1. Introduction
Disasters are complex crises that simultaneously disrupt human systems of perception, judgment, and action. In disaster environments such as fires, large-scale traffic accidents, structural collapses, and mass-casualty incidents, individuals are exposed not only to physical hazards but also to intense psychological stress. These conditions often undermine cognitive frameworks and decision-making processes developed under normal circumstances, making it difficult to maintain rational judgment and appropriate behavioral responses [1,2].
Firefighters and emergency responders experience significantly greater psychological burdens than the general population because they must make rapid decisions while simultaneously protecting lives and property under highly uncertain and dangerous conditions. Even highly trained personnel equipped with advanced expertise, extensive experience, and sufficient resources remain vulnerable to judgment errors when exposed to extreme stress and uncertainty [3,4]. These observations suggest that disaster response effectiveness cannot be explained solely by technical competence or operational procedures but is closely associated with psychological stability and self-regulation [5].
Contemporary firefighting and disaster management systems have achieved substantial advances through standardized operating procedures, technological modernization, simulation-based training, and resilience-oriented organizational management [5–7]. Nevertheless, considerable differences in response outcomes continue to be observed among responders operating under similar environmental conditions, organizational structures, and training systems [8]. Such differences indicate that psychological factors play a critical role in determining the success or failure of disaster response activities [5–8].
Response failures commonly observed in disaster situations generally appear in two contrasting forms. One involves delayed judgment, avoidance, or response paralysis caused by excessive risk perception and fear [1]. The other involves reckless decision-making and excessive intervention resulting from overconfidence and risk underestimation [4]. Although these behavioral patterns appear opposite, both can be interpreted as consequences of failures in psychological regulation and decision-making balance [2,3].
Recent studies in disaster psychology have increasingly emphasized that human responses to disasters are influenced not only by technical skills and organizational systems but also by cognitive regulation, emotional control, and resilience under uncertainty [5,6,9]. Consequently, understanding the psychological mechanisms that stabilize perception, judgment, and action has become an important research topic in disaster science.
Accordingly, this study reinterprets the concept of Junghwa (中和), traditionally understood as balance and harmonization in East Asian thought, as a psychological regulation principle applicable to disaster response [10–12]. Junghwa is not viewed as a static midpoint but as a dynamic process through which individuals continuously regulate perception, judgment, and action in response to changing circumstances [10,11]. From this perspective, Junghwa functions as a mechanism for preventing psychological deviations toward excessive avoidance or excessive intervention while maintaining adaptive and sustainable disaster response behaviors [12].
Furthermore, this study introduces an entropy-oriented perspective to explain how psychological imbalance contributes to uncertainty, resource consumption, and response inefficiency during disasters [13–15]. Entropy theory suggests that increasing uncertainty and disorder can undermine system stability and decision-making effectiveness [13–15]. By integrating disaster psychology, Junghwa, and entropy theory, this study seeks to establish a human-centered theoretical framework for understanding disaster response behavior and decision-making stability under conditions of uncertainty.
Therefore, the purpose of this study is to reconstruct the concept of Junghwa within the context of disaster psychology and disaster science and to propose an integrative theoretical framework for psychological regulation, uncertainty management, and sustainable disaster response.
2. Representation of the Human Psyche
In disaster response situations, the human psyche exists as an abstract internal state and is externally represented through perception, judgment, and action. In other words, the psyche transcends a purely psychological construct and becomes actualized as concrete behavioral patterns and decision-making forms under the extreme conditions of disasters [3,5]. Hence, this section examines how the human psyche is represented in disasters and how such representations structurally influence disaster response behaviors.
2.1 Concept of the Psyche and Its Manifestation in Disaster Situations
The human psyche is composed of a complex interplay of emotion, cognition, and volition, maintaining a relatively stable balance under normal conditions. However, in disaster situations, intense external stimuli, time pressure, and survival threats cause this balance to collapse rapidly or become excessively amplified in a particular direction [1–4]. This is because disasters act as triggering conditions that rapidly intensify latent psychological tendencies.
