Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association (한국가정과교육학회지)

Korea Home Economics Education Association (한국가정과교육학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Revisited meta-analysis of the effects of practical reasoning instruction on students' achievements in Home Economics classes

가정과수업에서 실천적추론수업의 학생성취에 대한 효과성 연구의 메타분석

  • Yu, Nan Sook (Dept. of Home Economics Education, Research Institute for Human Ecology, Chonnam National University)
  • 유난숙 (전남대학교 가정교육과, 생활과학연구소)
  • Received : 2018.09.03
  • Accepted : 2018.09.20
  • Published : 2018.09.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

The purposes of this study was to identify the magnitude and direction of the effects of Practical Reasoning Instruction (PRI) on students' achievements in Home Economics classes using the meta-analysis method and to examine whether the effects of PRI vary across publication status, study design, year of the studies, school level, gender of students, type of students' achievements, content area, location where the interventions of PRI were conducted, and duration. Thirty-four primary studies with 44 effect sizes were analyzed with calculation method of Becker(1988). A funnel plot method result revealed no publication bias. The results of this meta-analysis are as follows. First, PRI was more effective than traditional instruction on students' achievements. A summary statistic was 0.60 with a standard error of .074, which means that an increase of about two-third of a standard deviation beyond what would be expected from traditional instruction was gained from PRI intervention. Second, categorical and regression analyses were employed to find the sources of variance and moderators that predict the effects of PRI. The moderator analyses revealed no statistically significant effects of publication status, study design, school level, gender of students, type of students' achievements, and duration. Content area, location where the interventions of PRI were revealed to be moderators. It was concluded that PRI was effective in improving students' achievements regardless of publication status, study design, year of the studies, school level, gender of students, type of student achievement, and duration.

본 연구의 목적은 가정과수업에서 실천적추론수업을 적용하여 학생성취에 대한 효과를 살펴본 선행연구들을 양적으로 메타분석함으로써 효과크기를 알아보고, 실천적추론수업의 효과가 어떤 변수에 따라 달라지는 지 분석하는 데 있다. 분석대상의 기준에 맞는 선행연구를 검색한 결과, 1999년부터 2018년까지 수행된 34개 연구가 선정되었다. Becker(1988)가 제안한 방법을 이용하여 사례수를 고려한 표준화된 평균변화로부터 효과크기를 계산한 결과, 34개 분석대상 연구로부터 44개의 효과크기가 산출되었다. 분석에 앞서 출판여부에 따른 오류를 깔대기 기법을 이용하여 평가한 결과, 오류는 없었으며 연구결과는 다음과 같다. 첫째, 동질성검증 결과, 랜덤 효과 모형을 적용하였으며 실천적추론수업은 전통적 수업에 비해 학생성취에 통계적으로 의미있게 효과적인 것으로 나타났다(효과크기=0.60, SE=.074). 둘째, 조절변인을 찾기 위해 범주형 변수 및 연속형 변수 자료분석을 실행한 결과, 실천적추론수업의 효과성에 대한 선행연구들이 다룬 내용 영역과 학교소재지에 따라 효과크기가 다른 것으로 나타났다. 반면, 출판여부, 연구설계 방법, 분석대상 연도, 학교급, 연구대상자들의 성별, 학생성취의 종류, 수업시수 등에 따라서는 효과크기가 다르지 않았다.

Keywords

References

  1. Bae, J. -Y. (2018). The effects of practical problem-based Home Economics instruction on creativity of middle school students focusing on the content element of 'clothing management and recycle'. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  2. Becker, B. J. (1988). Synthesizing standardized mean-change measures. British Journal of Mathematical and Statistical Psychology, 41, 257-278. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.2044-8317.1988.tb00901.x
  3. Becker, B. J. (2000). Multivariate meta-analysis. In H. E. A. Tinsley & S. Brown (Eds.), Handbook of applied and multivariate statistics and mathematical modeling (pp. 499-525). San Diego, CA: Academic Press. 499-525.
  4. Borenstein, M., Hedges, L. V., Higgins, J. P. T., & Rothstein, H. R. (2009). Introduction to meta-analysis. John Wiley & Sons.
  5. Brown, M. M. (1978). A conceptual scheme and decision-rules for the selection and organization of home economics curriculum content. Madison, WI: Wisconsin Department of Public Instruction.
  6. Brown, M. M., & Paolucci, B. (1979). Home economics: A definition. Washington, DC: American Home Economics Association.
