Nuclear Engineering and Technology

Korean Nuclear Society (한국원자력학회)
권호 표지
DOI QR코드

DOI QR Code

CORIUM COOLABILITY UNDER EX-VESSEL ACCIDENT CONDITIONS FOR LWRs

  • Farmer, Mitchell T. (Nuclear Engineering Division, Argonne National Laboratory) ;
  • Kilsdonk, Dennis J. (Nuclear Engineering Division, Argonne National Laboratory) ;
  • Aeschlimann, Robert W. (Nuclear Engineering Division, Argonne National Laboratory)
  • Published : 2009.06.30
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

In the wake of the Three Mile Island accident, vigorous research efforts were initiated to acquire a basic knowledge of the progression and consequences of accidents that involve a substantial degree of core degradation and melting. The primary emphasis of this research was placed on containment integrity, with: i) hydrogen combustion-detonation, ii) steam explosion, iii) direct containment heating (DCH), and iv) melt attack on the BWR Mark-I containment shell identified as energetic processes that could lead to early containment failure (i.e., within the first 24 hours of the accident). Should the core melt fail the reactor vessel, then non-condensable gas production from Molten Core-Concrete Interaction (MCCI) was identified as a mechanism that could fail the containment by pressurization over the long term. One signification question that arose as part of this investigation was the effectiveness of water in terminating an MCCI by flooding the interacting masses from above, thereby quenching the molten core debris and rendering it permanently coolable. Successful quenching of the core melt would prevent basemat melt through, as well as continued containment pressurization by non-condensable gas production, and so the accident progression would be successfully terminated without release of radioactivity to the environment. Based on these potential merits, ex-vessel corium coolability has been the focus of extensive research over the last 20 years as a potential accident management strategy for current plants. In addition, outcomes from this research have impacted the accident management strategies for the Gen III+LWR plant designs that are currently being deployed around the world. This paper provides: i) an historical overview of corium coolability research, ii) summarizes the current status of research in this area, and iii) highlights trends in severe accident management strategies that have evolved based on the findings from this work.

