Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture (한국조경학회지)

The Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture (한국조경학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Development of Landscape Urbanism in Practice

랜드스케이프 어바니즘의 실천적 전개 양상

  • Kim, Youngmin (Dept. of Landscape Architecture, University of Seoul) ;
  • Jeong, Wookju (Dept. of Landscape Architecture and Rural Engineering, Seoul National University)
  • 김영민 (서울시립대학교 조경학과) ;
  • 정욱주 (서울대학교 조경지역시스템공학부)
  • Received : 2013.12.02
  • Accepted : 2014.01.13
  • Published : 2014.02.28
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

The Practice of Landscape Urbanism has been criticized on two aspects; Landscape Urbanism does not yet provide differentiated forms of planning and design neither able to fill the gap between theory and practice. In response to these criticisms, Landscape Urbanists have tried to provide additional cases that can exemplify achievements of Landscape Urbanism in practice. There has been another type of effort to suggest distinct planning and design strategies of Landscape Urbanism from theoretical texts. However, these approaches overlooked the fact that professional practice actually gave huge influence on the theoretical framework of Landscape Urbanism. Based on this observation, the study examined the development process of Landscape Urbanism by verifying the correlation between its practice and theory. Through an extensive literature review, the study suggested horizontality, infrastructure, process, ecology, media, hybrid, site, and scale as eight major concepts of Landscape Urbanism. Afterwards, the study classified 51 projects cited in major essays and articles of Landscape Urbanism into four categories: Archetypal projects, precedent projects, exemplary projects, and progressive projects. The correlation between strategies of the selected projects and main theoretical concepts was analyzed. The study found out that the early stage of the theory was focused on defining and explaining the new design and planning approaches of contemporary design projects related with landscape. However, these days, Landscape Urbanism became a more productive in providing diverse types of practice sharing the direction and vision proposed by the theory. Various projects influenced in constructing theoretical structure of Landscape Urbanism as well as proved that the suggestions of Landscape Urbanism could be effective to reorganize contemporary cites in the form of design and planning strategies. The observation of this study can contribute to provide proper answers to the criticism on practice of Landscape Urbanism and be helpful in understanding the limits and unrealized potentials of Landscape Urbanism as a practical theory.

랜드스케이프 어바니즘의 실천은 두 가지 측면에서 비판을 받아왔다. 하나는 차별화된 설계나 계획의 형태적 대안이 결여되어 있다는 비판이며, 다른 하나는 이론과 실천 사이의 괴리를 해소하지 못하고 있다는 비판이다. 이에 대한 대응으로 연구자들은 실천적 성과를 보여줄 수 있는 추가적인 사례를 지속적으로 제시하거나, 이론적 개념을 토대로 구체적인 설계 전략들을 도출하려고 노력해왔다. 그러나 기존의 접근 방식들은 실천이 이론의 형성에 미친 영향을 간과해온 한계점을 보인다. 본 연구는 실천적 사례를 중심으로 랜드스케이프 어바니즘의 전개 양상을 명확히 밝히고, 이론과 실천의 상관관계를 검토하여 실천적 이론으로서의 랜드스케이프 어바니즘의 정체성을 재확인하고자 하였다. 본 연구는 다양한 문헌을 검토하여 수평성, 인프라스트럭처, 프로세스, 생태, 매체, 혼성, 부지, 스케일의 여덟 가지로 랜드스케이프 어바니즘의 주요한 이론적 개념을 정리하였다. 이러한 이론적 고찰을 토대로 주요 문헌에서 인용된 사례들 중 51개의 프로젝트를 성격과 시기에 따라 원형적 사례, 선행적 사례, 예시적 사례, 발전적 사례로 구분하고, 실천적 전략과 앞서 도출된 주요 개념들과의 관계를 분석하였다. 연구의 결과, 랜드스케이프 어바니즘의 초기에는 선구적인 프로젝트들로부터 이론적 내용과 개념들을 구성하던 해설적 이론의 성격이 강했지만, 이후 이론적 구조가 갖추어지면서 이론에 기반을 둔 실천적 사례가 등장하면서 생산적 이론으로 변화하였음을 알 수 있었다. 이 과정에서 원형적 사례, 선행적 사례, 예시적 사례, 발전적 사례들은 그 시기와 성격에 따라 특징적인 방식으로 이론에 영향을 주었으며, 이론적 개념을 새로운 전략을 통해 실천의 형태로 구현하였다. 본 연구의 결과는 랜드스케이프 어바니즘의 실천에 대한 비판에 대해 대응할 실마리를 제시해 주고, 실천적 이론을 지향하는 랜드스케이프 어바니즘의 한계와 가능성을 보다 명확히 파악하는데 유용하게 활용될 수 있을 것이다.

