DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

Integrated Evaluation of Level of Service for Urban Streets Considering Sustainability

지속가능성을 고려한 도시부 도로의 서비스수준 통합 평가 연구

  • 최용석 (인천광역시청 교통기획과) ;
  • 김응철 (인천대학교 건설환경공학과)
  • Received : 2012.02.10
  • Accepted : 2012.11.16
  • Published : 2012.12.17

Abstract

PURPOSES : This paper aims to improve the evaluation method of the Level of Service(LOS) for urban streets presented by the current Korean Highway Capacity Manual(KHCM) and suggest its utilization plan as a part of the methods to evaluate the sustainability of a transportation policy. METHODS : This paper carried out a research in 3 steps to develop a new evaluation method. First of all, this paper reviewed the previous studies related to the LOS of urban streets and the socially requested items for a sustainable transportation system. Then this paper derived an index and weight through expert questions to select an evaluation index. Lastly, this paper compared the results according to the existing evaluation methods with the new evaluation methods through case studies. This paper used an Analytic Hierarchy Process(AHP) for importance analysis and weight selection between new evaluation items and indices, and applied a Grey System Theory(GST) for a synthetic and integrated evaluation between the selected evaluation indices. RESULTS : As a result of evaluating the LOS according to the existing evaluation methods and the integrated evaluation methods using a GST through case studies, it was analyzed that new methods' results are less than or equal to the existing evaluation methods; and as a result of applying a weight between evaluation indices according to AHP, it was noticed that the total score seems to rise more when the LOS in the existing evaluation is calculated lower. It was analyzed that the LOS calculated by reflecting the newly established evaluation items and the importance between indices in this study has difference from the LOS of the existing urban streets. CONCLUSIONS : It is expected that this evaluation method can diagnose the current conditions when establishing a future sustainable traffic system and can be used for the measurement of the sustainability effects of the improvement plans and so on.

Keywords

References

  1. Ministry of Construction and Transportation, 2001. Korean Highway Capacity Manual, Korean Society of Transportation (건설교통부, 2001. 도로용량편람, 대한교통학회)
  2. Ministry of Land, Transport and Maritime Affairs, 2009. Evaluation Guidance of Transport Investment, The third edition (국토해양부, 2009. 교통시설투자평가지침, 제3차 개정)
  3. Ministry of Land, Transport and Maritime Affairs, 2009. Korea Transport Survey and Database 2010 - Traffic costs and Greenhouse gas emission DB, The Korea Transport Institute (국토해양부, 2011. 2010년 국가교통수요조사 및 DB구축사업 - 교통비용 및 온실가스 배출량 DB 구축, 한국교통연구원)
  4. Kim, Dohwan, 2007. A Study on the Sustainability Evaluation Indicators and Method on Urban Traffic, Masters thesis, Graduate school of Kyunwon University (김도환, 2007. 도시 교통의 지속가능성 평가지표 및 방법에 관한 연구, 석사학위논문, 경원대학교)
  5. Kim, Tae-ho, Jeong, K., Koo, J., Won, J., 2009. A Development and Application of Evaluation Criteria for Pedestrian Quality of Service Using Analytic Network Process, Journal of korea planners association, Vol 44, No 1 (김태호, 정광섭, 구자훈, 원제무, 2009. 네트워크분석기법을 이용한 보행자 서비스 질 평가지표 개발 및 적용, 대한국토.도시계획학회지, 제44권, 제1호)
  6. Road Traffic Authority, 2010. Improvement Plans and Effect Analysis Standards for 2010 Traffic Accident-prone Areas (도로교통공단, 2010. 2010 교통사고 잦은 곳 기본개선계획 및 효과분석)
  7. Son, Banghoon, 2006. A Study on the Recognition of the Quality of Services in Urban Roadways, Masters thesis, Graduate school of Hanyang University (손방훈, 2006. 도시부 도로 서비스 질 인식에 관한 연구, 석사학위논문, 한양대학교)
  8. Lee, Shinhae, 2009. A Study on Sustainability Evaluation of Transportation Policy, Seoul studies, Vol 10, No 1, 209-221 (이신해, 2009. 교통정책의 지속가능성 평가에 관한 연구, 서울도시연구 제10권, 제1호, pp.209-221)
  9. Lee, Jinkak, Son, Y., Han, S., Park, J., Lee, S., 2010. Evaluation of Vehicle and Pedestrian Environments using Grey System Theory, The Journal of Korean society of Transportation, Vol 28, No 4, 141-156 (이진각, 손영태, 한상진, 박진영, 이상화, 2010. Grey System Theory를 이용한 차량 및 보행환경 통합평가, 대한교통학회지, 제28권, 제4호, pp.141-156)
  10. Jung, Hyeonyoung, Jung, J., Kim, S., 1998. A Study on The Local Resident's Evaluation in the traffic environment of Road, Urban Studies Report, Vol 6, No 1, 57-62 (정헌영, 정준영, 김승룡, 1998. 도로교통환경에 따른 지역주민들의 도로평가에 관한 연구, 도시연구보, Vol.6, No.1, 57-62)
  11. Korea Development Institute, 2008. Based on The Revised and Supplementary Study on Pre-Feasibility of Road and Railway Projects, The 5th edition (한국개발연구원, 2008. 도로.철도 부문 사업의 예비타당성조사 표준지침 수정.보완연구, 제5판)
  12. The Korea Transport Institute, 2011. Sustainability Survey of Transportation Logistics Systems and A Study on Selection of Special Area, Part 1 (한국교통연구원, 2011. 교통물류체계의 지속가능성 조사 및 특별대책지역 지정방안 연구, 제1권)
  13. Hong, Gapseon, 2002. A study on Strategy Establishment for Sustainable Transportation Systems, The Korea Transport Institute (홍갑선, 2002. 지속가능한 교통체계전략수립 연구, 한국교통연구원)
  14. Flannery, A, Wochinger, K.,Pecheux, K. K., and Rephlo, J., 2004. Research Approaches to Assess Automobile Drivers' Perception of Quality of Service
  15. Wen, K.-L., 2004. Grey System : modeling and prediction, Yang's Scientific Press