A Comparative Study of the Houses of Mies van der Rohe and Le Corbusier

미이스 반 데르 로에 주택과 르 꼬르뷔제 주택의 비교 연구

  • 김용립 (상명대학교 디자인학부 실내디자인전공)
  • Published : 2004.10.01

Abstract

There are probably no architects of the 20th Century who had more influence on modern architecture than Mies van der Rohe and Le Corbusier. Although the two architects share one thing in common, namely, both are master of modernism, each has developed unique architecture of his own. The objective of this study is to investigate the characteristics of their works through a comparison analysis of the Ideas, design principles and architectural language reflected in the works, focusing on the houses. this study will also aim to provide a foundation for a new design that harmonizes the design principles and architectural language of the two. Through the study the following common points and differences were found between the houses of the two. A) Common points: Both architects avoided ornamentation In houses while placing weight on the functions of houses and they tried to plan rational floor plans by separating the wall from the structure. B) Differences: \circled1 The houses of Mies express the structure in a straight forward manner, while those of Corbusier are formative houses focusing more on shapes. \circled2 The shapes of the houses of Mies are limited to basic shapes, quadrangle while those of Corbusier employ various geometric curves. \circled3 Using steel and glass, the houses of Mies are light and transparent. On the contrary, using concrete, the houses of Corbusier are somewhat bulky with Three-dimensional changes. \circled4 The houses of Mies show the value of moderation based upon the classical principles of design, while the houses of Corbusier show the value of moderation based upon geometry. \circled5 The houses of Mies feature horizontal intoners with flexibility. However, Corbusier's houses have vertical interiors with some changes in the cross sections. \circled6 In terms of material, the interiors of Mies' houses employ materials with various tones and textures, while interiors of Corbusier's houses are painted in simple white. Summing up these characteristics, it could be said that the houses of Mies have logical and rational beauty, whereas the houses of Corbusier have more emotional beauty.

Keywords

References

  1. Benton, Tim, The Villas of Le Corbusier 1920-1930, New Haven: Yale University Press, 1990
  2. Blaser, Werner, Mies van der Rohe / The Art of Structure, Birkhauser Verlag: Basel, 1993
  3. Blaser, Werner, Mies van der Rohe Furniture and Interiors, New York: Barron's, 1982
  4. Giedion, S., Space Time and Architecture, Cambridge Massachusetts: Harvard University Press, 1973
  5. Black, Peter, 현대건축의 거장/ 미이스 반 데어 로에, 윤정섭 역, 서울: 건우사, 1989
  6. Black, Peter, 현대건축의 거장/ 르 꼬르뷰제, 윤정섭 역, 서울: 건우사, 1993
  7. Blaser, Werner, 미스 반 데어 로에, 송춘식 역, 서울: 대우출판사, 1983
  8. Boesiger, W. and Stonorow, O. ed., Le Corbusier, 8 Vols., 르꼬르부지에 작품연구회 편역, 서울: 집문사, 1991
  9. Moos, Stanislaus Von., 르 꼬르뷔제의 생애 / 건축의 신화, 최창길 외 역, 서울: 기문당 1989
  10. Moos, Stanislaus Von., Le Corbusier, 10 Vols., 편집부 편역, 서울: 도서출판보원, 1994
  11. 정금화, Le Corbusier의 주거디자인요소에 관한 연구 / Villa Savoye를 중심으로 석사 학위논문, 홍익대학교 환경대학원, 1988
  12. Architectural Monographs, Mies van der Rohe, 이민 역, 서울: 공간도서, 1989