Keywords

References

  1. Bae, J.(2003) Theoretical terrains and design strategies of Landscape Urbanism. Journal of Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 32(1): 69-79.배정한(2003) Landscape Urbanism의 이론적 지형과 설계 전략. 한국조경학회지 32(1): 69-79.
  2. Bae, J.(2012) Landscape urbanism and Korean landscape architecture. Environment and Landscape Architecture (258): 102-107. 배정한(2012) 랜드스케이프 어바니즘과 한국 조경. 환경과 조경 (258): 102-107.
  3. Belanger, P.(2006) Synthetic Surface, in Waldheim, C. ed.(2006) Landscape Urbanism Reader. Kim, Y.(trans.) Landscape Urbanism. Paju: Jokyoung, 2007: 270-299.
  4. Bong, I.(2005) Dimension of Virtuality. Seoul: Spacetime 봉일범(2005) 잠재성의 차원. 서울: 시공문화사.
  5. Bru, E. ed.(2001) Coming from the South. Barcelona: ACTAR.
  6. Cho, K.(2010) Perspective of Korean Landscape Urbanism: Dilemma and potential. Environment and Landscape Architecture (272): 150-157. 조경진(2010) 한국적 랜드스케이프 어바니즘의 전망: 딜레마와 가능성, 환경과 조경 (272): 150-157.
  7. Cho, S.(2010) Practical strategies for urban regeneration through an application of Landscape Urbanism. Journal of Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 38(2): 109-118. 조세환(2010) 랜드스케이프 어바니즘 관점에서 본 도시재생 전략 연구. 한국조경학회지 38(2): 109-118.
  8. Corner, J.(1997) Ecology and Landscape as Agents of Creativity, in Thompson, G. and S. Fredrick eds.., Ecological Design and Planning, New York: John Wiley and Sons, 81-107.
  9. Corner, J.(2001) Landscraping, in Daskalakis, G. eds., Stalking Detroit, Barcelona: Actar.
  10. Corner, J.(2003) Landscape Urbanism, in Mostafavi, M. and C. Najle eds., Landscape Urbanism: A Manual for the Machinic Landscape, London: AA Publications: 58-63.
  11. Corner, J.(2006) Terra Fluxus, in Waldheim, C. ed.,(2006) Landscape Urbanism Reader. Kim, Y.(trans.) Landscape Urbanism. Paju: Jokyoung, 2007: 23-37.
  12. Corner, J.(2010) Landscape urbanism in the field. in Topos (71): 25-29.
  13. Czerniak, J. and H. George eds.(2007) Large Parks. Bae, J. and Idla (trans.), Large Park, Paju: Jokyung, 2010.
  14. Czerniak, J.(2006) Looking back at Landscape Urbanism: Speculations on Site, in Waldheim, C. ed.(2006) Landscape Urbanism Reader. Kim, Y.(trans.) Landscape Urbanism, Paju: Jokyoung, 2007: 120-141.
  15. Donnelly, B.(2013) Absorbing Landscape Urbanism, in Duany, A. and E. Talen edsl., Landscape Urbanism and its Discontents, New Society Publishers: 171-185.
  16. Drake, S.(2010) Term, definition, identity: Regenerating landscape architecture in the era of Landscape Urbanism, in Topos (71): 50-55.
  17. Drexler, H. and C. Duisburg(2003) In Conversation with RUR: On Material Logics in Architecture, Landscape and Urbanism, in Mostafavi, M. and C. Najle eds. Landscape Urbanism: A Manual for the Machinic Landscape, London, AA Publications: 102-110.
  18. Emily T.(2013) The social apathy of Landscape Urbanism, in Duany, A. and E. Talen edsl., Landscape Urbanism and its Discontents, New Society Publishers: 105-114.
  19. Gray, C.(2007) Turning Field: Contradictions in Landscape Urbanism, in Kerb 15: Landscape Urbanism, Melbouren, McLaren Press. 94-100.
