlo. "On the Typology of Architecture" Architectural Design, 1963, 12