• 한국농촌건축학회논문집
• /
• 제11권4호
• /
• pp.25-34
• /
• 2009

The modern philosophy of historic conservation focuses on the permanence of the material aspects of monuments as historic evidence of the artistic achievement of the past. However, so strongly are European attitudes to architecture and its conservation embedded in modern conservation, that it has skewed all conservation thinking towards the concept of the European-type monument which emphasizes visual beauty through its material substance. Thus, some basic ideas of modern conservation seem ill-suited to East Asian architecture which is conceived in a different spirit from its European counterpart. The purposes of the paper are to discuss the need for approaches which are different from the modern Western view of conservation for East Asian architectural heritage, and to make suggestions for developing conservation principles more suited to the unique values and aesthetic sense of East Asian culture and architecture. Conservation principles in the East Asian societies are determined in relation to the spiritual and naturalistic sensibilities of East Asian culture and architecture.

• 대한건축학회논문집:계획계
• /
• 제35권10호
• /
• pp.53-62
• /
• 2019

The purpose of this study is to analyze the way historical heritage was dealt with during the massive urban development period of the 1960s through the case of Deoksugung Palace. The wall of Deoksugung Palace was rebuilt and relocated in 1961. Later, it was rebuilt and relocated again in 1968, and Daehanmun Gate was soon moved back too. I analyzed the opinions of the Seoul Metropolitan Government, the Cultural Heritage Committee, experts and citizens that occurred during this process and reached the following conclusion. First, in 1961, the existing stone walls of Deoksugung Palace were rebuilt rather than restored and conserved for the urbanscape at the time. Second, in the 1960s, the Cultural Heritage Committee focused on the conservation of the origin of Daehanmun Gate, while citizens valued the overall harmony and function of Deoksugung Palace. Third, unlike the 1970s project led by the president to renovate national security and national defense sites, there was a call from citizens to realize the preservation of Deoksugung Palace.

• 건축역사연구
• /
• 제32권2호
• /
• pp.7-19
• /
• 2023

This article focuses on the Namdaemum repair and the Seokguram restoration, which had begun in 1961, as an important repair conducted during the time of seeking the conservation principle of architectural heritage after liberation in Korea. Through the analysis of the principles described in the repair report issued after the two repairs, meeting records, and related expert announcements, it is shown that the principle of 'preservation of the historic state' had been established at Namdaemun repair and later have changed to the principle of 'restoration of the historic form' which means reconstruction in Seokguram restoration. By analyzing the minutes of the Cultural Heritage Committee's meeting on the repair of other cultural properties during this period, it is revealed that the key terms related to the preservation principle, 'historic form' and 'restoration', were given meaning as 'object' and 'method' of preservation, and then 'restoration of the historic form' has been gradually used as a conservation principle.

• 건축역사연구
• /
• 제25권1호
• /
• pp.59-68
• /
• 2016

There are many reasons of damage in Namhansanseong Yeojang. Lots of damage types are observed in each Yeojang. There are many types of damage factors but major damage factor is breakage by freezing and thawing. So Conduct non-destructive evaluation about damage factors in Namhansanseong Yeojang to analysis weathering factors in Yeojang by measuring directional microclimate. The study will pave the way for conservation management in Namhansanseong by suggesting the conservation calendar about weather condition and damage factors.

• 건축역사연구
• /
• 제21권4호
• /
• pp.25-36
• /
• 2012

This paper is to review the conclusions of the Athens conference that has so far contributed to the conservation world. It is normally called the conclusions of the Athens conference as the Athens charter. But the conclusions of the Athens are not as same as the Athens Charter regarding the contents. The former had more valuable contents than the latter regarding historic monuments. And the report of the Athens conference including 56 articles and 500 pages with 55 photos was published in 1933 by the International Museums Office. But little attention has been given to the report of the Athens conference. Therefore the point I want to make is to review to the report in order to understand the agenda of the conference and to examine the Anastylosis in Acropolis. In conclusion, these agendas and the articles in the report show us that the conference was sort of milestone with some advanced modern philosophical and technical concepts about conservation and restoration of historic monuments. Also when the term of anastylosis turns to reconstruction in archaeological sites, we are going to face with the problems of authenticity.

• 한국주거학회논문집
• /
• 제17권2호
• /
• pp.87-96
• /
• 2006

Since the idea of registering architectural heritage from the early 20th century was introduced as part of the code in the Cultural Heritage Protection Law in July, 2001, more systematic and flexible application the code has been in great demand. It is the aim of this thesis that we preserve modern buildings and then use this research data what find our modern history. So we should find connection of modem and tradition with the overcome of the feeling of being victimized. Accordingly, based on preservation cases and finding of modern house heritage, it is the aim of this thesis that we find the way of the best use. The purpose of this research is to establish a more comprehensive and commonsensical guideline for the preservation of modern architecture satisfying both the government and the registering party, based on more thorough architectural analysis of residential edifices. The results of this study were as follows: (1) It is necessary for application and conservation by point, area and network method. (2) It is needed that periodically check and record central system for the purpose of the management of those. (3) It's consider that develop of conservation method on co-ownership with citizen by house personality.

