Difference of Human Error between Japanese and Indonesian Workers at Pipeline Construction

  • Received : 2010.02.22
  • Accepted : 2010.06.02
  • Published : 2010.06.30

Abstract

A big difference is seen in the perception of self-responsibility concerning safety, as a result of my survey on the safety measures taken in the pipeline construction at workers level between Japan and Indonesia. Specifically, when an accident occurs, a worker in Indonesia will think that the responsibility depends on the person who causes it. However a worker in Japan will think that safety is can only be protected by law and regulations. There is also another difference in the understanding of construction period. It is alright in Indonesia to take 5 times longer period than it takes in Japan if the cost is less. The idea of punctual delivery is very strong in Japan. Through this survey, points which construction industry in Japan could learn from Indonesia came to surface. In addition, over the recent years, several nasty accidents at Japanese sites were caused due to human error to disregard the law. Japanese should arouse the awareness of self-responsibility in this regard. Risk management should be upon self-recognition of each individual worker in both countries. What is important is the "work attitude education", "to grow sense of self-responsibility by thinking on one's own for one's self" in the education curriculum of man to man learning as in technical educational program.

Keywords

References

  1. Central Industrial Injuries Prevention Association: Safety Standards pp.18-32,2007,pp.18-32,2008,pp.18- 32, 2009.
  2. "Occupational Injury Statistics" by The Republic of Indonesia Worker Social Insurance Public Corporation. 1995 to 1997.
  3. The Ministry of Manpower and Transmigration Website http://www.nakertrans.go.idlENGLISHVERSION/ stat_ engjndex.php, 2008.
  4. Takahisa Yamada, Masayoshi NakamuraAFCase Study on the Natural Gas Pipeline Construction-Safety Management in Indonesia based on risk. Safety Engineering Committee 50th Anniversary commemorative event, 40th Safety Management Research Paper, pp.123-124, 2007.
  5. Japan: Occupational Health and Safety law,2008.
  6. The Republic of Indonesia : Act No.1 on Safety, 1970.
  7. Tomio Tanimura, Compiled under Ministry of Labor Safety and Health Division "Learning from the breathtaking experience"-Practical measures to eliminate the risk of disaster - Labor Newspaper Co. Ltd., 1995.