Journal of the Korean Society of Safety (한국안전학회지)

The Korean Society of Safety (한국안전학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Analysis of Collapse Accidents in Demolition Work using AcciMap and STAMP

AcciMap과 STAMP를 활용한 해체공사 붕괴사고 분석

  • Hyeon-Ji Jeong (Department of Disaster Prevention Engineering, Chungbuk National Universit) ;
  • Jeong-Hun Won (Department of Safety Engineering & Department of Big Data, Chungbuk National University)
  • 정현지 (충북대학교 방재공학 학과간협동과정) ;
  • 원정훈 (충북대학교 안전공학과)
  • Received : 2023.03.14
  • Accepted : 2023.05.26
  • Published : 2023.06.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

Investigation of the cause of the relatively recent building collapse accident in Gwangju revealed a lack of awareness about the safety of the dismantling construction system among stakeholders, in the form of issues such as illegal subcontracting, unauthorized design changes, and insufficient safety supervision. This study was conducted to analyze the safety interactions between the building dismantling construction system and the involved stakeholders and to propose ways to prevent accidents in related institutions and workplaces. AcciMap and STAMP-CAST analysis methods were used to evaluate safety interactions among the various stakeholders participating in building demolition work. Analysis results revealed that the collapse accident during the dismantling work was caused not only by structural causes occurring in the construction stage, but also by various causes throughout the system, such as the dismantling plan preparation stage and the construction permit stage. The results also revealed the need for proper implementation of safety control measures by various stakeholders to prevent collapse accidents during dismantling construction.

Keywords

Acknowledgement

This work is financially supported by Ministry of the Interior and Safety as Human Resource Development Project in Disaster Management.

