DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

The Post-Jeungsan Grassroots Movements: Charismatic Leadership in Bocheongyo and Mugeukdo in Colonial Korea

  • David W. KIM (Harvard University / Kookmin University)
  • Received : 2023.07.24
  • Accepted : 2023.09.20
  • Published : 2023.09.30

Abstract

The politico-economic waives of Western imperialism and colonialism, along with Christianity, affected East Asia's geopolitical landscape in the nineteenth and twentieth centuries. While the Korean people (of the Joseon Dynasty) witnessed the incompetence of Buddhism, Confucianism, and folk religions in maintaining social cohesion with a sense of frustration, the new religious movements (NRMs) emerged to provide altrnative teachings of hope through historical figures like Choe Je-u, Kang Il-sun (or Kang Jeungsan), Na Cheol, and Pak Chungbin. In terms of popularity, colonial Korea (1910-1940) was impressed by the native groups of Cheondogyo (=Donghak), Bocheongyo, and Mugeukdo. Son Byong-hee (1861-1922) was the third leader of the first Korean NRM, but both Cha Gyeong-seok (1880-1936) and Jo Cheol-Je (= Jo Jeongsan) (1895-1958) participated in the post-Jeungsan grassroots movements. How, then, did both of these new religions originate? How did they conceptualise their deities and interpret their teachings differently? What was their policy for national independence? The article explores the socio-religious leaders, historical origin, organizational structure, deities, teaching and doctrines, patriotism, and conflicts of both NRMs in a comparative context. As such, this article argues that they both maintained patriotic characteristics, but that Cha's Bocheongyo community with its ' 60-executives' system (60 bang) failed to manage their internal conflicts effectively. Meanwhile, Jo Cheol-Je of Mugeukdo had the charismatic leadership needed to maintain Mugeukdo, despite being seen as a pseudoreligion under the colonial pressure of Shintoism.