For firefighting and emergency response personnel, psychological manifestations during disasters extend beyond emotional reactions and translate into life-critical judgments and actions. Various psychological elements, such as fear, responsibility, sense of duty, overconfidence, and helplessness, operate simultaneously, and the balance among these elements determines the quality and safety of response actions [4–6].
2.2 Types of Psychological Representation in Disaster Situations
During disasters, the human psyche is represented in three main forms. First is the avoidant representation, characterized by delayed judgment or response paralysis due to excessive risk perception. In this state, the psyche is dominated by fear and anxiety, with risk avoidance as the primary behavior [1,2].
Second is the excessive representation, where individuals perceive risks as controllable or overestimate their capabilities, leading to reckless or overly aggressive responses. This psychologically biased state, driven by excessive confidence or responsibility, threatens individual responders and organizational safety [4,8].
Third is the regulatory representation, where risks are accurately perceived while emotional reactions are appropriately regulated, allowing responders to maintain an optimal response intensity. This study assumes that regulatory representation constitutes the most ideal and sustainable form of psychological manifestation in disaster response [5,6]. Such representations are structurally consistent with behavioral barriers and response types identified in disaster psychology and resilience studies [5–7].
2.3 Structural Link Between Psychological Representation and Perception–Judgment–Action
In disaster situations, the psyche is represented through a sequential process of perception, judgment, and action. During risk perception, identical stimuli may be overestimated or underestimated depending on psychological states. During judgment, emotionally driven cognition increases the likelihood of extreme decision-making [1,4]. These judgments are subsequently translated into concrete response behaviors during the action stage.
Within this chain, the psyche functions as a core variable mediating perception and judgment. Hence, disaster response failures can be understood primarily as failures of psychological representation rather than deficiencies in technical skills or procedural compliance [5,8].
2.4 Psychological Representation and Disaster Response Failure
Disaster response failures are often attributed to individual judgment errors or violations of regulations. However, fundamentally, they can be interpreted as collapses in psychological representation. Avoidant representation leads to delayed responses and rescue failures, while excessive representation results in safety accidents and secondary damage. Although these two forms appear opposite, they share the same underlying issue—failure of psychological regulation [1,4,8].
2.5 Theoretical Connection Between Psychological Representation and Junghwa
The psychological representations discussed in this section are directly linked to Junghwa (中和). Junghwa is a principle of psychological regulation that buffers the two extremes of avoidant and excessive representations while sustaining regulatory representation [10–12].
2.6 Interaction Between Disasters and the Human Psyche
Disasters fundamentally destabilize human cognitive systems and psychological equilibrium. Perceived as survival threats, disasters rapidly activate primal emotions such as fear, anxiety, and helplessness [3], causing survival-oriented responses to override rational judgment. Furthermore, disasters undermine judgment criteria based on prior experience and established rules, leading to the collapse of meaning systems and increased decision-making confusion. Hence, cognitive narrowing and extreme behaviors are reinforced [1,2].
For firefighting and emergency response personnel, disasters directly test psychological stability and judgment balance. Therefore, response failures often stem from failures in psychological regulation rather than from the magnitude of the disaster itself [5,6].
3. Firefighting and Disaster-Scientific Reinterpretation of Junghwa (中和)
3.1 Necessity for a Theoretical Transformation of Junghwa
Traditionally, Junghwa has been understood as a concept regulating inherent human dispositions and maintaining harmony. However, such discussions have largely remained within the contexts of everyday life, ethics, and moral cultivation, limiting their explanatory power for human behavior under extreme conditions such as disasters [10–12]. Since disasters activate qualitatively different psychological mechanisms characterized by uncertainty, time pressure, and survival threats, Junghwa requires theoretical transformation to accommodate these contexts.
3.2 Psychological Imbalance and Polarization of Response Behaviors
Both excessive responses and response paralysis in disaster situations result from psychological imbalance. This suggests that disaster response failures should not be reduced to insufficient experience or procedural noncompliance. Instead, they should be understood as manifestations of structural vulnerabilities in human cognition and psychological regulation [1,2,4]. Under conditions of extreme uncertainty, individuals may either overestimate risks and avoid action or underestimate risks and engage in excessive intervention, both of which undermine response effectiveness [8,9].