  20. Hight, C.(2003) Portraying the urban landscape: Landscape in Architectural Criticism and Theory, 1960-Present, in Mostafavi, M. and C. Najle eds.Landscape Urbanism: A Manual for the Machinic Landscape, London: AA Publications: 22-33.
  21. Kang, H. and J. Choi(2011) A study on the main concepts of Landscape Urbanism. Journal of Architectural Institute of Korea 27(8): 225-232. 강효정, 최재필(2011) 랜드스케이프 어바니즘의 주요 개념에 대한 연구.대학건축학회 논문집 계획계 27(8): 225-232.
  22. Kang, H.(2013) A study on Landscape Urbanism based on Korean cases. Journal of Urban Design Institute of Korea 14(4): 29-41. 강효정 (2013) 한국적 랜드스케이프 어바니즘에 관한 연구. 한국도시설계학회지 14(4): 29-41.
  23. Kang, Y. J., J. Kim and J. Pae(2008) Design strategies for urban parks as urban infrastructure-An analysis of the landscape design competition for the Incheon Cheongna District, Korea. Journal of Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 36(5): 42-54. 강연주, 김정화, 배정한(2008) 인천청라지구 조경설계공모를 통해 본 도시기반시설로서 도시공원의 설계전략. 한국조경학회지 36(5): 42-54.
  24. Kim, A, M. Koh, and H. Oh(2006) Re-reading Chuncheon G5 International Design Competition from a viewpoint of Landscape Urbanism. Journal of Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 34(3): 120-138. 김아연, 고미진, 오형석(2006) 랜드스케이프 어바니즘의 관점으로 본 춘천 G5 국제설계경기 출품작 분석. 한국조경학회지 34(3): 120-138.
  25. Kim, M.(2009) An analysis of the architectural and urban space through practical issues of Landscape Urbanism. Journal of Korean Association for Spatial Structure 9(3): 83-92. 김민경(2009) 랜드스케이프 어바니즘의 실천적 주제에 의한 건축 도시 공간 분석. 한국공간구조학회지 9(3): 83-92.
  26. Ko, J.(2013) Articulating Landscape Urbansim, in Duany, A. and E. Talen edsl., Landscape Urbanism and Its Discontents, New Society Publishers: 245-262.
  27. Kunstler, J. H.(2013) The Zombies of Gund Hall Go Forth and Eat America's Brains, in Duany, A. and E. Talen edsl., Landscape Urbanism and its Discontents, New Society Publishers: 125-140.
  28. Lee, Y. and W. Yoo(2010) Design strategies of high-rise mixed use complex through a viewpoint of Landscape Urbanism - Focused on projects of Jerde Partnership. Journal of Architectural Institute of Korea 26(2): 119-128. 이영미, 유우상(2010) 랜드스케이프 어바니즘 관점을 통해 본 입체 복합 시설의 설계 전략: 저드 파트너쉽 프로젝트를 중심으로, 대학건축학회논문집 계획계 26(2): 119-128.
  29. Mertins, D.(2003) Landscape urbanism happensin time, in Mostafavi, M. and C. Najle eds.Landscape Urbanism: A Manual for the Machinic Landscape, London, AA Publications 135-140.
  30. Morenas, L.(2013) A critique of the high line: Landscape Urbansim and the Global South, in Duany, A. and E. Talen edsl., Landscape Urbanism and its Discontents, New Society Publishers: 293-304.
  31. Mossop, E.(2006) Landscape of infrastructure, in Waldheim, C. ed.(2006) Landscape Urbanism Reader, Kim, Y.(trans.) Landscape Urbanism, Paju: Jokyoung, 2007: 186-203.
  32. Mostafavi, M. and C. Najle eds.(2003) Landscape Urbanism: A Manual for the Machinic Landscape, London: AA Publications
  33. Pollak, L.(2006) Constructed ground: Question of scale, in Waldheim, C. ed.(2006) Landscape Urbanism Reader, Kim, Y.(trans.) Landscape Urbanism. Paju: Jokyoung, 2007: 142-159.
