An Optical Pulse-Width Modulation Generator Using a Single-Mode Fabry-Pérot Laser Diode

Abstract

We have proposed and experimentally verified a pulse-width modulation (PWM) generator which directly generated a PWM signal in the optical domain. Output waveforms were clear at the repetition rate of 16 MHz; the duty cycle (DC) was from 14.7% to 72.1%; and the DC-control resolution was about 4.399%/dB. The PWM generator' operation principle is based on the injection-locking property of a single-mode Fabry-$P{\acute{e}}rot$ laser diode (SMFP-LD). The SMFP-LD, which has a self-locked mode wavelength at ${\lambda}_{PWM}$, was used to detect the power of the injection-locking signal (optical analog input). If the analog input power is high, the SMFP-LD is locked to the wavelength of the input signal ${\lambda}_a$ and there is no output after an optical bandpass filter (OBF). If the analog input power is low, the SMFP-LD is unlocked and there is output signal at ${\lambda}_{PWM}$ after the OBF. Thus, the SMFP-LD plus the OBF provide digital output for an analog input. The DC of the output PWM signal can be controlled by tuning the power of the analog input.

I. INTRODUCTION

Pulse-width modulation (PWM) is a well-known technique in the electrical domain and is used in several applications, such as telecommunications, power delivery and speed control, voltage regulation, inverters, and audio effects and amplification. In telecommunications, widths of pulses are used to specify data values, which are encoded at one end and decoded at the other [1]. PWM can be used to control the amount of power delivered to a load without incurring the losses that would result from linear power delivery by resistive means [2]. In efficient voltage regulators, PWM is used to switch voltage to the load with an appropriate DC to approximate an output voltage at the desired level [3, 4]. PWM is also used in sound (music) synthesis, in particular subtractive synthesis, as it gives a sound effect similar to a chorus, or slightly detuned oscillators played together [5]. Since electrical PWM is not suitable for applications where an electrically isolated amplifier is required (e.g. in medical electronics [6, 7]), nor in applications where a large common-mode signal is considered an important factor of disturbance in control (such as in the open/closed period of a Light-Triggered Thyristor (LTT) in high-voltage direct current (HVDC) conversion [8, 9]). Several schemes have been proposed so far for producing optical PWM signals [6, 10, 11]; however, none of them can directly generate an optical PWM signal in the optical domain. The common way to get an optical PWM signal in the schemes of [6, 10, 11] is to produce an electrical PWM signal first, then convert it into an optical PWM signal using an O/E converter. We have previously proposed an optical PWM generator (OPWMG) scheme using a SMFP-LD [12] in [13], in which analog signal power is kept constant while additional beam power (of the same wavelength as the analog input) is varied to control the DC. Since the analog input and additional beam have the same wavelength, the control of DC is difficult; hence this approach has the drawback of imprecise control of the output DC. In this paper, we propose another OPWMG scheme that has a larger DC range (14.7%-72.1%) and more precise control of the output DC, compared to that of the scheme proposed in [13]. In addition, a duty cycle versus analog input power (DC-vs-Pλa) curve with DC control resolution of about 4.399%/dB was obtained. In this proposed scheme, the analog input power Pλa is varied using a variable optical attenuator (VOA) to control the DC, and the assisting beam, which has the same wavelength as that of the SMFPLD’s self-locked mode (λPWM), has constant power Pλasst. The assisting beam in this paper is used to assist the SMFP-LD’s self-locked mode to quickly recover its original (unlocked) state, when Pλa is lower than the release power level, PRL. With the scheme proposed here, we experimentally found that the output waveform is clearer and the DC of the output PWM signal is easier to control.

 

