Journal of Korean Library and Information Science Society (한국도서관정보학회지)

Korean Library and Information Science Society (한국도서관정보학회)
권호 표지

A Study on the Development of Comprehensive Evaluation Model for Korean University Libraries

국내 대학도서관의 평가모형 개발에 관한 연구

  • 윤희윤 (대구대학교 문헌정보학과)
  • Published : 2001.12.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

University library is more than just a collection. In other words, it is an access point and gateway to a world-wide information. Therefore, the evaluation of hybrid library and information services should be recognized an essential management activity. The goal of this study is to develope a new evaluation model for Korean university libraries, based on the analysis of existing models and perception level of the shakeholder groups. As result of statistical analysis, the study suggested six evaluation domains, thirty-seven indicators, and the relative importance (weight) and measure criterion.

이 연구의 목적은 신세기 대학도서관의 상보성 명제, 즉 인쇄자료와 디지털정보, 실물소장과 원격 접근, 인간중심의 참고봉사와 기술집약형 정보봉사, 자료집적소와 정보게이트웨이 등을 종합적으로 측정·평가할 수 있는 모형을 개발하는데 있다. 이를 위하여 일련의 선행연구를 이론적 배경으로 국내외의 관련단체가 제안한 평가시스템의 문제와 한계를 개관한 다음, 이해집단의 인식도를 조사·분석하여 종합적 평가모형(비중, 항목과 지표, 가중치, 척도 등)을 제안하였다 특히 대교협을 비롯한 관련단체의 평가모형이 디지털 인프라 및 봉사기능을 재단하는데 취약하고, 지표구성 및 척도기준의 논거가 부족하며, 실용성이 떨어진다는 비판에 주목하여 가중치의 배정모형을 다양하게 제시하였다.

Keywords

References

  1. 國立大學圖書館報 v.第17輯 대학도서관 평가에 대한 건의서 國立大學圖書館協議會
  2. 大學圖書館實態調査結果報告 文部科學省 學術機關課
  3. 私立大學圖書館の自己點檢$\cdot$評價手法ガイドライン 私立大學圖書館協會
  4. 圖書館學會年報 v.41 no.2 大學圖書館におけゐ館內利用と館外貸出との相關關係についての實態分析 岸田和明(等)
  5. 情報管理學會誌 v.18 no.3 국내외 대학도서관 평가지표의 비교분석 윤희윤
  6. 한국문헌정보학회지 v.32 no.2 대학도서관 경영규모의 경제성 연구 윤희윤
  7. 한국도서관$\cdot$정보학회지 v.32 no.3 대학도서관 평가지표의 다의성과 지향성 윤희윤
  8. 제2주기 대학종합평가인정제 시행을 위한 대학 종합평가 편람 한국대학교육협의회
  9. 대학도서관 평가기준 한국도서관협회
  10. Standards for University Libraries : Evaluation of Performance ALA;ACRL
  11. EQUINOX : Library Performance Measurement and Quality Management System Brophy, P.(et al.)
  12. Management Information Systems and Performance Measurement for the Electronic Library Brophy, P.;Wynne, P.M.
  13. Australian Library Journal v.45 no.3 Performance Management, Measurement and Reporting in a Time of Information-centred Change Cram, J.
  14. Guidelines for Learning Resource Services in Further and Higher Education : Performance and Resourcing(6th ed.) Ennis, K.(ed.)
  15. Journal of Academic Librarianship v.25 no.1 Attribution Theory and Academic Library Performance Evaluation Gedeon, J.A.;Rubin, R.E.
  16. ISO 11620 : Library and Documentation - Library Performance Indicators International Organization for Standardization
  17. The Effective Academic library : a Framework for Evaluating the Performance of UK Academic Libraries Joint Funding Councils' Ad Hoc Working Group in Library Performance Indicators
  18. Libri v.48 Ranking University Libraries Kao, Chiang(et al.)
  19. Libri v.49 no.2 Performance Evaluation in Library and Information Systems of Developing Countries : A Study of the Literature Kebede, G.
  20. Performance Indicators for the Electronic Library Kena, Jenny
  21. Performance Measurement and Metrics v.1 no.1 The Missing Ingredient : Culture of Assessment in Libraries Lakos, Amos
  22. Library Collections, Acquisitions, & Technical Services v.25 no.1 The Contribution of Library Collections to Prestige of Academic Programs of Universities : A Quantitative Analysis Liu, L.G.
  23. International Journal of Information Management v.21 Developing Performance and Impact Indicators and Targets in Public and Education Libraries Markless, Sharon;Streatfield, David
  24. Australian Academic and Research Libraries v.22 no.3 Evaluating Library Performance : The Search for Relevance? McLean, N.;Wilde, C.
  25. Accreditation : Standard Five - Library and Information Resources Oregon State University
  26. Measuring Quality : International Guidelines for Performance Measurement in Academic Libraries Poll, Roswitha;Boekhorst, Peter te
  27. Encyclopedia of Library and Information Science v.45 no.SUP. Performance Measures for Academic Libraries Revill, D.H.
  28. Library Trends v.49 no.3;Fall Digital Library Evaluation : Toward and Evolution of Concepts Saracevic, Tefko
  29. Measuring Academic Library Performance Van House, N.A.;Weil, B.T.;McClure, C.R.
  30. Guidelines for the Application of Best Practice in Australian University Libraries Wilson, A.;Pitman, L.;Trahn, I.