• Architectural research
• /
• 제25권3호
• /
• pp.41-51
• /
• 2023

Building restoration is a complex process with a high level of uncertainty. Restoration professionals can significantly benefit from the well-established discipline of project management to achieve their targets; however, available evidence shows that the use of the project management body of knowledge in restoration projects is far from the desired level. Several historical organisations have since been established with the goal of preserving and governing cultural identity, and numerous studies have supported the need of preserving architectural heritage. Many owners, investors, academics, and developers believe that it would be considerably more expensive to renovate and restore an old building than to create a new one. Although the project management process is generally recognised, the concept of project management for architectural heritage projects differs due to the uniqueness of each project. It differs from many construction projects in terms of the need for research-based practices to define scope, planning, scheduling, supervision,decision-making,and also performance. The Greco-Roman Museum in Alexandria's planning, design, and building phases are being studied with the aim of identifying and analysing the variables that contribute to project delays. Three project management pillars were established as a result of gathering this data from the project's stakeholders: the first pillar addresses time management for the existing phase and how it will be incorporated into the new extension phase; the second pillar addresses performance in relation to project management issues in the delivery of the best quality of a construction project; and the third pillar addresses the scope of the new extension because it will significantly impact the other two pillars. This paper argues that a contemporary perspective which utilizes project management tools and techniques can contribute to the conservation of architectural heritage in line with the conservation principles.

• 헤리티지:역사와 과학
• /
• 제47권3호
• /
• pp.208-223
• /
• 2014

최근 2008년 화재로 소실되었다가 복구된 숭례문(崇禮門)의 단청 문제가 제기되면서 문화재 보존에 있어서의 전통기술 적용 문제가 논쟁거리가 되었다. 본고에서는 문화재 보존에 있어서의 전통기술의 의미를 살펴보고자 하였다. 일반적으로 전통기술에 대한 이해는 기본적으로 '전통'에 대한 관념에 기초하고 있다. 전통은 '고정불변하는 존재'가 아니라 '계승 발전하는 존재'로 보아 '살아있는 존재'로 규정되며, 그에 따라 '무형문화재로서의 전통연행, 전통공예 등'은 '고정된 실체를 가지고 있지 않는 것'으로 규정하고 있으며, 그에 따라 문화재 보존의 기본원칙인 '원형 보존'에서 '원형'이라는 것이 무엇인지를 정확히 규정하기 어려운 존재로 보고 있다. 한국의 경우 이렇게 원형을 규정하기 어려운 '무형문화재로서의 전통기술'이 유형문화재의 보존현장에 적용될 때 그 개념이 명확히 하지 않음으로 인해 보존 현장에서 여러가지 문제를 야기하고 있다. '전통기술'의 적용범위와 한계에 대한 논의 없이 현장에 적용되기 때문이다. 즉 '전통재료'를 사용하여 '전통기술'로 수복을 하는 것이 허용되는 것은 어디까지이며 문화재의 보존에서 이것이 어떠한 의미를 갖는가에 대한 논의가 결여되어 있기 때문이다. 본고에서는 이러한 전통기술의 적응문제를 국제적인 보존원칙 변화 과정의 검토와 함께 고찰해 보았다. 이러한 고찰 결과 '무형문화재로서의 전통기술'의 보존도 중요하지만 '유형문화재에 남아 있는 기술', 더 나아가 '제작 당시의 기술을 담고 있는 원래의 재료 보존'이 더욱 중요한 문제라는 점이 고려되어야 한다는 점을 강조하고자 한다.

• 한국문화재보존과학회:학술대회논문집
• /
• 한국문화재보존과학회 2005년도 제21회 발표논문집
• /
• pp.29-30
• /
• 2005

• 대한건축학회논문집:계획계
• /
• 제35권8호
• /
• pp.89-100
• /
• 2019

The purpose of this study is to critically review the repair works of Seokguram architecture and to search for its original form and space. Seokguram's architectural form has been transformed throughout three repair works. The first transformation occurred during the repair work of the Colonial Government in 1913-1915, and the second occurred during the repair work of the Colonial Government in 1920-1923. The repair work done by the Korean Government in 1961-1964 also caused a severe change in the architectural form and space of Seokguram architecture. The more the repair work was added to Seokguram, the more its original form flew away like a mirage. Through the three repair works, the spatial composition of Seokguram changed in the following directions: from ((front chamber + passageway) + main chamber) to (front chamber + (passageway + main chamber)) through the second repair work, from (front chamber + (passageway + main chamber)) to (front chamber + passageway + main chamber) through the last repair work. Although the compositional space hierarchy of Seokguram was maintained during the first repair work, the architectural form based on the dry method was changed to the form based on the wet method. The Korean government's repair work was a tragedy for the 'Seokguram conservation project' that the people who led the conservation process misunderstood the architectural nature of Seokguram.