Comparative Clinical Study between Oriental Medicine and Oriental-western Medicine Treatment on Facial Nerve Paralysis

구안와사(口眼喎斜)에 대한 한의(韓醫) 및 한(韓)·서의(西醫) 협진(協診) 치료(治療)의 임상(臨床) 관찰(觀察)

  • Kang, Mi-Jung (Dept. of Acupuncture & Moxibustion, Oriental Medical College, Kyungwon University) ;
  • Kim, Kee-Hyun (Dept. of Acupuncture & Moxibustion, Oriental Medical College, Kyungwon University) ;
  • Hwang, Hyeon-Seo (Dept. of Acupuncture & Moxibustion, Oriental Medical College, Kyungwon University)
  • 강미정 (경원대학교 한의과대학 침구학교실) ;
  • 김기현 (경원대학교 한의과대학 침구학교실) ;
  • 황현서 (경원대학교 한의과대학 침구학교실)
  • Published : 2000.03.20

Abstract

The following results have been obtaind after examing 72patients with facial paralysis who were hospitalzed and treated through the time period of December 1st, 1996 to November 30th, 1999 at the Department of Acupuncture and Moxibustion of Seoul Oriental Medicine, Kyungwon University. During the examination, those 72 patients were divided into two groups, and One group was treated by oriental-western treatment, the other group was treated by oriental treatment. Oriental treatments were acupuncture and moxibustion, herb medicine, physical treatment and hygienic treatment. The one of main western treatments is steroid therapy. The results were obtained as follows : 1. In regard to signs at the first medical examination, lacrimation was showed highest number and facial paralysis, dysgeusia, hyperacusis were showed in numerical order. 2. In regard to prescription of oriental herb medicine, Kamissangbotang(加味雙補湯) was prescribed in greatest numbers and Boyangwhanotang(補陽還五湯), Kamiboiktang(加味補益湯), Ligigepungtang(理氣祛風湯) were prescribed in numerical order. 3. In regard to treatment number, 10~19 times for treatment was showed highest number and 1~9 times, 20~29 times, 40~49 times were showed in numerical order . 4. In regard to mean treatment times about injury region and main sign, the effect of oriental-western treatment was showed as follows: lacrimal gland disorder, hyperacusis, dysgeusia, facial paralysis were treated for 15.1, 27, 13.2 and 21.4 times, repectively. The effect of oriental treatment was showed as follows: lacrimal gland disorder, hyperacusis, dysgeusia, facial paralysis were treated for 34.8, 22.1, 33.8 and 16.3 times, respectively. 5. In regard ta the effect of treatment about injury region and main sign, oriental-western treatment was showed as follows: cases of lacrimal gland disorder were showed 1 of excellent case, 1 of fair case, 5 of good cases. In hyperacusis patients, there was showed 1 of fair case. In dysgeusia patients, there was showed 1 of excellent case, 3 of fair cases, 1 of good case. In facial paralysis, there were showed 5 of fair cases. Oriental treatment was showed as follows: In lacrimal gland disorder, the excellent were 4 cases, the fair were 10 cases, the good were 3 cases and the poor were 4 cases, In hyperacusis, the fair were 5 cases, the poor 2 cases. In dysgeusia, the excellent were 4 cases, the fair were 1 case, the good were 1 case and the poor was 1 case, In facial paralysis, the excellent were 9 cases, the fair were 4 cases, the good 3 cases and the poor were 3 cases. 6. The effect of total treatment was as follows: 30 cases were showed fair effect, 19 cases were showed excellent effect, 13 cases were showed good effect and 10 cases were showed poor effect. 7. In regard to attack factor, overlabour was showed highest number and wind-cold, mental stress, trauma, ear disease, common cold, dental diseae, reason unknwon were showed in numerical order. 8. In regard to premonitory symptoms, non significant symptoms were in 38 cases, the pain of peri-stylomastoid region were in 38 cases and headache, dysaesthesia of periorbit, dysgeusia, stomatitis, eyelid tic were showed in numerical order. 9. In regard to sex, male were 33 cases and female were 39 cases. The distribution of age was disclosed that thirty, forty, fifty, seventy, sixty, twenty and below twenty years were revealed in turn. Sex and paralytic side were showed as follows: male-left were 15 cases, male-right were 18 cases, female-left were 19 cases and female-right were 19 cases. In regard to attack frequence in month, March was showed highest number and January, April, May, August, October, etc were showed in numerical order. In regard to attack frequence in season, spring was showed highest number and winter, summer, fall were showed in numerical order, but attack frequence between four seasons wasn't showed significant difference.

Keywords

References

  1. 韓方臨床四十年 朴炳昆
  2. 臨床實用綜合鍼灸學 康華柱
  3. 常見病症辨證診治槪要 白洪龍
  4. 大韓鍼灸學會誌 v.16 no.4 電鍼을 利用한 口眼괘斜의 臨床的 觀察 이승우(外)
  5. 大韓鍼灸學會誌 v.15 no.1 口眼괘斜 患者 72例에 대한 臨床的 考察 李姸炅(外)
  6. 大韓外官科學會誌 v.10 no.1 左右側 口眼괘斜 患者에 대한 臨床的 考察 林眞淇(外)
  7. 大韓外官科學會誌 v.7 no.1 口眼괘斜에 관한 臨床的 觀察 崔政和
  8. 大韓鍼灸學會誌 v.11 no.1 末梢性 顔面神經痲痺의 臨床的 硏究 崔翊善
  9. 大韓鍼灸學會誌 v.15 no.1 末消性 顔面神經痲痺에 대한 韓洋方 臨床的 考察 李京美(外)
  10. 大韓外官學會誌 v.12 no.2 口眼괘斜 後遺症에 대한 臨床的 考察 金南權
  11. 大韓外官科學會誌 v.4 no.1 口眼괘斜에 대한 臨床的 考察 安秀基(外)
  12. 東醫學會誌 v.3 no.1 口眼괘斜 患者에 대한 治驗 6例 한의철(외)
  13. 大韓鍼灸學會誌 v.12 no.2 口眼괘斜의 韓洋方協診에 관한 臨床的 考察 尹炫珉(外)
  14. 원색최신의료대백과사전 신태양사 편집국
  15. 黃帝內經靈樞 楊維傑(編)
  16. 中醫症狀鑑別診斷學 中醫硏究院
  17. 金궤要略 張仲景
  18. 巢氏諸病源候論 巢元方
  19. 三因極一病證方論 陳無擇
  20. 東垣十種醫書 李고
  21. 醫學正傳 虞搏
  22. 東醫寶鑑 許浚
  23. 醫林改錯 王淸任
  24. 實用中西醫結合診斷治療學 陳貴延
  25. 人體解剖學 鄭然泰(外)
  26. 人體解剖學 강기선(外)
  27. 神經外科學 大韓神經外科學會
  28. 최신실전임상가이드 이영진(外)
  29. 證例를 통한 臨床神經解剖學 醫科大學神經解剖學敎授(編)
  30. 神經學原論 서울대학교의과대학(편)
  31. 오늘의 診斷 및 治療 全國醫科大學敎授(譯)
  32. 內科學 해리슨내과학편찬위원회
  33. 家庭醫學 醫學敎育硏修院