A Study of Combined Web Archiving Policy : BnF's Three Layers Web Archiving Strategy

복합적 웹 아카이빙 정책에 관한 고찰 - 프랑스국립도서관의 사례를 중심으로 -

  • 김유승 (중앙대학교 문헌정보학과)
  • Published : 2008.12.30


This study aims at discussing development of web archiving policies in South Korea. The study is based on the understanding of that the institutional environment and efforts for keeping Web information resources are insufficient, compared to the value and importance of them. For the study, Web archiving practices are analyzed into three aspects: scope, method, and quality. Futhermore, they are graphically schematized as a comparative analysis model. Based on the model, the study classifies national Web archiving practices into seven unique types and diagnoses their cons and pros. In this context, a combined Web archiving policy is discussed as an optimal Web archiving approach. As a case study, the France National Library's Web archiving is discussed in depth and the Korean National Library's Web archiving project, OASIS, is critically analyzed. As a result, the study proposes two alternative plans for the development of Web archiving policy in South Korea.

본 연구는 웹 정보자원이 우리 삶의 전 영역에서 지니는 가치와 중요성에 비해, 이를 지키고 보존하려는 제도적 환경과 노력이 미흡하다는 인식 아래, 우리의 정보자원 수집 보존정책의 발전 방향에 대한 논의를 목적으로 한다. 이를 위해 범위, 방법, 품질이라는 세 가지 측면에서 웹 아카이빙의 특성을 분석하고, 비교 모델로서 도식화한다. 이러한 분석에 기반 하여 각국의 웹 아카이빙 사례를 7가지 유형으로 나누어 각각의 장점과 단점을 진단하고, 최적의 웹 아카이빙 접근법으로서의 복합적 아카이빙 정책에 대해 논의한다. 이에 복합적 웹 아카이빙 정책을 채택하고 있는 프랑스 국립도서관의 웹 아카이빙 사례를 심층적으로 살펴본 후, 우리나라의 국가적 웹 아카이빙 프로젝트 OASIS를 비판적으로 분석한다. 결론으로, OASIS 프로젝트, 나아가 우리나라 웹 아카이빙 정책 발전을 위한 두 가지 방안을 제시한다.