  7. Byun, H. (1999). The effect of practical reasoning instruction in Home Economics of the critical thinking: Family relations and resource management. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  8. Byun, H., & Chae, J. (2002). The effect of practical reasoning instruction in Home Economics on the critical thinking: Focusing on family relations and resource management. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 14(3), 1-9.
  9. Chae, J. (1999). The effects of practical reasoning instruction in Home Economics and other factors on Korean high school female students' decision making skills. Journal of Korean Home Economics Association, 37(3), 43-61.
  10. Chae, J., Park, M., Kim, S., & Han, J. (2010). Introduction to Home Economics education. Gyeonggi: Kyomunsa.
  11. Chae, J., & Yoo, T. (2006). The effects of practical reasoning Home Economics instruction on middle school students' self-esteem. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 18(1), 31-47.
  12. Chae, J., Yoo, T., Park, M., & Lee, J. (2003). The effects of practical reasoning Home Economics instruction on morality of middle school students. Journal of Korean Home Economics Association, 41(12), 53-68.
  13. Chang, H. -K. (1994). Lesson plan development for "Human development and family relationship" part based on Marjorie Brown's Home Economics curriculum model. Unpublished master's thesis, Ewha Womans University, Seoul, Korea.
  14. Cho, H. -J. (1999). A study of teaching based on Practical Problems solving on the area of food habits in middle school Home Economics. Unpublished master's thesis, Chungang University, Seoul, Korea.
  15. Cho, H. -J., & Ahn, S. (2000). A study of teaching based on Practical Problems solving on the area of food habits in middle school Home Economics. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 12(2), 29-45.
  16. Cho, H. -J., & Lee, G. (2004). The analysis and the effect of the Practical Problem Solving method of the clothings chapter in middle school Home Economics and Technology in the 7thcurriculum. The Secondary Education Research, 52(2), 385-417.
  17. Choi, J. (2008). Meta-analysis on the effects of the problem solving instruction in the Practical Arts (Technology, Home Economics) education. Journal of Korean Practical Arts Education, 14(4), 283-302. https://doi.org/10.17055/jpaer.2008.14.4.283
  18. Choi, S. (2010). A development and evaluation of Practical Problem-based lesson plans with multiple intelligence: Focused on the unit 'Nutrition & meals' of Home Economics in middle school. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  19. Choi, S.-Y., & Chae, J.-Y. (2011). A development and evaluation of practical problem-based Home Economics lesson plans applying to multiple intelligence teaching-learning strategy: Focused on the unit 'Nutrition & Meals' of middle Home Economics subject matter. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 23(1), 87-111.
  20. Choi, Y. (2002). The effects of Practical Reasoning study on problem solving ability in Home Economics. Unpublished master's thesis, Chonnam National University, Gwangju, Korea.
  21. Cohen, J. (1988). Statistical power analysis for the behavioral sciences (2nded.). Hillsdale, NJ: Lawrence Erlbaum Associates.
  22. Cooper, H. (1998). Synthesizing research: A guide for literature reviews (3rd ed.). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage.
  23. Doh, N. (1997). Lesson plans applying a practical problem solving model on the personal development and family relations in junior high schools' home economics. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  24. Egger, M., Davey, S. G., Schneider, M., & Minder, C. (1997). Bias in meta-analysis detected by a simple, graphical test. British Medical Journal, 315, 629-634. https://doi.org/10.1136/bmj.315.7109.629
  25. Glass, G. V. (1976). Primary, secondary, and meta-analysis of research. Educational Researcher, 5, 3-8.
  26. Glass, G. V., McGaw, B., & Smith, M. L. (1981). Meta-analysis in social research. Beverly Hills, CA: Sage.
  27. Han, J. (2014). Experiences of the teachers and students in the practical problem based Home Economics class. Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  28. Hedges, L. V. & Olkin, I. (1985). Statistical methods for meta-analysis. Orlando, FL: Academic Press.
  29. Hedges, L. V., & Stook, W. (1983). The effects of class size: An examination of rival hypotheses. American Educational Research Journal, 20, 63-85. https://doi.org/10.3102/00028312020001063
  30. Jackson, G. (1980). Methods for integrative reviews. Review of Educational Research, 50, 438-484. https://doi.org/10.3102/00346543050003438
  31. Jung, S. J. (2014). The effect of practical problem-focused teaching-learning of unit 'understanding of family' in middle school Technology and Home Economics on improvement of students' perspective on health family. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  32. Kang, K. (2010). The development and application of Practical Problem-based lesson plan on consumer choice of genetically modified food: Focused on the 'dietary life' unit in high school Home Economics. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  33. Kang, K., & Kim, Y. (2010). The development and application of Practical Problem-based lesson plan on consumer choice of genetically modified food: Focused on the 'dietary life' unit in high school Home Economics. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 22(2), 101-113.