Keywords

References

  1. B. R. Sehgal, “Light Water Reactor (LWR) Safety,” Nucl. Eng. Technol., 38, 1 (2006)
  2. B.R. Sehgal, 'Accomplishments and Challenges of the Severe Accident Research,' Nucl. Eng. Design, 210, 79 (2001) https://doi.org/10.1016/S0029-5493(01)00433-2
  3. M. T. Farmer et al., “Modeling and Database for Melt- Water Interfacial Heat Transfer,” $2^{nd}$ CSNI Specialist Meeting on Core Debris-Concrete Interactions, Karlsruhe, Germany, April 1-3, 1992
  4. T. G. Theofanous, C. Liu, and W. W. Yuen, “Coolability and Quench of Corium-Concrete Interactions by Top- Flooding,” MACE-TR-D14, Electric Powe Research Institute (1998)
  5. R. E. Blose, J. E. Gronager, A. J. Suo-Anttila, and J. E. Brockman, “SWISS: Sustained Heated Metallic Melt/ Concrete Interactions With Overlying Water Pools,” NUREG/CR-4727 (1987)
  6. R. E. Blose, D. A. Powers, E. R. Copus, J. E. Brockmann, R. B. Simpson, and D. A. Lucero, “Core-Concrete Interactions with Overlying Water Pools - The WETCOR- 1 Test,” NUREG/CR-5907 (1993)
  7. H. Nagasaka, M. Kato, I. Sakaki, Y. Cherepnin, Y. Vasilyev, A. Kolodeshnikov, V. Zhdanov, and V. Zuev, “COTELS Project (1): Overview of Project to Study FCI and MCCI During a Severe Accident,” OECD Workshop on Ex-Vessel Debris Coolability, Karlsruhe, Germany, November 15- 18, 1999
  8. H. Nagasaka, I. Sakaki, M. Kato, Y. Vasilyev, A. Kolodeshnikov, and V. Zhdanov, “COTELS Project (3): Ex-vessel Debris Cooling Tests,” OECD Workshop on Ex- Vessel Debris Coolability, Karlsruhe, Germany, November 15-18, 1999
  9. M. T. Farmer, B. W. Spencer, D. J. Kilsdonk, and R. W. Aeschlimann, “Results of MACE Corium Coolability Experiments M0 and M1b,” Proceedings $8^{th}$ Int. Conf. on Nucl. Eng., Baltimore, MD USA, April 2-6, 2000
  10. M. T. Farmer, B. W. Spencer, J. L. Binder, and D. J. Hill, “Status and Future Direction of the Melt Attack and Coolability Experiments (MACE) Program at Argonne National Laboratory,” Proceedings $9^{th}$ Int. Conf. on Nucl. Eng., Nice, France, April 8-12, 2001
  11. M. T. Farmer, S. Lomperski, and S. Basu, “Results of Reactor Material Experiments Investigating 2-D Core- Concrete Interaction and Debris Coolability,” Proceedings ICAPP '04, Pittsburgh, PA USA, June 13-17, 2004
  12. M. T. Farmer, S. Lomperski, and S. Basu, “The Results of the CCI-2 Reactor Material Experiment Investigating 2-D Core-Concrete Interaction and Debris Coolability,” 11th International Topical Meeting on Nuclear Reactor Thermal- Hydraulics (NURETH-11), Avignon, France, October 2-6, 2005
  13. M. T. Farmer, S. Lomperski, D. Kilsdonk, R. W. Aeschlimann, and S. Basu, “A Summary of Findings from the Melt Coolability and Concrete Interaction (MCCI) Program,” Proceedings ICAPP '07, Nice, France, May 13-18, 2007
  14. S. Lomperski and M. T. Farmer, “Experimental Evaluation of the Water Ingression Mechanism for Corium Cooling,” Nuclear Eng. Design, 237, 905 (2006). https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2006.12.009
  15. S. Lomperski, M. T. Farmer, and S. Basu, “Experimental Investigation of Corium Quenching at Elevated Pressure,” Nuclear Eng. Design, 236 2271 (2006) https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2006.03.041
  16. S. Lomperski and M. T. Farmer, “Corium Crust Strength Measurements,” accepted for publication in Nuclear Eng. Design (2009) https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2009.06.013
  17. M. T. Farmer, B. W. Spencer, and R. W. Aeschlimann, “Liquidus/Solidus and Zr Solubility Measurements for PWR and BWR Core Melt Compositions,” OECD Workshop on Ex-Vessel Debris Coolability, Karlsruhe, Germany, November 15-18, 1999
  18. J. J. Sienicki and B. W. Spencer, “The Jet Impingement Stage of Molten Core-Concrete Interactions,” OECD CSNI Specialist Meeting on Core Debris/Concrete Interactions, Electric Power Research Institute, Palo Alto, CA USA, September 3-5, 1986
  19. D. H. Thompson, J. K. Fink, D. R. Armstrong, B. W. Spencer, and B. R. Sehgal, “Thermal-Hydraulic Aspects of the Large-Scale MCCI Tests in the ACE Program,” $2^{nd}$ CSNI Specialist Meeting on Core Debris-Concrete Interactions, Karlsruhe, Germany, April 1-3, 1992
