Journal of Korean Society of Archives and Records Management (한국기록관리학회지)

Korean Society of Archives and Records Management (한국기록관리학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

A Study on the International Research Trends in Electronic Records Management: InterPARES 3 and ITrust Achievements

전자기록관리에 대한 국제 연구 동향 분석 - InterPARES 3와 ITrust 성과물을 중심으로 -

  • 박옥남 (상명대학교 문헌정보학과) ;
  • 박희진 (한성대학교 지식정보학부)
  • Received : 2016.01.24
  • Accepted : 2016.02.23
  • Published : 2016.02.29
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

This study aims to understand the concept and changes of the records management of InterPARES based on the analysis of background, main research interests, and major achievements of IP3 and ITrust. To this end, this study conducted a content analysis of IP3 and ITrust to drive main keywords. This study also utilized word clouds from IP project titles. In addition, a comparative analysis of IP3 and ITrust was conducted based on the environment, scope, core research areas, keywords, objectives, and record management life cycle perspectives. The research identified that InterPARES research was widely expanding the content and subject areas of the study: 1) to apply across the life cycle, as well as long-term preservation; 2) to focus on the concept of trust as well as the concept of authenticity; and 3) to include the concept of the Internet, digital forensics, and the open government along with electronic records.

본 연구는 InterPARES 3와 ITrust의 배경, 주요 연구분야, 주요 연구성과를 소개하고, IP 3와 ITrust 주요 연구내용의 비교분석을 통하여 InterPARES 프로젝트의 기록관리에 대한 개념 및 변화를 이해하고자 하였다. 이를 위해 IP 3와 ITrust 연구프로젝트에 대한 내용분석을 수행하였으며 이를 통해 주요 키워드를 도출하고, 연구프로젝트 제목을 워드클라우드로 도식화하여 IP 3와 ITrust 비교에 활용하였다. IP 3와 ITrust 연구결과를 환경, 범위, 주제, 키워드, 연구목표, 기록관리 생애주기관점에서 비교분석하였다. 연구결과 InterPARES는 1) 장기보존 뿐만 아니라 생애주기 전반에 적용될 수 있는 분야로, 2) 진본성의 개념에서 신탁의 개념으로, 3) 전자기록에서 인터넷, 디지털 포렌식, 열린정부 또는 공공데이터 등을 포함하는 범위로 연구의 내용과 주제가 광범위하게 확장되고 있음을 파악하였다.

