Journal of Society of Preventive Korean Medicine (대한예방한의학회지)

Society of Preventive Korean Medicine (대한예방한의학회)
권호 표지

Analysis of Clinical Researches on Traditional Medicine Treatment for Behcet's Disease in Korea, China, and Japan

한중일의 베체트병에 대한 한의약 임상연구 분석

  • Yong, Seokil (School of Korean Medicine, Pusan National University) ;
  • Gu, Hyungyung (School of Korean Medicine, Pusan National University) ;
  • Kim, Daehun (Department of Acupuncture & Moxibustion Medicine, Pusan National University Korean Medicine Hospital) ;
  • Sohn, Kyungwoo (Department of Oriental Internal Medicine, Samse Oriental Medicine Hospital) ;
  • Yun, Youngju (Department of Integrative Medicine, School of Korean Medicine, Pusan National University)
  • 용석일 (부산대학교 한의학전문대학원 한의학과) ;
  • 구현경 (부산대학교 한의학전문대학원 한의학과) ;
  • 김대훈 (부산대학교 한방병원 침구의학과) ;
  • 손경우 (삼세한방병원 한방내과) ;
  • 윤영주 (부산대학교 한의학전문대학원 동서협진의학)
  • Received : 2014.03.31
  • Accepted : 2014.04.25
  • Published : 2014.04.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

Objective : To find a treatment strategy, this study aimed to review and compare the clinical studies of Korea, China, and Japan on traditional medicine treatment for Behcet's disease. Method : Literature searches were performed on six databases in each country and English databases, such as OASIS, KoreanTK, CNKI, J-STAGE, PubMed, and Cochrane CENTRAL. In addition, using the limited keywords, the area was restricted to traditional medicine treatment, but the period was not limited. Studies were categorized according to the study design and we analyzed the difference of treatment among three countries. Results : One hundred and forty-one clinical studies met our inclusion criteria: 11 studies in Korea, 15 in Japan, 115 in China. Randomized controlled trials (RCT) have increased in China, however, no RCT was reported in Korea and Japan. The method of treatment was mainly traditional herbal medicine in all the three countries, but there were significant differences in the field of syndrome identification and prescription among countries. The studies in China made use of most various treatment modalities and reported the highest effectiveness. Conclusion : Traditional medicine treatment showed a considerable effect for improving various symptoms of Behcet's disease. However, more research for answering the safety and well-designed studies considering characteristics of Behcet's disease should be performed to evaluate the effectiveness of traditional medicine treatment objectively in the future.