II. OPERATION PRINCIPLE

A simple electrical PWM generator is composed of three functional parts [13]: an analog input, a reference, and a comparator. The comparator provides high output (ON) when the input value is less than the reference, and low output (OFF) when the input value is greater than or equal to the reference. Hence, based on the inequality between the analog input (typically a saw-tooth, ramp, triangle, or sinusoidal wave) and the reference, the comparator will provide a square wave as output (digital output) with tunable ON/OFF duration. Figure 1 shows the block diagram of the proposed OPWMG, where the output PWM signal is taken after the optical bandpass filter (OBF) at wavelength λPWM. The SMFP-LD used in our experiment was specially designed and developed in our laboratory to have a dominant self-locked mode with a high side-mode-suppression ratio [13]. To shorten the SMFP-LD’s recovery time after being injection-locked by the analog signal from an optical analog signal generator, the assisting light beam’s wavelength λasst is set to be the same as that of the SMFP-LD’s dominant self-locked mode (λasst=λPWM). In this proposed scheme, the assisting beam power Pλasst is kept constant; the assisting beam is used to help the SMFP-LD’s self-locked mode to recover the unlocked state quickly, which can yield better output waveforms. The SMFP-LD in the proposed scheme has the property of bistability [14], which is explained as follow: When the SMFP-LD is injected with appropriate power from an external light beam at a wavelength close enough to one of the SMFP-LD’s side modes, it is fully injection-locked, and all of its side modes are suppressed. That power level is called full-lock power (PFL). The SMFP-LD’s locking state is released when the injected power is decreased to a level called release power (PRL). The SMFP-LD works as a comparator; both PFL and PRL were used as references, and Pλa is used to control the DC.

FIG. 1.Block diagram of the OPWMG where λa is the wavelength of the optical signal generator, λasst the wavelength of the assisting beam, λPWM the self-lock mode’s wavelength of the SMFP-LD (which carries the PWM signals), VOA the Variable Optical Attenuator, and PWM is Pulse Width Modulation.

According to the injection-locking and bistability properties of the SMFP-LD, the locking duration can be varied when the power differences (Pλa - PFL and Pλa - PRL) are varied. In other words, the DC can be varied as the change of Pλa compared to PRL and PFL. In this proposed scheme, Pλa is varied to control the relative difference between Pλa and PFL/PRL. It is noted that when λa, λasst, and Pλasst are constant, only power from the analog input contributes to the control of PWM’s DC. In fact, PRL and PFL can be changed, depending on the wavelength detuning of λa to the corresponding side mode of the SMFP-LD; however, in this paper we only focus on one specific wavelength detuning.

Figure 2 shows the relationship between Pλa and the output power, where the red dashed and black solid lines represent respectively the states of the analog input and output PWM signals before and after increasing Pλa. Pλa is controlled by the VOA after the MOD, as shown in Fig. 3. When Pλa is increased, more of the sinusoidal wave is above the locking power, and the locking duration is increased, or, in other words, the DC is decreased (DC2 < DC1). It is noted that the period is unchanged, if the analog input period (T) is constant (T2 = T1 = T). In conclusion, optical PWM signals can be generated in the optical domain, and the PWM’s DC can be controlled by varying the power of the analog input.

FIG. 2.Generated PWM before (red dashed line) and after (solid black line) increased input power, for the case where the input source is a sinusoidal wave. DC1, T1, DC2, and T2 are respectively the duty cycle and period of the output PWM generator before and after the analog input power is increased.

FIG. 3.Experimental setup of the OPWMG, where PC is the Polarization Controller, TLD the Tunable Laser Diode, MOD the Electro-absorption Optical Modulator, VOA the Variable Optical Attenuator, OC the Optical Circulator, CL the Optical Coupler, OBF the Optical Bandpass Filter, OSC the Oscilloscope, and EDFA is the Erbium-Doped Fiber Amplifier.

 

III. EXPERIMENTAL SETUP AND RESULTS

Figure 3 shows the experimental setup of the OPWMG where the threshold current, bias current, and temperature of the SMFP-LD are 11 mA, 19 mA, and 25.3℃ respectively. Under these working conditions the SMFP-LD has dominant modes at λPWM = 1546.96 nm. The optical analog input has a wavelength of 1550.4 nm, corresponding to the SMFP-LD’s side mode wavelength of 1550.28 nm (wavelength detuning Δλ = 1550.4 − 1550.28 = 0.12 nm). The assisting beam’s wavelength λasst was set to be the same as that of the SMFP-LD’s self-locked mode (λasst = λPWM = 1546.96 nm), and its lasing power was fixed at about −10.70 dBm (measured before the optical circulator). When the assisting beam was turned on, the SMFP-LD was fully locked for Pλa ≥ −5.77 dBm, and the SMFP-LD’s full-lock state was released for Pλa ≤ −6.68 dBm. Actually, the locking state was not fully released even when the input power was less than −6.68 dBm; we still observed the weak-lock phenomenon, where the self-locked mode power was reduced but not fully eliminated. The polarization controller PC1 is used to minimize the polarization-dependent loss in the Mach-Zehnder modulator (MOD), and PC2 and PC3 are used to maximize the TE optical powers that are injected into the SMFP-LD. Due to the injection-locking property of the FP-LD, the more TE power that is injected into the SMFP-LD, the greater the suppression of its side modes and the higher the power at the injected mode.