Keywords

References

  1. 국가기록원 (2007). 전자기록의 관리와 보존을 위한 국제협력 아젠다 개발. 서울: 국가기록원. National Archives of Korea (2007). International Cooperation Agenda for Management and Preservation of Electronic Records. Seoul: National Archives of Korea.
  2. 김명옥, 리상용 (2010). 전자기록물의 장기보존을 위한 기능요소 연구. 한국기록관리학회지, 10(2), 101-126. Kim, Myeong-Ok & Lee, Sang-Yong (2010). A Study on the Functional Elements for Long-term Preservation of Electronic Records. Journal of Korean Society of Archives and Records Management, 10(2), 101-126.
  3. 김유승 (2014). 기록으로의 공공데이터 관리를 위한 제도적 고찰. 한국기록관리학회지, 14(1), 53-73. Kim, You-Seung (2014). A Study on Legal Issues of Public Data Management as Records:Focused on Analysis of the Act on Provision and Use of Public Data. Journal of Korean Society of Archives & Records Management, 14(1), 53-73. https://doi.org/10.14404/JKSARM.2014.14.1.053
  4. 박준영, 구자훈, 용찬호, 허의남 (2015). 하이브리드 클라우드에서의 보안 위험 평가 모델 연구. 한국정보과학회, 6, 1051-1053. Park, Jun-Young, Ku, Ja-Hun, Yong, Chan-Ho, & Huh, Eui-Nam (2015). A Study on Security Assessment Model in Hybrid Cloud Computing. Korean. The Society for Korean Information Science, 6, 1051-1053.
  5. 박형근 (2012). 퍼블릭 클라우드 컴퓨팅 사용 기업이 고려해야 할 보안 위험과 대응방안에 대한 소고. 정보보호학회논문지, 22(7), 46-53. Park, Hyung-Kun (2012). Public Enterprise Use Cloud Computing about Security Risks and Countermeasures. Journal of Institute of Information Security and Cryptology, 22(7), 46-53.
  6. 설문원 (2005). 기록의 품질기준분석 - 진본성, 신뢰성, 무결성, 가용성을 중심으로. 한국기록학연구, 11, 41-90. Seol, Moon-Won (2005). Quality Criteria for Measuring Authenticity, Reliability, Integrity and Usability of Records. Journal of Korean Society of Archival Studies, 11, 41-90.
  7. 오형용, 민병원, 오용선 (2011). SaaS기반 전자도서관 시스템에 최적화된 사용자 맞춤형 웹 인터페이스 디자인: LinkSaaS 웹사이트를 중심으로. 한국콘텐츠학회논문지, 11(5), 148-156. Oh, Hyungyong, Min, Byoung-Won, & Oh, Yong-Sun (2011). User Customized Web Interface Design Optimized for SaaS-based Digital Library System - focusing on the LinkSaaS Website. Journal of Korean Contents Society, 11(5), 148-156. https://doi.org/10.5392/JKCA.2011.11.5.148
  8. 이윤주, 이소연 (2009). 진본 전자기록의 장기보존을 위한 정책프레임워크 - InterPARES 성과물에 기초하여. 기록학연구, 19(1), 193-249. Lee, Yoon-Ju & Lee, So-Yeon (2009). A Policy Framework for the Long-term Preservation of Authentic Digital Records: Based on InterPARES Studies. The Korean Journal of Archives Studies, 19(1), 193-249.
  9. 이원상, 이성식 (2012). 클라우드 컴퓨팅 환경에서의 사이버범죄와 대응방안 연구. 형사정책연구, 7, 1-273. Lee, Won Sang & Lee, Seong Sik (2012). A Study on Countermeasures against Cybercrime in Cloud Computing. Criminal Policy Research, 7, 1-273.
  10. 임지훈, 김은총, 방기영, 이유진, 김용 (2014). 클라우딩 컴퓨팅 기반의 전자기록관리시스템 구축방안에 관한 연구. 한국기록관리학회, 14(3), 153-179. Lim, Ji-Hoon, Kim, Eun-Chong, Bang, Ki-Young, Lee, Yu-Jin, & Kim, Yong (2014). An Application Method Study on the Electronic Records Management Systems Based on Cloud Computing. Journal of Korean Society of Archives & Records Management, 14(3), 153-179.
  11. 임진희 (2011). 연구 품질 확보를 위한 기록관리 방안 연구. 한국기록관리학회지, 11(1), 183-206. Yim, Jin-Hee (2011). A Study on the Records Management Tasks for Obtaining Quality Research and Laboratory. Journal of Korean Society of Archives and Records Management, 11(1), 183-206.
  12. 홍예슬, 강서영, 김승인 (2012). 국내 포털사이트의 클라우드 스포리지 서비스 사용성 평가 연구. 디지털디자인학 연구, 12(1), 165-175. Hong, Yeo-Sul, Kang, Seo-Young, & Kim, Seung-In (2012). Evaluation of the Usability of Local Web Portal Cloud Storage Services - Focused on Naver NCloud and Daum Cloud. Research for Digital Design, 12(1), 165-175.
  13. Andaur, G. & Barnard, A. (2015). LA05 - Open Data and Open Government in Latin America. InterPARES Trust.
  14. Barnard, A. (2014). LA02 - Policies for government records produced and maintained by IFAI. InterPARES Trust.
  15. Boel, J. (2015). TR01-The Use of Cloud Services for Records Management in International Organizations. InterPARES Trust.
  16. Bonilla, E. (2015). LA06 - Email in Mexican Governmental Agencies-INAI. InterPARES Trust.
  17. Bunn, J. (2015). EU19 - The role of the records manager / records management in an open government environment in the UK. InterPARES Trust.
  18. Bunn, J. (2015). EU28 - User Perceptions of Born-Digital Authenticity. InterPARES Trust.
  19. Cai, Y. (2015). AS06 - Policies, legislation, regulations, and standards for RM in the cloud. InterPARES Trust.
