Preparative Chromatographic Separaction: Simulated Moving Bed and Modified Chromatography Methods

  • Yi Xie (School of Chemical Engineering. Purdue University) ;
  • Koo, Yoon-Mo (Department of Biological Engineering, ERC for Advanced Bioseparation Technology, Inha University) ;
  • Nien-Hwa Linda Wang (School of Chemical Engineering. Purdue University)
  • Published : 2001.12.01

Abstract

Chromatography has been method of choice for the separation complex biologi-cal mixtures fro analytical purpose, particularly for the last fifty years. Its use has recently been extended to preparative separation where the productivity relative to the amount of resin and sol-vent used is a matter of concern. To overcome the inherent thermodynamic inefficiency of batch chromatography, as exemplified by the partial temporal usage of the resin and dilution of the product with the solvent, chromatography has been continually modified by separation engineers. Column switching and recycling represnet some of the process modifications that have brought high productivity to chromatography. Recently, the simulated moving bed (SMB) method, which claims a high separation efficiency based on counter-current moving bed chromatography. has be-come the mainstay of preparative separation, especially in chiral separation. Accordingly, this pa-per reviews the current status of SMB along with several chromatographic modification, which may be helpful in routine laboratory and industrial chromatographic practices.

Keywords

References

  1. Separation and Purification Techniques in BViotechnology Dechow, E. J
  2. Trans. A. I. Ch.E v.42 Hypersorption process for separationof light gases Berg,C
  3. U.S Patent 2 985 589 Continuous sorption process employing fixed bed of sorbent and moving inlets and outlets Broughton, D. B;C. G. Gerhold
  4. Chem. Eng. Sci. v.40 An experimental study of a simulated counter-current adsorption system-I. Isothermal steady state operation Ching, C. B;D. M. Ruthven
  5. Preparative and Production Scale Chromatography Semicontinuous Countercurrent Chromatographic Refiners Ganetsos, G;P. E. Barker;G. Ganetsos(ed);P. E. Barker(eds)
  6. Paper presented at 28th Starch Convention Continuous counter-current separation of saccharides with inorganic adsorptions Bieser, H. J;A.J. deRosset
  7. Chem. Eng. Sci v.44 Counter-current and simulated counter-curent adsorption separation processes Ruthven, D. M;C. B. Ching
  8. Chem. Eng. Sci v.53 Experimental study of a simulated counter-current adsorption system-V. Comparison of resin zeolite adsorbents for fructose-glucose separation at high concentration Ching, C. B;C. Ho;K. Hidajat;D.M. Ruthven
  9. Chem. Eng. Sci v.40 Experimental study of simulated counter-current adsorption system: III. Sorbex operation Ching, C. B;D. M. Ruthven;R. Hidajat
  10. Can, J. Chem. Eng v.62 Analysis of the performance of a simulated counter-current chromatographic systme for fructose-glucose separation Ching, C. B;D. M. Ruthven
  11. AIChE J v.32 Improved adsorption process for production of high purity fructose Ching, C. B;C. Ho;D. M. Ruthven
  12. J. Chem. Eng. Japan v.16 Theoretical model for simulation of the operation of the semi-continuous chromatographic refiner for separating glucose and fructose Ching, C. B
  13. J. Chromatogr v.590 Optical resolution by simulated moving bed chromatography Negawa, M;F. Shoji
  14. J. Chromatogr v.624 Preparative resolution of praziquantel enantiomers by simulated counter-current chromatography Ching, C. B;B. G. Lim;E. J. D. Lee;S. C. Ng
  15. Chirality v.5 Preparative scale enantioseparation of a chiral epoxide: comparison of liquid chromatography and simulated moving bed adsorption technology Nicoud, R.M;G. Fuchs;P. Adam;M. Bailly;E. Kusters;F. D. Antia;R. Reuille;E. Schmid
