• Clinical and Experimental Pediatrics
• /
• 제52권7호
• /
• pp.818-823
• /
• 2009

목 적 : 국내 소아 아토피피부염 환자의 부증상의 빈도 및 연령과 중등도에 따른 차이를 분석하여 아토피 피부염의 진단 및 치료에 도움이 되고자 본 연구를 시행하였다. 방 법 : 2007년 4월부터 12월까지 순천향대학교 병원 소아알레르기 호흡기센터에 내원하여 아토피피부염으로 진단 받은 106명 환아를 대상으로 하였다. 대상 환자들은 첫 내원시 3명의 소아과 전문의에 의해 아토피피부염 부증상이 평가 되었으며 Hanifin과 Rajka의 부증상 항목과 2001년 아토피피부염 국제진단기준을 바탕으로 한 20가지 항목을 작성하였다. 대상 환자들은 2세 미만과 2세 이상으로 연령군을 분류하고 SCORAD 점수를 이용하여 중증도를 분류하였으며 원인 항원 특이 IgE 항체를 측정하여 아토피군과 비아토피군으로 분류하였다. 결 과 : 아토피피부염 환자에서 부증상으로 피부건조증(78.3%), 환경이나 감정요인에 의한 악화(43.4%), 태선화(35.8%), 눈 주위 색소 침착(34.0%), 이개 균열(33.0%), 피부 감염(31.1%)이 높은 빈도를 보였다. 2세 이상인 군에서 눈주위 색소 침착(P=0.01), 목주름(P=0.01), 태선화(P=0.001) 항목에서 통계학적으로 유의하게 높은 빈도를 보였고중증 아토피피부염에서 피부 건조증(P=0.04), 피부 감염(P=0.03), 모공 각화증(P=0.02), 반복적인 결막염(P=0.02), 눈 주위 색소침착(P=0.001), 안면 피부염(P=0.001), 태선화(P=0.001), 손/발 습진(P=0.04) 항목이 높은 빈도를 보였다. 아토피군에서 안면 피부염(P=0.01)과 태선화(P=0.04) 항목이 유의하게 높은 빈도를 보였다. 결 론 : 국내 소아 아토피피부염 환아에서 흔히 관찰되는 부증상의 빈도 및 나이, 중증도에 따른 차이를 확인하였고 국내 소아 아토피피부염 진단 및 중증도 평가에 있어 부증상의 몇몇 항목이 유의하게 활용될 수 있는 가능성을 제시할 수 있었다.

• 한방안이비인후피부과학회지
• /
• 제35권1호
• /
• pp.91-104
• /
• 2022

Objectives : The objective of this study is to report a case of a male atopic dermatitis patient accompanying seborrheic capitis and nummular eczema improved by Korean medicine therapy and lifestyle modification. Methods : A male patient was hospitalized for eczematous lesions in the head, face, and both hands which relapsed on March 2021. For 15 days, he took Korean medicine therapy including acupuncture, Bangpungtongseongsan-gagam, pharmacopuncture, and wet dressing with Hwangryunhaedok-tang. Simultaneously, lifestyle correction also conducted during administration. On the other hand, corticosteroid and antihistamine were prescribed from internal medicine of our hospital for the first 10 days because of severe skin lesions. As an outpatient, he was continuously treated by the same Korean medicine therapy except herbal decoction weekly for about 7 months after discharge. To assess symptoms, scoring atopic dermatitis(SCORAD) index, taking photos, and numerical rating scale(NRS) were used. Results : After 15 days of hospitalization, the SCORAD index decreased to 30.0, which was about a half of the initial SCORAD index(61.2). NRS score also dropped from 6 to 3. Despite stopping western medicine administration, skin lesions and subjective symptoms of the patient were steadily improved without aggravation. For 7 months of continued outpatient treatment, atopic dermatitis were steadily ameliorated despite temporary aggravation and improvement of symptoms, and seborrheic capitis was not relapsed. The final SCORAD index and NRS on November 9th, 2021 were 24.7 and 1, respectively. Conclusions : These results suggests that Korean medicine therapy contributes to improving SCORAD index, subjective symptoms, and skin lesions of the patient. Furthermore, lifestyle modification is also important as much as proper treatment for caring atopic dermatitis patients.

