• Title/Summary/Keyword: comparative assessment

Search Result 942, Processing Time 0.027 seconds

A Comparative Research of Assessment System Development for Low Carbon and Sustainable Neighborhood (친환경 근린주구 인증제도 개발을 위한 국내외 인증제도 비교연구 : 탄소를 중심으로)

  • Shin, Eun-Mi;Lee, Byeongho;Shin, Sung-Woo
    • KIEAE Journal
    • /
    • v.13 no.3
    • /
    • pp.21-26
    • /
    • 2013
  • Recently, as the concern over environmental problem has been serious all over the world, carbon has become a key issue to mitigate the problem. In the field of Architecture, various sustainable assessment systems and LCCO2 assessment strategies have been developed, guiding low carbon building while planning. However, assessment system for low carbon neighborhood, which can be more efficient strategy, is still in the stage of research. In this paper, as a research for low carbon assessment system and planning guideline for neighborhood, scope meeting domestic condition has been set and sustainable assessment system for neighborhood, which is similar to low carbon concept, have been compared. LEED-Neighborhood Development, BREEAM-Communities, CASBEE-Urban Development, and GBCC-Apartment Houses were used for comparison. As a result, it is found that those systems has many differences in judging system, aggregating method, scope of evaluation, and relations with a building assessment system. The concern about carbon is not insufficient yet. Finally, assessment system for low carbon neighborhood, which is not only for establishing the plan, but also for giving guideline at the very first state of the plan, should be developed as fast as passible. With the result of this paper, establishment of assessment criteria and the way to measure quantitative $CO_2$ should be studied forward.

Comparative LCA of three types of Interior Panel (IP) in Electric Motor Unit (EMU) (전동차 내장패널(Interior Panel)에 대한 비교 전과정평가)

  • Choi, Yo-Han;Lee, Sang-Yong;Kim, Yong-Ki;Lee, Kun-Mo
    • Journal of the Korean Society for Railway
    • /
    • v.10 no.5
    • /
    • pp.596-599
    • /
    • 2007
  • A comparative Life Cycle Assessment (LCA) among three types of Electric Motor Unit (EMU) Interior Panel (IP) was conducted. A functional unit for comparative LCA is a weight of IP for 1 EMU. It is assumed that Manufacturing stage and its upstream processes, Use stage and End of Life (EoL) stage are included in the boundary of product system. For Use stage, the weight of IP causes electricity consumption. It is assumed that aluminum IP is recycled and the other IPs are incinerated at the EoL stage. As a comparison results, aluminum IP has much larger environmental impact (5.162pt) than others (FRP IP; 4.069pt, Phenol IP; 4.053pt) even though recycling consideration is included. The manufacturing stage of aluminum IP has relative big environmental impact (1.824pt) and this point make the most important difference from other IPs (FRP IP; 0.1617pt, Phenol IP; 0.4534pt)). Despite of large weight difference between FRP IP (888.96kg) and phenol IP (316kg), the final environmental impact result has only little difference (0.016pt, 0.39%). With this result, the EMU designer can choose IP with a consideration of the environmental performance of IP.

A Study on the Effect and Improvement Directions of KGBCC based on the Comparison of Green Residents Satisfaction (친환경 주거단지의 거주자 만족도 비교를 통한 친환경 건축물 인증제도 효과 및 개선방향 연구)

  • Kwon, Hyuk-Jin;Yeom, Dong-Woo;Lee, Kyu-In
    • KIEAE Journal
    • /
    • v.11 no.5
    • /
    • pp.79-90
    • /
    • 2011
  • The KGBCC(Korean Green Building Certification Criteria), which is the assessment standard of green buildings, is not enough to reflect all the current demands of residents. Therefore, the comparative analysis between the certification score and the residents' satisfaction of a promotional green apartment, a awarded green apartment, and a certified green building apartment was carried out to derive improvements of the KGBCC. The residents of selected three apartments were surveyed through the assessment items of the KGBCC. According to the research, the certified green building apartment shows the highest certification score and residents' satisfaction overall, compared with other two apartments. Finally, the improvements of KGBCC were determined through the reason of the residents' dissatisfaction. The KGBCC that is improved by this study can be used for the new assessment standard of green buildings.