  16. J. Chromatogr v.A906 Preparative enantioseparation by simulated moving bed chromatography Schulte,M;J. Strube
  17. TrendsBiotechnol v.18 Simulated moving-bed chromatography and its application to chirotechnology Juza, M;M. Mazzotti;M. Morbidelli
  18. Pharm. Technol. Eur v.11 The separation of optical isomers by simulated moving bed chromatography (part II) Nicoud, R. M
  19. Chem. Process Des. Dev v.15 Liquid coulumn chromatography as a predictive tool for continuous countercurrent adsorptive separations deRosset, A. J;R.W. Neuzil;D. J. Korous
  20. J. Chromatogr v.108 Continuous liquid chromatography Szepesy; L. Zs. Sebestyen; I,Feher,;Z. Nagy
  21. J. Chem. Eng. Japan v.26 A simulated moving-bed adsorber for the separation of tricomponents Hashimoto, K;Y.Shirali;S. Adachi
  22. J. Chem. Eng. Japan v.25 A new process for multicomponent continuous separation by combining multiple liquid-chromatography columns Hatanaka, T;M. Ishida
  23. AIChE J v.40 Multicomponent separation using a column-switching chromatographic method Ching, C. B;K. H. Chu;K. Hidajat
  24. Proceedings of ACS Annual Meeing Multicomponent separation by a novel simulated moving bed system Matsuda, F
  25. Int. Sugar. J v.94 Continuous chromatographic-separation of sucrose, glucose and fructose using a simulated moving-bed adsorber Kishihara, S;S. Fujii;H. Tamaki; K. B. Kim;N. Wakiuchi;T. Yamamoto
  26. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res v.37 A nine-zone simulating moving bed for the recovery of glucose and xylose from biomass hydrolyzate Wooley, R;Z. Ma;N.-H. L.Wang
  27. Proceedigns of 7th International Conference on Fundamental of Adsorption Standing wave design of tandem and parallel SMBs for the recovery of a sugar from a ternary mixture. Hritzko, B.J;Y. Xie;R. J. Wooley, Z. Ma;N.-H. L. Wang
  28. Submitted to AIChE J Standing wave design of sigle and tandem SMB processes for multicomponent fractionation: Linear isotherm systems Hritzko, B.J;Y. Xie;R. J. Wooley;N.-H. L. Wang
  29. Proceedings of Presentation to the Israeli Mining Institution ISEP & CSEP, a novel separation technique for process engineers Rossiter, G. J
  30. Chem. Eng. Sci v.52 Simulated moving bed chromatography. Effects of axial dispersion and mass transfer under linear conditions Zhong, G;G. Guiochon
  31. Chem. Eng. Sci v.44 Optimal design of multicomponent countercurrent adsorption adsorption separation processes in volving nonlinear equilibria Storti, G;M. Mazzotti; S, Cara;M. Morbidelli
  32. J. Chromatogr. v.A769 Optimal operation of simulated moving bed units for nonlinear chromatographic separations Mazzotti,M; G. Stroti;M. Morbidelli
  33. Sep. Purif. Technol v.20 Design of simulated moving bed multicomponent separations: Langmuir systmes Migliorini, C;M. Mazzotti;M. Morbidelli
  34. AIChE J v.43 Standing wave analysis of SMB chromatography: linear systems Ma, Z;N.-H.L.Wang
  35. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res v.39 Extended standing wave design method for simulated lmoving bed chromatography: linear systems Xie, Y;D.-J. Wu;Z. Ma;N.-H. L. Wang
  36. Phil. Trans. Roy. Soc. London v.A269 Multi component adsorption in continuous countercurrent exchangers Rhee, H. K;R. Aris;N. R. Amundson
  37. AIChE J v.40 Ro-bust design of countercurrent adsorption separation process. 2. Multicomponent systems Mazzotti,M;G. Storti;M. Morbidelli
  38. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res v.35 Vapor-phase SMB adsorptive separation of linear/nonlinear paraffins Mazzotti; M. R. Baciocchi; G, Storti;M. Morbidelli
  39. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res v.40 Temperature gradient operation of a simulated moving bed unit Migliorini, C;M. Wendlinger;M. Mazzotti;M. Morbidelli
  40. Blackie Academic & Professional Rate-Controlled Separations. 1st ed Wankat, P. C