  20. Cai, Y. (2015). AS09 - Digital Certificates in e-Government in China. InterPARES Trust.
  21. Callow, H., Sloan, B., & Shaffer, E. (2009). Alma Mater Society of the University of British Columbia - Policies and Procedures for Web Site Preservation: Final Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  22. Caravaca, M. M. & Nahum, R. (2012). Design and Implementation of a Records Management System at ICCROM: Final Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  23. Casellas, L-E. (2013). EU06 - Girona City Council in the Cloud: Analysis of e-Services between Public Administrations. InterPARES Trust.
  24. Chaterera, F. (2016). AF03 - Enterprise digital records management in Zimbabwe. InterPARES Trust.
  25. Childs, S. (2015). EU17 - A Case Example of Public Trust in Online Records: The UK care.data Programme. InterPARES Trust.
  26. Cohen, F. (2015). NA23 - Sharing cyber-threats and events in cloud-based archives. InterPARES Trust.
  27. Cohen, F. (2015). TR07 - Inviolable Distributed Global Archives for Transnationals. InterPARES Trust.
  28. Croatia Team (2015). EU24 - Long-Term Preservation of Digital Print Masters in Croatia. InterPARES Trust.
  29. David, G. (2015). EU26 - Monitoring the Information Management Function in Hospitals in Portugal. InterPARES Trust.
  30. Demoulin, M. (2015). NA14 - Developing Model Cloud Computing Contracts. InterPARES Trust.
  31. Demoulin, M. & Yves Marcoux, Y. (2015). NA21 - Model for a trusting hybrid records management of the statement. InterPARES Trust.
  32. Dingwall, G. (2014). NA09 - Establishing Retention and Disposition Specifications and Schedules in a Digital Environment. InterPARES Trust.
  33. Duranti, L. (2013). Introduction to InterPARES. InterPARES Trust.
  34. Engvall, T. (2015). EU11 - Role of the Archivist and Records Manager in an Open Government Environment in Sweden. InterPARES Trust.
  35. Flinn, A. & Shepherd, E. (2015). EU19 - The role of the records manager / records management in an open government environment in the UK. InterPARES Trust.
  36. Foscarini, F. (2014). NA04 - Putting the "Fun" back in "Functional". RInterPARES Trust.
  37. Foscarini, F. (2014). NA13 - Patents, Petitions and Trust - From Traditional to Online Environment. InterPARES Trust.
  38. Franks, P. (2015). NA05 - Social Media and Trust in Government. InterPARES Trust.
  39. Franks, P. (2015). NA06 - Retention and Disposition in a Cloud Environment. InterPARES Trust.
  40. Goh, E. (2013). Organizational Culture: Final Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  41. Groover, M. & Tome, A. (2012). Public Sector Audit Reports on Digital Recordkeeping: General Study Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  42. Guanyan, F. (2015). AS10 - Disclosure of Chinese Government Information. InterPARES Trust.
  43. Guercio, M. (2012). Guidelines and Recommendations for E-Mail Records Management and Long-Term Preservation. InterPARES 3 Project.
  44. Guercio, M. (2015). EU04 - Policies for Recordkeeping and Digital Preservation: Recommendations for Analysis and Assessment Services. InterPARES Trust.
  45. Hua, F. (2014). AS05 - Enterprise business records management in the cloud. InterPARES Trust.
  46. Inefuku, H. W. & Mclellan, C. (2010). Morris and Helen Belkin Art Gallery - Policies and Procedures for Acquisition and Preservation of Digital Art: Final Report. InterPARES 3 Projcet.
  47. Jimenez, J. S. (2012). The Protocol Register of Terrassa City Council: Case Study Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  48. Kalusopa, T. (2016). AF04 - Enterprise digital records management in Botswana. InterPARES Trust.
  49. Katuu, S. (2014). TR03 - Security Classification of Records in the Cloud in International Organizations. InterPARES Trust.
  50. Katuu, S. (2015). TR04 - Assessing Information Systems: A Template for Analysis. InterPARES Trust.
  51. Katuu, S. & Ngoepe, M. (2015). AF01 - Curriculum Alignments at Institutions of Higher Learning in Africa. InterPARES Trust.
  52. Klein, P. (2014). NA19 - International Reporting Program Creative Commons Content Archive. InterPARES Trust.
  53. Kulcu, O (2015). EU07 - Evaluating Metadata Description Schemas of the Cultural Heritage Organizations in Electronic Environments for Interoperability. InterPARES Trust.
