Journal of Arbitration Studies (한국중재학회지:중재연구)

The Korean Association of Arbitration Studies (한국중재학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Cases of Disputes and Patterns of Dispute Resolution in the Area of Public-Private Partnership(PPP) in India

인도의 민관협력사업(PPP): 분쟁사례와 분쟁해결유형

  • Chung, Yongkyun (Department of International Trade and Business, Kangwon National University)
  • 정용균 (국립강원대학교 춘천캠퍼스 국제무역학과)
  • Received : 2021.05.09
  • Accepted : 2021.05.31
  • Published : 2021.06.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

India is one of the fast growing country in the world. For the acceleration of economic growth of India, it is indispensable for Indian government to construct infrastructure, such as railroad, airport, harbor, power plant, and water management system. For example, Modi, prime minister of federal government of India proclaimed that Indian government plans to construct 100 smart cities in 2015. In recent times, India is expected to be the largest recipient of Public-Private Partnership(PPP) type projects in the world. Owing to PPP, it is possible for India to pursue her objective to transform the whole economy into digital economy beyond agricultural society. One of major problem related with implementation of PPP type projects is the growth of disputes concomitant to the rising phenomena of PPP type projects in order to build infrastructure in India. Because of this, non-negligible number of projects has been cancelled during last two decades. This study investigates seven failure cases of PPP in India. Those include Nabi mumbai airport, Dabhol power plant, Munbai water project, and Kolkata subway project. Main types of dispute resolution are mediation or conciliation, dispute review board, arbitration, expert adjudication in PPP.