• Safety and Health at Work
• /
• 제10권1호
• /
• pp.3-20
• /
• 2019

This review aimed to identify risk factors for occupational accidents and illnesses among young workers in the Nordic countries and to attain knowledge on specific vulnerable groups within the young working force that may need special attention. We conducted a systematic review from 1994 to 2014 using five online databases. Of the 12,528 retrieved articles, 54 met the review criteria and were quality assessed, in which data were extracted focusing on identifying occupational safety, health risk factors, and vulnerable groups among the young workers. The review shows that mechanical factors such as heavy lifting, psychosocial factors such as low control over work pace, and organizational factors such as safety climate are all associated with increased injury risk for young Nordic workers. Results show that exposures to chemical substances were associated with skin reactions, e.g., hand eczema. Heavy lifting and awkward postures were risk factors for low back pain, and high job demands were risk factors for mental health outcomes. The review identified young unskilled workers including school drop-out workers as particularly vulnerable groups when it comes to occupational accidents. In addition, apprentices and young skilled workers were found to be vulnerable to work-related illnesses. It is essential to avoid stereotyping young Nordic workers into one group using only age as a factor, as young workers are a heterogeneous group and their vulnerabilities to occupational safety and health risks are contextual. Politicians, researchers, and practitioners should account for this complexity in the education, training and organization of work, and workplace health and safety culture.

