Journal of the Korea Safety Management & Science (대한안전경영과학회지)

Korea Safety Management & Science (대한안전경영과학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Analysis of Perception Differences between Construction Workers and Managers Implementing for the Severe Accident Punishment Act: Focused on Measures to Improve Safety Management Effectiveness

중대재해처벌법 시행에 따른 건설현장 근로자와 관리자의 인식차 분석: 안전관리 실효성 향상 방안을 중심으로

  • Received : 2024.02.21
  • Accepted : 2024.03.18
  • Published : 2024.03.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

The objective of this study was to conduct research and analysis using Group Focus Interview to survey the between construction site workers and managers implementing for the Severe Accident Punishment Act. Focused on measures to improve safety management effectiveness for the effectiveness of establishing a safety management system. A plan to improve the efficient safety management system was presented to 50 construction industrial managers and workers. In order to ensure the industrial accident prevention policies appropriately, it is necessary to be aware of safety obligations for workers as well as business operators. In addition, despite the existence of a commentary on the Serious Accident Punishment Act, confusion in the field still persists, so in the event of a major accidents, the obligation to take safety and health education is strengthened, and effective case education is proposed by teaching actual accident cases suitable for actual working sites. It is necessary to make all training mandatory, and it is necessary to reconsider awareness through writing a daily safety log, awareness of risk factors, etc., and writing down risk information. Above all, at the construction ordering stage, it is necessary to keep the construction safety, request corrections and supplements for problems issues that arise, and consult between the orderer and the construction company about the problems issues. Rather than having only the construction company correct or supplement the safety management plan, the contents should be shared with supervisors and workers to establish a more practical solution. Results of this study will contribute to improving the effectiveness of the serious accident and construction safety management system.

