Evaluation of Capture Efficiencies of Push-Pull Hood Systems by Trace Gas Method under the Presence of Some Cross-draft

방해기류 존재시 추적자 가스법을 이용한 푸쉬풀 후드 효율 평가

  • Received : 2006.08.03
  • Accepted : 2006.09.12
  • Published : 2006.09.30

Abstract

A push pull hood system is frequently applied to control contaminants evaporated from an open surface tank. Efficiency of push pull hood system is affected by various parameters, such as, cross draft, vessel shapes, tank surface area, liquid temperature. A previous work assisted by flow visualization technique qualitatively showed that a strong cross draft blown from the pull hood to push slot could destroy a stable wall-jet on the surface of tank, resulting in the abrupt escape of smoke from the surface. In this study, the tracer gas method was applied to determine the effect of cross-draft on the capture efficiency qualitatively. A new concept of capture efficiency was introduced, that is, linear efficiency. This can be determined by measuring the mass of tracer gas in the duct of pull hood while the linear tracer source is in between push slot and pull hood. By traversing the linear tracer source from the push slot to the pull hood, it can be found where the contaminant is escaped from the tank. Total capture efficiency can be determined by averaging the linear efficiencies. Under the condition of cross-draft velocities of 0, 0.4, 0.75, 1.05 and 1.47m/s, total capture efficiencies were measured as 97.6, 95.4, 94.6, 92.7 and 70.5% respectively. The abrupt reduction of efficiency with cross-draft velocity of 1.47m/s was due to the destruction of tank surface wall-jet by the counter-current cross-draft. The same phenomenon was observed in the previous flow visualization study. As an alternative to overcome this abrupt efficiency drop, the 20% increase of hood flow rates was tested, resulting in 20% efficiency increase.

Keywords

References

  1. 송세욱, 김태형, 하현철, 홍좌령. 개방조 후드가 설치된 도금 작업장의 방해기류 측정. 한국산업위생학회지 2004;14(3):243-250
  2. 송세욱, 김태형, 하현철, 강호경. 기류 가시화기법을 이용한 방해기류 방향과 속도에 따른 푸쉬풀 후드 효율 평가. 한국산업위생학회지 2005;15(1):36-44
  3. American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists Industrial Ventilation a Manual of Recommended Practice 24th Edition, 2001. p. 10:108-110
  4. American Conference of Governmental Industrial Hygienists : Industrial Ventilation a Manual of Recommended Practice 25th Edition, 2004. p. 10:99-117
  5. Mazal F, Gonzalez E, Minana A, Baeza A. Determination and Interpretation of total and transversal linear Efficiencies in pushpull ventilation systems for open surface tanks. Ann. occup. Hyg 2002(a);46(7):629-635 https://doi.org/10.1093/annhyg/mef078
  6. Mazal F, Gonzalez E, Minana A, Baeza A. Influence of push element geometry on the capture efficiency of push-pull ventilation systems in surface treatment tanks. Ann. occup. Hyg 2002(b);46(4):383-393 https://doi.org/10.1093/annhyg/mef048
  7. Mazal F, Gonzalez E, Minana A, Baeza A. Visualization of Airflows in Push-Pull Ventilation Systems Applied to Surface Treatment Tanks. Ann. occup. Hyg 2003(a);64(4):455-460
  8. Mazal F, Gonzalez E, Minana A, Baeza A. Methodologies for determining capture efficiencies in surface treatment tanks. Ann. occup. Hyg 2003(b);64:604-608
  9. Rota R, Nano G, Canossa L. Design guidelines for push-pull ventilation systems through computational fluid dynamics modeling. AIHAJ 2001;62:141-148
  10. Woods J, McKarns J. Evaluation of capture efficiencies of large push-pull ventilation systems with both visual and tracer techniques. AIHAJ 1995;56:1208-1214 https://doi.org/10.1080/15428119591016232