• Title/Summary/Keyword: 판례분석

Search Result 219, Processing Time 0.021 seconds

A Study of Children's Statements in sexual violence cases of children less than the age of 13 -Focusing on video-recorded hearsay evidence- (13세미만 아동성폭력 재판에서의 아동진술연구 -영상매체를 통한 전문 증거를 중심으로-)

  • Park, Yeon Ju;Kim, Jung Woo
    • Journal of the Korean Society of Child Welfare
    • /
    • no.55
    • /
    • pp.87-111
    • /
    • 2016
  • This study aimed to examine how video-recorded hearsay statements are taken in trial with regard to testimony of children less than the age of 13 in terms of children's rights, and to assess policy implications for the purpose of improving the current system. This study analyzed the precedents in accordance with their facts and contents. The analysis of the contents dealt with the main issues of trials concerning the sexual violence of children less than the age of 13. Specifically, This study selected precedents dealing with video-recorded hearsay statements, which are children's indirect statement, as core legal issues; examined the credibility(probative power) and admissibility of video-recorded statements; and prepared systemic alternatives in accordance with the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child, the international standards for the protection of children's rights. As a result, this study proposed creating and utilizing indicators to assess evidence admissibility and the credibility of video-recoded statements in trial, thus reducing judgement through judges' discretion. Also proposed are new regulations with regard to cross-examination coverage of the hearsay statement of a child in a sexual violence trial of concerning children less than the age of 13. This study suggests an improvement in legal policies, based given that children's rights are more vulnerable than those of adults in trial. Nevertheless, this study is limited in that it selected and reviewed only among precedents that are in the public record.

Analysis of Precedents Related to Child Abuse Cases in Child Care Centers and Its Implications (어린이집 아동학대 사건의 판례분석과 시사점 : 아동학대범죄의 처벌 등에 관한 특례법을 중심으로)

  • Jeon, Byeong-Joo;Kim, Keon-Ho
    • The Journal of the Korea Contents Association
    • /
    • v.17 no.4
    • /
    • pp.209-218
    • /
    • 2017
  • In Korea, child abuse in child care centers occurs continuously, and it is becoming a social problem. The government has intensified the supervision of management in child care centers, and through strong countermeasures and prevention against child abuse, it enacted the special act on child abuse in oder to enable children to become healthy members of society. In this study, this researcher gasped the legal application on child abusers, and analysed how the punishment for abusers changed according to the application of the special act on child abuse, through examining precedents of child abuse in child care centers. 21 cases related to child abuse cases were collected by searching homepage of the supreme court and each district court in this study. As a result of analyzing the precedents, the sentence of the defendant did not increase greatly, and it differed from the criminal identification of the people in cases of child abuse on which the special act on child abuse was applied. Therefore, it can be seen that there is a demand for more rigorous legal application for abusers in order to prevent child abuse in child care centers.

An Analytical Study on Precedents of Emotional Child Abuse at Daycare Centers of Korea : Focusing on Emotional Abuse Type, Issues, and Preventive Measures (국내 어린이집의 아동학대 판례 분석 연구 : 정서적 학대 유형, 쟁점 사안 및 예방대책을 중심으로)

  • Youn, Ki-Hyok
    • Journal of Convergence for Information Technology
    • /
    • v.7 no.5
    • /
    • pp.157-167
    • /
    • 2017
  • This study aims to establish measures to prevent emotional abuse by analyzing court precedents related to emotional abuse at daycare centers of Korea. For this, ten precedents of first trial and four precedents of appellate trial related to emotional abuse were analyzed in depth. In the results of study, there were diverse types of emotional abuse at daycare centers such as assaulting(hitting head, face, and buttocks with hands and feet), throwing things, neglecting, forcefully feeding food, stopping mouth with handkerchief and wet tissue, skipping meals, and showing scary images. And the main issues of precedents included the matter of justifiable act as circumstances precluding wrongfulness, and the matter of applying the joint penal provision. Based on such results, the measures to prevent emotional abuse at daycare centers were suggested.

