직접전방 접근법을 통한 인공 고관절 치환술의 학습곡선 (Learning Curve of the Direct Anterior Approach for Hip Arthroplasty)
-
- 대한정형외과학회지
- /
- 제55권2호
- /
- pp.143-153
- /
- 2020
목적: 58예의 직접전방 접근법을 통한 인공 고관절 치환술의 임상결과와 학습곡선을 분석하여 학습능력이 향상되는 시점에 대하여 알아보고자 하였다. 대상 및 방법: 2016년 11월부터 2018년 11월까지 58명의 환자를 대상으로 직접전방 접근법을 사용한 인공 고관절 치환술을 시행하였다. 초기 시행한 29명과 후기 시행한 29명을 후향적으로 비교분석하였다. 수술시간과 합병증(대전자 견열 골절, 외측 대퇴피신경 손상, 이소성 골화증, 감염, 탈구 등)을 바탕으로 분석하였다. 통계적 방법은 양 군 간에 대응표본 T 검정, 카이제곱 검정과 누적합법(cumulative sum, CUSUM) 분석을 사용하였다. 결과: 수술 시간은 전치환술은 평균 132.1분, 반치환술은 평균 79.7분으로 양 군에서 유의한 차이를 보였다. 수술 기간에 따른 CUSUM 분석을 시행하였고, 전치환술에서는 16번째 증례, 반치환술에서는 14번째 증례부터 수술시간이 각각 평균 수술시간보다 감소하였다. 합병증으로 전반기에 5예, 후반기에 0예로 총 5예의 대전자 견열골절이 있었으며, 외측대퇴피하신경 손상은 전반기 8예, 후반기 2예로 총 10예, 이소성 골화증은 전반기 3예, 후반기 2예로 총 5예, 탈구와 감염은 각각 전반기 1예씩, 기타 합병증 3예가 있었다. 전반기 1년간 수술 중 발생한 대전자 견열골절은 5예(17.2%), 후반기에는 0예(0%)가 있었으며 이를 CUSUM 분석을 통해 모니터링하였으나 증례가 많지 않아 유의한 차이를 보이지는 않았다. 결론: 직접전방 접근법을 이용한 인공 고관절 치환술은 해부학적 이해가 선행되어야 하고, 수술 시야의 확보가 어렵기 때문에 습득하는 데 최소 30예 이상의 학습곡선이 필요하다.
연구배경: 치과계 특히 치과 의원들은 최근 수년간 보조 인력의 부족을 호소하고 있는 반면 치위생계에서는 미국 치과위생사와 같이 고유의 업무를 어느 정도 독자적으로 수행할 수 있는 구강 위생 전문가의 역할을 추구하고 있어 이러한 업무 범위의 조정과 치과 보조 인력의 양성에 대한 전반적인 논의가 절실하다. 연구방법: 이러한 논의에서 자주 언급되는 미국의 치과위생사와 치과 보조원제도에 대하여 미국 치과의사 협회(ADA), 미국 치과위생사 협회(ADHA), 미국 치과위생사 국가시험위원회(NBDHE), 미국 치과 보조원 협회 (ADAA), 미국 치과 보조원 국가시험위원회(DANB)에서 제공하는 면허취득을 위한 교육요건, 업무영역 등을 조사 분석하였다. 연구결과: 미국은 각 주별 제도가 서로 다르지만 일반적으로 치과위생사는 치위생 교육을 이수할 수 있는 기초 학습 능력 시험을 통과한 후에 2~3년의 전문학사 과정을 수료하고, NBDHE(National Board Dental Hygiene Examination)를 통해 면허를 취득한다. 이후, 주로 환자 검사, 구강 위생 관리 및 예방 처치와 관련된 업무를 수행한다. 치과 보조원(Dental Assitant)은 9~11개월 정도의 교육과정을 마친 후 기본적인 면허(General Chairside Assisting, GC) 취득을 위한 면허시험에 응시할 수 있고, 추가적인 업무를 위해서는 해당 업무에 대한 주별 자격시험 통과, 교육 이수 또는 학위취득, 일정 시간 및 기간 이상의 임상 경험 등이 요구된다. 결론: 우리나라의 의료 기사법과 시행령에서 지정하는 치과위생사의 업무 범위는 미국의 치과위생사와 치과 보조원의 업무를 모두 포함하고 있는데, 현재의 치과 보조 인력 부족을 해소하기 위해 미국과 같은 치과 보조원 제도를 도입한다면 이러한 업무 범위에 대한 조정과 구강 위생 관리 및 예방 업무에서의 치과위생사의 역할 확대 등의 제도적인 보완이 필요하고 이에 대한 구체적인 논의가 필요하다.
