대한지리학회지 (Journal of the Korean Geographical Society)

대한지리학회 (The Korean Geographical Society)
권호 표지

사회적 수행의 개념을 통한 지정학적 영향의 평가 -몰몬교 연차대회를 사례로-

Evaluating Geopolitical Impact through the Concept of Social Performance: The Case of a Mormon General Conference

  • 투고 : 2010.08.31
  • 심사 : 2010.10.10
  • 발행 : 2010.10.31
PDF 다운로드
⟨ 이전 논문 다음 논문 ⟩

초록

종교 지정학은 그 영향이나 효과 보다는 내용을 확인하고 분석하는데 초점을 두고 있다고 비판을 받는다. 본 논문은 종교 지정학의 영향을 신중하게 고려하기 위하여 사회적 수행의 개념을 사용하는 측면들을 제안한다. Judith Butler의 정체성 지향적인 수행성의 개념은 주로 지리학자들이 수행의 문제에 접근하기 위한 시작점이 된다. 그러나 정체성 지향적인 수행성의 개념은 인간의 자율적인 행위 수행(agency)을 매우 불신함으로써 후기구조주의의 기본적인 믿음에 대한 의문을 제시하는 연구자들에게 그 개념의 영향력은 제한적이다. 본 논문은 종교 지정학적 행위의 영향을 평가하는데 수행의 다른 이론의-문화 사회학자인 Jeffrey Alexander에 의한 사회적 수행의 최근의 실용적, 연극론적, 비후기구조주의 이론화-부가적인 유용성을 최근의 지정학적인 몰몬교 연차대회를 사례로 실증한다. 본 연구는 Butler와 Alexander를 통해서 몰몬교 연차대회는 유의미한 지정학적 성취를 이루었다고 결론짓는다. 그러나 본 연구는 주로 Alexander를 통해서 이러한 지정학적 성취는 새롭거나 추가적인 지정학적 행위를 유발시키는데 제한된 역할을 했다는 것을 논의한다. 이러한 지정학적 성취의 영향력은 변환시키기 보다는 강화시키는 것이었다.

Critical scholarship has shown itself much more adept at identifying and analyzing the content of religious geopolitics than its impacts or effects. This article suggests ways in which the concept of social performance can be used to more carefully consider the effects of religious geopolitics. Judith Butler's identity-oriented notion of performativity is usually geographers' point of entry into issues of performance. But its strong poststructuralist distrust of agency limits its power among those who question poststructuralism's grounding beliefs. This article illustrates the added utility of other theories of performance-particularly the recent pragmatic, dramaturgical, and non-poststructuralist theorization of social performance by the cultural sociologist Jeffrey Alexander-in evaluating the impact of religious geopolitical action. It does so through the case of a recent, particularly geopolitically laden Mormon General Conference. It concludes, through Butler and Alexander, that this General Conference likely accomplished significant geopolitical work. But it also, mainly through Alexander, argues that this work likely had limited capacity to motivate new or additional geopolitical action. Its power was more to reinforce than transform.