• 한방안이비인후피부과학회지
• /
• 제15권2호
• /
• pp.271-288
• /
• 2002

Authors investigated the pathogenesis and treatment of dennatosurgical diseases in the ImJeungJiNamUiAn(臨證指南醫案). 1. The symptoms and diseases of dermatosurgery were as follows; 1) BanSaJinRa(반사진라) : eczema, atopic dermatitis, seborrheic dermatitis, psoriasis, lichen planus, pityriasis rosea, hives, dermographism, angioedema, cholinergic urticaria, urticaria pigmentosa, acne, milium, syringoma, keratosis pilaris, discoid lupus erythematosus, hypersensitivity vasculitis, drug eruption, polymorphic light eruption, rheumatic fever, juvenile rheumatoid arthritis(Still's disease), acute febrile neutrophilic dermatosis(Sweet's syndrome), Paget's disease, folliculitis, viral exanthems, molluscum contagiosum, tinea, tinea versicolor, lymphoma, lymphadenitis, lymphangitis, granuloma annulare, cherry angioma 2) ChangYang(瘡瘍) : acute stage eczema, seborrheic dermatitis, stasis ulcer, intertrigo, xerosis, psoriasis, lichen planus, ichthyosis, pityriasis rosea, rosacea, acne, keratosis pilaris, dyshidrosis, dermatitis herpetiformis, herpes gestationis, bullae in diabetics, pemphigus, lupus erythematosus, fixed drug eruption, erythema multiforme, toxic epidermal necrolysis, toxic shock syndrome, staphylococcal scaled skin syndrome, scarlet fever, folliculitis, impetigo, pyoderma gangrenosum, tinea, candidiasis, scabies, herpes simplex, herpes zoster, chicken pox, Kawasaki syndrome, lipoma, goiter, thyroid nodule, thyroiditis, hyperthyroidism, thyroid cancer, benign breast disorder, breast carcinoma, hepatic abscess, appendicitis, hemorrhoid 3) Yeok(疫) : scarlet fever, chicken pox, measles, rubella, exanthem subitum, erythema infectiosum, Epstein-Barr virus infection, cytomegalovirus infection, hand-foot-mouth disease, Kawasaki disease 4) Han(汗) : hyperhidrosis 2. The pathogenesis and treatment of dermatosurgery were as follows; 1) When the pathogenesis of BalSa(발사), BalJin(發疹), BalLa(발라) and HangJong(項腫) are wind-warm(風溫), exogenous cold with endogenous heat(外寒內熱), wind-damp(風濕), the treatment of evaporation(解表) with Menthae Herba(薄荷), Arctii Fructus(牛蒡子), Forsythiae Fructus(連翹) Mori Cortex(桑白皮), Fritillariae Cirrhosae Bulbus(貝母), Armeniaoae Amarum Semen(杏仁), Ephedrae Herba(麻黃), Cinnamomi Ramulus(桂枝), Curcumae Longae Rhizoma(薑黃), etc can be applied. 2) When the pathogenesis of BuYang(부양), ChangI(瘡痍) and ChangJilGaeSeon(瘡疾疥癬) are wind-heat(風熱), blood fever with wind transformation(血熱風動), wind-damp(風濕), the treatment of wind-dispelling(疏風) with Arctii Fructus(牛蒡子), Schizonepetae Herba(荊芥), Ledebouriellae Radix(防風), Dictamni Radicis Cortex(白鮮皮), Bombyx Batrytioatus(白？?), etc can be applied. 3) When the pathogenesis of SaHuHaeSu(사후해수), SaJin(사진), BalJin(發疹), EunJin(은진) and BuYang(부양) are wind-heat(風熱), exogenous cold with endogenous heat(外寒內熱), exogenous warm pathogen with endogenous damp-heat(溫邪外感 濕熱內蘊), warm pathogen's penetration(溫邪內陷), insidious heat's penetration of pericardium(伏熱入包絡), the treatment of Ki-cooling(淸氣) with TongSeongHwan(通聖丸), Praeparatum(豆？), Phyllostachys Folium(竹葉), Mori Cortex(桑白皮), Tetrapanacis Medulla(通草), etc can be applied. 4) When the pathogenesis of JeokBan(적반), BalLa(발라), GuChang(久瘡), GyeolHaek(結核), DamHaek(痰核), Yeong(？), YuJu(流注), Breast Diseases(乳房疾患) and DoHan(盜汗) are stagnancy's injury of Ki and blood(鬱傷氣血), gallbladder fire with stomach damp(膽火胃濕), deficiency of Yin in stomach with Kwolum's check (胃陰虛 厥陰乘), heat's penetration of blood collaterals with disharmony of liver and stomach(熱入血絡 肝胃不和), insidious pathogen in Kwolum(邪伏厥陰), the treatment of mediation(和解) with Prunellae Spica(夏枯草), Chrysanthemi Flos(菊花), Mori Folium (桑葉), Bupleuri Radix(柴胡), Coptidis Rhizoma(黃連), Scutellariae Radix(黃芩), Gardeniae Fructus(梔子), Cyperi Rhizoma(香附子), Toosendan Fructus(川？