  41. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res v.37 Design of simulated moving bed chromatography for amino acid separations Wu, D,-J;Y. Xie;Z. Ma;N.-H. L. Wang
  42. AIChE J v.44 Standing wave design of nonlinear SMB systems for fructose purification Mallmann, T;B. D. Burris;Z. Ma;N. -H. L. Wang
  43. AIChE J v.42 Physically meaningful modeling of the 3-zone and 4-zone simulated moving bed processes Hotier. G
  44. AIChE J v.45 Design of a mulated moving bed in the presence of mass-transfer tesisances Axevalo, D. C. S;A. E. Rodrigues
  45. Preparative and Pro-Junral Scale Chormatography Canetsos, G;P. E. Barker
  46. Sep. Sci. Technol v.32 Dynamics of simulated moving-bed adsorption separation processes Lu, Z. P;C. B. Ching
  47. AIChE J v.44 Modeling strategies for enantiomers separation by SMB chromatography Pais, L. S;J. M. Loureiro;A. E. Rodrigues
  48. Dynamics of Chromatofraphy Giddings,J. C
  49. Chem. Eng. Res. Des v.61 Mathematical model forthe fractionation of dextran on a semi-contimuous counter-current simulated moving bed chromatograph Barker, P. E;K. England;G. Vlachogiannis
  50. J. Chem. Eng. Japan v.16 Models for separation of glucose-fructose mixture using a simulated moving bed adsorber Hashimoto, K;S. Adachi;H. Noujima;A. Maruyama
  51. Fundamentals of Adsorption Mathematical models of moving beds and simulated moving beds for adsorption separation: analysis and comparison Morbidelli, M;G. Storti; R. Paludetto;S. Carra
  52. AIChE J v.46 Design of a carousel process for cesium removal using crystalline silicotitanate Hritzko, B. J. D. D. Walker;N. -H. L. Wang
  53. Ind. Eng. Chem. Res v.39 Optimal design and operation of simulated moving bed chromatographic reactors Dunnebier, G;J. Fricke;K.-U. Klatt
  54. Rate-Controlled Separations Wankat, P. C
  55. Large-Scale Adsorption and Chromatogpaphy v.II Wankat, P. C
  56. J.Chromatogr v.B731 Automated determination of 5-fluorouracil and its metabolite in urine by HPLC with column switching Maeda, T;S. Sumi;K.Hayashi;K. Kidouchi;T. Owaki;H.Togari;S. Fujimoto;Y. Wada
  57. J. Kor. Chem. Soc v.39 Micro-determination of D-amino acids in milk by using column switching Lee, S. H;K. H. Kim;Y. C. Lee;S.T. Kim
  58. Arch. Phar. Res v.17 On-line trace enrichment for the determination of insulin in biological sample using reversed-phase HPLC with column switching Lee, J. S;H. Lee;H. S. Lee;K. C. Lee
  59. J. Liq. Chromatogr v.13 Column switching technique for group-type separation of different PAH classes by use of C-18-modified silica and polystyrene packings Grosserhode, C;H. G. Kicinski;A. Kettrup
  60. J. Chromatogr. Sci v.11 Throughput and band overlap in production and preparative chromatography Conder, J. R;M. K. Shingari
  61. Chem. Eng. Sci v.37 Recycle optimization in non-linear productive chromatography. Bailly, M;D.Tondeur
  62. Agilent Technologies HPLC sample peak recycler
  63. Biotechnol. Tech v.13 On-line recovery of large molecule sfrom mixtures usin greciprocation size exclusion chromatography Chang, W.-J;Y.-M. Koo
  64. Submitted to Kor J. Chem. Eng Separation of mixed solutes using reciprocating size exclusion chromatography: computer simulation based upon experimental parameters Kim, Y.-M;Y.-M. Koo
  65. Kor. J. Chem. Eng v.10 Mechanism of simultaneous solutes separation and concentration by size exclusion cyclic separation Choi, S.-W;M.-H. Yoon;Y,-M. Koo
  66. J. Chromatogr v.87 Gel chromatography: The effect of temperature on partitioning Chitumbo, K;W. Brown
  67. Ind. Eng. Chem. Fundam v.24 Size exclusion parametric pumping Koo, Y.-M;P. C. Wankat
  68. Dairy Ind v.38 Aspects of whey processing by gel filtration Lindquest, L. Q;K. W. Williams
  69. Chem. Eng. Sci v.36 Two-way chromatography: Flow reversal in nonlinear preparative liquid chromatography Bailly, M;D. Tondeur