  54. Lacombe, C. R. (2015). LA01 - Preserving and managing records' life-cycle in a multi-provenance government digital environment. InterPARES Trust.
  55. Lemieux, V. L. (2015). NA07 - Sensors in the Cloud. InterPARES Trust.
  56. Leverich, M. & Whyte, M. (2014). NA03 - Standard of Practice for Trust in Protection of Authoritative Records. InterPARES Trust.
  57. Liu, Y. (2015). AS04 - Responsibility Chain of Records Management and Preservation in Cloud for Local Governments in China. InterPARES Trust.
  58. Lysenko, V. (2015). NA20 - Role of Cyber Tools and Social Media in the Development of the Ukraine Crisis. InterPARES Trust.
  59. Makhlouf-Shabou, B. (2016). EU29 - Information Governance Maturity in EU Public Administration-Phase 1. InterPARES Trust.
  60. Makhlouf-Shabou, B. (2016). EU30 - Information Governance Maturity in EU Public Administrations-Phase 2. InterPARES Trust.
  61. McCausland, S. (2015). Review and update of Digital Records Pathways: Topics in Digital Preservation Modules - Stage 1. InterPARES Trust.
  62. McLeod, J. (2015). EU18 - Economic Models for Cloud Storage. InterPARES Trust.
  63. Mclellan, C. & Malmas, S. (2010). North Vancouver Museum and Archives - Policies and Procedures for the Preservation of Electronic and Digital Materials Acquired from Private Donors: Final Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  64. McLelland, R., Hurley, G., & Collins, D. (2014). NA10 - Contract Terms for Cloud-Based Record Keeping Services. InterPARES Trust.
  65. McLeod, J. (2015). EU20 - Economic Models for Cloud Storage Decision-Making. InterPARES Trust.
  66. Michetti, G. (2015). NA22 - Arrangement and Description in the Cloud. InterPARES Trust.
  67. Michetti, G. (2015). TR05 - Development of an ontology of functional activities for archival systems. InterPARES Trust.
  68. Mitchell, G. (2015). TR02 - IFRCjobs Case Study - A SaaS Recruiting Tool. InterPARES Trust.
  69. Moseti-Morara, I. (2016). AF05 - Enterprise digital records management in Kenya. InterPARES Trust.
  70. Nathan, L. (2014). NA17 - Plurality and Policy: Designing for Trust in the Digital Age. InterPARES Trust.
  71. Ngoepe, M., Mohlabi, P., & Katuu, S. (2015). AF02 - Managing records in networked environments using EDRMS applications: Rand Water. InterPARES Trust.
  72. Oh, S. (2014). AS01 - Security Awareness of Record Managers in Korea. InterPARES Trust.
  73. Oliver, G. (2015). AA01 - Digital Preservation in the Cloud. InterPARES Trust.
  74. Oliver, G. (2015). AA03 - Dark Repositories as a Service. InterPARES Trust.
  75. Oliver, G. (2015). AA04 - Reinventing business and operating models for trusted archival services that accommodate both analog and digital records. InterPARES Trust.
  76. Oliver, G. (2015). AA05 - Trusted online access to distributed holdings of digital public records. InterPARES Trust.
  77. Oliver, G. (2015). AA06 - Encouraging records creating agencies to use and trust digital archiving. InterPARES Trust.
  78. Oliver, G. (2015). AA08 - The Impact of Access to Trusted Digitised Archives of Indigenous Languages:Case Study of Te Reo Maori. InterPARES Trust.
  79. Oliver, G. (2015). AS03 - Trusted Certification Based on Long-Term Preservation of Digital Archival Resources. InterPARES Trust.
  80. Oliver, T. (2015). AA02 - User Perspectives of Trust. RInterPARES Trust.
  81. Paivarenta, T. & Samuelsson, G. (2015). EU14 - ITrust and Benefits Realization Management. InterPARES Trust.
  82. Park, E. (2012). Certified e-Document Authority (CeDA) - Policies, Procedures and Systems for Trusted Third Party Certification Authorities of Electronic Documents: Final Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  83. Park, E. (2012). Examining the Criteria for Open Standard File Formats: Final Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  84. Park, E. (2015). NA18 - Assessment of Privacy-Preserving and Security Techniques for Records Management. InterPARES Trust.
  85. Pearce-Moses, R. (2015). NA01 - Core Terminology for InterPARES Trust. InterPARES Trust.
  86. Rogers, C. & Shaffer, E. (2013). Open-Source Records Management Software: Final Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  87. Rogers, C. & Tennis, J. (2012). Appliction Profile for Authenticity Metadata. InterPARES 3 Project.