Keywords

References

  1. An, Hu Sang 2000 "Consideration About the Birth of Cha Gyeongseok." Journal of the Korean Academy of New Religions 2: 58-69.
  2. An, Hu Sang 2001 "Bocheongyo's Sibiljeon and Jogyesa's Daeungjeon. " Journal of the Korean Academy of New Religions 4: 203-225.
  3. An, Hu Sang 2012 "The Opening of Poch'on'Gyo During the Colonial Period and the Opening Background." Journal of the Korean Academy of New Religions 26: 145-181. https://doi.org/10.22245/jkanr.2012.26.26.145
  4. An, Hu Sang 2016 "The Independence Movement of Bochongyo During the Japanese Colonial Period." Won-Buddhist Thought & Religious Culture 70: 431-476. http://www.riss.kr/link?id=A102652621 102652621
  5. Cha, Seon-keun 2018 "The Transformation Process of Daesoon Jinrihoe and Its Relationship with Mugeukdo." Daesoon Bulletin 94, accessed on 1 April 2023. https://webzine.daesoon.org/board/index.asp?webzine=125&menu_no=1960&bno=3372&page=1.
  6. Cui, Feng Long 2016 "A Reconsideration on the Records on Doju Cho Jeongsan and His Family in Manchuria, China." Journal of the Daesoon Academy of Sciences 26: 215-253. https://doi.org/10.25050/jdaos.2016.26.0.215
  7. Hwang, Seongjo 2019 "Founding Source of Independence Movement 'Bocheongyo' Kim Gu 'I Am Debited to Jeongup'." Jeolla Daily News 24 October 2019, accessed on 1 April 2023. http://www.jeollailbo.com/news/articleView.html?idxno=582194
  8. Introvigne, Massimo 2021 "The Flourishing of New Religions In korea." Nova Religio 25(1): 5-13. https://doi.org/10.1525/nr.2021.25.1.5
  9. Jang, Wona 2013 "Activities of Bocheongyo in 1920s and Response of Korean Society." Master Thesis, Seoul: Seoul National University.
  10. Jeon, Kwangsu 2019 "A Role of National Religion and Independence Movement of Bocheongyo During the Japanese Colonial Era." Korean Journal of Religious Education 60: 257-270.
  11. Jin, Jung-Ae. 2011 "A Review on the Object of Belief of Bocheon-Gyo and Mugeuk-Do." Journal of the Korean Academy of New Religions 25 https://doi.org/10.22245/jkanr.2011.25.25.167
  12. Kim, Chul-Soo 2016 "The Japanese Colonial Power and the Destiny of Bocheongyo in the Japanese Colonial Period." Sundo Culture 20: 371-403. http://dx.doi.org/10.35573/JKSC.20.10
  13. Kim, Chul-Soo 2018 "A Study on the Way and Way out of Bocheongyou in the 1920s - Centered on Official Document of Japanese Colonial Power." Journal of the Korean Academy of New Religions 38: 93-125. https://doi.org/10.22245/jkanr.2018.38.38.93
  14. Kim, Chul-Soo 2021 "A Study on the Organizational Formation of Korea-Occurred Religion and Modernity During the Period of Japanese Colonial Rule in Korea - Centered on Bocheonkyou." Sundo Culture 30: 333-372. https://doi.org/10.35573/jksc.30.9
  15. Kim, David W  2020 Daesoon Jinrihoe in Modern Korea: The Emergence, Transformation and Transmission of a New Religion. Newcastle, UK: Cambridge Scholars Publishing
  16. Kim, David W 2021a "Cao Dai" and "Gucheon Sangje": New Ethnical Grassroots Religions in Colonial Vietnam and Korea." The International Journal of Religion and Spirituality in Society 11(2): 81. https://doi.org/10.18848/2154-8633/CGP/v11i02/81-101
  17. Kim, David W 2021b "Jin-Gyeong and Sin-Ingan: The Prophecy of the Later World in the Canonical Scripture of Daesoon Jinrihoe." Journal of Daesoon Thought and the Religions of East Asia 1(1): 127-151. https://doi.org/10.25050/JDTREA.2021.1.1.127
  18. Kim, Jae-Young 2000 "Bochengyo: The Religious Symbolism of Jeongup in the Eye of Feng Shui and Land." Journal of the Korean Academy of New Religions 2: 70-83.
  19. Kim, Jae-Young 2006 "Educational Practices of Bocheonkyo." Journal of the Korean Academy of New Religions 14: 279-306.
  20. Kim, Jae-Young 2009 "Hyeongpyeongsa and Bochongyo." Journal of the Korean Academy of New Religions 21: 267-288. https://doi.org/10.22245/jkanr.2009.21.21.267
  21. Kim, Min-Young 2019 "Progress of Korean Production Movement in 1920s and 1930s and Religious Circle." Journal of Korean-Japanese National Studies 36. https://doi.org/10.35647/kjna.2019.36.5
  22. Ko, Byoung-chul 2020 "Issues Involving the Relationship between Religion and the Anti-Japanese Independence Movement: A Case Study of Mugeukdo." The Journal of Daesoon Academy of Sciences 35: 39-71. https://doi.org/10.25050/jdaos.2020.35.0.39
  23. Ko, Nam-Sik 2004 "Jeungsan's Taoistic Tendency and the Daoism Element of Mugeugto." The Journal of Daesoon Academy of Sciences 17: 1-33. https://doi.org/10.25050/jdaos.2004.17.0.1
  24. Kwon, Dong_woo 2021 "A Study on the Truth of 'Dissolution Decrees of Pseudo_Religions': Focusing on the Cases of 'Mugeukdo(無極道)'." Korean Studies Quarterly 44(4): 41-77. https://doi.org/10.25024/ksq.44.4.202112.41
  25. Lee, Jeongman 2019 "Doju and the Organisation of Mugeukdo." Daesoon Bulletin 219, accessed on 01 April 2023. https://webzine.daesoon.org/m/view.asp?webzine=260&menu_no=4535&bno=8404&page=
  26. Lee, Jeongman 2020 "The Influence of Mugeukdo in the Beginning - Membership and Outreach Regions." Daesoon Bulletin 233, accessed on 01 April 2023. https://webzine.daesoon.org/m/view.asp?webzine=277&menu_no=4772&bno=8859&page=1
  27. Lee, Kil-Yong 2012 "A Study of the Structural Character of the Korean New Religions from the Viewpoint of Self-Cultivation: Focusing on Donghak and Jeungsan-Gyo." The Korea Journal of Donghak Studies 25: 149-181.
  28. Lim, Byeong Hak 2016 "Bocheon-Gyo'S Doctrine and Zhengyi(正易) Thought -Focusing on Eight Trigram." Journal of the Korean Academy of New Religions 34: 59-84. https://doi.org/10.22245/jkanr.2016.34.34.59
  29. Park, Ingyu 2013 "Activities of Bocheongyo in 1920s and Response of Korean Society." Doctral Thesis Seoul: Seoul National University.
  30. Park, Sang-kyu 2022a "A Study on the Documentation Related to Mugeuk-Do: Focusing on Its Comparison and Historical Evidence." The Journal of Daesoon Academy of Sciences 41: 27-61. https://doi.org/10.25050/jdaos.2022.41.0.27
  31. Park, Sang-kyu 2022b "Organisational Research of Modern Korean New Religions in the System of Yeonwun (Relation Link)". Doctral Thesis: The Academy of Korean Studies.
  32. Park, Sung Soon 2018 "A Study of Working Student's Club in the Peninsula(半 島苦學生親睦會) in Early 1920s." Soong Sil Sahak(The Historical Review of Soong Sil University) 41: 175-196. https://doi.org/10.16942/ssh.2018.41.12.08
  33. Shin, Sang Gu 2010 "Necessity of Appointing a Sacred Site for the First Outreach Place of Taegeukdo, the Place of Anmyeon-Eups Uiljae (1)". Chungcheong Newspapers 11 November. 2010, accessed on 1 April 2023 http://www.dailycc.net/news/articleView.html?idxno=50909.
  34. Song, Seok Won 2018 "The Japanese Imperial Mentality: Cultural Imperialism as Colonial Control - Chosun as Exemplar." Pacific Focus: Inha Journal of International Studies 33(2): 308-329. https://doi.org/10.1111/pafo.12120
  35. Tipton, Elise  2016 Modern Japan: A Social and Political History. London: Routledge.