3.3 Redefining Junghwa in Firefighting and Disaster Contexts
This study redefines Junghwa in disaster response contexts as a principle of judgment stabilization. Rather than representing a static midpoint, Junghwa is understood as a dynamic regulatory mechanism that continuously balances perception, judgment, and action under changing disaster conditions [10,11].
This interpretation is consistent with Yao's explanation that Confucian harmony is maintained through adaptive regulation in response to changing circumstances [12].
It functions as an internal reference point that prevents the psyche from deviating toward the extremes of fear or overconfidence while maintaining adaptive and sustainable response behaviors [10–12].
3.4 Junghwa and Disaster Response Judgment Capacity
Junghwa serves as a psychological precondition that allows technically accumulated skills, operational experience, and training-derived competencies to be expressed effectively during actual disasters. Even highly trained responders may fail to utilize their capabilities appropriately when psychological regulation collapses [5,6]. Therefore, Junghwa functions not merely as a philosophical concept but as a foundational psychological condition supporting effective disaster response capacity and resilient decision-making under uncertainty [7,9].
4. Junghwa from the Perspective of Disaster Response Resources and Entropy
4.1 Structural Limitations of Disaster Response Resources
Disaster response inherently involves controlling uncertain situations with limited resources, including personnel, equipment, information, and time. As disaster operations continue, accumulated fatigue, equipment degradation, information overload, and judgment deterioration gradually amplify systemic instability across response activities [5–7]. Consequently, disaster response can be understood not only as a technical process but also as a continuous effort to manage resource constraints and organizational stability.
4.2 Interpreting Disaster Response Through the Concept of Entropy
The depletion of resources and the increase in instability can be interpreted through the concept of entropy. In systems theory, entropy refers to the tendency of systems to move toward disorder and uncertainty over time [13–15]. Within disaster response environments, entropy is reflected in declining situational awareness, communication breakdowns, reduced coordination efficiency, and weakened decision-making capacity. Thus, disaster response may be conceptualized as a process of continuously controlling entropy under conditions of uncertainty.
4.3 Correlation Between Entropy Increase and Response Failure
As entropy increases rapidly, the likelihood of judgment errors, communication failures, and safety accidents also increases. Excessive uncertainty may result in delayed decision-making, response paralysis, or loss of operational control [13,15]. Conversely, attempts to suppress entropy through excessive control and rigid procedures may produce overly conservative responses, reducing operational flexibility and increasing overall disaster impacts [9]. Therefore, both uncontrolled entropy growth and excessive entropy suppression can negatively affect disaster response effectiveness.
4.4 Entropy-Regulatory Function of Junghwa
Junghwa does not seek to minimize or maximize entropy. Rather, it functions as a principle for regulating entropy at an appropriate level. From the perspective of Junghwa, disaster response resources should be allocated gradually and adjusted flexibly according to changing situational demands [10–12]. In this sense, Junghwa serves as a balancing mechanism that maintains adaptive stability while preventing both excessive disorder and excessive rigidity.
4.5 Organizational-Level Junghwa and Sustainability
Junghwa extends beyond individual psychological regulation and can be applied as an organizational operating principle. When incorporated into staffing rotations, command structures, resource allocation strategies, and response-phase management, Junghwa may contribute to organizational sustainability by preventing excessive resource consumption and reducing systemic instability [5–7]. Accordingly, Junghwa can be interpreted not only as a psychological concept but also as a strategic framework for maintaining long-term resilience and sustainable disaster response capability.
5. Application to Firefighting and Emergency Response Education and Organizational Management
5.1 Limitations of Existing Training Systems
Current firefighting and emergency response training systems primarily emphasize procedural accuracy, technical proficiency, and operational standardization. While these approaches are effective in reducing technical errors and improving task performance, they exhibit structural limitations in preventing psychological collapse and judgment failures under extreme disaster conditions [5,8]. Consequently, existing training frameworks may be insufficient for preparing responders to manage uncertainty, emotional stress, and cognitive instability during actual disasters.