子), Curcumae Radix(鬱金), Moutan Cortex(牧丹皮), Paeoniae Radix Rubra(赤芍藥), Unoariae Ramulus Et Uncus(釣鉤藤), Cinnamorni Ramulus(桂枝), Paeoniae Radix Alba(白芍藥), Polygoni Multiflori Radix (何首烏), Cannabis Fructus (胡麻子), Ostreae Concha(牡蠣), Zizyphi Spinosae Semen(酸棗仁), Pinelliae Rhizoma(半夏), Poria(백복령). etc can be applied. 5) When the pathogenesis of BanJin(반진), BalLa(발라), ChangI(瘡痍), NamgChang(膿瘡). ChangJilGaeSeon(瘡疾疥癬), ChangYang(瘡瘍), SeoYang(署瘍), NongYang(膿瘍) and GweYang(潰瘍) are wind-damp(風濕), summer heat-damp(暑濕), damp-warm(濕溫), downward flow of damp-heat(濕熱下垂), damp-heat with phlegm transformation(濕熱化痰), gallbladder fire with stomach damp(膽火胃濕), overdose of cold herbs(寒凉之樂 過服), the treatment of damp-resolving(化濕) with Pinelliae Rhizoma(半夏), armeniacae Amarum Semen(杏仁), Arecae Pericarpium(大腹皮), Poria(백복령), Coicis Semen(薏苡仁), Talcum(滑石), Glauberitum(寒水石), Dioscoreae Tokoro Rhizoma(？？), Alismatis Rhizoma(澤瀉), Phellodendri Cortex(黃柏), Phaseoli Radiati Semen(？豆皮), Bombycis Excrementum(?沙), Bombyx Batryticatus(白？?), Stephaniae Tetrandrae Radix(防己), etc can be applied. 6) When the pathogenesis of ChangPo(瘡泡), hepatic abscess(肝癰) and appendicitis(腸癰) are food poisoning(食物中毒), Ki obstruction & blood stasis in the interior(기비혈어재과), damp-heat stagnation with six Bu organs suspension(濕熱結聚 六腑不通), the treatment of purgation(通下) with DaeHwangMokDanPiTang(大黃牧丹皮湯), Manitis Squama(穿山甲), Curcumae Radix(鬱金), Curcumae Longae Rhizoma(薑黃), Tetrapanacis Medulla(通草), etc can be applied. 7) When the pathogenesis of JeokBan(적반), BanJin(반진), EunJin(은진). BuYang(부양), ChangI(瘡痍), ChangPo(瘡泡), GuChang(久瘡), NongYang(膿瘍), GweYang(潰瘍), Jeong(정), Jeol(癤), YeokRyeo(疫？) and YeokRyeolpDan(疫？入？) are wind-heat stagnation(風熱久未解), blood fever in Yangmyong(陽明血熱), blood fever with transformation(血熱風動), heat's penetration of blood collaterals(熱入血絡). fever in blood(血分有熱), insidious heat in triple energizer(三焦伏熱), pathogen's penetration of pericardium(心包受邪), deficiency of Yong(營虛), epidemic pathogen(感受穢濁), the treatment of Yong & blood-cooling(淸營凉血) with SeoGakJiHwangTang(犀角地黃湯), Scrophulariae Radix(玄參), Salviae Miltiorrhizae Radix(丹參), Angelicae Gigantis Radix(當歸), Polygoni Multiflori Radix(何首烏), Cannabis Fructus(胡麻子), Biotae Semen(柏子仁), Liriopis Tuber(麥門冬), Phaseoli Semen(赤豆皮), Forsythiae Fructus(連翹), SaJin(사진), YangDok(瘍毒) and YeokRyeoIpDan(역려입단) are insidious heat's penetration of pericardium(伏熱入包絡), damp-warm's penetration of blood collaterals(濕溫入血絡), epidemic pathogen's penetration of pericardium(심포감수역려), the treatment of resuscitation(開竅) with JiBoDan(至寶丹), UHwangHwan(牛黃丸), Forsythiae Fructus(連翹), Curcumae Radix(鬱金), Tetrapanacis Medulla(通草), Acori Graminei Rhizoma(石菖蒲), etc can be applied. 9) When the pathogenesis of SaHuSinTong(사후신통), SaHuYeolBuJi(사후열부지), ChangI(瘡痍), YangSon(瘍損) and DoHan(盜汗) are deficiency of Yin in Yangmyong stomach(陽明胃陰虛), deficiency of Yin(陰虛), the treatment of Yin-replenishing(滋陰) with MaekMunDongTang(麥門冬湯), GyeongOkGo(瓊玉膏), Schizandrae Fructus(五味子), Adenophorae Radix(沙參), Lycii Radicis Cortex (地骨皮), Polygonati Odorati Rhizoma(玉竹), Dindrobii Herba(石斛), Paeoniae Radix Alba(白芍藥), Ligustri Lucidi Fructus (女貞子), etc can be applied. 10) When the pathogenesis of RuYang(漏瘍) is endogenous wind in Yang collaterals(陽絡內風), the treatment of endogenous wind-calming(息風) with Mume Fructus(烏梅), Paeoniae Radix Alba (白芍藥), etc be applied. 11) When the pathogenesis of GuChang(久瘡), GweYang(潰瘍), RuYang(漏瘍), ChiChang(痔瘡), JaHan(自汗) and OSimHan(五心汗) are consumption of stomach(胃損), consumption of Ki & blood(氣血耗盡), overexertion of heart vitality(勞傷心神), deficiency of Yong(營虛), deficiency of Wi(衛虛), deficiency of Yang(陽虛), the treatment of Yang-restoring & exhaustion-arresting(回陽固脫) with RijungTang(理中湯), jinMuTang(眞武湯), SaengMaekSaGunjaTang(生脈四君子湯), Astragali Radix (황기), Ledebouriellae Radix(防風), Cinnamomi Ramulus(桂枝), Angelicae Gigantis Radix(當歸), Ostreae Concha(牡蠣), Zanthoxyli Fructus(川椒), Cuscutae Semen(兎絲子), etc can be applied.

