Response of the Resistant Biotype of Echinochloa oryzoides to ACCase and ALS inhibitors, and Effect of Alternative Herbicides

ACCase 및 ALS 저해 제초제들에 대한 저항성 강피의 반응과 대체약제들의 효과

  • 박태선 (국립식량과학원 벼맥류부) ;
  • 구본일 (국립식량과학원 벼맥류부) ;
  • 강신구 (국립식량과학원 벼맥류부) ;
  • 최민규 (국립식량과학원 벼맥류부) ;
  • 박홍규 (국립식량과학원 벼맥류부) ;
  • 이경보 (국립식량과학원 벼맥류부) ;
  • 고재권 (국립식량과학원 벼맥류부)
  • Received : 2010.08.24
  • Accepted : 2010.09.10
  • Published : 2010.09.30


Cyhalofop-butyl and penoxsulam, known for respective acetyl CoA carboxylase (ACCase) and acetolactate synthase (ALS) inhibitor, have been widely using as a post-emergence foliar application for many years in wet-seeded rice field in Korea. Since 2009, control of Echinochloa oryzoides with cyhalofop-butyl and penoxsulam was no longer satisfactory. Greenhouse and experiment in rice field were conducted to confirm E. oryzoides resistance to ACCase and ALS inhibitors and to compare herbicide treatments for control of the resistant E. oryzoides to ACCase and ALS inhibitors. Three resistant E. oryzoides to ACCase and ALS inhibitors accessions were tested for levels of resistance to cyhalofop-butyl and penoxsulam, base on survival rate. Iksan and Kimje accessions were not any affected to the survival by treatment with recommended doses of two herbicides tested. Buan accession displayed an intermediate response of 62 and 72% survival at recommended doses of cyhalofop-butyl and penoxsulam, respectively. Survival rates to herbicides mixed with ACCase and ALS inhibitors at 3.5 leaf stage of E. oryzoides was over 80%. Benzobicyclon+fentrazamide+bensulfuron SC, benzobicyclon+mefenacet+bensulfuron SC, benzobicyclone +cafenstrole+pyrazosulfuron-ethyl GR controlled effectively by 2 leaf stage of resistant E. oryzoides to ACCase and ALS inhibitors. In the field experiment, single treatment of benzobicyclon+ fentrazamide+bensulfuron SC and benzobicyclon+mefenacet+bensulfuron SC failed to control E. oryzoides, but squential treatment of benzobicyclon+thiobencarb SE and benzobicyclon+ mefenacet+ bensulfuron SC controlled effectively it in rice infant seedling culture with machine. Our results suggest that resistant E. oryzoides to ACCase and ALS inhibitors had not developed multiple resistance to herbicides with different modes of action. In particular, cafenstrole, fentrazamide, mefenacet were effective control measures.

ACCase 저해해제인 cyhalofop-butyl과 ALS 저해제인 penoxsulam은 한국의 직파재배 논에서 수년 동안 경엽 처리용으로 사용되어지고 있다. 그러나 2009년 이후 익산, 김제, 부안에서 이들 제초제를 사용한 벼 직파재배 논에서 강피 약효에 대한 민원이 증가하고 있다. ACCase 및 ALS 저해제 저항성으로 추정되는 강피를 3개 지역에서 수집하여 온실조건에서 cyhalofop-butyl과 penoxsulam에 대한 저항성 정도를 검증하였다. 익산과 김제의 수집종은 cyhalofopbutyl과 penoxsulam의 추천량에서 완전 생존하였으며, 부안 수집종은 약 60% 생존하였다. 온실조건에서 화본과 잡초인 피를 방제를 위한 ACCase 및 ALS 저해제들이 혼합된 제초제들을 강피 3.5엽기에 처리한 결과 무처리 대비 생존율은 80% 이상으로 나타났다. 파종 및 이앙전 처리제들인 oxadiazon EC, pyrazolate SC, pretilachlor EC, benzobicyclon+thiobencarb SE들은 강피 0.5엽기에서 효과적이었으며, benzobicyclon+fentrazamide+bensulfuron SC, benzobicyclon+ mefenacet+bensulfuron SC 그리고 benzobicyclone+cafenstrole+pyrazosulfuron-ethyl GR은 강피 2엽기까지 효과적으로 방제하였다. 포장실험에서 benzobicyclon+fentrazamide+bensulfuronSC과 benzobicyclon+mefenacet+bensulfuron SC의 단일처리에서는 저항성 강피의 방제에 실패하였으나, benzobicyclon+thiobencarb SE와 benzobicyclon+mefenacet+bensulfuron SC의 체계처리는 강피를 효과적으로 방제하였다. 따라서 강피의 익산, 김제 수집종은 cyhalofopbutyl과 penoxsulam애 대하여 강한 저항성을 보였으나, 작용기작이 다른 cafenstrole, fentrazamide, mefenacet에 의해 2엽기 이내에는 효과적으로 방제되었다.