A Comparative Analysis on the Methods of Quantifying Damages - Focused on the CISG - (손해배상액(損害賠償額) 산정방식(算定方式)에 관한 비교연구(比較硏究) - CISG를 중심으로 -)

  • Bae, Jun-Il
    • THE INTERNATIONAL COMMERCE & LAW REVIEW
    • /
    • v.16
    • /
    • pp.59-81
    • /
    • 2001
  • There are two methods of quantifying the damages when the contract is avoided. One is 'concret' assessment, the other is 'abstract' assessment. The former looks to the actual cost incurred by the aggrieved party in concluding a contract for the substitute transaction, while the latter is based on the market price. The concrete method of assessment forms the starting point in the Civil Law systems. In the Common Law systems, it is likewise available. The aggrieved party is entitled to recover the difference between the cost of cover or (as the case may be) the proceeds of resale and the contract price. Both systems also recognize the abstract method of assessment. If the aggrieved party does not resell or cover, damages are equal to the difference between the price fixed by the contract and the market price. The CISG and the UNIDROIT Principles recognize expressly both concrete and abstract methods. Under the relevant articles, the aggrieved party can recover the damages assessed by one of the methods as well as any further damages such as loss of profit, incidental and consequential damages.

  • PDF

A Comparative Study on the Domestic and Foreign Technology Assessment systems (국내외 기술사업평가시스템에 대한 비교 연구)

  • Hahn, hyuk;Choi, yoon-jeong;Park, Chang-kirl
    • Proceedings of the Korea Contents Association Conference
    • /
    • 2007.11a
    • /
    • pp.495-500
    • /
    • 2007
  • This study presents the case of technology assessment system as one of the major tools for R&D planning and analyzes the various cases of the domestic and foreign technology assessment systems to develop the differentiated and effective technology assessment system.

  • PDF

A Study for the Development of Korean Voice Assessment Model for the Patients with Voice Disorders: A Qualitative Study (음성장애 진단 및 평가에 관한 질적 연구: 진단 및 평가 모형 정립을 위한 기초연구)

  • Pyo, Hwa-Young;Sim, Hyun-Sub
    • Speech Sciences
    • /
    • v.14 no.2
    • /
    • pp.7-22
    • /
    • 2007
  • The purpose of this study was to develop a Korean assessment model for the patients with voice disorders. Interviews were conducted with 4 voice therapists and the results were analyzed by using a qualitative, constant-comparative design. According to the three themes emerged from the qualitative analysis, 10 subthemes were derived. The three main themes were 1) consideration on the disordered voice, 2) status quo of instrumental and perceptual evaluation, and 3) suggestions for the other voice therapists. The 10 subthemes can be summarized as the following: 1) judgment centering on the patients, 2) increase of the reliability of instrumental and perceptual evaluation, 3) voice therapists' positive participation in the assessment procedure of voice disorder.

  • PDF

Comparison of the Incineration Processes of Domestic Wastes Based on Life Cycle Assessment (생활폐기물(生活廢棄物) 소각(燒却) 처리공정(處理工程)의 전과정(全科程) 평가(平價)에 의한 비교(比較))

  • Jung, Woo-Jung;Lee, Sang-Don;Kim, Dong-Su
    • Journal of Environmental Impact Assessment
    • /
    • v.14 no.6
    • /
    • pp.443-453
    • /
    • 2005
  • For the purpose of the comparative environmental estimation of the incineration processes for domestic wastes, environmental impacts for several incineration processes for one ton of domestic wastes have been estimated by employing life cycle assessment as the environmental impact assessment method. The scheme of minimum production of environmental pollutants has been considered for three different incineration processes. The evaluation for latent influence on environment was carried out by using CML(Center of Environmental Science) method which was developed by University of Leyden in Netherlands based on the equivalency factor suggested by Korea Accreditation Board. The result of life cycle assessment has showed that the total cost analysis according to the amount of incinerating waste was dependent on the operating conditions of incineration process. In addition, the annual running cost for the incineration of one ton of wastes was estimated to be negatively dependent on the amount of wastes. The degree of environmental pollution was mainly due to the kinds of the wastes rather than by the amount of wastes.