This Study involved the development of a survey form and the collection of data in an effort-to provide information which can be used in the improvement of nursing curricula. The data examined were the kinds courses currently being taught in the curricula of nursing education institutions throughout Korea, credits required for course completion, and year in-which courses are taken. For the purposes of this study, curricula were classified into college, nursing school and vocational school categories. Courses were directed into the 3 major categories of general education courses, supporting science courses and professional education course, and further subdirector as. follows: 1) General education (following the classification of Philip H. phoenix): a) Symbolics, b) Empirics, c) Aesthetics. 4) Synthetics, e) Ethics, f) Synoptic. 2) Supporting science: a) physical science, b) biological science, c) social science, d) behavioral science, e) Health science, f) Educations 3) Professional Education; a) basic courses, b) courses in each of the respective fields of nursing. Ⅰ. General Education aimed at developing the individual as a person and as a member of society is relatively strong in college curricula compared with the other two. a) Courses included in the category of symbolics included Korean language, English, German. Chines. Mathematics. Statics: Economics and Computer most college curricula included 20 credits. of courses in this sub-category, while nursing schools required 12 credits and vocational school 10 units. English ordinarily receives particularly heavy emphasis. b) Research methodology, Domestic affair and women & courtney was included under the category of empirics in the college curricula, nursing and vocational school do not offer this at all. c) Courses classified under aesthetics were physical education, drill, music, recreation and fine arts. Most college curricula had 4 credits in these areas, nursing school provided for 2 credits, and most vocational schools offered 10 units. d) Synoptic included leadership, interpersonal relationship, and communications, Most schools did not offer courses of this nature. e) The category of ethics included citizenship. 2 credits are provided in college curricula, while vocational schools require 4 units. Nursing schools do not offer these courses. f) Courses included under synoptic were Korean history, cultural history, philosophy, Logics, and religion. Most college curricular 5 credits in these areas, nursing schools 4 credits. and vocational schools 2 units. g) Only physical education was given every Year in college curricula and only English was given in nursing schools and vocational schools in every of the curriculum. Most of the other courses were given during the first year of the curriculum. Ⅱ. Supporting science courses are fundamental to the practice and application of nursing theory. a) Physical science course include physics, chemistry and natural science. most colleges and nursing schools provided for 2 credits of physical science courses in their curricula, while most vocational schools did not offer t me. b) Courses included under biological science were anatomy, physiologic, biology and biochemistry. Most college curricula provided for 15 credits of biological science, nursing schools for the most part provided for 11 credits, and most vocational schools provided for 8 units. c) Courses included under social science were sociology and anthropology. Most colleges provided for 1 credit in courses of this category, which most nursing schools provided for 2 creates Most vocational school did not provide courses of this type. d) Courses included under behavioral science were general and clinical psychology, developmental psychology. mental hygiene and guidance. Most schools did not provide for these courses. e) Courses included under health science included pharmacy and pharmacology, microbiology, pathology, nutrition and dietetics, parasitology, and Chinese medicine. Most college curricula provided for 11 credits, while most nursing schools provide for 12 credits, most part provided 20 units of medical courses. f) Courses included under education included educational psychology, principles of education, philosophy of education, history of education, social education, educational evaluation, educational curricula, class management, guidance techniques and school & community. Host college softer 3 credits in courses in this category, while nursing schools provide 8 credits and vocational schools provide for 6 units, 50% of the colleges prepare these students to qualify as regular teachers of the second level, while 91% of the nursing schools and 60% of the vocational schools prepare their of the vocational schools prepare their students to qualify as school nurse. g) The majority of colleges start supporting science courses in the first year and complete them by the second year. Nursing schools and vocational schools usually complete them in the first year. Ⅲ. Professional Education courses are designed to develop professional nursing knowledge, attitudes and skills in the students. a) Basic courses include social nursing, nursing ethics, history of nursing professional control, nursing administration, social medicine, social welfare, introductory nursing, advanced nursing, medical regulations, efficient nursing, nursing english and basic nursing, College curricula devoted 13 credits to these subjects, nursing schools 14 credits, and vocational schools 26 units indicating a severe difference in the scope of education provided. b) There was noticeable tendency for the colleges to take a unified approach to the branches of nursing. 