DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

A Study of Improvement Plan and Post Occupancy Evaluation of Block Housing in Korea - Focused on Block Housing in Eun-Pyeong First District and Nok-Yang District -

국내 중정형 집합주택단지의 거주후평가(居住後評價)와 개선방안에 관한 연구 - 의정부 녹양지구와 서울 은평1지구를 중심으로 -

  • Published : 2013.05.25

Abstract

Since the early 2000s, block housing has been a topic of increasing interest, and planners have issued many block houses through design contests. The main purpose of the block housing was to promote the formation of community among residents, and supplemental plan has also been completed in order to support the previously envisioned level of residency which is weak due to the inherent characteristics of block style housing. Currently, there are several housing complexes which have been recently built in Korea. However, questions have been aroused whether the residents are as satisfied as the planners had originally intended. In the midst of planning a new block housing complex, this research was motivated with the hope of making a measure of improvement based on the result of the post-occupancy survey. Block housing complex shows various problems such as noise, privacy, access to sunlight, and security. These problems are closely related to habitability, so resolving such problems will transform the block housing into a more comfortable and meaningful housing type and also contribute to the future promotion of the block housing complex. Therefore, the purpose of this research is to develop planning elements for the improvement of habitability as part of developing an attactive block-style housing complex, discern the level of satisfaction with habitability, problematic spatial issues and amenities based on the post-occupancy evaluation of the cases of actual residence, extract measures of improvement and implement the results at the times of future planning. In accomplishing such goal, this research performed and analyzed the post-occupancy evaluation on two block housing complexes built in Korea. Eunpyung 1st District and Nokyang District were chosen for the research, which were built 5 years ago. The data and documents obtained from the on-site visits of the two districts were classified according to the 3 physical spaces: 'external space to the complex,' 'unit living space' and 'common living space.' Survey questionnaires have been developed in terms of the level of satisfaction, problems and issues related to the amenities of the 3 spaces. The survey was performed in the form of in-person interview by visiting individual residents in the districts. Total of 200 residents were interviewed, and the SPSS statistical package was used for the analysis. Contrary to the one's expectation, the overall satisfaction level was shown as satisfactory on major evaluation points of the post-occupancy survey. Preferred amenities were landscaping in the complex, walk trails and unmaned parcel storage. Noise from the children's playground, privacy from the neighbors, insecurity issued from the inept visitor control, main buildings with poor sunlight access, low level of reputation due to complexity of the apartment structure are some of the space-related problems revealed by the survey. Detailed drawings and verified data were proposed as the means of improvement on the issues and problems. Based on the research and evaluation results of the post-occupancy surveys, it was concluded that the research on block housing complex should be continuously pursued and results from the early design stage should be arranged as planned-out elements that later ought to be implemented, thereby a residential complex with higher quality can be planned out.

Keywords

References

  1. 김현수, 변혜선, "중정형 저층고밀 주거단지 계획에 관한 연구", 대한건축학회논문집 14권 10호(통권120호), 1998.10
  2. 김진균, 이금진, "중정형 집합주택단지의 특성 연구", 대한건축학회논문집 2001.2
  3. 강부성, 박진호, "가로형 집합주택의 거주후평가 연구", 대한건축학회논문집 계획계 20권 5호(통권187호) 2004.05
  4. 박중현, 강부성, 김진욱, "한국과 일본의 가구형 집합주택의 거주후평가 비교연구", 한국주거학회 Vol.20, No. 6. 2009
  5. 박중현, 추선경, 강부성, "가구형 집합주택의 거주후평가 연구", 한국주거학회 학술발표논문집 2009. V1(춘계) 0.4
  6. 박소영, "중정형 집합주택의 공간계획 특성 연구", 한남대, 석사논문, 2006.02
  7. 정승원, "도심 비정형 블록 내 단독주거지 개발 계획안", 홍익대, 석사논문, 2004.06
  8. 디에이그룹 당선작, "의정부 녹양지구 A-1,2블럭 현상설계보고서", LH공사, 2004년
  9. 디에이그룹 당선작. "은평1지구 A공구 대안설계 TK 설계보고서" SH공사, 2005년
  10. 하지영, 임유경, "블록형 집합주택의 주거성능 평가 및 제도개선 방안 연구", 건축도시공간연구소, 2011.12
  11. 성기수, 이승조, 김현호 "중정형 집합주택단지의 거주성 향상을 위한 계획방안 연구" 대한건축학회 춘계학술대회논문집 제33권 제1호(통권 제59집) 2013.04