영어어문교육 (English Language & Literature Teaching)
- 제16권1호
- /
- Pages.123-142
- /
- 2009
- /
- 1226-2889(pISSN)
A FACETS Analysis of Rater Characteristics and Rater Bias in Measuring L2 Writing Performance
-
Shin, You-Sun
(Division of English Language and Literature Pukyong National University)
- 투고 : 20100100
- 심사 : 20100300
- 발행 : 2009.12.30
초록
The present study used multi-faceted Rasch measurement to explore the characteristics and bias patterns of non-native raters when they scored L2 writing tasks. Three raters scored 254 writing tasks written by Korean university students on two topics adapted from the TOEFL Test of Written English (TWE). The written products were assessed using a five-category rating scale (Content, Organization, Language in Use, Grammar, and Mechanics). The raters only showed a difference in severity with regard to rating categories but not in task types. Overall, the raters scored Grammar most harshly and Organization most leniently. The results also indicated several bias patterns of ratings with regard to the rating categories and task types. In rater-task bias interactions, each rater showed recurring bias patterns in their rating between two writing tasks. Analysis of rater-category bias interaction showed that the three raters revealed biased patterns across all the rating categories though they were relatively consistent in their rating. The study has implications for the importance of rater training and task selection in L2 writing assessment.