  1. 민이기, R. Mann. 2004. 새로운 수도용 제초제 penoxulam 액상수화제의 이앙답 경엽처리에 의한 제초효과 및 작물기작. 한국잡초학회지 24(3):192-198.
  2. 이인용, 박재읍, 박태선, 김길웅. 1999. 국내 피 수집종에 대한 cyhalofop-butyl과 pyribenzoxim의 약제반응 및 흡수이행. 한국농약과학회지 3(2):19-29.
  3. 오정임, 김진석, 변종영, 조광연. 2003. Fenoxapropethyl과 cyhalofop-butyl의 초증상 및 발현특성 차이. 한국잡초학회지 23(3):257-266.
  4. Adkins, S. W., D. Wills, M. Boersma, S. R. Walker, G. Robinson, R. J. MacLeod, and J. P. Einam. 1997. Weeds resistant to chlorsulfuron and atrazine from the north-east grain region of Australia. Weed Res. 3:343-349.
  5. Bjelk. L. A. T. J. Monaco and P. S. Zorner. 1991. Effecr fenoxaprop, haloxyfop and sethoxydim on acetyl coenzyme A carboxylase from, barnyardgrass and sprangletop. Plant Science. 73:129-135.
  6. Daou, H., and R. Talbert E. 1999. Control of propanil-resistant barnyardgrass (Echinochloa crus-galli) in rice(Oryza sativa) with carbaryl/ propanil mixtures. Weed Tech. 13:65-67.
  7. Fischer, A. J., C. M. Ateh, D. E. Bayer and J. E. Hill. 2000. Herbicide-resistant Echinochloa oryzoides and E. phyllopogon in California Oryza sativa fields. Weed Sci. 48:225-230.[0225:HREOAE]2.0.CO;2
  8. Heap, I. 2010. International survey of herbicide resistant weeds,
  9. Im, S. H, M. W. Park, M. J. Yook and D. S. Kim. 2009. Resistance ACCase inhibitor cyhalofop-butyl in Echinochloa crus-galli var. crus-galli collected in Seosan, Korea. Kor. J. Weed Sci. 29(2): 178-184.
  10. Itoh, K., and K. Ito. 2005. Weed ecology and its control in south-east tropical countries. Japanese J. of Tropical Agriculture. 38:369-373.
  11. Lebaron, H. M., J. Gressel, B. B. Smale and D. M. Horne. 1992. International organization for resistant pest management (IOROM)-a step toward rational resistance management recommendations. Weed Tech. 6:765-770.
  12. Norsworthy, J. K., J. Rutledge S., R. Talbert E., and R. Hoagland E. 2002. Agrichemical interactions with propanil on propanil-resistant barnyardgrass (Echinochloa crus-galli). Weed Tech. 13:296-302.
  13. Park, T. S., Y. S. Kang and S. K. Heu. 2007. DNA sequence characterization of the acetolactate synthase (ALS) of sulfonylirea-resistant and susceptible Monochoria vaginalis. Kor. J. Weed Sci. 27(1):41-48.
  14. Valverde, B. B. 1998. Multiple resistant junglerice (Echinochloa colona) resistance to herbicides in groups A/1, B/2, and C2/7 in Costa Rica.

Cited by

  1. Occurrence Trends of SU-Herbicide Resistant Weeds in Paddy Fields in Korea vol.2, pp.3, 2013,
  2. Development and validation of an analytical method for pyrimisulfan determination in agricultural commodities by LC-MS/MS vol.26, pp.2, 2013,
  3. Survey of Pesticide Use in Leaf and Fruit Vegetables, Fruits, and Rice Cultivation Areas in Korea vol.5, pp.4, 2016,
  4. Cross-resistance of Echinochloa species to acetolactate synthase inhibitor herbicides vol.17, pp.2, 2017,
  5. Simple sequence repeat analysis of genetic diversity among Acetyl-CoA carboxylase inhibitor-resistant and -susceptibleEchinochloa crus-galliandE. oryzicolapopulations in Korea vol.55, pp.1, 2015,
  6. Herbicidal Activity of New Rice Herbicide Pyrimisulfan+Mefenacet SC against Sulfonlurea-Resistant Sea Club Rush (Scirpus planiculmis) vol.31, pp.2, 2011,
  7. Agronomic Characteristics and Herbicidal Response of Barnyard Millet Strains Under Paddy Rice vol.32, pp.3, 2012,
  8. A Survey on Farm Management and Occurrence Area of Herbicide Resistant Paddy Weeds in Chungbuk Province vol.2, pp.1, 2013,
  9. Fact-Finding Survey of Herbicide Use at Farmer's Level and Distribution of Herbicide Resistant Weeds in Paddy Field of Jeonbuk Province, Korea vol.3, pp.4, 2014,
  10. Herbicidal Activity of Newly Rice Herbicide Tefuryltrione Mixture against Sulfonylurea Resistant Weeds in Korea vol.32, pp.2, 2012,
  11. Status and Prospect of Herbicide Resistant Weeds in Rice Field of Korea vol.31, pp.2, 2011,
  12. Classification According to Site of Action of Paddy Herbicides Registered in Korea vol.3, pp.3, 2014,
  13. Herbicidal Efficacy Affected by Different Formulation of Benzobicyclon-Mixtures Herbicides in Paddy Rice Field vol.31, pp.4, 2011,
  14. Occurrence Trends of Herbicide Resistant Weeds in Paddy Fields in Korea vol.32, pp.2, 2012,
  15. Weeding Effect of Echinochloa oryzoides Resistant to ACCase and ALS Inhibitors by the Leaf Stages vol.31, pp.2, 2011,
  16. Fact-finding Survey on Occurrence of Weeds and Herbicide Usage for Paddy Rice Cultivation in Gyeonggi Province, Korea vol.2, pp.4, 2013,
  17. Identification of Herbicide-Resistant Barnyardgrass (Echinochloa crus-galli var. crus-galli) Biotypes in Korea vol.3, pp.2, 2014,
  18. Taxonomic Review of the Genus Echinochloa in Korea (II): Inferred from Simple Sequence Repeats vol.3, pp.3, 2014,