A Comparison of the Methodologies in Food Consumption Surveys and Daily Dietary Fat Intake between America and Korea

한국과 미국의 식품 섭취 조사 방법 및 지방섭취량의 비교

  • Published : 1996.12.01

Abstract

The nutritional status is America has been monitored by National Monitoring System since 1960's, mainly conducted by United States Department of Agriculture. The data from these programs were computerized and distributed to researchers. Researchers have manipulated and recalculated the data to produce meaningful results. Korean nutritional status has been investigated by National Nutrition Survey ever year, including food consumption, biochemical measurements and demographic variables. The Korean Nutritional Survey has not been organized and integrated as much as the nutritional survey in the United States and its results have been presented no more than as a report. Its raw data should be distributed to researchers and researchers could use the data to get more information. The purpose of this study is to compare the measurement of food consumption in Korean and America using Korean Nutrition Survey and Continuing Survey of Food Intake by Individuals(CSFII), respectively, and to compare the consumption of fat and foods with a high fat content. The fat consumption in the Unite States has been decreased from more than 40% of total energy intake to 35%, while Koreas have consumed more fat according to the economic growth. However, the fat consumption in Korea was still much lower than that in the United States. Korean should pay attention to saturated fat consumption(animal fat), especially rich middle aged men, since they ate meat as much as much as men in the United States according to a recent study. In America availability of food with a low fat content(e.g. low-fat milk) and new recipes along with nutritional education has decreased fat consumption, especially animal fat, any more. Also, each consumption of polyunsaturated fat and saturated fat should be measured since the ratio of them are more important for preventing heart disease and some cancers.

Keywords

References

  1. Journal of Dietetic Association v.91 ADA timely statement on implementation of National Nutrition Monitoring and Related Research Act
  2. Journal of the American Dietetic Association v.84 National Nutrition Monitoring System : A congressional perspective G.E.Brown Jr.
  3. Interpretation and utilization of data from the National Nutrition Monitoring System, in Research: Successful Approaches, ed. E.R. Monsen(Chicago : American Dietetic Association) C.E.Woteki;F.L.Wong
  4. Journal of Dietetic Association v.94 Diet quality index : Capturing a multidimensional behavior Pattersin,R.E.;Haines,P.S.;Popkin,B.M.
  5. J. of Dietetic Association v.95 Secular trends in diet and risk factors for cardiovascular disease : The Framingham Study B.M.Posner;M.M.Franz;P.A.Quatromono;D.R.Gagnon;P.A.Quatromoni;D.R.Gagnon;P.A.Sytkowski;D.Agostino;L.A.Cupples
  6. Continuing Survey of Food Intakes by Individuals(CSFII) US Department of Agriculture(USDA)
  7. 국민 영양 조사보고서 보건복지부
  8. 국민 영양 조사보고서 보건복지부
  9. 국민 영양 조사보고서 보건복지부
  10. Poverty in the United States 1989. Washington DC : US bureau of the Census 1991 Current Population Reports, Series P-60, No.169
  11. USDA Nutrient Data Base For Individual Food Intake Surveys, Release 4 Human Nutrition Information Service US Dept. of Agriculture
  12. Dietary assessment. In : M.E. Shils, J.A. Olson and M. Shike ed. Modern Nutrition in Health and Disease 8th ed. J.T.Dwyer
  13. Am. J. Epidemiology v.120 Comparison between dietary intake methodology J.M.Samet,C.G.Jumble,A.E.Skipper
  14. Journal of Nutrition v.120 Dietary intake methodology Ⅰ.USDA Surveys and Supporting Research R.L.Rizek;E.M.Pao
  15. MMWR v.43 Daily dietary fat and total food-energy intakes-Third National Health and Nutrition Examination Survey, Phase Ⅰ. 1988-1991 Health Objectives for the Nation
  16. Hum. Nut. Appl. Nutr. v.38A The NACNE report : are the dietary goals realistic? Comparisons with the dietary patterns of dieticians A.E.Black;C.Ravenscroft;A.J.Sims
  17. Am. J. Clin. Nutr. v.52 Trends in individual consumption of dietary fat in the United States. 1920-1984 A.M.Stephen;N.J.Wald
  18. 사망원인통계 경제기획원
  19. 93국민 영양 조사보고서 보건복지부
  20. 한국영양학회지 v.29 no.5 아침식사의 규칙성이 중년 남녀의 식습관 및 영양상태에 미치는 영향 이선희;심정수;김지윤;문형아
  21. Anticancer Research v.16 no.2 The Effects of Omega-3 and Omega-6 Fatty-Acids on in Vitro Prostate-Cancer Growth P.K.Pandalai;M.J.Pilat;K.Yamazaki;H.Naik;K.J.Pienta
  22. Diabetes v.40 Influence of dietary fat composition on development of insulin resistance in rats. Realtionship to phospholipid L.H.Storlien;A.B.Jenkins;D.J.Chisholm;W.S.Pascoe;S.Khouri;E.W.Kraegen