Keywords

References

  1. Ministry of Employment of Labor(2020), The Serious Accident Punishment Act.
  2. Ministry of Employment of Labor(2020), Explanation of the Serious Accident Punishment Act, Ministry of Employment of Labor, 5-42.
  3. Ministry of Employment of Labor(2022), Safety and Health Management System to Prevent Industrial Accidents Guide Book, Ministry of Employment of Labor.
  4. Korea Occupational Safety and Health Agency (2021), Korea Occupational Safety and Health Management System(KOSHA 18001, KOSHA-MS) Certification Status.
  5. Y. G. Kim(2021), "Legal issues and legal policy tasks of the Serious Accident Punishment Act-From the perspective of strengthening corporate safety and health measures." Legislative Studies, 18(1):111-147.
  6. M. J. Kim(2020), "Background and implications of the enactment of the Act on Punishment of Companies for Severe Accidents." Social Law Research, 42:105-122.
  7. J. J. Shim(2016), "Enforcement system and method of the Occupational Safety and Health Act: British cases and implications." Law and Business Studies, 6(3):37-67.
  8. H. B. Jeon(2017), "Expanding the scope of application of the Occupational Safety and Health Act and strengthening responsibility for the CEO." Labor Law Forum, 22:137-164.
  9. H. B. Jeon(2020), "Review of the legislation for the Severe Accident Punishment Act." Labor Law Forum, 30:253-277.
  10. H. P. Park(2018), "A Fundamental Study for Analyzing the Cause of Construction-critical Disaster." 2018 Korean Architectural Society Spring Conference Paper Collection, 38(1).
  11. S. M. Choi, D. E. Lee, C. B. Son(2008), "Assessing the Safety Performance of Small-size Contractors and Improvement Measures." J. Korea Soc. Saf., 23(4):53-58.
  12. H. C. Kwak(2020), "Research on effect analysis to introduce occupational safety and health management system of internal partner." Master thesis, Korea University of Technology and Education, Cheonan, Korea.
  13. J. A. Lee(2020). "A The effect of safety and health culture on the certification of occupational health and safety management system-Focusion on the electronic industry." Master thesis, Graduate school The Catholic University of Korea, Seoul, Korea.
  14. K. M. Chung(2016), "A study on the Proposing an Efficiency Action Plan based on Analyzing Current status of Safety Management in Construction Site." Master Science, Seoul National University of Science and Technology.
  15. J. G. Kim(2023), "Serious Accidents Punishment Act: Management Direction of Serious Civic Accidents." Review of Architecture and Building Science, Special Feature, 67(4):43-47.
  16. I. H. Song, K. S. Kim, J. M. Ryu, C. S. Kim, S. Y. Park(2022), "Efficient operation plan for safety and health management system in accordance with the enforcement of the Serious Accident Punishment Act." Journal of the Korea Academia-Industrial cooperation Society, 23(5):452-459.
  17. Y. H. Ahn(2021), "Study on ways to improve Korea's Serious Accident Punishment Act: Focusing on the Serious Accident Punishment Act." Legislation and Policy, 13(1).
  18. Y. K. Kang, C. D. Lee, S. N. Lee(2021), "Review of companies' response plans following the enforcement of the Severe Accident Punishment Act." Law and Business Research, 11(2):211-245.
  19. S. Y. Lee(2021), "Achievements and challenges of the movement to enact the Corporate Punishment Act for Serious Accidents." Citizens and the World, 38:233-242.
  20. J. G. Lim(2021), "Thoughts on the enforcement of the Act on Punishment for Serious Disasters, etc." Korea Gas Society, 2021 Fall Conference Papers.
  21. Korea Shipowners Mutual Insurance(2022), Deployment of dedicated organizations and professional personnel related to the safety and health of shipping companies in accordance with the Serious Accident Punishment Act and the Occupational Safety and Health Act, Korea Shipowners Mutual Insurance, Korea Maritime Affair.
  22. T. S. Kang(2021), "Tasks of other occupational safety and health administrative organizations in the implementation of the Severe Accident Punishment Act." Labor Law Research, 51:75-109.
  23. K. R. Chung(2021), "Safety Risk Management in Preparation for the Serious Accidents Punishment Act." Review of Architecture and Building Science, 65(5):13-16.
  24. J. W. Jeong(2022), "Is Serious Accident Punishment Act Sustainable?." Magazine of the Korea Concrete Institute, 34(4):66-71.
  25. K. W. Kim(2020), "A Study on the Psychological Trauma, Safety Atmosphere, Safety Accidents, and Safety Behavior of Workers with Serious Accident Experience in Industrial Sites." The Korean Journal of Health Psychology, 25(6):1077-1095.
  26. Korea Industrial Safety Association(2022), Safety education teaching plan (Understanding the Occupational Safety and Health Act and the Severe Accident Punishment Act, KISA-General-51.
  27. P. K. Kim, H. Y. Chae, S. I. Kim, K. H. Jung(2022), "Relationship Analysis of the Factors for Safety and Health Management System Stipulated in the Serious Disaster Punishment Act with accident Statistics of Construction Industry." Journal of the Korean Society of Safety, 37(4):44-50.
  28. D. H. Park(2022), "Protected subjects of safety and health laws and issues of application of the Severe Accident Punishment Act." Democratic Legal Studies,
  29. Ministry of Employment and Labor(2022), press release, '21 Industrial Accident Death Status Announcement.
  30. D. G. Seol(2022), "Serious Accident Punishment Act, how effective is it?." Electrical Journal, pp.40-43.
  31. Y. J. Ahn(2022), "Policy shift in safety management to prevent major disasters." Electrical Journal, pp.57-65.
  32. J. Y. Kim(2021), "The Enactment and Future Tasks of the Fatal Industrial Accidents Punishment Act." Legal Theory and Practice Review, 9(4):43-66.
  33. H. Kwon(2021), "The legal system status of the Serious Accident Punishment Act and Consideration of Legislative Policy Significance." Labor Law Forum, 34:1-28.
  34. S. E. Ko, E. H. Yang, H. J. Hwang(2022), "Affinity Analysis Between Factors of Serious Occupational Accidents in Manufacturing Industry." 2022 Korea Communications Society Summer Conference.
  35. J. W. Jeong(2021), "Legal issues and remaining tasks in the process of enacting the Severe Accident Punishment Act." Science Technology and Law, 27(2):47-94.
  36. H. K. Kim(2022), "Analysis of Sentencing Factors in the UK's Enterprise and Fraudulent Law (Regarding the application of the Severe Disaster Punishment Act)." Korean Criminological Review, 33(2):33-66.
  37. H. K. Kim(2022), "Analysis of sentencing factors of the UK's Corporate Manslaughter Act (in relation to the application of the Serious Accident Punishment Act)." Journal of Criminal Policy Studies, 33(2):33-36.
  38. J. W. Jeong(2021), "A critical review of the legislative notice of the Enforcement Decree of the Severe Accident Punishment Act (Focusing on Severe Industrial Accidents)." Journal of the Korean Society of Occupational Health, 31(4): 417-426.
  39. Y. Toyosawa, K. Ohori, N. Yoshikawa(2015), "Study of occupational safety and health management in construction work based on comparison between Japan and the UK." Proceedings of the Japan Society of Civil Engineers F6 (Safety Issues), 71(2):I_1-I_12.
  40. Australia Parliamentary Counsel's Committee (2023), Model Work Health and Safety Bill, Nationally Consistent work health and safety laws.
  41. V. Roper(2018), "The Corporate Manslaughter and Corporate Homicide Act 2007, a 10 Year Review." The Journal of Criminal Law, 82(1):48-75.
  42. T. Numano(2016), "Corporate Manslaughter in the UK and Control of Corporate Accidents." Japanese Law, 82(2).
  43. Y. Hino(2011), "Occupational Safety at Construction Sites in Developed Countries." JCM Monthly Report, 20(3).
  44. Japan Industrial Safety and Health Act about the Federal Employers' Liability Act.
  45. W. MacDonald, T. Driscoll, R. Stuckey, J. Oakman(2012), "Occupational Health and Safety in Australia." Industrial Health, 50(3):172-179.
  46. S. H. Han(2021), "Law academia's opinion on legal issues regarding the enactment of the Act on Punishment of Companies for Severe Accidents." Democratic Law Studies, 75.
  47. J. H. Choi(2017), "Study on the punishment provisions of Article 66-2 of the Occupational Safety and Health Act." Ilgam Law Studies, 36: 331-355.
  48. J. M. Lee(2021), "Problems of punitive damages regulations in the Act on Punishment for Serious Accidents: Focusing on compensation requirements and scope." Hongik Law, 22(1):311-336.
  49. J. Y. Lee(2022), "A Consideration of Perception on Enforcement of Serious Accident Punishment Act(SAPA) among the Workers in the Nuclear Medicine Department." J. Korean Soc. Radiol., 16(4):477-490.
  50. H. T. Chae(2022), "Correct awareness of the Serious Accident Punishment Act and response by small and medium-sized businesses." Report of Korea SME's and Startups Institute, 22(2):1-19.
  51. D. H. Park(2022), "The Subject of the Safety and Health Act and the Application of the Serious Disaster Punishment Act." Democratic Legal Studies, 79:119-134.