References

  1. J. M. Lim, J. H. Kim and J. J. Kim, "A Preliminary Study on the Necessity of Safety Management System during the Demolition Work", Journal of the Architectural Institute of Korea Academic Presentation, Vol. 31, No. 2, pp. 389-390, 2011.
  2. Y. K. Shim, J. W. Jeong. J. H. Lee and J. M. Jeong, "Necessity of Improvements on Code of Practice at the Demolition Work considering Building Structure Type : Based on Demolition work of Permission and Registration", Korean Journal of Construction Engineering and Management, Vol. 21, No. 6, pp. 66-74, 2020.
  3. K. H. Kim. J. S. Choi. S. H. Shin and C. H. Yang, "Analysis of the Risk Factors in Demolition", Architectural Research, Vol. 24, No. 1, pp. 151-158, 2008.
  4. H. W. Shin. C. Y. Song. Y. T. Kong. I. H. Im and D. H Choie, "Support for Decision-Making of Small-Scale Old Building Safety Management.", Journal of the Korean Geographlcal Society, Vol. 16, No. 4, pp. 53-54, 2019.
  5. J. S. Choi and S. T. Heo, "Development of Safety Management Manual for Deconstruction Works - Focused on the Mechanical Deconstruction Method -", J. Korean Soc. Saf., Vol. 24, No. 1, pp. 43-49, 2009.
  6. S. J. Jeong and J. Y. Park, "A Study on the Improvement of Safety Management for Military Demolition Works", J. Korean Soc. Saf., Vol. 37, No. 6, pp. 71-80, 2022.
  7. Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, "Investigation Report on the Collapse of Demolition Work in Gwangju", 2021.
  8. H. K. Kim. T. H. Kim and C. G, Cho, "A Study on the Regulations and Standards for Structural Demolition Safety", KICEM, Vol. 23, No. 2, pp. 8-12, 2022.
  9. KJDally, The True Face of 'Safety Apathy: Bureaucratic Administration, 2021.06.20.
  10. NEWSIS, Half of Gwangju Citizens Attribute Final Responsibility for Collapse Accident to Hyundai Development, 2021.12.06.
  11. The JoongAng, Controversy over the Punishment for Gwangju Hakdong Disaster with 17 Fatalities, 2022.11.03.
  12. S. Y. Kang. S. Min. W. S. Kim. J. H. Won. Y. J. Kang and S. Kim, "Types and Characteristics of Fatal Accidents Caused by Multiple Processes in the Workplace: Based on the Actual Cases in South Korea", International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, Vol. 19, No. 4, 2047, 2022.
  13. J. H. Won. H. J. Jeong. W. Kim. S. Kim. S. Y. Kang and J. M. Hwang, "Mechanisms Analysis for Fatal Accident Types Caused by Multiple Processes in the Workplace: Based on Accident Case in South Korea", International Journal of Environmental Research and Public Health, Vol. 19, No. 18, 11430, 2022.
  14. H. H. Cho, "In the Scope of Application of the Occupational Safety and Health Act Comparative Study with Other Laws elated to", Occupational Safety and Health Research Institute. 2013.
  15. H. K. Yoon. Y. J. Kwon. B. H. Oh. Y. I. Gwon. Y. G. Yoon and T. K. Oh, "A Study on the Improvement of Safety Management of Plan/Order, Design, and Construction Business Management", J. Korean Soc. Saf., Vol. 35, No. 4, pp. 56-63, 2020.
  16. Arshed Almad, Accident Models, 2016.
  17. EUROCONTROL. A White Paper on Resilience Engineering for ATM, 2009
  18. P. Underwood and P. Waterson, "Systems Thinking, the Swiss Cheese Model and Accident Analysis: A Comparative Systemic Analysis of the Grayrigg Train Derailment using the ATSB, AcciMap and STAMP models", Accident Analysis & Prevention, Vol. 68, pp. 75-94, 2014. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.aap.2013.07.027
  19. N. G. Leveson, "A New Accident Model for Engineering Safer Systems", Safety Science, Vol. 42, No. 4, pp. 237-270, 2004. https://doi.org/10.1016/S0925-7535(03)00047-X
  20. P. M. Salmon. M. Cornelissen and M. J. Trotter, "SystemsBased Accident Analysis Methods: A Comparison of Accimap, HFACS, and STAMP", Safety Science, Vol. 50, No. 4, pp. 1158-1170, 2012. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.ssci.2011.11.009
  21. D. H. Seo. O. S. Han and Y. R. Choi, "A Study on the Systematic Cause Analysis of Fire and Explosion Accidents in Chemical Plants", Occupational Safety and Health Research Institute, 2020.
  22. N. G. Leveson, "An STPA Primer version1", MIT, 2015.
  23. T. Jhon, "Systems Theoretic Process Analysis(STPA) Introduction", 2015.
  24. Leveson, N., "CAST HANDBOOK: How to Learn More from Incidents and Accidents". 2019.
  25. DongA, [Exclusive] Jamwon-dong Collapsed Building 'Man-made Calamity'... There was no Support or Plan to Install 2020.05.08.
  26. Korea Policy News View, "The Gwangju Building Collapse Incident is a Human Error: Causes Resulted from Excessive Demolition and Excessive Soil Piling, 2021.08.09.
  27. K. Branford. N. Naikar and A. Hopkins, Guidelines for AcciMap Analysis, 2009.
  28. Yonhapnews, Illegal Subcontracting Is the Source of Shoddy Construction... "The Cheapest and Fastest", 2022.1.16.
  29. Topstarnews, [Issue] Cause of 'Jamwon-dong Building Collapse' Revealed to Be Due to the Absence of Jack Supports... "Lack of Stair Also Contributed" Point Out, 2019.7.6.
  30. The JoongAng, "Building Manager of Jamwon-dong Collapse Did Insane Things to Save 300,000 KRW", 2019.7.8.
  31. Dnews, Seoul City, Mandates Demolition Contractors to Submit Demolition and Supervision Contracts, 2019.11.12.
  32. Munhwa, The Jamwon-dong Building Collapse Incident is a Human Error: Demolition Performed on a Structure in a State of Collapse, 2019. 9. 9.
  33. Anjun Journal, Site Manager of 'Jamwon-dong Collapse Accident' Sentenced to Actual Imprisonment in Second Trial, 2020.7.31
  34. NEWSIS, Site Manager of 'Jamwon-dong Collapse Accident' Sentenced to Actual Imprisonment in Second Trial... "Unreasonable Construction", 2020.7.17.
  35. Moneytoday, Site Manager of 'Jamwon-dong Collapse Accident' Sentenced to Actual Imprisonment in First Trial... "Disregarded Work Plan", 2020.1.14.
  36. SBSNEWS, [Exclusive] "Jamwon-dong Accident, There Was No Pillar to Support"... Obtained Report, 2019.7.6.
  37. Joint Press Release of Relevant Ministries and Agencies, Strengthening Safety Measures for Building Demolition Works, 2021.
  38. Yonhapnews, The Cause of the Gwangju Building Collapse Incident: Unauthorized Structural Modifications... "a Collective Human Error", 2022.3.14.
  39. Ministry of Land, Infrastructure and Transport, The Gwangju Building Collapse Incident: Causes Stemming from Excessive Demolition Methods and Excessive Soil Piling, 2021.8.9.
  40. The JoongAng, [Exclusive] Gwangju Building Demolition Plan Given "Appropriate" Rating After Self-Review, 2021.6.14.
  41. Hankyoreh, Official Involved in the 'Gwangju Hakdong Building Collapse Incident' Receives Fine for Soliciting Bribery in the Selection of supervisor, 2023.2.22.
  42. KJDally, Police Confirm "Illegal Multi-Level Subcontracting" in Hakdong Building Collapse Incident, 2021.6.11.
  43. Korea Policy News View, The Gwangju Building Collapse Incident: Causes Stemming from Excessive Demolition Methods and Excessive Soil Piling,, 2021.8.9.
  44. SeoulNews, [Exclusive] Supervisor of Gwangju Incident Never Visited Construction Site, 2021.6.13.
  45. Hankyoreh, Excessive sprinkle water Instruction by HDC Hyundai Development Company..One of the Factors in Gwangju Collapse Incident, 2021.9.9.