• 혜화의학회지
• /
• 제2권2호
• /
• pp.219-246
• /
• 1993

In 1991, Obesity rate of South Korea has reached to 18.7%. Because of economical development, the pattern of diet is exchanged from carbohydrate to rich protein and fat. The more problem is not only obesity of adult but also one of little child. Obesity is induced to diabetes mellitus, hypertension, artherosclerosis, hyperlipoidemia. heart and C.V.A disease, etc. In Woman, special important ploblem is the complex of beauty about Woman's figure. In Oriental Medicine, the factor of obesity is mainly regarded as dampness. And there are many treatments and methods to body weight loss, but obesity patients dislike to use them because of their side effects and inconvenience, intolerance. Now ear acupuncture is applied on so many disease because of its easy handly, non-side effect and high efficiency in clinics. Here obesity acupuncture is used to ear and whole body acupuncture. Because they react eachother for lack point. Therefore, in order to investigate the effect of obesity acupuncture and develop non-drug, non-starvation etc, we analyzed 453 the cases of body weight loss patients treated with ear and whole body acupuncture in Oriental Medicine Hospital of Jeon-Ju Woo-Sug University from April.1.1992. to March.17. 1993. The results were summarized as follows. 1. Distribution of sex ; male (4.4%), Female(95.6%) 2. Distribution of age in descending order ; 30s, 20s, 40s, 10s, 50s, below 10s, abowe 60s. The 20s-30s are group made up 60.7% of the group. 3. Distribution of occupation in descending order; housewife, student, service, salaried, merchant, teacher, farmer, inoccupation. 4. Distribution of human coporal constitution in descending order : Tae-Eum-In, So-Eum-In, So-Yang-In. 5. Distribution of body height and weight, 155-164cm ; 71.1%, 60-70kg, 74.6% are majority. 6. Distribution of weight variation, 2-6kg(71.0%) is majority, also 13-14kg(0.4%). 7. Distribution of duration in descending order ; 1-3 years, 3-6 years, 1-12months, above 10 years but in success, 1-12 months, 1-3 years, 3-6 years, above 10 years. Therefore, we know that the shorter duration of obesity is, the more loss of body weight. 8. Past experiences to body weight loss; Yes(69.5%), No(30.5%). The success rate accordant with the past temporary experiences shows that the cases without experience is higher than the ones with experience. 9. In distribution of times(treatments), 10 times is top. The rate of body weight loss is the highest in 14 times. Therefore, I think that one would need at least 10 times. in order lose body weight 10. Distribution of body weight variation in treatments times is at 2 times(3-4kg loss), and surprisingly is 14kg loss at above 15 times. 11. Distribution of symptoms improvement, in descending order ; heavy sense in body, dec. of appetite, inc.of exercise, lumbago, edema, knee pain, inc.of urine, inc. of fullness sense, thirsty, disease of gynecology, white tung, chest burning, heart burning, dec.of tobacco, drink taste. motion sickness, allergy, water eczema, arthma, belching. 12. Distribution of snack; Yes(87.4%), No(78.6%) 13. Distribution of exercise; Yes(21.4%), No(78.6%) 14. Distribution of sleeping times, above 7 hours(79.0%) 15. Distribution of the reason to body loss, the complex of beauty(68.7%) is top. 16. Distribution of side effect in obesity acupuncture, constipation (17.4%) is top. 17. Distribution of method in body weight loss ; dietary treatment (31.1%), sauna(26.7%), exercise(19.7%), the center of body weight loss (15.0%) herb-med and starvation treatments (5.1%), hand-finger acupuncture (hand-foot acupuncture) is 1.6%, diet pill(0.3%), etc(0.6%).

• Journal of Preventive Medicine and Public Health
• /
• 제29권4호
• /
• pp.785-799
• /
• 1996

