Analysis of the Priority Decision for Establishment Criteria of Environmental Sculptures in Urban Areas

대도시 옥의 환경조형물의 설치기준에 대한 우선순위 분석

  • Lee, Sang-Seol (Dept. of Industrial Management Information, Kumi College) ;
  • lee, Jeong (Dept, of Landscape Architecture, Sunchon National University)
  • 이상설 (구미1대학 산업경영정보과) ;
  • 이정 (순천대학교 조경학과)
  • Published : 2000.12.01

Abstract

This research focused on the priotity decision for establishment sriteria on the effects which environmental sculptures in urban area. The analysis performed in this study used the AHP(Analytic Hierarchy Process) that is recognized as a useful decision-making tool to select and evaluate alternatives through pairwise comparison in the context of hierarchical decision structure. The results obtained from the analysis drawn by collecting the professional opinions of 5 experts for environmental sculptures are as follows: 1. The orders of establish criteria priorities on environmental sculptures were harmony of environment> symbol> public> function. The harmony of environment was the most important priority because it showed the highest weight of criteria. 2. The alternative priorities of environmental sculptures were the meaning of work>setting place> social contribution> physical quality .The meaning of work showed the highest change in the weight of alternative. 3.The sensitivity analysis of environmental sculptures demonstrated that the rate of change in the alternative priorities of the public was stabilized although the criteria importance varied, while the harmony of environment, the symbol intimated and function of priorities has their rates of weight changed if the criteria priorities were high.

Keywords

References

  1. 建築法 · 條例解說 건축법32조, 대지안의 조경(미술작품 설치편) 尹赫敬
  2. 한국조경학회지 v.24 옥외예술 장식품 설치공간의 실태에 관한 연구 김도경
  3. 한국정원학회지 v.17 대도시 환경조형물의 실태 및 시각적 이미지 특성분석 이정;이현택
  4. Environment and sculpture 최병상
  5. OutdoorSculpture-Object and Environment Robinett,A.;Margaret
  6. Journal of Mathematical Psychology v.15 A Scaling Method for Priorities in Hierarchical Structures Saaty,T.L.
  7. 경영논총, 고려대학교논문집 v.32 AHP기법의 신뢰성에 관한 연구 황규승
  8. European Journal of Operational Research v.48 How to make a decision: The Analytic Hierarchy Process Saaty,T.L.
  9. European Journal of Operational Research v.4 Modelling New Zealand Energy System Smith,B.R.
  10. Information and Management v.18 Using the Analytic Hierarchy Process for Information System Project Selection Muralidhar,K.;R.Sanhtanam;L.Wilson
  11. European Journal of Operational Research v.13 Multi-Criteria Analysis of the Impacts of Energy Alternatives: A Survey and a New Comparative Approach Siskos,J.;Hubert,P.
  12. 건국대학교 박사학위논문 전문가의 일관성 및 평가성향이 고려된 계층적 의사결정에 관한 연구 李相卨
  13. 영남대학교 대학원, 석사학위논문 온천지 개발에 있어서의 개발요소의 중요도 평가 권은숙
  14. 한국조경학회지 v.24 도시공원조성의 우선순위 결정에 있어서 계층분석과정 기법의 적용 박문호
  15. 서울대학교 대학원 박사학위논문 저수지유역의 옥외 레크레이션 시설입지에 영향을 미치는 개발잠재력 지표설정에 관한 연구 장병관
  16. 경희행정논총 v.7 계층적 분석절차에 의한 지역 개발정책의 우선순위 설정 羅濟民;朴英美
  17. Management Science v.32 Axiomatic Foundation of the Analytic Hierarchy Process Saaty,T.L.
  18. Journal of Multi-Criteria Decision Analysis v.1 Software Review Three Packages for AHP : Criterium, Expert Choice and HIPRE3 Buede,D.M.
  19. Based on the Analytic Hierarchy Process Export Choice
  20. Decision Sciences v.19 no.97 A Note on Input Consistency in the Application of AHP Zahedi,F.
  21. The Analytic Hierarchy Process Saaty,T.L.
  22. アメリカ50都市の環境彫刻 楗口正一郞
  23. 造園雜誌 v.53 視覺反應實驗による都市環境 にわける抽象彫刻ぴ具象彫刻ぴ背景の適合性に關する 硏究 竹前直樹;白井彦衛
  24. 日科技蓮 ゲ -ム感覺意思決定法 刀根薰