Keywords

References

  1. 김관호, "투자협정 정책의 딜레마: 최근 인도사례의 고찰", 「국제.지역연구」, 서울대학교 국제지역원, 제25권 제3호, 2016.
  2. 김승현, "FIDIC 계약조건에서 국제중재 전 선결절차로서의 분쟁재정위원회(Dispute Adjudication Board)의 효용성연구", 「국제사법연구」, 한국국제사법학회, 제24권 제1호, 2018.
  3. 김용일.오현석, "ICSID 중재판정 취소를 통한 불복", 「중재연구」, 한국중재학회, 제31권 제1호, 2021.
  4. 문경연.박현아, "일본 ODA의 민관협업 체계에 관한 연구", 「아태연구」, 제26권 제3호, 2019.
  5. 박찬호, "인도의 사법제도와 소송외 분쟁해결제도", 「아시아법제연구」, 2007.
  6. 안건형, "비변호사 중재인 활용의 문제점과 개선방안", 「중재연구」, 한국중재학회, 제25권 제1호, 2015.
  7. 양선희.김선정, "싱가포르 국제상사분쟁해결 허브 전략으로서의 국제중재센터(SIAC)과 국제상사법원(SICC)", 「무역보험연구」, 한국무역보험학회, 제17권 제4호, 2016.
  8. 윤덕근.이동주, "민관협력(PPP)사업의 리스크 관리를 위한 제도개선 연구", 「법과 정책연구」, 한국법정책학회, 제18집 제3호, 2018.
  9. 임재빈, "인도 스마트시티: 100개 스마트 시티 건설기회 민관협력(PPP)방식 사업 준비해야", CHINDIA Plus, 2015.
  10. 장준영, "모디 독트린(Modi Doctrine)과 인도의 동북부 발전전략: 미야마와의 연계를 중심으로", 「동남아연구」, 한국외국어대학교 동남아연구소, 제29권 제1호, 2019.
  11. 장지순, "공적개발원조(ODA) 활성화를 위한 민간과의 협력거버넌스 체제 구축방안", 「한국공공관리학보」, 한국공공관리학회, 제26권 제4호, 2012.
  12. 정대영.홍세진.강신영.김영태, "동남아시아 민관협력사업(PPP)에 관한 법제도 현황 및 진출전략: 베트남 인도네시아를 중심으로", 「GRI 연구논총」, 경기연구원, 제19권 제1호, 2017.
  13. 정대영.홍세진.강신영.김영태, "국가별 민관협력사업(PPP) 제도 및 진출환경 평가를 통한 글로벌 인프라시장 진출전략", 「GRI 연구논총」, 경기연구원, 제19권 제3호, 2017.
  14. 정용균, "캄보디아의 분쟁해결문화와 협상방식", 「동남아연구」, 한국외국어대학교 동남아연구소, 제28권 제2호, 2018a.
  15. 정용균, "라오스의 분쟁해결제도와 비즈니스 협상문화", 「분쟁해결연구」, 단국대학교 분쟁해결연구소, 제16권 제3호, 2018b.
  16. 정용균, "필리핀의 분쟁해결문화와 비즈니스 협상전략", 「국제지역연구」, 국제지역학회, 제28권 제4호, 2019a.
  17. 정용균, "인도의 분쟁해결문화와 ADR제도: Panchayat와 Lok Adalat을 중심으로", 「중재연구」, 한국중재학회, 제29권 제2호, 2019b.
  18. 조광걸, "KOICA의 민관파트너쉽(PPP) 개발협력사업 도입방안", 「국제개발협력」, 한국국제협력단, 제4권 제3호, 2009.
  19. 조영태.박신원.오명택.김병환.조예진, "4차 산업혁명과 Smart City의 도시기반시설", Geotechnical Engineering, 2017.
  20. 홍석모, "중재상소제도에 대한 연구", 「중재연구」, 한국중재학회, 제10권 제1호, 2010.
  21. Adekilekun, M.T., Olatunji, O.A., Gan, C.C., and Akanbi, M.M., "Public-Private Partnership Initiative in Nigeria and Its Dispute Resolution Mechanism: An Appraisal", Journal of Malay and Comparative Law, Vol.40, 2014.
  22. Almarri, K., "Improving PPP Contract Design for Procurement of Public Projects", Proceedings of the 10th International Conference on Project Management(ProMAC2016), 2016.
  23. Amir Ullah, "An Analysis of Public Private Partnership(PPP) Policies in South Asia", International Journal of Humanities and Social Sciences, Vol.4, No1, 2014.
  24. Babatunde, O. Solomon Adeniyi, Onapepo, and Awodele, Oluwaseyi, "Investigation into the Causes of Delay in Land Aquisition for PPP Projects in Developing Countries", Journal of Engineering Design and Technology, Vol.15, No.4, 2017.
  25. Bettauer, Ronald, "India and International Arbitration: The DABHOL Experience", George Washington International Law Review, Vol.41, No.2, 2009.
  26. Bharne Smita and Patil, Suryakant, "Exploring in the Context of Development of Smart Cities in India", V. K. Gunjan and J. M. Zurada(eds), Proceedings of International Conference on Recent Trends I Machine Learning IoT Smart Cities and Applications, Advances in Intelligent Systems and Computing, 2021.
  27. Bowes, Denise, "Identifying Barriers to the Establishment of Dispute Boards in UK Construction", in A. Dainty(ed), Proceedings of 24th Annual ARCOM Conference, Cardiff, 2008.
  28. Cheung, Sai On, "Critical Factors Affecting the Use of Alternative Dispute Resolution Processes in Construction", International Journal of Project Management, Vol.17, No.3, 1999.
  29. Chung, Yongkyun, "Combining Arbitration with Mediation: Two Cultures of China and Malaysia", Journal of Arbitration Studies, Vol.26, No.3, 2016.
  30. Chung, Yongkyun and Ha, Hong-Youl and Kim, Kwang-Soo, "The Moderating Effects of Fairness of Arbitration and Speed of Arbitration on Korean Traders' Attitude toward Arbitration", Journal of Korea Trade, Vol.18, No.2, 2014.
  31. Chung, Yongkyun and Ha, Hong-Youl, "Arbitrator Acceptability in International Commercial Arbitration: The Trading Firm Perspective", International Journal of Conflict Management, Vol.27, No.3, 2016.
  32. Cremades, B. M., "Overcoming the Clash of Legal Cultures: The Role of Interactive Arbitration", Arbitration International, Vol.14, No.2. 1998.
  33. Das, Sutapa, "Hidden Cost in Public Infrastructure Project: A Case Study of Kolkata East-West Metro", Kala Seetharam and Guang Hua(eds), Urbanization in Asia: Governance, Infrastructure and the Environment, Springer, 2014.
