The Korean Society of Law and Medicine (의료법학)
- Volume 14 Issue 2
- /
- Pages.281-313
- /
- 2013
- /
- 1229-8069(pISSN)
A Study on Main Issue and Supreme Court Decisions regarding the Duty of Interhospital Transfer of Patients - Focusing on the Supreme Court Decision 2010DO7070 Delivered on April 29, 2010 -
전원의무 관련 쟁점 및 대법원판례 고찰 - 대법원 2010. 4. 29. 선고 2009도7070 판결을 중심으로 -
- Kim, Young Tae (Seoul High Public Prosecutors' Office)
- 김영태 (서울고등검찰청)
- Received : 2013.10.31
- Accepted : 2013.12.10
- Published : 2013.12.31
Abstract
A physician has to do his best for the better treatment of his patiensts. But, if a physician cannot remedy his patients because of the lack of hospital facilities, the lack of medical knowledge and etc., the physician must transfer his patients to another suitable hospital immediately. This is called the duty of interhospital transfer of patients. The necessity of interhospital transfer of patients is primarily ocurred in emergency medical care situations. The Supreme Court Decision 2010DO7070 delivered on April 29, 2010 is one of the important decisions related to the duty of interhospital transfer of patients. The Supreme Court ruled that there were the physician's medical malpractice and the causation between the physician's medical malpractice and the death of patient, as the physician has left the patient without due observations for 1 hour and 30 minutes after the caesarean operation inspite of mass bleeding during the operation, and has transferred the patient to another suitable hospital later. And the Supreme Court ruled that the transferring physician has to explain the situation of the patient in detail to the physician being transferred. I agree with the Supreme Court Decision. As decided by the Supreme Court, physicians will treat their patients more carefully and in case of necessity for transfer, physicians will transfer their patients with more caustion. However, the study for this issue should be continued hereafter because concrete standards are not given to lawers and physicians just by the Supreme Court Decisions itself.
Keywords