A Combat Effectiveness Evaluation Algorithm Considering Technical and Human Factors in C4I System

NCW 환경에서 C4I 체계 전투력 상승효과 평가 알고리즘 : 기술 및 인적 요소 고려

  • Jung, Whan-Sik (Department of Operations Research, Korea National Defense University) ;
  • Park, Gun-Woo (Department of Defense Information Systems, Korea National Defense University) ;
  • Lee, Jae-Yeong (Department of Operations Research, Korea National Defense University) ;
  • Lee, Sang-Hoon (Department of Defense Information Systems, Korea National Defense University)
  • 정환식 (국방대학교 운영분석학과) ;
  • 박건우 (국방대학교 전산정보학과) ;
  • 이재영 (국방대학교 운영분석학과) ;
  • 이상훈 (국방대학교 전산정보학과)
  • Received : 2010.02.14
  • Accepted : 2010.04.06
  • Published : 2010.06.30

Abstract

Recently, the battlefield environment has changed from platform-centric warfare(PCW) which focuses on maneuvering forces into network-centric warfare(NCW) which is based on the connectivity of each asset through the warfare information system as information technology increases. In particular, C4I(Command, Control, Communication, Computer and Intelligence) system can be an important factor in achieving NCW. It is generally used to provide direction across distributed forces and status feedback from thoseforces. It can provide the important information, more quickly and in the correct format to the friendly units. And it can achieve the information superiority through SA(Situational Awareness). Most of the advanced countries have been developed and already applied these systems in military operations. Therefore, ROK forces also have been developing C4I systems such as KJCCS(Korea Joint Command Control System). And, ours are increasing the budgets in the establishment of warfare information systems. However, it is difficult to evaluate the C4I effectiveness properly by deficiency of methods. We need to develop a new combat effectiveness evaluation method that is suitable for NCW. Existing evaluation methods lay disproportionate emphasis on technical factors with leaving something to be desired in human factors. Therefore, it is necessary to consider technical and human factors to evaluate combat effectiveness. In this study, we proposed a new Combat Effectiveness evaluation algorithm called E-TechMan(A Combat Effectiveness Evaluation Algorithm Considering Technical and Human Factors in C4I System). This algorithm uses the rule of Newton's second law($F=(m{\Delta}{\upsilon})/{\Delta}t{\Rightarrow}\frac{V{\upsilon}I}{T}{\times}C$). Five factors considered in combat effectiveness evaluation are network power(M), movement velocity(v), information accuracy(I), command and control time(T) and collaboration level(C). Previous researches did not consider the value of the node and arc in evaluating the network power after the C4I system has been established. In addition, collaboration level which could be a major factor in combat effectiveness was not considered. E-TechMan algorithm is applied to JFOS-K(Joint Fire Operating System-Korea) system that can connect KJCCS of Korea armed forces with JADOCS(Joint Automated Deep Operations Coordination System) of U.S. armed forces and achieve sensor to shooter system in real time in JCS(Joint Chiefs of Staff) level. We compared the result of evaluation of Combat Effectiveness by E-TechMan with those by other algorithms(e.g., C2 Theory, Newton's second Law). We can evaluate combat effectiveness more effectively and substantially by E-TechMan algorithm. This study is meaningful because we improved the description level of reality in calculation of combat effectiveness in C4I system. Part 2 will describe the changes of war paradigm and the previous combat effectiveness evaluation methods such as C2 theory while Part 3 will explain E-TechMan algorithm specifically. Part 4 will present the application to JFOS-K and analyze the result with other algorithms. Part 5 is the conclusions provided in the final part.