A Study on the Substaintiality Program of Teaching Material on Environmental Impact Assessment - Comparative Study in Domestic and Foreign Teaching Materials - (환경영향평가 교재의 내실화 방안 - 국내외 도서의 비교검토를 통해 본 교재의 내실화 방안 -)

  • Kim, Im-Soon;Yang, Won-Ho;Choi, Won-Wook;Han, Sang-Wook
    • Journal of Environmental Impact Assessment
    • /
    • v.11 no.3
    • /
    • pp.205-221
    • /
    • 2002
  • Environmental impact assessment (EIA) is a tool used in planning development strategies and projects, and its use has been adopted into planning regulations in a number of countries. EIA has progressed from the consideration of pollution assessment, through the wider range of ecological assessment. Now EIA is required to consider the textbook of university students. Students taking lesson on EIA textbook are generally majoring in a variety of subjects, including environmental engineering, environmental health, environmental science, city planning, civil engineering, public policy, economics, and applied earth sciences. However, substantiality program of teaching material on EIA textbook has not been studied at expert society in the meantime, though a number of EIA textbook have been published every year in Korea. In current study, we presented the point at issue and improvement method of teaching material of EIA for student using domestic and foreign teaching materials and papers.

Comparative Study of Probabilistic Ecological Risk Assessment (PERA) used in Developed Countries and Proposed PERA approach for Korean Water Environment (확률생태위해성평가(PERA) 선진국 사례분석 및 국내수계에 적합한 PERA 기법 제안)

  • An, Youn-Joo;Nam, Sun-Hwa;Lee, Woo-Mi
    • Journal of Korean Society on Water Environment
    • /
    • v.25 no.4
    • /
    • pp.494-501
    • /
    • 2009
  • Probabilistic Ecological risk assessment (PERA) is extensive approach to qualify and quantify risk on the multi species based on species sensitivity distribution (SSD). As a while, deterministic ecological risk assessment (DERA) considers the comparison of predicted no-effect concentration (PNEC) and predicted exposure concentration (PEC). DERA is used to determine if there is potential risk or no risk, and it doesn't consider the nature variability and the species sensitivity. But PERA can be more realistic and reasonable approach to estimate likelihood or risk. In this study, we compared PERA used in developed countries, and proposed PERA applicable for the Korean water environment. Taxonomic groups were classified as "class" level including Actinopterygill, Branchiopoda, Chlorophyceae, Maxillapoda, Insects, Bivalvia, Gastropoda, Secernentea, Polychaeta, Monocotyldoneae, and Chanophyceae in this study. Statistical extrapolation method (SEM), statistical extrapolation method $_{acutechronicratio}$ ($SEM_{ACR}$) and assessment factor method (AFM) were used to calculate the ecological protective concentration based on qualitative and quantitative levels of taxonomic toxicity data. This study would be useful to establish the PERA for the protection of aquatic ecosystem in Korea.

A Study on the Comparative Analysis of Building Life Cycle Carbon Emission Assessment in Korea and China (한국과 중국의 건축물 전과정 탄소배출량 평가 비교분석에 관한 연구)

  • Zheng, Peng-Fei;Tae, Sung-Ho;Lim, Hyo-Jin;Kim, Hyeon-Suk
    • Proceedings of the Korean Institute of Building Construction Conference
    • /
    • 2023.05a
    • /
    • pp.155-156
    • /
    • 2023
  • This study aims to analyze the factors that cause differences in the evaluation results of the life cycle carbon emissions assessment of buildings in both Korea and China as part of the methodology research of building life cycle assessment for Chinese buildings to promote building life cycle assessment in China. Specifically, it examines the building LCA standards of Korea and the standard for building carbon emission calculation in China as mentioned in the green building certification systems of both countries. Based on the investigation of the two standards, the life cycle carbon emissions of the evaluation target building were evaluated using the building life cycle assessment methods of both countries, and the influencing factors that cause differences in the life cycle carbon emission assessment results of the two countries were analyzed.

  • PDF