  20. J. M. Bonnet and J. M. Seiler, “Coolability of Corium Spread Onto Concrete Under Water, the PERCOLA Model,” $2^{nd}$ CSNI Specialist Meeting on Core Debris-Concrete Interactions,” Karlsruhe, Germany, April 1-3, 1992
  21. J. J. Foit, “Modeling of Oxidic Molten Core-Concrete Interaction in WECHSL,” Nucl. Eng. Design, 170, 73 (1999) https://doi.org/10.1016/S0029-5493(97)00013-7
  22. M. T. Farmer, J. J. Sienicki, and B. W. Spencer, “CORQUENCH: A Model for Gas Sparging-Enhanced, Melt-Water, Film Boiling Heat Transfer,” ANS Winter Meeting on the Thermal Hydraulics of Severe Accidents, Washington, D.C. USA, November 11-15, 1990
  23. M. T. Farmer and B. W. Spencer, “Status of the CORQUENCH Model for Calculation of Ex-Vessel Corium Coolability by an Overlying Water Layer,” OECD Workshop on Ex-Vessel Debris Coolability, Karlsruhe, Germany, November 15-18, 1999
  24. M. T. Farmer, “Modeling of Ex-Vessel Corium Coolability with the CORQUENCH Code,” Proceedings $9^{th}$ Int. Conf. on Nucl. Eng., Nice, France, April 8-12, 2001
  25. C. R. B. Lister, “Qualitative Theory on the Deep End of Geothermal Systems,” Proceedings 2nd UN Symposium on Development and Use of Geothermal Resources, San Francisco, CA USA, May 20-29, 1975
  26. M. Epstein, “Dryout Heat Flux During Penetration of Water Into Solidifying Rock,” J. Heat Transfer, 128, 847 (2006) https://doi.org/10.1115/1.2227042
  27. H. Bjornsson, S. Bjornsson, and Th. Sigurgeirsson, “Penetration of Water into Hot Rock Boundaries of Magma at Grimsvotn,” Nature, 295, 580 (1982) https://doi.org/10.1038/295580a0
  28. B. Tourniaire, J. M. Seiler, J. M. Bonnet, and M. Amblard, “Liquid Ejection Through Orifices by Sparging Gas – The PERCOLA Program,” Proceedings ${10}^{th}$ Int. Conf. on Nucl. Eng, Arlington, VA USA, April 2-6, 2000
  29. B. Tourniaire and J. M. Seiler, “Modeling of Viscous and Inviscid Fluid Ejection through Orifices by Sparging Gas,” Proceedings ICAPP '04, Pittsburgh, PA USA, June 13-17, 2004
  30. M. T. Farmer, “Phenomenological Modeling of the Melt Eruption Cooling Mechanism During Molten Corium Concrete Interaction (MCCI),” Paper 6165, Proceedings ICAPP '06, Reno, Nevada USA, June 6-8, 2006
  31. M. T. Farmer, S. Lomperski, D. J. Kilsdonk, and R. W. Aeschlimann, “OECD MCCI Project Final Report,” OECD/ MCCI-2005-TR06 (2006)
  32. T.G. Theofanous, C. Liu, S. Addition, S. Angelini, O. Kym$\ddot{a}$l$\ddot{a}$inen, and T. Salmassi “In-vessel Coolability and Retention of a Core Melt”, Nucl. Eng. Design, 169, 1 (1997) https://doi.org/10.1016/S0029-5493(97)00009-5
  33. T.N. Dinh, J.P. Tu, and T.G. Theofanous, “Two-Phase Natural Circulation Flow in AP-1000 In-Vessel Retention – Related ULPU-V Facility Experiments”, Proceedings of ICAPP'04, Pittsburgh, PA USA, June 13-17, 2004
  34. M. Fischer and H. Henning, “EPRTM Engineered Features for the Mitigation of Severe Accidents,” Proceedings ICAPP '09, Tokyo, Japan, May 10-14, 2009
  35. V.B. Khabensky, V.S. Granovsky, S.V. Bechta, and V.V. Gusarov, “Severe Accident Management Concept of the VVER-1000 and the Justification of Corium Retention in a Crucible-Type Core Catcher,” published in Nucl. Eng. Technol., June (2006)
  36. H. Alsmeyer, M. Farmer, F. Ferderer, B. Spencer, and. W. Tromm, “The COMET-Concept for Cooling of Ex-Vessel Corium Melts,” Proceedings 6th Int. Conf. on Nucl. Eng., San Diego, CA USA, May 10-14, 1998
  37. C. Journeau and H. Alsmeyer, “Validation of the COMET Bottom-Flooding Core-Catcher with Prototypic Corium,” Proceedings ICAPP '06, Reno, Nevada USA, June 6-8, 2006
  38. M. J. Konovalikhin and B. R. Sehgal, “Investigation of Volumetrically Heated Debris Bed Quenching Proceedings $\9^{th}$ Int. Conf. on Nucl. Eng., Nice, France, April 8-12, 2001
  39. K. Nayak, B. R. Sehgal, and A. V. Stepanyan, “An Experimental Study on Quenching of a Radially-Stratified Heated Porous Bed,” Nucl. Eng. Design, 236 2189 (2006) https://doi.org/10.1016/j.nucengdes.2006.03.057

Cited by

  1. Revisiting Insights from Three Mile Island Unit 2 Postaccident Examinations and Evaluations in View of the Fukushima Daiichi Accident vol.172, pp.3, 2012, https://doi.org/10.13182/NSE12-3
  2. Further Study on Containment Effectiveness for CAP1400 vol.05, pp.02, 2017, https://doi.org/10.12677/NST.2017.52008