5.2 Direction of Junghwa-Based Disaster Response Education
Junghwa-based disaster response education reframes disaster response not merely as the execution of technical procedures but as the maintenance of psychological and judgmental balance under uncertainty. Such an approach incorporates emotional regulation, balanced risk perception, adaptive decision-making, and judgment stabilization training [10–12]. From this perspective, responders are trained not only to perform tasks correctly but also to regulate excessive fear, overconfidence, and emotional bias during disaster operations [5,7].
Furthermore, Junghwa-oriented education may contribute to strengthening organizational resilience by promoting flexible thinking and adaptive responses rather than rigid adherence to procedures alone [6,7]. This educational approach supports the development of responders capable of maintaining stable performance in complex and rapidly changing disaster environments.
5.3 Organizational Management and Policy Applications
The concept of Junghwa can be extended beyond individual education and applied to organizational management and disaster response policy. Principles of balanced regulation may be incorporated into personnel deployment systems, shift scheduling, command structure design, and resource allocation strategies [5–7]. Such applications can reduce excessive workload concentration, prevent decision-making fatigue, and enhance long-term organizational sustainability.
From a policy perspective, Junghwa may serve as a guiding principle for balancing operational efficiency, responder safety, and resource conservation. Accordingly, Junghwa can be interpreted as both a psychological regulation framework and an organizational management strategy that supports sustainable disaster response capability under conditions of uncertainty [9,12].
6. Discussion
This study reinterprets disaster response failures through the lens of psychological regulation failure. Conventional disaster research has primarily focused on technology, operational procedures, and institutional systems. While these approaches have contributed substantially to improving disaster response capacity, they have provided limited explanations for variations in human behavior and judgment under conditions of extreme uncertainty. Accordingly, the present study complements the limitations of technology- and institution-centered perspectives by emphasizing psychological regulation as a critical determinant of disaster response effectiveness [5–7].
The findings suggest that disaster response failures may be understood not merely as technical errors or procedural violations but as manifestations of psychological imbalance. Avoidant responses characterized by excessive fear and response paralysis, as well as excessive responses driven by overconfidence and risk underestimation, represent two opposing forms of the same underlying problem—failure of psychological regulation [1–4]. From this perspective, disaster response effectiveness depends not only on technical competence but also on the ability to maintain balanced perception, judgment, and action under uncertainty.
Junghwa functions as a higher-order regulatory principle that integrates these opposing tendencies and promotes adaptive behavioral regulation. Unlike conventional interpretations that emphasize static balance, the present study conceptualizes Junghwa as a dynamic process of continuously regulating psychological states in response to changing environmental conditions [10–12]. This interpretation extends the concept of Junghwa beyond philosophical discourse and positions it as a practical framework for understanding disaster response behavior.
Furthermore, when combined with entropy-oriented perspectives, Junghwa provides a theoretical framework capable of explaining how individuals and organizations regulate uncertainty and maintain operational stability. Entropy theory suggests that increasing disorder and uncertainty can weaken decision-making effectiveness and organizational resilience [13–15]. Accordingly, Junghwa may be interpreted as a regulatory mechanism that prevents both uncontrolled entropy growth and excessive rigidity, thereby supporting sustainable disaster response systems.
The Junghwa-based disaster response psychological theory proposed in this study can be empirically validated through future research. Avoidant, excessive, and regulatory psychological representations may be measured through surveys, scenario-based simulations, and field case analyses. Previous studies have reported significant associations between psychological factors, judgment errors, and behavioral performance in high-risk environments [1–9]. In addition, future studies involving firefighters, emergency medical personnel, and disaster response organizations may further verify the applicability and validity of the proposed framework.
Therefore, this study provides a theoretical foundation for integrating disaster psychology, Junghwa, and entropy theory and suggests a new human-centered approach to understanding psychological regulation and decision-making stability in disaster response.
7. Conclusion
The success or failure of disaster response depends not only on equipment, operational procedures, and institutional systems but also on the stability and balance of the human psyche. This study reconstructed the Myeongri concept of Junghwa (中和) as a human-centered behavioral theory within firefighting and disaster science and proposed an integrative theoretical framework for understanding psychological regulation, decision-making stability, and response behaviors in disaster contexts.
