Abstract
This study was performed to compare the shear bond strength of primary enamel & dentin treated by AQ Bond $Plus^{TM}$ and G $Bond^{TM}$, recently developed 6th generation dentin bonding system, to that of Single $Bond^{TM}$ being widely used. Also by observing the resin tag under scanning electron microscope, Resin tags of each material were also observed under scanning electron microscope and compared to one another. The possibility of clinical application of All-in-One system which has an advantage to reduce chair-time for children with difficult behavior pattern was evaluated. The results obtained are as follows: 1. No statistically significant difference between groups was found in shear bond strength of primary enamel. 2. In primary dentin, the shear bond strength of AQ Bond $Plus^{TM}$ was $1.15\;{\pm}\;0.37\;MPa$, G $Bond^{TM}$ was $1.69\;{\pm}\;0.74\;MPa$ and Single $Bond^{TM}$ was $0.56\;{\pm}\;0.11\;MPa$. There were no statistical difference between AQ Bond $Plus^{TM}$ and G $Bond^{TM}$ and between G $Bond^{TM}$ and Single $Bond^{TM}$, whereas statistically significant difference was found between AQ Bond $Plus^{TM}$ and Single $Bond^{TM}$. 3. Under scanning electron microscope, resin tags observed in AQ Bond $Plus^{TM}$ and G $Bond^{TM}$ were very weak and tangled while strong and thick tags were shown with many lateral branches in Single $Bond^{TM}$. The result of the present study coupled with the advantages of less working time over the previous generation suggests that All-in-One system might be effectively used in adhesive dental procedures for primary teeth.
유치 60개를 준비하였으며, 사용된 접착 시스템은 AQ Bond $Plus^{TM}$, G $Bond^{TM}$, Single $Bond^{TM}$였다. 유치의 법랑질과 상아질을 노출시킨 후 제조사의 지시에 따라 접착 레진을 적용한 후, 내경 1.7 mm의 폴리에틸렌 튜브를 이용하여 Z-$250^{TM}$ 복합레진을 수복하였다. 100% 습윤 상태에서 24시간동안 보관 후 $5^{\circ}C$와 $55^{\circ}C$ 조건하에서 500회 열순환을 시행 후 만능시험기로 전단결합강도를 측정하였다. Resin tag 관찰을 위하여 상아질 접착면에 대해 수직으로 절단하고 인산과 질산으로 처리하여 치질을 용해시킨 후 주사 전자 현미경으로 관찰한 결과 다음과 같은 결론을 얻었다. 1. 유치 법랑질에서 측정된 전단 결합 강도는 AQ Bond $Plus^{TM}$에서 $1.04\;{\pm}\;0.13\;MPa$, G $Bond^{TM}$에서 $1.23\;{\pm}\;0.35\;MPa$, Single $Bond^{TM}$에서 $1.28\;{\pm}\;0.50\;MPa$이었으며, 세 군 간의 유의차는 없었다. 2. 유치 상아질에서의 전단 결합 강도는 AQ Bond $Plus^{TM}$는 $1.15\;{\pm}\;0.37\;MPa$, G $Bond^{TM}$는 $1.69\;{\pm}\;0.74\;MPa$ 그리고 Single $Bond^{TM}$는 $0.56\;{\pm}\;0.11\;MPa$로 나타났으며, AQ Bond $Plus^{TM}$와 G $Bond^{TM}$ 간에는 통계학적 유의차가 없었으나(p>0.05), AQ Bond $Plus^{TM}$와 Single $Bond^{TM}$, G $Bond^{TM}$과 Single $Bond^{TM}$ 간에는 통계학적 유의차를 보였다. 3. 주사 전자 현미경 소견에서 AQ Bond $Plus^{TM}$와 G $Bond^{TM}$는 resin tag 형성이 매우 미약하고 짧은 양상을 보인 반면, Single $Bond^{TM}$에서는 길게 형성된 resin tag가 관찰되었으며 resin tag의 표면에 불규칙하게 형성된 측부가지들이 관찰되었다.
(Department of Pediatric Dentistry, School of Dentistry, Dankook University)