  88. Rozhneva, Z. (2015). EU22 - Personal Cloud: Regulation and Trust. InterPARES Trust.
  89. Scarpinetti, A. J. et al. (2012). Public Relations and Press Office of the State University of Campinas (UNICAMP) - Digital Photographic Records: Final Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  90. Schenkolewski-Kroll, S. (2015). EU01 - Reesearch of Retention and Disposition Processes in an Internet Website of the Government of Israel. InterPARES Trust.
  91. Serra, M. & Roca, E. (2012). The Preservation of Vital E-Records in Pompeu Fabra University (UPF) - collaboration with University of Girona (UdG): Case Study Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  92. Shenkolewski-Kroll, S. (2015). EU25 - Using Web Analytics in Appraisal of Records on the Foreign Ministry of Israel Website. InterPARES Trust.
  93. Shepherd, E. (2015). EU02 - Open Government Data Literature Review. InterPARES Trust.
  94. Shepherd, E. & Flinn, A. (2015). EU21 - Recordkeeping Open Data and Privacy Literature Review. InterPARES Trust.
  95. Sheppard, A. (2015). NA15 - Identifying Privacy Concerns and Attendant Issues in Cloud Computing. InterPARES Trust.
  96. Soyez, S. (2015). EU16 - Model for Trustworthy Records Management of the Statement of Offence. InterPARES Trust.
  97. Stancic, H. (2014). EU05 - Models for Monitoring and Auditing of Compliance in the Flow from Registration to Archive in e-Register. InterPARES Trust.
  98. Stancic, H. (2014). EU08 - Ensuring Trust in Storage in Infrastructure-as-a-Service (IaaS). InterPARES Trust.
  99. Stancic, H. (2015). EU09 - Comparative Analysis of Implemented Governmental e-Services. InterPARES Trust.
  100. Stancic, H. (2015). EU15 - Analysis of the Interoperability Possibilities of Implemented Governmental e-Services. InterPARES Trust.
  101. Suderman, J. (2014). NA08 - Implications of Open Government, Open Data, and Big Data on the Management of Digital Records in an Online Environment. InterPARES Trust.
  102. Suderman, J. (2015). NA11 - Historical Study of Cloud-Based Services. InterPARES Trust.
  103. Sundqvist, A. (2014). EU13 - The Materiality of Records and Attributes of Trust. InterPARES Trust.
  104. Tennis, J. & Rogers, C. (2014). NA16 - Metadata, Mutatis Mutandis - Design Requirements for Authenticity. InterPARES Trust.
  105. The InterPARES Canada Team (2007). UBC Graduate School of Journalism - Preservation and Access System for High Definition Digital Video Archive in Online and Electronic Formats: Case Study Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  106. The InterPARES Canada Team (2010). Digital Preservation Cost-Benefit Models: General Study Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  107. The InterPARES Canada Team (2010). International Standards Relevant to the InterPARES 3 Project: Final Report.
  108. Thibodeau, K. (20155). NA12 - Preservation as a Service for Trust (PaaST). InterPARES Trust.
  109. Tiurmenko, I. (2014). EU12 - Social and Ethical Foundations of Preservation of Digital Historical-Cultural Heritage. InterPARES Trust.
  110. University College London (2014). EU03 - Role of the Records Manager in an Open Government Environment in the UK. InterPARES Trust.
  111. Varlamova, L. N., Kukarina, Y. M., & Lanskoy, G. N. (2015). EU23 - Contemporary studies of Records Management and Internet Archives in Russia. InterPARES Trust.
  112. Voutssas, J. (2012). Records/Archives Appraisal in Latin America (including Spain): Publication (Textos y contextos II, VIII, 2013). InterPARES 3 Project.
  113. Voutssas, J. (2014). LA03 - Regulations for Federal Public Administration (FPA) Cloud Data Storage. InterPARES Trust.
  114. Voutssas, J. (2015). LA04 - Records in the Cloud survey in Mexico and then beyond. InterPARES Trust.
  115. Xie, S. (2012). Establishing a Recordkeeping System for Records with Unstructured data Utilizing Shared Drive: Final Report. InterPARES 3 Project.
  116. Xie, S. (2014). AS02 - Ensuring Trustworthiness of the Agent of Public Trust in China. InterPARES Trust.
  117. Zhang, N. (2014). AS08 - Exploration of electronic records' authenticity: social awareness. InterPARES Trust.