Investigation of Disputes for Nominated Sub-contractor(NSC) -Focused on the Judicial Precedent of NSC issues in Singapore, Malaysia and Hong Kong- (아시아 건설 시장에서의 지정하도급자(NSC)문제에 관한 연구 - 싱가포르, 말레이시아 그리고 홍콩의 판례를 중심으로 -)

  • Cho, Jaeyong;Kim, Junggon;Park, Hyeonggeun;Kim, Youngsuk;Lee, Boknam
    • Korean Journal of Construction Engineering and Management
    • /
    • v.16 no.6
    • /
    • pp.112-123
    • /
    • 2015
  • Many disputes are happened with various causes in overseas construction projects. One of major disputes is closely related with nominated subcontractors (NSC). This paper investigates 30 judical precedents for Singapore, Malaysia and Hongkong to analyze the detailed disputes related with the NSC, and then the judical precedents are classified into 6 categories: Delay and Defect Trouble (T1), Contract Relation (T2), Payment Trouble (T3), Set-off (T4), Liquidation (T5) and so forth (T6). According to the analytical results, the frequency of occurrence of disputes is considerably related with social and economical changes, and the dispute between NSC and employer for residential and commercial building projects is the most frequently happened case. As the results of analysis, therefore, it is concluded that the employer needs to response aggressively to the problems related with NSC, and it is also important to make the council for communication among related bodies. Furthermore, the institutional reform that make the role and the responsibility of employer consistent under considering contract terms and conditions is considered as the most important and fundamental issue.

A Comparative Study on the Legal Responsibilities Classified by Time Slots and Educational Participants Using School Safety Accident Cases of Korea and China (한국과 중국의 학교안전사고 판례에 기초한 시간대별 및 교육주체별 책임에 대한 비교연구)

  • Piao, Li-Na;Lee, Il-Yong
    • Korean Journal of Comparative Education
    • /
    • v.28 no.1
    • /
    • pp.25-49
    • /
    • 2018
  • The rate of school safety accident is increasing gradually. Recently bullying at school also became harsh, the number of related cases is increasing. The purpose of this study is to compare laws between Korea and China, to analyze law cases related with school safety accidents, and to suggest alternatives for the People's Republic of China. Total 80 cases were used. The research results are as follows. First, responsibility decision criteria of both countries are different because of related laws and regulations. Second, responsibility ranges of educational participants are different because of responsibility reversion principle and school safety accident policy. Third, through the results of comparison, prevention of school safety accident, preparation of legal ground, and supplement of present laws were suggested for the future of China.

A Graphical Understanding on the Protection of Advertising as Expression (표현으로서의 광고의 보호 정도에 대한 탐구: 인격권 관련 판례에 대한 분석을 중심으로)

  • Lee, Jae-Jin
    • Korean journal of communication and information
    • /
    • v.32
    • /
    • pp.333-367
    • /
    • 2006
  • This paper attempted to examine to what extent advertising as expression has been constitutionally protected through an analysis on the reputational-right-related legal cases. In order to make the understanding more clearly, this paper applied Van Alstyne's graphical depiction on how commercial speech is protected compared with other constitutional rights such as political speech, private expression, defamation, and obscene expression. Through the analysis, this paper found out that first, in the legal cases, there has been no consideration on whether the status of the plaintiff is public figure or private figure, whereas in the libel cases, Korean courts has made a distinction between public figure and private figure since 2002; second, when the case is concerned with corporations, the Korean courts do not give consideration on the status of corporation, while the status of corporation is a somewhat important factor in deciding the degree of responsibility in the U.S.; third, even though it is clear that advertising in Korea is being protected as expression, it is nebulous whether it is well balanced with other personal rights that are constitutionally protected. Conclusively, applying the Alstyne's graphical depiction on Korean advertising, it advertising as expression in Korea is being provided lower protection than defamation. To put it differently, like the case in the U.S., advertising, although it is allegedly protected as expression, does not yet enjoy full-fledged constitutional protection in Korean society. Rather, there must be some actions to be taken to enhance the degree of protection of advertising.

  • PDF