절삭유의 사용과 피부질환의 관계를 알아보기 위하여 한 자동차공장의 엔진 및 구동부서 근로자 1,004명을 대상으로 피부 이상 증세에 대한 기초설문조사를 실시하여 응답을 해준 근로자 667명을 대상으로 분석 및 피부과적 검진을 실시하였다. 또한 절삭유의 노출 정도를 알기 위한 방법으로 공기 중 오일 미스트를 측정하였다. 이 조사의 결과를 요약하면 다음과 같다. 1. 공기 중 오일미스트는 3개 부서로 나누어서 측정 하였는데, 전체 52건의 측정건수 중에서 8시간가중 평균 기준치인 $5mg/m^3$을 넘는 건수는 9건(17.3%)이었고, 로그정규분포상에서 95% 신뢰한계의 전체 상한치는 기준치 미만이었다. 2. 조사한 부서는 엔진가공부(258명), 가솔린 엔진조립부(210명), 디젤엔진조립부(96명), 구동부 가공반(86명), 구동부 조립반(17명)의 5개 부서였으며, 조사한 667명의 평균 나이는 34.5세였고, 근무연수의 중앙값은 7년 7개월이었다. 3. 이들 부서 중 엔진가공부와 구동부 가공반(A군)은 절삭유를 공정상 많이 사용하는 부서로 근로자 344명 중 298명 (86.6%)이 한 가지 이상의 절삭유를 사용하고 있는 반면, 가솔린엔진 조립부, 디젤엔진 조립부, 구동부 조립반의 근로자 323명(B군) 중에는 31명 (9.1%)만이 절삭유를 사용하고 있었다. 4. 피부 이상 증세의 경험자 227명 중 213명에 대하여 피부과전문의의 진찰을 시행하였는데, 이중에 172명이 검진당시 증세를 호소했는데, 1인당 평균 호소증세 건수가 1.5건 정도였다. 가장 많은 증세는 가려움증(32.5%), 구진(21.6%), 인설(15.7%), 소수포(12.5%), 반점(9.4%)의 순서였다. 5. 검진을 받은 근로자 231명 중 정상소견이나 뚜렷한 병변이 없는 사람으로 분류된 경우는 53명이었고, 나머지 160명에서 피부과적 질환이 발견되었다. 가장 많은 것은 접촉 피부염으로 전체 질환자 중 92명 (57.5%)을 차지하였고, 이들 중에는 여드름이나 낭포염 등 기타 다른 피부질환을 동반한 경우가 23명 (25%) 이었다. 기타 낭포염, 여드름만 있는 경우도 각각 9명(5.6%), 8명(5.0%)이었으며 , 각질화와 색소 이상도 1명 씩 발견되었다. 기타의 수부 습진은 비특이성 수부습진으로 분류되었는데 이들은 47명이었다. 6.피부질환이 있다고 진단받은 160명에서 발견된 피부과적 이상부위는 1인당 1.3부위였다. 이상이 발견된 부위는 손바닥(27.6%), 손가락과 손톱(22.7%), 상박부(16.0%), 손등(11.8%), 손가락 사이(10.3%)의 순이었고, 이들 수부 및 상박부위의 이상이 전체 이상의 약 88.7%였다. 7. 전체 피부질환의 유병상태는 각 부서별로 차이가 많았는데, 특히 접촉 피부염의 경우 엔진가공부는 1,000명당 213명, 가솔린엔진 조립부는 1,000명당 29명, 디젤엔진 조립부는 1,000명당 73명이었고, 구동부 가공반은 1,000명당 267명, 구동부 조립반은 1,000명당 59명으로 부서별로 차이가 매우 켰다. 이러한 경향은 절삭유 사용에 따라서 특히 수용성 절삭유만 사용하는 군과 두 종류의 절삭유를 모두 사용하는 근로자에서 마찬가지로 높게 관찰되었다. 8. 감별진단이 필요하다고 판단된 접촉 피부염 환자 49명은 첩포 검사를 시행하였다. 첩포 검사 결과, 기본 표준시료에 양성이 나타난사람이 12명, 기본표준시료와 오일시료에 모두 양성이 나타난 사람 3명, 그리고 오일 시료에만 양성이 나타난 사람 3명이 있었고, 기본 표준시료와 유기용제시료에 양성이 나타난 사람, 유기용제 시료에만 양성이 나타난 사람이 각각 1명 있었다. 9. 전체 피부질환의 유무에 대하여, 근로자의 나이와 근무기간의 영향을 통제한 후 근로자들이 사용하는 절삭유의 종류에 따른 위험도를 알아보기 위하여 다변량 분석을 하였다. 분석결과 절삭유를 전혀 사용하지 않는 군과 비수용성 절삭유만을 사용하는 군과는 유의한 차이가 없었으며 수용성 절삭유만 사용하는 사람은 $1.4\sim3.3$배(교차비의 95%신뢰한계), 두 종류의 절삭유를 모두 사용하는 사람은 $1.9\sim4.1$배 정도로 위험도가 높았다. 10. 알레르기성 접촉 피부염을 종속변수로 같은 분석을 했을 때도 결과는 같았으나, 수용성 절삭유만 사용하는 군이 $2.7\sim9.7$배, 두 종류를 모두 사용하는 군에서는 $3.7\sim12.6$배 정도로 위험도가 증가한 것을 관찰할 수 있었다.