Analysis of Elementary School Dietitians' Sanitary Practices and Perceptions of Obstacles According to the HACCP System in Gwangju and Jeonnam Regions of South Korea

광주${\cdot}$전남지역 초등학교 영양사들의 HACCP시스템 적용현황에 따른 위생실천도와 장애요인 비교분석

  • Kim, Sun-Hee (Dept. of Food and Nutrition, Chosun University)
  • 김선희 (광주여성발전센터 식품조리부)
  • Published : 2007.04.30

Abstract

The objective of this study was to analyze dietitians' sanitary practices and perceptions of obstacles according to HACCP. Questionnaires were administered to 94 elementary school dietitians in the Gwangju and Jeonnam Regions of South Korea. The data were evaluated by a 5 scale Likert method and statistically analyzed The results of the study are as follows. Each subject was generally characterized as a university graduate 79.8%, with 10 to 15 years experience 37.6%, and in her mid to late thirties 39.4%. We found that direct management was the highest occurring form of food service system 96.8%. With regards to the type of food service operation quantitative service as 60.6%, and partial self-service was 30.9%, 89.4%of all served only lunch. In all, 93.6% of the teams collaborated, while their organic collaboration was 64.9%. When HACCP was applied, sanitary practices scored an average of 4.83, which was significantly higher than 4.62 when HACCP was not applied. The dietitians' perception of sanitary practices was as very high 4.75 of 5. Sanitation, in regards to food management, scored 4.89 among the detailed items. This proves that in relation to food management, sanitation is considered most important. When HACCP was not applied, the perception of obstacles was, on an average, 3.07, which was higher than 2.74 when HACCP was applied. The results for the detailed items, which focused on sanitary practices and different perceptions of obstacles according to HACCP, were as follows. When HACCP was applied, a high mean of 3.32 occurred for facilities and utilities shortages followed by degree of cooperation at 3.22, and then monitoring at 3.01. The item that dietitians viewed as the biggest obstacle was lack of departmental budget support (M=3.46). Other serious obstacles were facilities, facility sanitation, and utility shortages (M=3.38), as well as the aappropriateness of machines and cooking utensils and arrangements in the dining room (M=3.28). Stepwise multiple regression was used to better understand how much these perceptions of obstacles would influence sanitary practices when HACCP was applied. The item analysis of the HACCP obstacles proved that persons involved in food service, except the food service employees, didn't cooperate enough with their food service employees. As a result, this lack of cooperation had a negative effect on sanitary practices. Accordingly, it is necessary to determine the causes of for lack of cooperation and attract the active attention of those involved.