  34. Kim, E. (2009). Developing and implementing Practical Problem Based lesson plan to improve self-leadership skills: focused on the unit of 'Youth's self management' in middle school Technology & Home Economics. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea University, Seoul, Korea.
  35. Kim, E. -S. (2010). Development and application of Home Economics teaching-learning plan for the improvement of gender equity awareness and family life among middle school student. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  36. Kim, E.-S., & Cho, B. E. (2010). The application of a practical problem-based lesson plan for the 'Understanding myself and my family' unit th heighten awareness of gender-role equity degree of participation in household chores. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 22(3), 77-94.
  37. Kim, H. (2004). The development and application of web-based Practical Problem-Solving learning lesson plan: The case of the adolescent nutrition and diet unit in middle school technical and home economics class. Unpublished master's Thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  38. Kim, J. S. (2007). Development and application of food life education program based on practical problem-solving approach. Unpublished master's thesis, Kyungnam University, Kyungnam, Korea
  39. Kim, J. -W. (2007). Development, application and assessment of Practical Problem-based instruction for the food & nutrition field in middle school Technology & Home Economics: Compared with competency-based instruction. Unpublished master's thesis, Seoul National University, Korea.
  40. Kim, S. -E. (2007). The effect of Practical Problem Solving study in Food and Nutrition area on elementary school student's critical thinking disposition. Unpublished master's thesis, Cheongju National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  41. Kim, S. -H. (2006). The differences in adolescents' decision making abilities according to the level of critical thinking in terms of practical problem-based instruction of Home Economics. Unpublished master's thesis, Kyungpook National University, Daegu, Korea.
  42. Kim, S. -H., & Jang, Y. -O. (2007). The differences in adolescents' decision making abilities according to the level of critical thinking in terms of practical problem-based instruction of Home Economics. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 19(1), 133-148.
  43. Kim, M. -J. (2013). Development and application of practical problem-focused teaching-learning plan for helping teenagers' healthy friendship. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  44. Kim, M. S. (2010). The development and application of teaching-learning process plans for cultivating awareness of the secondary school student's LOHAS (Lifestyles of Health and Sustainability): Focused on 'choice and control of clothing'. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  45. Kim, M. S., & Lee, H. J. (2010). The development and application of teaching-learning process plans for raising awareness of the secondary school student's LOHAS(Lifestyles of Health and Sustainability) -Focused on the unit of 'the choice and maintenance of clothing' in Technology-Home Economics-. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 22(1), 51-65.
  46. Kim, Y.-N. (2009). The development and application of practical problem-focused teaching-learning process plans on the elderly housing in high school technology-Home Economics. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  47. Kim, Y. -S. (2010). The effect of library assisted Practical Problem-Based Home Economics instruction on student's consciousness and attitude of 'life and career planning'. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea University, Seoul, Korea.
  48. Kim, Y. -N., & Cho, J. (2009). The Development and Application of Practical Problem Focused Teaching-Learning process plan for the later life: in high school Technology & Home Economics. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 22(1), 1-19.
  49. Kim, S. -H., & Jang, Y. (2007). The differences in adolescents' decision making abilities according to the level of critical thinking in terms of practical problem-based instruction of Home Economics. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 19(1), 133-148.
  50. Kim, E., & Lee, Y. (2009). Developing and implementing Practical Problem Based lesson plan to improve self-leadership skills: focused on the unit of 'Youth's self management' in middle school Technology & Home Economics. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 21(4), 35-54.
  51. Kim, Y. -S., & Lee, Y. (2010). The effect of library assisted Practical Problem-Based Home Economics instruction on student's consciousness and attitude of 'life and career planning'. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 22(2), 61-79.
  52. Kister, J. Laurenson, S., & Boggs, H. (1995). Family relations resource guide. Work and Family Life Program. Ohio Department of Education.
  53. Ko, M. -J. (2012). The effects of green food education program based on practical problem solutions on the dietary attitudes of elementary school students. Unpublished master's thesis, Gyeongin National University of Education, Gyeonggi, Korea.
  54. Ko, M.-J., & Kim, Y. H. (2012). The effects of green food education program based on the practical problem solutions to the dietary attitudes of elementary school students. Journal of Korean Practical Arts Education, 25(2), 151-172.