  34. Delmon, Jeffrey, Creating a Framework for Public-Private Partnership(PPP) Programs: A Practical Guide for Decision-makers, World Bank Group, 2015.
  35. Devkar Ganesh, Mahalingam, Ashwin and Kalidindi, Satyanarayana, "Competencies and Urban Public Private Partnership Projects in India: A Case Study Analysis", Policy and Society, Vol.32. No.2, 2013.
  36. Dezalay, Y. and Garth, B., Dealing in Virtue: International Commercial Arbitration and the Construction of a Transnational Legal Order, The University of Chicago Press, 1996.
  37. Fratap, V. Kumar, "The Increasing Incidence of PPP Project Cancellation in India", Economic & Political Weekly, Vol.L1, No.39, 2016.
  38. Gluck, G., "Great Expectations: Meeting the Challenge of a New Arbitration Paradigm", American Review of International Arbitration, Vol.23, 2012.
  39. Graham, S., Desai, R., and McFarlane, "Water Wars in Mumbai", Public Culture, Vol.25, No.1, 2013.
  40. Harisankar K S, and Seeparathy, G. "Rethinking Dispute Resolution in Public-Private Partnerships for Infrastructure Development in India", Journal of Infrastructure Development, Vol.5, No.1, 2013.
  41. Karmarkar, Dipesh, "Impact of Water Privatization on the Urban Poor: A Case of Mumbai", Online International Interdisciplinary Research Journal, Vol.11, No.1, 2012.
  42. Kendall, J, Expert Determination, Sweet & Maxwell, 4th edition, 2008.
  43. Kudtarkar, G. S., "Failure of Operational PPP Projects in India Leading to Private Developer's Apathy to Participate in Future Projects: A Case Study Based Analysis", Indian Journal of Finance and Banking, Vol.4 No.2, 2020a.
  44. Kudtarkar, G. S., "Resetting PPP in Infrastructure Model in India Post-COVID-19 Pandemic", Indian Economic Journal, Vol.68, No.3, 2020b.
  45. Kumar, N., Goel, S., and Mallick, P., "Smart Cities in India: Features, Policies, Current Status, and Challenges", IEEE International Conference on Technologies for Smart City Energy Security and Power (ICSESP-2018), India, 2018.
  46. Mohan, B. and Nair, Latha, "PPP at Cross Roads: Alternative Models an Imperative", S C M S Journal of Indian Management, 2017.
  47. Nallanthiga, Ramakrishna, "Factors Affecting the Success/Failure of Road Infrastructure Projects under PPP in India". KICEM Journal of Construction Engineering and Project Management, Vol.7, No.4, 2017.
  48. Osei-Kyei, R., Chan, A., Yu, Y., Chen, C., and Dansoh, A., "Root Causes of Conflict and Conflict Resolution Mechanism in Public-Private Partnerships: Comparative Study between Ghana and China", Cities, 2018.
  49. Pathak, Harsh, "International Standardization of arbitration as an Alternate Dispute Resolution Forum and Its Acceptance in India", Judicial Tribune, Vol.6, 2016.
  50. Pucher, J., Korattyswaropam, N, Mittal, N., and Ittyerah, N., "Urban Transport Crisis in India", Transport Policy, Vol.12, 2005.
  51. Ranjan, Prabhash and Raju, Deepak, "The Enigma of Enforceability of Investment Treaty Arbitration Awards in India", Asian Journal of Comparative Law, Vol.6, No.1, 2011.
  52. Ravindra, Geetha, "India: Panchayats Mediation and Lok Adalat People's Court Conciliation and the Institutionalization of ADR", Stephanie P. Stobbe, Conflict Resolution in Asia, Lexington Books, 2018.
  53. Ribeiro-Biadaoui, Joao, Andriotis, T. Lee, S., and Taguchi, Jan, "Settling Direct Disputes with Sovereigns : Striving for Transparency in the Settlement of Public -Private Partnership Disputes", Journal of International Business and Law, Vol.17, No.2. 2018.
  54. Sambrani, N. Vinod, "PPP from Asia and African Perspective towards Infrastructure Development: A Case Study of Greenfield Bangalore International Airport, India", Procedia, 2014.
  55. Sharma, Rohit and Newman, Peter, "Urban Rail and Sustainable Development Key Lessons from Hong Kong, New York, London, and India for Emerging Cities", Transportation Research Procedia, Vol. 26, 2017.
  56. Swamy, R, Tiwari, P, and Sawhney, A., "Assessing Determinants of PPP Project Performance: Applying AHP to Urban Drinking Water Sector in India", Liverpool John Moores University, 2018.
  57. Valasek, Martin and Wilson, Frederic, "Distinguishing Expert Determination from Arbitration: The Canadian Approach in a Comparative Perspective", Arbitration International, Vol.29, No.1, 2013.
  58. World Bank Group, Public-Private Partnerships Reference Guide Version 2, 2014.