The findings suggest that disaster response failures may be interpreted as consequences of psychological imbalance rather than solely as technical deficiencies or procedural violations. Avoidant responses characterized by excessive fear and response paralysis, as well as excessive responses driven by overconfidence and risk underestimation, can both be understood as manifestations of failures in psychological regulation. In contrast, Junghwa represents a regulatory state that supports balanced perception, judgment, and action under conditions of uncertainty [10–12].
Furthermore, by integrating Junghwa with entropy-oriented perspectives, this study extends the concept beyond individual psychological regulation and applies it to organizational resilience and sustainable disaster response management. From this perspective, Junghwa functions as a mechanism for regulating uncertainty, maintaining operational stability, and preventing both excessive rigidity and uncontrolled disorder within disaster response systems [13–15].
The Junghwa-based disaster response psychological theory proposed in this study extends beyond a conceptual framework and possesses substantial potential for empirical validation. Avoidant, excessive, and regulatory psychological representations may be measured through surveys, scenario-based simulations, and field case analyses. Future studies involving firefighters, emergency medical personnel, and disaster response organizations may investigate the relationships among psychological regulation, risk perception, judgment stability, and response performance [1–9].
In addition, new Junghwa-based psychological regulation scales may be developed and validated based on the theoretical framework proposed in this study. Educational programs incorporating Junghwa principles may also be designed and evaluated by comparing pre- and post-training changes in psychological stability, judgment consistency, and response safety [5–7].
Therefore, this study contributes to expanding disaster research beyond technology- and institution-centered approaches by introducing a human-centered perspective grounded in psychological regulation. It is expected that future empirical research will further establish the practical applicability of Junghwa in disaster response education, organizational management, and policy development.
참고문헌
- J. Leach, "Why People 'Freeze' in an Emergency: Temporal and Cognitive Constraints on Survival Responses." Aviation, Space and Environmental Medicine, 75:6, pp.539-542, (2004).
- J. Leach, "Cognitive Paralysis in an Emergency: T he Role of the Supervisory Attentional System." Aviation, Space and Environmental Medicine, 76:2, pp.134-136, (2005).
- C. A. Morgan III, G. Hazlett, S. Wang, E. G. Richardson, P. Schnurr, S. M. Southwick, "Symptoms of Dissociation in Humans Experiencing Acute, Uncontrollable Stress." American Journal of Psychiatry, 158:8, pp.1239-1247, (2001). https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.158.8.1239
- G. Klein, Sources of Power: How People Make Decisions, MIT Press, Cambridge, MA, (1998).
- K. E. Weick, K. M. Sutcliffe, Managing the Unexpected: Sustained Performance in a Complex World, 3rd ed., Wiley, Hoboken, NJ, (2015).
- L. K. Comfort, A. Boin, C. C. Demchak, Designing Resilience: Preparing for Extreme Events, University of Pittsburgh Press, Pittsburgh, (2010).
- E. Hollnagel, D. D. Woods, N. Leveson, Resilience Engineering: Concepts and Precepts, Ashgate Publishing, Aldershot, (2006).
- S. Dekker, The Field Guide to Understanding Human Error, 3rd ed., CRC Press, Boca Raton, FL, (2014).
- N. N. Taleb, Antifragile: Things That Gain from Disorder, Random House, New York, (2012).
- R. T. Ames, D. L. Hall, Focusing the Familiar: A Translation and Philosophical Interpretation of the Zhongyong, University of Hawai 'i Press, Honolulu, (2001).
- W. Tu, Centrality and Commonality: An Essay on Confucian Religiousness, State University of New York Press, Albany, NY, (1989).
- X. Yao, An Introduction to Confucianism, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, (2000).
- C. E. Shannon, "A Mathematical Theory of Communication." Bell System Technical Journal, 27:3, pp.379-423, (1948). https://doi.org/10.1002/bltj.1948.27.issue-3
- C. E. Shannon, "A Mathematical Theory of Communication", Bell System Technical Journal, 27:4, pp.623-656, (1948). https://doi.org/10.1002/bltj.1948.27.issue-4
- I. Prigogine, I. Stengers, Order Out of Chaos: Man's New Dialogue with Nature, Bantam Books, New York, (1984).