Keywords

References

  1. 질병관리본부 희귀난치성질환센터(http://helpline. nih.go.kr). 희귀난치성질환교육자료#5(베체트병). 2006:1-12.
  2. 방동식. 베체트병의 진단과 치료. Drug information. 2009:35(3):26-35.
  3. 張仲景. 金櫃要略. 서울:大成文化社. 1984:360.
  4. 陳貴延. 楊思澍:實用中西醫結合診斷治療學. 서울: 一中社. 1992:652-656.
  5. 권해원, 곽민안, 이자영. 베체트장염 환자 한방처치 후 경과보고 1례. 東西醫學. 2001:36(4):75-81.
  6. 이지연, 백동기, 조권일, 최우정, 정대영, 신선호, 김동웅, 문구. 베체트씨 병의 구강궤양에 대한 증례보고. 대한한방내과학회지. 2002:23(3):479-485.
  7. 金憲靜,蔡炳允. 베체트 병에 대한 임상적 고찰. 大韓外官科學會誌. 1999:12(1):387-395.
  8. 김호준, 이종립, 신현대. 하지부전마비를 동반한 Neuro-Behcet 병 1례 보고. 大韓韓醫學會誌. 2000: 21(4):286-291.
  9. 서해경. Behcet Syndrom 患者 1例에 對한 症例 報告. 韓藥應用學會誌. 2001:1(1):149-158.
  10. 김미랑, 정승현, 서운교, 이원철. 신경 베체트병 1례. 대한중풍학회지. 2001:1(1):97-102.
  11. 안춘재,박춘서,최서영. Behcet's Syndrome 患者 1例의 證例報告. 大韓韓方成人病學會誌. 2002:8(1): 99-107.
  12. 김광호, 김수장, 박찬규, 우인, 정선미. 신경베체트병 환자의 中樞性 眩暈과 步行失調 치험 1례. 韓方再活醫學科學會誌. 2007:17(3):207-216.
  13. 양동선, 구희준, 여은주, 양승정, 조성희, 박경미. 甘草瀉心湯으로 호전된 베체트병 의증 환자 1례. 大韓韓方婦人科學會誌. 2009:22(4):187-193.
  14. 백상철, 조소현, 조은희, 박민철. 越婢湯으로 치료된 베체트병의 결절홍반양 병변 치험 1례. 韓方眼耳鼻咽喉皮膚科學會誌. 2012:25(2):83-91.
  15. 이승민, 지영승, 전주현, 김정호, 김영일. 어깨관절통을 주소로한 베체트병 환자의 매선요법과 침치료 병행효과. 대한침구의학회. 2013:30(4):219-224.
  16. Yakazu D. On the Kampo-treatment of Behcet's syndrome. Journal of the Japan Society for Oriental Medicine. 1966:17(1):9-14.
  17. Ogura S. Study from Serious Disease. Journal of the Japan Society for Oriental Medicine. 1970:21(1):54-57
  18. Kikutani T. Clinical Experience on the Treatment of Behcet's Disease and Stomatitis Aphthosa by Unseiin. Journal of the Japan Society for Oriental Medicine 1970:21(3):155 -161.
  19. Ogura S. Rest and cultivation. Journal of the Japan Society for Oriental Medicine. 1972:23(1): 17-19.
  20. Takahashi S, Saito C, Shimura K, Kamata H, Matsuda N, Yokobori M, Nagumo M, Ito S, Fujita K, Kinoshita F, Osuga T, Ishibashi K, Nakagawa Y, Uchida Y, Ushiyama T, Ozeki H, Tojo H, Tanabe H, Komori E, Oinuma SI, Adachi F, Ohno T, Kuno Y, Satoh T, Yoshinari N, Izumi H, Ohmori M, Kato T. 慢 性再発性アフタに対するツムラ温清飲の使用経験 (多施設における共同治験).日本口腔科学会雑誌. 1987:36(2):498-511.
  21. Nishimoto T, Kin M, Arai Y, Nagase C, Matsumoto K. Treatment with Traditional Chinese Medicine (TCM) for Behcet's Disease. Kampo Medicine. 1991:42(1):11-15. https://doi.org/10.3937/kampomed.42.11
  22. Ogura S. Fasting-cure in addition to kampo treatment. Journal of the Japan Society for Oriental Medicine. 1967:18(4):141-146.
  23. Yakazu D. Effect of some medicaments localiy applied into nable hole (Fusai-treatment). Journal of the Japan Society for Oriental Medicine. 1973:24(3):417-421.
  24. Ogura S. Application of aconite containing recipes to some serious diseases. Journal of the Japan Society for Oriental Medicine. 1975: 26(3):145-149.
  25. Ziyal N. BEHCET'S DISEASE. The Japanese Journal of Ryodoraku Autonomic Nervous System 1984:29(9):234-235. https://doi.org/10.17119/ryodoraku1968.29.234
  26. Ono T, Matsumoto K, Beppu M, Nishimoto T, Tagawa K, Fujioka A. A Case Report; Entero-Behcet's Disease Which Developed Perforative Panperitonitis. Kampo Medicine. 1987:38(1):37-44. https://doi.org/10.3937/kampomed.38.37
  27. 岡田弘. 29-3 温清飲投与により著効を認めたベー チェット病の1例. 東洋医学. 1992:46:649.
  28. Kobayashi Y, Kita T, Shibahara N, Goto H, Terasawa K. Case Report of Seinetsu-hoketsu- to. Kampo Medicine. 1999:50(1):73-78. https://doi.org/10.3937/kampomed.50.73