키워드

참고문헌

  1. Agnew, J., 2004, Is there a politics to geopolitics? Progress in Human Geography, 28, 619-640. https://doi.org/10.1191/0309132504ph508oa
  2. Agnew, J., 2006, Religion and geopolitics, Geopolitics, 11, 183-191. https://doi.org/10.1080/14650040600598619
  3. Alexander, J. C., 2006, Social pragmatics: Social performance between ritual and strategy, in Alexander, J. C., Giesen, B., and Mast, J. L. (eds.), Social Performance: Symbolic Action, Cultural Pragmatics, and Ritual, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 29-90.
  4. Baker, S. and Campbell, J., 2010, Mitt Romney's religion: A five factor model for analysis of media representation of Mormon identity, Journal of Media and Religion, 9, 99-121. https://doi.org/10.1080/15348421003738801
  5. Ballard, M. R., 2008, The truth of God shall go forth, in General Conference.
  6. Bell, C., 1998, Performance, in Taylor, M. C. (ed.), Critical Terms for Religious Studies, University of Chicago Press, Chicago, 205-224.
  7. Bialasiewicz, L., Campbell, D., Elden, S., Graham, S., Jeffrey, A., and Williams, A. J., 2007, Performing security: The imaginative geographies of current US strategy, Political Geography, 26, 405-422. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2006.12.002
  8. Butler, J., 1990, Gender Trouble: Feminism and the Subversion of Identity, Routledge, New York.
  9. Butler, J., 1995, Burning acts-injurious speech, in Parker, A. and Sedgwick E. K. (eds.), Performativity and Performance, Routledge, New York, 197-227.
  10. Butler, J., 2006, Afterword, in Armour E. T. and St. Ville S. M. (eds.), Bodily Citations: Religion and Judith Butler, Columbia University Press, New York, 276-92.
  11. Chen, C. H., 2004, Mormon and Asian American Model Minority Discourses in News and Popular Magazines, Edwin Mellen Press, Lewiston, New York.
  12. Children of men, 2008, Economist, 12 April, 36.
  13. Christofferson, D. T., 2008, Come to Zion, in General Conference.
  14. Conference conventions: traditions and happenings that define the experience, 2008, (40-page insert in) Salt Lake City Deseret News, 30 September.
  15. Crouch, D., 2003, Performances and constitutions of natures: A consideration of the performance of lay geographies, in Szerszynski, B., Heim, W., and Waterton, C. (eds.), Nature Performed: Environment, Culture and Performance, Blackwell, Oxford, 17-30.
  16. Dalton, E. S., 2008, A return to virtue, in General Conference.
  17. Dittmer, J., 2008, The geographical pivot of (the end of) history: Evangelical geopolitical imaginations and audience interpretation of Left Behind, Political Geography, 27, 280-300. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2007.12.002
  18. Dittmer, J. and Sturm, T. (eds.), 2010, Mapping the End Times: American Evangelical Geopolitics and Apocalyptic Visions, Ashgate, Farnham, Surrey.
  19. Dodds, K., 2007, Geopolitics: A Very Short Introduction, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
  20. Dodds, K. and Atkinson, D., (eds.), 2000, Geopolitical Traditions: A Century of Geopolitical Thought, Routledge, London.
  21. Dougherty, J. M., 2008, LDS General Conference: Stand fast love others, Salt Lake City Deseret News, 6 October, URL: http://www.deseretnews.com/ article/print/700264340/LDS-general-conference- Stand-fast-love-others.html, accessed 18 August 2009.
  22. Driver, F. and Gilbert, D., 1998, Heart of empire? Landscape, space and performance in imperial London, Environment and Planning D: Society and Space, 16, 11-28. https://doi.org/10.1068/d160011
  23. Duncan, N., (ed.), 1996, BodySpace: Destabilizing Geographies of Gender and Sexuality, Routledge, London.
  24. Eyring, H. B., 2008a, O ye that embark, in General Conference.
  25. Eyring, H. B., 2008b, Our hearts knit as one, in General Conference.
  26. Giesen, B., 2006, Performing the sacred: A Durkheimian perspective on the performative turn in the social sciences, in Alexander, J. C., Giesen, B., and Mast J. L. (eds.), Social Performance: Symbolic Action, Cultural Pragmatics, and Ritual, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, 325-367.
  27. Givens, T. L., 2007, People of Paradox: A History of Mormon Culture, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
  28. Hales, R. D., 2008, Christian courage: The price of discipleship, in General Conference.
  29. Hamula, J. J., 2008, Winning the war against evil, in General Conference.
  30. Hinckley, G. B., 2003, War and peace, 173rd Annual General Conference, April 2003, The Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints, URL: http://lds.org/conference/talk/display/0,5232,49- 1-353-27,00.html, accessed 29 May 2010.
  31. Howe, N., 2009, Secular iconoclasm: Purifying, privatizing, and profaning public faith, Social & Cultural Geography, 10, 639-656. https://doi.org/10.1080/14649360903068092
  32. Jacobs, J. M. and Nash, C., 2003, Too little, too much: Cultural feminist geographies, Gender, Place and Culture, 10, 265-279. https://doi.org/10.1080/0966369032000114037
  33. Katzenstein, P. J. and Sil, R., 2004, Rethinking Asian security: A case for analytical eclecticism, in Suh J. J., Katzenstein, P. J., and Carlson, A. (eds.), Rethinking Security in East Asia: Identity, Power, and Efficiency, Stanford University Press, Stanford, California, 1-33.