최근, NCW에 적합한 C4I 체계의 전투력 상승효과 평가의 필요성이 제기되고 있다. 기존의연구는 체계 자체에 중점을 두었으며, 인적 요소를 중요한 요소로 고려하지 않았다. 따라서, C4I 체계의 전투력 상승효과 평가 시 기술 및 인적 요소를 고려하여 평가하는 것이 필요한 시점이라고 할 수 있다. 이에 본 연구에서는 E-TechMan(A Combat Effectiveness Evaluation Algorithm Considering Technical and Human Factors in C4I System)이라 불리는 전투력 상승효과 평가 알고리즘을 제안한다. E-TechMan 알고리즘은 합동화력체계(Joint Fire Operating System-Korea)에 적용되어 전투력 상승효과를 평가해보았다. 또한, 기존의 연구방법인 C2 이론 및 고전 역학에 의한 결과와 비교를 하였다. 본 연구는 인적요소에 의한 영향을 반영함으로써 기존의 연구보다 현실적인 전투력 상승효과 결과를 제시했다는데 가치가 있다.

Keywords

References

  1. Alberts, David S., John, Garstka J., and Hayes, Richard E., "Understanding Information Age Warfare", CCRP(2001), 142-143.
  2. Ablerts, David S., Garstka, John J., and Stein, Frederick P., "Network Centric Warfare : Developing and Leveraging Inforamtion Superiority", CCRP, 2nd Edition(2002), 94.
  3. A. K. Cebrowski, "The Implementation of Network-Centric Warfare", Department of Defense Office of Freedom of Information and Security Review, 05-S-0235, http://www.oft.osd.mil(2005).
  4. Bjorklund, Raymond C., The Dollars and Sense of Command and Control, National Defense University Press, Washington D. C.(1995).
  5. Chong-Man Kim, Injai Kim, "A Study of Influencing Factors Upon Using C4I Systems : The Perspective of Mediating Variables in a Structured Model", APJIS, Vol.19, No.2 (2009), 73-94.
  6. Darilek, Richard et al., Measures of Effectiveness for the Information-Age Army, RAND(2001), 14.
  7. Dekker, A., "Revisiting "SCUDHunt" and the Human Dimension of NCW : Some Thoughts, Human Factor Issues in NCW", TTCP Symposium(2006).
  8. Guiasu and Siliu, Information Theory with Applications, McGraw-Hill(1997).
  9. Han, H. et al., "A Study on the Concept of Information Warfare", Korea Institute for Defense Analyses(1999), 41.
  10. Jung, W. S. and Lee, J. Y., "An Assessment of Combat Effectiveness of C4I System Established for Joint Fire Operation", Journal of Defence Science and Technology, Vol.1, No.2(2008), 42.
  11. Kim, Y. K., "A Basic Study on the Analysis of Combat Contribution Effectiveness of Networking Weapon System", Korea Institute for Defense Analyses(2000), 46-47.
  12. Lee, J. Y. et al., "A Basic Concept Study on the Assessment Method of Information Combat Power Systems Analysis of Combat Contribution Effectiveness of Networking Weapon System", Korea Research Institute for Military Affairs(2001), 51-52.
  13. Lee, Y. B. et al., "A Proposal of New MOE to Assess the Combat Power Synergistic Effect of Warfare Information System", IE Interfaces, Vol.22, No.3(2009), 205-213.
  14. Loughran, J., Stahl, M., and Perla, P., "Key Drivers for C2 Performance : Data Mining SCUDHunt Experiment Data", ThoughtLink Inc(2001).
  15. Moon, J. L., "The Application of Classical Mechanical Concepts to the Combat Theory and its Limitations", Won Kwang Military Review( 2005).
  16. Park, S. K. and Lee, J. Y., "A Study on The Assessment of Power Improvement Effectiveness of Corps Level C4I System Applied to Integrated Fire Operation", Journal of the Military Operations Research Society of Korea, Vol.29, No.1(2003), 26.
  17. Paul, W. Phister, Jr, Igor G.Plonisch, "Information and Knowledge Centric Warfare : The Next Steps in the Evolution of Warfare", CCRTS(2004).
  18. Schutzer, D. M., Selected Analytical Concepts in Command and Control, C2 Theory and Measures of Effectiveness, Gordon and Breach Science Publisher(1982).