  55. Koo, S. -H(2009). Developing of graphic organizer and practical problem-based teaching-learning process plans for constructing a unit on the Home Economics textbook in a middle school: The case of a unit 'the menu and selecting food' on 8 grade of Technology and Home Economics. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  56. Laster, J. F. (1982). A practical action teaching model. Journal of Home Economics, 74(3), 41-44.
  57. Lee, D. H. (2010). Effect of practical problem solving instruction on problem solving ability and dietary self-efficacy: Centering on the field of food and nutrition area of practical arts education. Unpublished master's thesis, Chuncheon National University of Education, Gangwon, Korea.
  58. Lee, D., & Yang, J. (2010). Effects of Practical Problem Solving Instruction on problem solving ability and dietary self-efficacy: Centering on the unit of food and nutrition of Practical Arts Education. Journal of Korean Practical Arts Education, 23(1), 73-94.
  59. Lee, G. (2010). Practical problem-focused instructional design applying universal design concept and effects: Focusing on 'Designing my home'. Unpublished master's thesis, Gyeongsang National University, Kyungnam, Korea.
  60. Lee, H. (1999). The effects of Practical Reasoning Instruction in Home Economics on high school female students' creativity. Unpublished master's thesis, Ewha Womans University, Seoul, Korea.
  61. Lee, Jin-Hee (2008). Development and evaluation of Practical Problem-based Home Economics teaching-learning process plans by blended learning strategy: the case of a unit 'The youth and consumer life'. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  62. Lee, Jin-Hee & Chae, J. -H. (2008). Development of practical problem-based Home Economics teaching learning process plans by blended learning strategy: Focusing on a unit 'the youth and consumer life'. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 20(4), 19-42.
  63. Lee, Ji-Hyun. (2010). Effects of practical problem solving study on the environmental literacy of elementary school students: The case of a unit 'My environment-friendly life' in Practical Arts. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  64. Lee, J. H. (2011). Development of practical problem-focused teaching plan for 'family life in old age' unit and its effect on teenagers' 'preparation for successful aging': Cooperative study between students in academic and those in vocational high schools. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  65. Lee, J. H., & Cho, B. E. (2011). The effect of Home Economic education teaching plans for students in academic and those in vocational high schools' 'preparation for successful aging' in the 'family life in old age' unit: A comparative study between practical problem-teaching lesson plans and instructor-led teaching and learning plans. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 23(4), 105-124.
  66. Lee, J. H., & Choi, J. (2011). Effects of practical problem solving instruction on the environmental Literacy of elementary schol students: the case of a unit 'my environment-friendly life' in practical Arts. Journal of Korean Practical Arts Education, 24(1), 55-80.
  67. Lee, G., & Jang, S. (2010). Practical Problem-Focused instructional design and its perception applying universal design. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 22(2), 155-169.
  68. Lee, S. -H., & Yoo, T. -M.(2008). Focus group interview for the development of an in-service educational program on the practical problem focused Home Economics curriculum. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 20(3), 1-23.
  69. Leucht, S., Kissling, W., & Davis, J. M. (2009). How to read and understand and use systematic reviews and meta-analyses. Acta Psychiatrica Scandinavica, 119(6), 443-450. https://doi.org/10.1111/j.1600-0447.2009.01388.x
  70. Lipsey, M. W., & Wilson, D. B. (2001). Practical meta-analysis. Applied Social Research Methods Series (Vol. 49). Thousand Oaks, CA: Sage Publications.
  71. Moon, S. (1999). The effect of Practical Reasoning Instruction applied to food and nutrition units on female high school student's morality. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  72. Moon, S., & Chae, J. (2001). The effect of Practical Reasoning Home Economics instruction applied to food and nutrition units on female high school student's morality. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 13(3), 119-130.
  73. Park, M. R. (2010). Application and development of teachimg-learning plan for 'sustainable residence created with neighbor'. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  74. Park, M., & Cho, J. (2010). Application and development of teachimg-learning plan for 'sustainable residence created with neighbor'. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 22(3), 1-18.
  75. Park, S. (2009). Development and application of teaching program for the 'Being parents' segment of high school Technology & Home Economics: focusing on practical inference instruction. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education.
  76. Park, S., & Cho, B. (2009). The application and effectiveness of a Practical Reasoning model of teaching and learning curriculum for the 'Parenthood' unit in high school Technology & Home Economics. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 21(2), 187-202.
