A Study on Sensory Factors Contributing to the Identification and Preference of Lamb Meat

양고기를 인식하는 관능적 요인 및 기호도에 관한 연구

  • Kim Gi-Ryoon (Dept. of Culinary Science and Food Service Management, The Graduate School of Tourism, Kyung Hee University) ;
  • Lee Kyung-Hee (Dept. of Food Service Management, Kyung Hee University)
  • 김기륜 (경희대학교 관광대학원 조리외식경영학과) ;
  • 이경희 (경희대학교 외식산업학과)
  • Published : 2005.08.01

Abstract

In the results of sensory evaluation, beef steak was preferred with the highest overall acceptability while lamb steak was less preferred than pork in flavor and overall acceptability. Sensory tests were conducted to examine whether taste, aroma, or texture is the dominant contributor to people's ability to identify the animal species of meat. The meat samples used were beef, pork, and lamb. Panelists wearing eye masks ate cooked pieces, patties, and heated soups prepared from the meats of these 3 species with and without pinching their noses to regulate the aroma sensation. The results led us to the conclusion that aroma is the most important contributor to the identification of lamb meat, with texture being the 2nd most important contributor. The contribution of taste appeared much smaller than that of aroma and texture. A sensory evaluation of lamb steaks with added herbs or herbal vegetables showed that steak with ginger and rosemary was preferred as having the significantly highest overall acceptability. It was also more preferred au 3 kinds of steak with added garlic and mint, garlic and rosemary, and ginger and mint in appearance, taste and flavor, although there was no significant difference. In difference test, odor was least noticeable in lamb steak when ginger and rosemary were added. Its taste gained the highest preference level, although the difference was not significant. A sensory evaluation that measured the effect of herbs and herbal vegetables on lamb steaks showed that steak with ginger and rosemary had the significantly highest overall acceptability. The second most preferred was beef steak, which had most significantly preferred in taste, and which ranked lower than lamb in flavor with no significant differences. The difference test showed lamb steak with ginger and rosemary scored the least odor and the highest level of palatability.

Keywords

References

  1. 구성자, 김희선. 2005. 새롭게 쓴 세계의 음식문화, 교문사, 서울, p5-192
  2. 김혜영, 조은자, 한영숙, 김지영, 표영희 1998. 문화와 식생활. 효일출판사. 서울, p.124
  3. 농림부 2005. 가축사육동향 및 육류소비량 통계자료, 축산정책과 한국인의 육류 음식
  4. 서유구 1827. 임원십육지. 영인본
  5. 식품재료사전편찬위원회. 1997. 식품재료사전, 한국사전연구사, 서울, p160
  6. 이성우. 1985. 한국식품사회사, 교문사, 서울, p71
  7. 조금호, 조여원. 2005. 약이 되는 우리음식, 교문사. 서울, p82
  8. 한국문화재보호재단. 1999. 한국음식대관. 한림출판사. 서울, p46, 440
  9. 한복려, 한복선, 한복진. 1999. 다시 보고 배우는 음식디미방, 궁중음식연구원, 서울, p88-94
  10. Bai YH, Hwang DH. 1998. A study on the dining-out preference and behavior of consumers for the chilled meat consumption strategy in Seoul-Kyunggi area, Korean J Dietary Culture, 13(3): 169-181
  11. Chae YC. 2001. The study of banquet menu in seoul delux hotel, J Research of Ulsan College, 28(2): 171-181
  12. http://www.foodnetwork.com/food/recipe/0,,Foodm
  13. Kim TH. 1994. The historical study of lamb cooking in korea, Korean J Dietary Culture, 9(1):23-40
  14. Kye SH, Lee HS, Park MA, Moon HK. 1996. The study on frequently consumed food items from 1993 Korean National Nutritional Survey(I) -Amounts and frequency of foods-, Korean J Dietary Culture, 11(5): 569-579
  15. Matsuishi M, Igeta M, Takeda S, Okitani A. 2004. Sensory factors contributing to the identification of the animal species of meat, J of Food Science, 69(6):S218-220
  16. Pamela GK, Kathryn PS. 1998. Food and Culture in America, second edition, West/Wadsworth, U.S.A, p7-9
  17. Pamela GK, Kathryn PS. 2000. Cultural Foods, Wadsworth, U.S.A., p31-163
  18. Park HI, Le MH, Chung MS. 1994. Comparition of flavor characteristics and palatability of beef obtained from various breeds, Korean J Food Sci Technol, 26(5):500-506
  19. Roberts DD, Acree TE. 1995. Simulation of retronasal aroma using a modified head-space technique: Investigating the effects of saliva, temperature, shearing and oil on flavor release, J of Agric Food Chem, 43:2179-2186 https://doi.org/10.1021/jf00056a041
  20. Shin MJ, Lee YS, Choi SK. 2001. Literature review on the pharmaceutical effect on korean traditional foods in Eumsikdimibang, J East Asian Soc. Dietary Life, 11(5):325-335
  21. Yook HS, Lee JW, Lee KH, Kim DJ, Shin HK, Byun MW. 1999. Effect of gamma irradiation on the improvement of beef tenderness, Korean J Food Sci Technol, 31(4):1005-1010
  22. Yoon GS, Woo JW. 1999a. The perception and the consumption behavior for the meats in Koreans, J Korean Soc. Food Sci Nutr, 28(1): 246-256
  23. Yoon GS, Woo JW. 1999b. Preference of meat food and its related factor in koreans, Korean J Soc Food Sci, 19(5):524-532
  24. Yun SJ, Kim CJ, Jang MS. 1994. Effect of the powder from fruit of paper mulberry on the tenderness and palatability of cooked ground beef, Korean J Soc. Food Sci, 10(4):346-350