  29. Sekiya N, Namiki T, Kasahara Y, Chino A, Hayashi K, Hirasaki Y, Ogawa K, Raimura M, Hashimoto S, Ohno K, Terasawa K. Cases Report of Seishitsuketanto. Kampo Medicine. 2008:59(6):793-798. https://doi.org/10.3937/kampomed.59.793
  30. Nagai Y, Masuda K. A Case of Behcet's Disease Successfully Treated with Keishibukuryogan, Whose Liver Damage Was Caused by Orengedokuto. Kampo Medicine. 2009:60(5):527-531.
  31. 姚峰, 趙永青. 雷公藤加丹參治療白塞氏病療效觀察. 臨床口腔醫學雜志. 1994:10(3):150-151.
  32. 賀松其, 李勝才, 文彬. 中西醫結合治療白塞氏病30 例. 深圳中西醫結合雜志. 1998:8(2):30-31.
  33. 薑世文, 呂沛忠. 中西醫結合治療白塞氏病 38 例 療效觀察, 中醫藥研究, 2000:16(3):35-36.
  34. 張磊, 張儂. 丹參合昆明山海棠治療白塞氏病21例臨床 觀察. 中國中醫藥科技. 2001:8(4):259-261.
  35. Yu P, Bai H, Chen L, Zhang W, Xia Y, Wu G. Clinical study on therapeutic effect of acupuncture on Behcet's disease. J Tradit Chin Med 2003:23(4)271-3.
  36. 高小平, 王佩. 白塞化解膠囊治療白塞氏病60例. 甘肅中醫學院學報. 2004:21(2):28-31.
  37. 王小麗, 孟會娟, 曾昭武. 雷苓解毒湯加減聯合西藥 治療白塞氏病22例療效觀察. 中醫藥導報. 2005:11 (10):27-28.
  38. 王建君, 龔時賢. 辨證治療白塞氏病葡萄膜炎18例. 浙江中醫雜志. 2007:42(9):518.
  39. 劉書珍, 王福蘭.中西醫結合治療白塞氏病60 例療效 觀察. 浙江中醫雜志. 2008:43(8):460.
  40. Wang DY. 50 cases of behcet disease treated with the therapy integrated traditional chinese and western medicine. Modern Journal of Integrated Traditional Chinese and Western Medicine. 2008:17(5):692-693.
  41. 李傑, 曹秀峰. 雙子熟地顆粒治療白塞氏病26例臨床 研究. 哈爾濱醫藥. 2009:29(3):41.
  42. 李明, 朱安龍, 楊飛, 劉銀華, 李忠玉. 中西醫聯合治 療白塞氏病45例臨床療效觀察. 中外醫療. 2010:11:31.
  43. 朱紅軍, 杜金龍. 中西醫結合治療白塞氏病37例. 河南中醫. 2011:31(12):1418.
  44. Wu ZW, Yang CY, Bian TY. Behcet's disease: clinical report of 88 cases treated with herbal decoctions. J Tradit Chin Med. 1983:3(3): 223-6.
  45. 吳堃達, 許富琴, 何叔平. 徐金合劑治療白塞氏病眼 部病變106例臨床分析. 中醫雜志. 1994:35(11):677 -678.
  46. 張燕春. 三聯症片白塞氏病 116例 臨床觀察, 醫藥集悟, 1999:14(5):79-80.
  47. 秦長林, 馬武開. 白塞氏病l06例臨床分析與療效觀察. 中國中醫藥信息雜志. 2001:8:46.
  48. Yu P, Bai H, Zhang W, Wu G. Effects of acupuncture on humoral immunologic function and trace elements in 20 cases of Behcet's disease. J Tradit Chin Med. 2001:21(2)100-2.
  49. 嚴可斌. 中醫經絡學說辨治狐惑病 108例 臨床硏究, 河北中醫藥學報, 2002:17(2):6-7.
  50. 王桂玲, 邱若旗. 內服和外用中藥治療白塞氏病100 例臨床觀察. 中國社區醫師(綜合版). 2005:7(128):69.
  51. 左朝曦. 中西醫結合治療白塞氏病療效觀察. 中國社區醫師(醫學專業). 2011:13(275):179.
  52. Shaoqiong X. Three typical dermatological cases treated by Dr. Li Yueping. J Tradit Chin Med. 2005:25(3):129-31.
  53. Zhang M. Professor LU De-Ming's experience in clinical application of the method for replenishing qi and nourishing yin. Zhong Xi Yi Jie He Xue Bao 2005:3(2):141-3. https://doi.org/10.3736/jcim20050217
  54. Zhou WY, Zhang H, Zhuang ZY. Chinese medicine in the treatment of Behcet's disease's uveitis: a case report. Chin J Integr Med. 2012:18(3):219-21. https://doi.org/10.1007/s11655-011-0949-y
  55. 해리슨내과학편찬위원회. 해리슨내과학. 서울:정담. 1997:3000.
  56. International Study Group for Behct' disease. Criteria fordiagnosis of Behct56' disease. Lancet 1990;335:1078-1080.
  57. Mizushima Y, Inaba G, Mimura Y, Ono S. Diagnostic criteriafor Behçet's disease in 1987, and guidelines for treating Behçet's disease. Saishin-Igaku 1988:43:382-391.
  58. 천재희, 신성재, 김상우, 김주성, 김원호. 베체트 장염 진단 가이드라인. 대한소화기학회지. 2009:53: 187-193.
  59. 陈灏珠主编. 实用内科学. 第10 版. 北京:人民卫生 出版社. 1997:2104.
  60. 장현규. 베체트병의 치료. 대한류마티스학회지. 2003: 10(2):101-108.
  61. 박종운, 고형준, 김홍복. 한국인에서의 베체트병. 대한안과학회지. 2002:43(1):67-74.
  62. 巢元方. 諸病源候論. 台北:集文書局. 1976:187.
  63. 전국한의과대학피부외과학 교재편찬위원회. 한의피부외과학. 부산:선우. 2007:547.
  64. 中島一. 皮膚科의 漢方治療(辨證과臨床). 서울:一中社. 1991:91-93.
  65. 錢曉嵐. 狐惑病患者的護理. 深圳中西醫結合雜志. 2001: 11(3):191-192.
  66. 陳愛林, 陳美玲. 痹證1號配合西藥治療白塞氏病 38 例. 陝西中醫. 2009:30(12):1617.