Keywords

References

  1. 곽동경, 강영재, 박선희, 류경, 홍완수, 장혜자, 문혜경, 김성희, 박신정. 학교급식의 HACCP 제도도입 및 위생관리 시스템구축. 1999. 교육부 정책과제 보고서 : 1-195
  2. 교육부. 2003. 학교급식위생관리지침서. http://www.moe.go.kr/ main.jsp?idx=0306010101
  3. 교육인적자원부. 2005. 2005년도 학교급식 실시현황. http:// www.moe.go.kr/main.jsp?idx=0306010101
  4. 교육인적자원부. 2007. 학교급식 개선 종합대책(2007~2011년). http://www.moe.go.kr/main.jsp?idx=0306010101
  5. 류경. 2004. 국내외 식중독 발생동향과 급식, 외식산업의 예방대책 (1) 국내 식중독 발생 현황. 국민영양 27(1) : 34-38
  6. 부산광역시 교육청. 2005. 학교급식 지원센터 자료실. http://food.pen.go.kr/index.php
  7. 식품의약품안전청 식품관리과. 2006. 식중독 발생현황 통계 (2006). http://kfda.go.kr/open_content/foodpoison/news/ inner_issue_view.php?av_datacd=1&av_menucd=1&av_id=foodnews&av_textfield=&av_keyfield=&av_pg=1&av_index=7
  8. Albrecht JA, Summer SS, Hemmemen A. 1992. Food safety in child care facilities. Dairy Food & Envir Sanit 12 : 739-740
  9. Bae HJ. 2005. Evaluation of dietitians' perception of importance about HACCP guidelines in foodservice facilities. J Korean Diet Assoc 11(1) : 105-113
  10. Blakeslee KM, Penner KP. 1999. A case study of school foodservice cook-chill operation to develop a Hazard Analysis Critical Control Point Program. Dairy Food & Envir Sanit 19 : 257-267
  11. Bryan FL. 1991. Teaching HACCP Techniques to Food Processors and Regulatory Officials. Dairy Food & Envir Sanit 11(10) : 562-568
  12. Choe SH, Kim SH, Gwag DG. 2003. The Survey of Perception on Obstacles in Implementing Generic HACCP Plan for School Food service Operations. J Korean Diet Assoc 9(3) : 209-218
  13. Han EH, Yang HS, Shon HS, Ryo JO. 2005. A study on the investigation of sanitary knowldege and practice level of school foodservice employees in Jeonju. J Korean Soc Food Sci Nutri 34(8) : 1210-1218 https://doi.org/10.3746/jkfn.2005.34.8.1210
  14. Hernandez J. 1998. Managing the flow of food. Food Manag 33 : 73-78
  15. Hong WS, Yoon JY. 2003. Foodservice employees' sanitation and hygiene practice in school foodservice. Korean J Soc Food Cookery Sci 19(4) : 403-412
  16. Hong WS. 2005. The evaluation of foodservied employees' sanitary performance in elementary school foodservice operations. J Food Serv Manag Soc of Korea 8(1) : 127-143
  17. Kim EK, Kang MH, Kim EM, Hong WS. 1997. The Assessment of Foodservice Management Practices in Elementary School Food services. J Korean Diet Assoc 3(1) : 74-89
  18. Kim JG. 2000. Evaluation of the management of sanitation in food service establishments in Korea and strategies for future improvement. J food hygi & safe 15(3) : 186-198
  19. Kim JW, Yoo WC. 2000. Hygienic status of Korean hospital food service Korean J Soc Food Sci 16(3) 232-244
  20. Kim SH. 2005. Evaluation of importance and performance for students and employees about sanitary characteristics for high school foodservice in Busan. J Korean Soc Food Sci Nutri 34(9) : 1414-1426 https://doi.org/10.3746/jkfn.2005.34.9.1414
  21. Kim SY. 2000. Performance Assessment of Sanitary Management for Elementary School Food Service Staff in Seoul. Food Service Management. Master's thesis. The graduate school of Industrial Sciences Dongduk women's University : 1-68
  22. Kwon MH. 2001. Assessments of TQM-based sanitation management practices for the implementation of HACCP system in hospital foodservice operations. Major in foodservice management. Master's thesis. The graduate school of human Environmental Sciences Yonsei University : 1-79
  23. Lee KE, Ryu K. 2004. Infruences of school food servied employees' food safety training on food safety knowledge and practices. Korean J Commu Nutri 9(5) : 597-605
  24. Lee YJ. 2003. A comparative study on sanitary practices and perception of employees in elementary school, hospital and industry food service in the Inchon area. J Korean Diet Assoc 9(1) : 22-31
  25. Lee YW 1988. A suggestion for the improvement of food sanitation in Korea. J Korean Publ Health Assoc 14(2) : 1-3
  26. Lyu ES. 1999. Recognition about the HACCP Concepts by the Industry Foodservice Poerations of Pusan and Kyung Nam. J Korean Soc Food Cookery Sci 15(6) : 579-585
  27. Moon HK, Jean JY, Lyu ES. 2004. Assessment of hygiene knowledge and recognition on Job performance levels for HACCP implementation for dieticians and employees at contract foodservices. J Korean Diet Assoc 10(3) : 261-271
  28. Sneed J, Henroid D. 2003 HACCP Implementation in School Foodservice: Perspectives of Foodservice Directors. J Child Nutri & Manag http://www.asfsa.org/childnutrition/jcnm/ 03spring/sneed/,2003
  29. Yoo WC. 2000. Current information and sanitation status of professional catering companies, Korean J Commu Nutri 5(2) : 253-262