  77. Pillemer, D., & Light, R. (1980). Synthesizing outcomes: How to use research evidence from many studies. Harvard Educational Review, 50(2), 176-195. https://doi.org/10.17763/haer.50.2.v755316522jkup33
  78. Pyun, E. (2009). The development of the teaching-learning process plans based on practical problem with motive induction strategy for 'Nutrition and meal of youth' unit. Unpublished master's thesis, Ewha Womans University.
  79. Ryu, S. (2007a). Effect of Practical Reasoning teaching strategy on elementary school students' problem solving action in Practical Arts instruction. Journal of Korean Practical Arts Education, 20(2), 75-87.
  80. Ryu, S. (2007b). Effect of Practical Reasoning Practical Arts instruction on elementary school students' problem solving action and ethical action. Journal of Korean Practical Arts Education, 20(4), 1-16. https://doi.org/10.17055/JPAER.2014.20.4.1
  81. Shin, H.-S., & Choi, Y.-M. (2003). The effect of practical reasoning study on problem solving ability in Home Economics. Journal of Human Ecology, 13, 36-47.
  82. Song, E. S. (2007). Effect of nature dying instruction based on Practical Problem Solving on Elemenraty school student's achievement motivation. Unpublished master's thesis, Cheongju National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  83. Song, E. S., & Cho, J. (2017). Practical problem-based teaching. learning process plan to develop and apply to enhance safety awareness in middle school students. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 29(1), 15-33. https://doi.org/10.19031/jkheea.2017.03.29.1.15
  84. Song, E. M. (2016). Practical, problem-based teaching-learning process to develop, apply, and enhance a sense of safety in middle school aged students. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  85. Song, M. (2003). The effect of the ICT teaching method by ICT instructional environment on learning the unit of 'Understanding of myself and family' in middle school Home Economics. Unpublished master's thesis, Gyeongsang National University, Kyungnam, Korea.
  86. Sung. E. (2000). Developing the curriculum by adapting the practical problem solving instruction model on the clothes purchasing chapter in middle school's home economics. Unpublished master's thesis, Seoul National University.
  87. Woo, Y.-S. (2018). A Study of development and application of a practical problem-based teaching-learning process for housing life with the neighborhood. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  88. Yoo, T. -M.. & Lee, H. -S. (2009). Effects of Practical Reasoning Instruction on Problem Solving Ability. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 21(2), 203-215.
  89. Yoo, T. & Lee S. H.(2014). A critical review of Korean Home Economics education research based on a critical science perspective. International Journal of Human Ecology, 15(1), 23-37. https://doi.org/10.6115/ijhe.2014.15.1.23
  90. Yoon, B. (1997). The effects of Practical Problem-Based Home Economics instruction on both female and male high school students. Unpublished master's thesis, Ewha Womans University.
  91. Yoon, B. & Chae, J. (1998). Effects of Practical Problem-Based Home Economics instruction perceived by both female and male high school students. Journal of Korean Home Economics Association, 36(5), 151-166.
  92. Yu, G. -H.(2004). Case work study through the application of practical problem-solving process. Unpublished master's thesis, Gangwon National University, Gangwon, Korea.
  93. Yu, J. H. (2012). Development of practical problem based teaching-learning plans of a unit 'Youth's self Management' and evaluation of its effectiveness in middle school Technology-Home Economics: Focused on middle school students' self efficacy, ego resilience and happiness. Unpublished master's thesis, Korea University, Seoul, Korea.
  94. Yu, J. H., & Lee, Y. S. (2013). Development of practical problem based teaching-learning plans and evaluation of its effectiveness on middle school students' self efficacy, ego resilience and happiness: Focused on the unit 'Youth's self management' in middle school Technology.Home Economics. Journal of Korean Home Economics Education Association, 25(4), 79-98.
  95. Yu, N. S. (2009). Home Economics teacher's reflection on Pedagogical Content Knowledge in Home Economics education. Unpublished doctoral dissertation, Korea National University of Education, Chungbuk, Korea.
  96. Yu, N. S. (2012). Meta-analysis of the effect of practical reasoning instruction on student outcome in Home Economics education in Korea. Asia Pacific Education Review, 13(4), 649-664. https://doi.org/10.1007/s12564-012-9226-9
  97. Yuk, S. H. (2010). Nurturing critical literacy through practical problem based instruction: Based instruction for the food nutrition field in high school education Home Economics Science. Unpublished master's thesis, Seoul National University, Korea.