  34. Latter-day Conservative, 2010, URL: http://www.latterday conservative.com/videos, accessed 29 May 2010.
  35. Mahmood, S., 2006, Agency, performativity, and the feminist subject, in Armour E. T. and St. Ville S.M. (eds.), Bodily Citations: Religion and Judith Butler, Columbia University Press, New York, 177-221.
  36. Mauss, A. L., 1994, The Angel and the Beehive: The Mormon Struggle with Assimilation, University of Illinois Press, Urbana.
  37. McMullin, K. B., 2008, God loves and helps all his children, in General Conference.
  38. Medhurst, M. J., 2009, Mitt Romney, 'Faith in America', and the dance of religion and politics in American culture, Rhetoric & Public Affairs, 12, 196-221.
  39. Megoran, N., 2006, For ethnography in political geography: Experiencing and re-imagining Ferghana Valley boundary closures, Political Geography, 25, 622-640. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2006.05.005
  40. Mitchell, D., 2004, Historical materialism and Marxism, in Duncan, J. S., Johnson, N. C., and Schein, R. H. (eds.), A Companion to Cultural Geography, Blackwell, Malden, Massachusetts, 51-65.
  41. Muller, M., 2008, Reconsidering the concept of discourse for the field of critical geopolitics: Towards discourse as language and practice, Political Geography, 27, 322-338. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2007.12.003
  42. Nash, C., 2000, Performativity in practice: Some recent work in cultural geography, Progress in Human Geography, 24, 653-664. https://doi.org/10.1191/030913200701540654
  43. Nelson, L., 1999, Bodies (and spaces) do matter: The limits of performativity, Gender, Place and Culture, 6, 331-353. https://doi.org/10.1080/09663699924926
  44. Nelson, R. M., 2008, Celestial marriage, in General Conference.
  45. Oaks, D. H., 2009, Religious freedom, in Church of Jesus Christ of Latter-day Saints newsroom, URL: http://newsroom.lds.org/ldsnewsroom/eng/new s-releases-stories/religious-freedom, accessed 29 May 2010.
  46. O Tuathail, G., 1996, Critical Geopolitics: The Politics of Writing Global Space, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.
  47. Packer, B. K., 2008, The test, in General Conference.
  48. Parker, A. and Sedgwick, E. K., 1995, Introduction: Performativity and performance, in Parker, A. and Sedgwick, E. K. (eds.), Performativity and Performance, Routledge, New York, 1-18.
  49. Power, M. and Campbell, D., 2010, The state of critical geopolitics, Political Geography, 29, 243-246. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.polgeo.2010.06.003
  50. Readers comments to 'LDS General Conference: Stand fast, love others', 2008, Salt Lake City Deseret News, 6 October, URL: http://www.deseretnews. com/user/comments/700264340/LDS-generalconference- Stand-fast-love-others.html, accessed 18 August 2009.
  51. Secor, A., 2001, Islamist politics: Antisystemic or postmodern movements?, Geopolitics, 6, 117-134. https://doi.org/10.1080/14650040108407731
  52. Sharp, J., 2000, Condensing the Cold War: Reader's Digest and American Identity, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.
  53. Shipps, J., 2000, Sojourner in the Promised Land: Forty Years among the Mormons, University of Illinois Press, Urbana.
  54. Smith, P., 1988, Discerning the Subject, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.
  55. Stack, P. F., 2008, LDS leaders condemn 'rampant materialism', announce new temples, Salt Lake City Tribune, 5 October.
  56. Stack, P. F., 2010, China's a prize in LDS's eyes, Salt Lake City Tribune, 9 September, URL: http://www. sltrib.com/sltrib/home/50189317-76/churchchina- chinese-lds.html.csp, accessed 5 October 2010.
  57. Sturm, T., 2008, Critical methodological geopolitics: Discourse analysis/ethnography, Geopolitics, 13, 600-609. https://doi.org/10.1080/14650040802203927
  58. Thrift, N., 2000, It's the little things, in Dodds, K. and Atkinson, D. (eds.), Geopolitical Traditions: A Century of Geopolitical Thought, Routledge, London, 380-387.
  59. Thrift, N., 2004, Performance and performativity: A geography of unknown lands, in Duncan, J. S., Johnson, N. C. and Schein, R. H. (eds.), A Companion to Cultural Geography, Blackwell, Malden, Massachusetts, 121-136.
  60. Watson, M., 2003, Performing place in nature reserves, in Szerszynski, B., Heim, W., and Waterton, C. (eds.), Nature Performed: Environment, Culture and Performance, Blackwell, Oxford, 145-160.
  61. Van Biema, D., 2009, The storm over the Mormons, Time, 22 June, 48-53.
  62. Yorgason, E., 2010, Contests over Latter-day space: Mormonism's role within Evangelical geopolitics as seen through last-days novels, in Dittmer, J. and Sturm, T. (eds.), Mapping the End Times: American Evangelical Politics and Apocalyptic Visions, Ashgate, Farnham, Surrey, 49-71.
  63. Yorgason, E., in preparation, Mormonism's geopolitical vision of the Last Days: A survey of young Latter-day Saints, paper to be submitted to Journal of the Scientific Study of Religion.
  64. Yorgason, E. R., 2003, Transformation of the Mormon Culture Region, University of Illinois Press, Urbana.
  65. Yorgason, E. and Robertson, D. B., 2006, Mormonism's raveling and unraveling of a geopolitical thread, Geopolitics, 11, 256-279. https://doi.org/10.1080/14650040600598528