  34. Reed, C.(2006) Public works practice, in Waldheim, C. ed.(2006) Landscape Urbanism Reader, Kim, Y.(trans.) Landscape Urbanism, Paju: Jokyoung, 2007: 301-321.
  35. Reed, C.(2010) Landscape Urbanism in parctice, in Topos (71): 90-107.
  36. Russel, S. J.(2001) It's the future not a contradiction. Landscape Urbanism, in Architectural Record 2001(8): 66-74.
  37. Shane, G.(2006) The emergence of Landscape Urbanism, in Waldheim, C. ed.,(2006) Landscape Urbanism Reader, Kim, Y.(trans.) Landscape Urbanism, Paju: Jokyoung, 2007: 61-77.
  38. Shannon, K.(2006) Place as resistance: Landscape Urbanism in Europe, in Waldheim, C. ed.(2006) Landscape Urbanism Reader, Kim, Y.(trans.) Landscape Urbanism, Paju: Jokyoung, 2007: 160-185.
  39. Smith, T.(2010) Landscape Urbanism: The academic spectrums and practices. Environment and Landscape Architecture (272): 126-133.
  40. Tatom, J.(2006) Urban highways and the reluctant public realm, in Waldheim, C. ed.,(2006) Landscape Urbanism Reader, Kim, Y.(trans.) Landscape Urbanism, Paju: Jokyoung, 2007: 205-223.
  41. Thompson, I. H.(2011) Ten tennets and six questions for Landscape Urbanism. Landscape Research 37(1): 7-26.
  42. Waldheim, C.(2010b) Interview: Charles waldheim. Environment and Landscape Architecture (272): 160-163.
  43. Waldheim, C. ed.,(2006) Landscape Urbanism Reader, New York: Princeton Architectural Review. Kim, Y.(trans.) Landscape Urbanism, Paju: Jokyoung, 2007:
  44. Waldheim, C.(2002) Landscape urbanism: A genealogy, in Praxis 4: 10-17.
  45. Waldheim, C.(2006) Landscape as Urbanism, in Waldheim, C. ed. (2006) Landscape Urbanism Reader, Kim, Y.(trans.) Landscape Urbanism, Paju: Jokyoung, 2007: 38-59.
  46. Waldheim, C.(2007) Precedents for a North American Landscape Urbanism, in Almy, D. ed. Center 14: On Landscape Urbanism, Austin: the Center for American Architecture and Design: 292-303.
  47. Waldheim, C.(2009) The Other '56 in Krieger, A. and Willian S. S. eds., Urban Design, Minneapolis: University of Minnesota Press: 229-236.
  48. Waldheim, C.(2010a) On landscape, ecology and other modifiers to urbanism. in Topos (71): 20-24
  49. Weller, R.(2006) An art of instrumentality: Thinking through Landscape Urbanism, in Waldheim, C. ed.(2006) Landscape Urbanism Reader, Kim, Y.(trans.) Landscape Urbanism, Paju: Jokyoung, 2007: 78-99.
  50. Weller, R.(2007) Global theory, local practice, in Miller, Andy ed., Kerb 15: Landscape Urbanism, Melbouren: McLaren Press, 66-71.
  51. Weller, R.(2008) Landscape (Sub)Urbanism in theory and practice. Landscape Journal 27: 2-8.
  52. Yang, P. P.(2013) Landscape ecology and its urbanism, in Duany, A. and E. Talen edsl., Landscape Urbanism and its Discontents, New Society Publishers: 263-279.
  53. Yoon, H.(2010) Landscape urbanism in special west chelsea district rezoning and high line open space redevelopment project. Journal of Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture 38(1): 84-97. 윤희연(2010) 웨스트 첼시 개발과 하이라인의 역할에서 나타난 랜드스케이프 어바니즘의 성격. 한국조경학회지 38(1): 84-97.