Figure 4 presents the spectra at the output of the SMFP-LD before the OBF, where in Fig. 4(a) the red dashed line represents the SMFP-LD spectrum only (assisting beam and analog input are turned off) and the black solid line represents the SMFP-LD spectrum when only the assisting beam is turned on. In this figure we can see the weak-lock phenomenon, where side-mode powers are reduced a little but not fully suppressed. In Figs. 4(b), 4(c), and 4(d) the red dashed line represents the spectra of the SMFP-LD when only the assisting beam is ON, and the black solid line represents the spectra of the SMFP-LD before the OBF when both assisting beam and optical analog input are ON (Pλa = −2.48, −4.48, and −7.48 dBm respectively). We can see the full-lock phenomena in Figs. 4(b) and 4(c), where all side modes of the SMFP-LD are deeply suppressed because Pλa (−2.48 and −4.48 dBm) is above the full-lock power level PFL = −5.77 dBm, whereas the full-lock state is released (all side modes are recovered) in Fig. 4(d) because Pλa = −7.48 dBm, which is below the release power level PRL = −6.68 dBm.

FIG. 4.Output spectra of the OPWMG at the output of the SMFP-LD and before the OBF, (a) without the assisting beam and analog input (red dashed line) and with only the assisting beam (black solid line), and with both assisting beam and analog input in the cases (b )Pλa= −2.48, (c) −4.48, and (d) −7.48 dBm, respectively.

Figure 5 shows optical sinusoidal waveforms of the analog input signal taken before the optical circulator (OC), and the output optical PWM signal taken after the EDFA. The analog optical sinusoidal source is operated at a frequency of 16 MHz, and the oscilloscope has a time resolution of 20 ns/div. In Fig. 5, the input and output waveforms appear to be almost in phase, contradicting their working principle, which is out of phase, as shown in Fig. 2. The reason is that the time difference between the two light paths traveled to the oscilloscope (OSC) is about one period, which is equivalent to 12.5 m of optical fiber. The output PWM has DCs of 14.7%, 25.0%, 29.8%, 48.8%, 59.8%, and 72.1%, corresponding to Pλa = −2.48, −4.48, −7.48, −10.48, −13.48, and −15.48 dBm respectively.

FIG. 5.Optical input and output waveforms for various cases of analog input power Pλa and output duty cycle DC. The sinusoidal source works at a frequency of 16 MHz and the oscilloscope has a time resolution of 20 ns/div.

By changing the analog sinusoidal source power in intervals of about 0.5 dB, we measured the DC of the proposed OPWMG, as shown in Fig. 6. In this figure the DC versus Pλa curve has a resolution of about 4.399 %/dB. The measurement process is taken as follows: The value of each data point on the curve (represented by a black dot) was the average of 5 readings of the DC value (20-second interval) from the OSC. The error bars, which are included for every data point on the curve, reflected the standard error based on the recorded DC values. The reading error is seen to increase at low input power, which may arise from the increase in mode-partition noise of the SMFP-LD when the input analog power is low [17], and also from the mode beating between the injected and self-locked modes. The highest observed standard error was about 0.6% at input power of −15.48 dBm. If the input power is above −2.48 dBm, all modes of the single mode FP-LD are collapsed (DC = 0). If the input power is below −15.48 dBm, the locking state is unstable and the output signal so noisy that the output DC cannot be identified. When we decreased the input power about 1 dB more, the locking state was destroyed totally (DC = 100%).

FIG. 6.Plot of the output PWM’s duty cycle versus power Pλa with standard error bars. The curve shows a resolution of about 4.399%/dB.

 

IV. CONCLUSION

We have proposed and experimentally verified an optical PWM generator, which is based on the injection-locking property of an external cavity-based single-mode FP-LD. The OPWMG can directly generate a PWM signal in the optical domain with a working frequency of 16 MHz, a duty cycle range between 14.7% and 72.1%, clear output waveforms, and duty cycle resolution of about 4.399 (%/dB). The PWM’s duty cycle can be varied by tuning the power of the optical analog input. It is possible to increase the working frequency of the OPWMG up to several GHz, because the proposed scheme is based on injection-locking of an SMFP-LD. Indeed, several works have been based on injection-locking of SMFP-LD showing working frequencies up to 10 GHz, such as those are reported in [15, 16]. An Optical PWM possesses significant advantages for applications that require strong immunity to EMI (e.g. in an HDVC plant) and an electrically isolated amplifier (e.g. in medical electronics).