  1. 곽승진, 최재황, 조영주, 류희경. 2008. 디지털 납본에 대한 보상 체계 요구. '한국도서관,정보학회지', 39(2): 65-83
  2. 김유승. 2007. 웹 아카이빙의 법, 제도적 문제에 대한 고찰. '한국문헌정보학회지', 41 (3): 5-24
  3. 서혜란. 2004. 웹 아카이빙의 성과와 과제. '한국비블리아', 15(1): 5-22
  4. 송병호. 2005. 진본성 확보를 위한 전자기록물 관리 방안. '한국비블리아학회지', 16(2): 43-59
  5. 이소연. 2004. 디지털유산의 장기적 보존: 국가정책수립을 위한 제언. '기록학연구', 10: 27-64
  6. 이혜원. 2004. 온라인 디지털 자원 구축 사례: 국립중앙도서관을 중심으로. '2004년 디지털 유선보존에 관한 기초연구 보고서'. 147-160
  7. 임진희. 2006. 전자기록의 장기보존을 위한 보존정보패키지(AIP) 구성과 구조. '기록학연구', 13: 41-90
  8. Arvidson, Allan and Persson, Krister. 2000. The Kulturarw3 Project―The Royal Swedish Web Archiw3e―An example of 'complete' collection of web pages. 66th IFLA Council and General Conference, Jerusalem, Israel. [citied 2008. 10. 4]
  9. Baeza-Yates, R. A. and C. Castillo. 2004. Crawling the infinite Web: Five levels are enough. In Workshop on algorithms and models for the Web-Graph WAW 2004. Rome, Italy: Springer Verlag
  10. Bergmark, D. 2002. Collection syntesis. Paper presented at the 2nd ACM/IEEE-CS Joint Conference on DIgital libraries, Portland, July 14-18
  11. Bergmark, D., C. Lagoze, and A. Sbityakov. 2002. Focused crawls, tunneling, and digital libraries. Paper presented at the 6th European Conference on Research and Advanced Technology for Digital Libraries, Rome, Italy, September 16-18
  12. BnF. 2006. Web archiving at BnF. [citied 2008. 10. 3]
  13. BnF. 2008. Legal deposit:five questions about Web Archiving at BnF. [citied 2008. 10. 3]
  14. Cordereix, Pascal. 2008. The legal deposit of Audiovisual and Multimedia material in France: the example of the Audiovisual Department of the National Library of France(Bibliothèque national de France/ BnF). World Library and Information Congress: 74th IFLA General Conference and Council, Québec, Canada
  15. Cruse, P., Eckman, C., and Kunze, J. 2003. Web-based government information: Evaluating solutions for capture, curation, and preservation. Okland: California Digital Library
  16. Day, Michael. 2003. Collecting and preserving the World Wide Web: A feasibility study undertaken for the JISC and Wellcome Trust. UKOLN, University of Bath
  17. Electronic Publication Pilot Project team and Electronic Collections Committee. 1996. Electronic Publication Pilot Project (EPPP) Final Report. [cited 2008. 10. 1]
  18. Hallgrimsson, Þorsteinn and Bang, Sverre. 2003. Nordic Web Archive. 3rd ECDL Workshop on Web Archives, Trondheim, Norway. [citied 2008. 10. 3]
  19. Henriksen, Birgit. 2001. Legal Deposit from the Internet in Denmark : Experiences with the Law from 1997 and the Need for Adjustments. Preserving the Present for the Future: Strategies for the Internet conference. The Royal Library, Copenhagen 18th -19th of June 2001. [cited 2007. 7. 25]
  20. Illien, Gildas. 2007. Re-Inventing Collection Development Policy in the Age of Web Archiving: Experience of the National Library of France. BnF. [cited 2008. 8. 2]
  21. Johnson, David., David, Post. 1996. Law and borders: The rise of law in cyberspace. Stanford Law Review, 48(1367)
  22. Kim, Heejung and Hyewoon, Lee. 2007. Development of Metadata Elements for Intensive Web Archiving. '정보관리학회지', 24(2): 143-160
  23. Koehler, W. 2004. 'A longitudinal study of Web pages continued: a consideration of document persistence.' Information Research, 9(2): 174
  24. Koerbin, Paul. 2004. PANDORA: Australia's web archive. Library Science Talks 2004. Swiss National Library/CERN. [citied 2008. 10. 2]
  25. Larivière, Jules. 2000. Guidelines for Legal Deposit Legislation. Paris: UNESCO
  26. Lasfargues, France., Oury, Clément., and Wendland, Bert. 2008. Legal deposit of the French Web: harvesting strategies for a national domain. IWAW '08. Aarhus, Denmark. [citied 2008.10.3]
  27. Lawrence, S., D. M. Pennock, G. W. Flake, R. Krovertz, F. M. Coetzee, E. Glover, F. Å. Nielsen, A. Kruger, and C. L. Giles. 2001. 'Persistence of Web references in scientific research.' Computer, 34(2): 26-31
  28. Lyle, J. A. 2004. Sampling the domain. The 4th International Web Archiving Workshop, Bath, UK
  29. Masanès, Julien. 2002. Archiving the deep Web. 2nd International Workshop on Web Archives, Rome, Italy. [citied 2008. 10. 4]
  30. Masanès, Julien. 2005a. Collecting the hidden Web. In J. Masanés (Ed.), Web Archiving. New York: Springer Verlag
  31. Masanès, Julien. 2005b. 'Web Archiving Methods and Approaches: A Comprartive Study.' Library Trends, 54(1): 72-90
  32. National Library of Australia. 2008a. Legal deposit. [cited 2008. 7. 30]
  33. National Library of Australia. 2008b. Web archiving [cited 2008. 10. 1]
  34. National Library of the Netherlands. 2004. The archiving system for electronic publications: The e-Depot. [citied 2008. 10. 3]
  35. OASIS. 2006a. OASIS 소개: 온라인디지털자원 선정 지침. [cited 2008. 8. 3]
  36. OASIS. 2006b. OASIS 시스템: 수집보존프로세스. [cited 2008. 10. 8]
  37. Phillips, Margaret. 2003. Collecting Australian Online Publications. PANDORA. [cited 2008. 9. 4]
  38. Phillips, Margaret. 2005. 'What should we preserve? The question for heritage libraries in a digital world.' Library Trends, 54(1): 57-71
  39. Rustad, Kjersti. 2005. Our digital heritage as source material to end-users: collection of and access to net publications in The National Library of Norway. World Library and Information Congress: 71th IFLA General Conference and Council. Oslo, Norway. [citied 2008. 10. 3]
  40. Sigurðsson, Kristinn. 2006. Archiving the Icelandic Web. ICA/SUV Seminar. Reykjavík, Iceland. [citied 2008.10.3]
  41. UNESCO. 2003. Charter on the Preservation of the Digital Heritage. The 32nd session of the General Conference of UNESCO, 17 October 2003

Cited by

  1. Research on the OASIS, a Web Archive in Korea vol.44, pp.2, 2010,