60% of the schools had courses in public health nursing, 80% in pediatric nursing, 60% in obstetric nursing, 90% in psychiatric nursing and 80% in medical-surgical nursing. The greatest number of schools provided 48 crudites in all of these fields combined. in most of the nursing schools, 52 credits were provided for courses divided according to disease. in the vocational schools, unified courses are provided in public health nursing, child nursing, maternal nursing, psychiatric nursing and adult nursing. In addition, one unit is provided for one hour a week of practice. The total number of units provided in the greatest number of vocational schools is thus Ⅲ units double the number provided in nursing schools and colleges. c) In th leges, the second year is devoted mainly to basic nursing courses, while the third and fourth years are used for advanced nursing courses. In nursing schools and vocational schools, the first year deals primarily with basic nursing and the second and third years are used to cover advanced nursing courses. The study yielded the following conclusions. 1. Instructional goals should be established for each courses in line with the idea of nursing, and curriculum improvements should be made accordingly. 2. Course that fall under the synthetics category should be strengthened and ways should be sought to develop the ability to cooperate with those who work for human welfare and health. 3. The ability to solve problems on the basis of scientific principles and knowledge and understanding of man society should be fostered through a strengthening of courses dealing with physical sciences, social sciences and behavioral sciences and redistribution of courses emphasizing biological and health sciences. 4. There should be more balanced curricula with less emphasis on courses in the major There is a need to establish courses necessary for the individual nurse by doing away with courses centered around specific diseases and combining them in unified courses. In addition it is possible to develop skill in dealing with people by using the social setting in comprehensive training. The most efficient ratio of the study experience should be studied to provide more effective, interesting education Elective course should be initiated to insure a man flexible, responsive educational program. 5. The curriculum stipulated in the education law should be examined.
1. The 'Kao Zheng Pai(考證派) comes from the 'Zhe Zhong Pai' and is a school that is influenced by the confucianism of the Qing dynasty. In Japan Inoue Kinga(井上金娥), Yoshida Koton(吉田篁墩) became central members, and the rise of the methodology of historical research(考證學) influenced the members of the 'Zhe Zhong Pai', and the trend of historical research changed from confucianism to medicine, making a school of medicine based on the study of texts and proving that the classics were right. 2. Based on the function of 'Nei Qu Li '(內驅力) the 'Kao Zheng Pai', in the spirit of 'use confucianism as the base', researched letters, meanings and historical origins. Because they were influenced by the methodology of historical research(考證學) of the Qing era, they valued the evidential research of classic texts, and there was even one branch that did only historical research, the 'Rue Xue Kao Zheng Pai'(儒學考證派). Also, the 'Yi Xue Kao Zheng Pai'(醫學考證派) appeared by the influence of Yoshida Kouton and Kariya Ekisai(狩谷掖齋). 3. In the 'Kao Zheng Pai(考證派)'s theories and views the 'Yi Xue Kao Zheng Pai' did not look at medical scriptures like the "Huang Di Nei Jing"("黃帝內經") and did not do research on 'medical' related areas like acupuncture, the meridian and medicinal herbs. Since they were doctors that used medicine, they naturally were based on 'formulas'(方劑) and since their thoughts were based on the historical ideologies, they valued the "Shang Han Ja Bing Lun" which was revered as the 'ancestor of all formulas'(衆方之祖). 4. The lives of the important doctors of the 'Kao Zheng Pai' Meguro Dotaku(目黑道琢) Yamada Seichin(山田正珍), Yamada Kyoko(山田業廣), Mori Ritsi(森立之) Kitamura Naohara(喜多村直寬) are as follows. 1) Meguro Dotaku(目黑道琢 1739
1.The 'Kao Zheng Pai'(考證派) comes from the 'Zhe Zhong Pai(折衷派)' and is a school that is influenced by the confucianism of the Qing dynasty. In Japan Inoue Kinga(井上金峨), Yoshida Koton(古田篁墩