정보시스템 서비스의 종합적 품질평가모형에 관한 연구

A Study on Total Quality Evaluation Model of Information System Services

  • 이명호 (한국외국어대학교 경영학과) ;
  • 윤재욱 (한국외국어대하교 산업공학과) ;
  • 이경근 (한국외국어대학교 경영학과 박사과정 졸업)
  • 발행 : 1999.09.01

초록

Recently, information technology and information system(IS) are rapidly diffused throughout the world. In the global competitive environment, the success of IS becomes the important one among the critical success factors(CSF) of the firm. For achieving it, the firm must continually involve itself in the quality evaluation and improvement of IS. The quality concept was changed into the customer-oriented quality one. There is no exception to the quality of IS. In the past, IS quality was determined by the IS developer or IS department offering service. Now it is evaluated by the user of IS service, and then the customer-oriented user satisfaction becomes an important issue. The purpose of this study is to develope the total quality evaluation model of IS through TQM approach. First, all success factors of the domestic IS are extracted from the foreign and domestic literatures of IS success factors contained the technical and behavioral aspects. And the extracted factors are classified with evaluation levels for quality evaluation and developed into a total quality evaluation model. Finally the model usefulness is analyzed.

키워드

참고문헌

  1. 신경제 품질경영 어떻게 추진하나(QM시리즈 배포자료 93-1) 공업진흥청;한국표준협회
  2. Management Science v.29 no.5;May Development of a Tool of Measureing and Analyzing Computer User Satisfaction Bailey, J. E.;Pearson, W. S.
  3. The Essence of Total Quality Management Banks, J.
  4. Journal of Management Information System v.4 A short form measure of user satisfaction and notes on use Baroudi, J.J.;Orlikowski, W. J.
  5. Sloan Management Review no.Spring Listening to the customer - The Concept of a Service-Quality Information System Berry, L. L.;Parasuraman, A.
  6. Journal of Consumer Research v.17 A Multistage model of customer's assessments of service quality and value Bolton, R. N.;Drew, J. H.
  7. Journal of Marketing v.56 no.July Measuring Service Quality : A Reexamination and Extension Cronin, J. J.;Taylor, S. A.
  8. Journal of Marketing v.58 no.January SERVPERF Versus SERVQUAL: Reconciling Performance-Based and Perceptions-Minus-Expectations Measurement of Service Quality Cronin, J. J.;Taylor, S. A.
  9. Quality is Free Crosby, P.B.
  10. Information System Research v.3 no.1;March Information Systems Success : The Quest for the Dependent Variable DeLone, W. H.;McLean, E. R.
  11. Management Science v.24 no.10 Organizational context and the success of management information system Ein-Dor, P.;Segev, E.
  12. Information & Management v.32 Perceived importance of information system success factors : A meta analysis of group difference Eldon Y. Li
  13. Managing Customer Value Gale, Bradley T.
  14. Solan Management Review v.26 What Does Quality Mean? Garvin, D. A.
  15. Harvard Business Review no.Nov.;Dec. Competing on the eight dimensions of quality Garvin, M. S.
  16. Proceedings of the Twenty-Fifth Annual Hawaii International Conference on System science v.4 User evaluations of MIS success: Wha are we really measuring? Goodhue, D.;J. F. Nunamaker(ed.);R. H. Sprague(ed.)
  17. European Journal of Marketing v.18 A Service Quality Model and Its Marketing Implication Gronroos, C.
  18. EOQC Quality Conformance or Fitness for Use Groocock, J. M.
  19. MIS Quarterly v.5 no.3 Evaluating information system effectiveness part Ⅰ: Comparing evaluation approaches Hamilton, S.;Chervany, N. L.
  20. MIS Quarterly v.5 no.4 Evaluating information system effectiveness part Ⅱ: Comparing evaluator viewpoints Hamilton, S.;Chervany, N. L.
  21. Service Quality : New Directions in Theory and Practice The Nature of customer value : an axiology of service in consumption ecperience Holbrook, Morris B.;Rust, R.T.(ed.);Oliver, R.L.(ed.)
  22. Perceived Quality Quality and Value in the consumption experience : Phaedrus rides again Holbrook, Morris B.;Corfman, K. P.;Jacoby. J.(ed.);Olson, J.(ed.)
  23. Advances in Service Marketing Management v.3 The calculus of service quality of customer satisfaction : Theoretical and empirical differentiation and integration Iacobucci, D.;Grayson, K. A.;Ostrom, A. L.;Swartz, A. T.(ed.);Bowen, D. E.(ed.);Brown, S. W.(ed.)
  24. Advances in Service Marketing Management v.5 A canonical model of consumer evaluation and theoretical bases of expectations Iacobucci, D.;Ostrom, A. L.;Baig, B.;Beezjian-Avery, A.;Swartz, A.T.(ed.);Bowen, D.E.(ed.);Brown, S.W.(ed.)
  25. ISO 8402 Quality Management and Quality Assurance-Vocabulary ISO
  26. MIS Quarterly no.Sep. Evaluating Information System Effectiveness Part Ⅰ Ives, B.;Chervany, N. L.
  27. Communications of the ACM v.26 The measurement of user information satisfaction Ives, B.;Olson, M. H.;Barouddi, J. J.
  28. Information Processing & Management v.32 no.5 Information System Effectiveness : A User Satisfaction Approach James Y. L. Thong;Chee-Sing Yap.
  29. ASQC Annual Quality Congress The Upcoming Century of Quality Juran, J. M.
  30. Decision Science v.25 no.5 Perceived Service Quality and User Satisfaction with the Information Service Function Kettinger, W. J.;Lee, C. C.
  31. Decision Science v.26 no.5 Global Measures of Information Service Quality : A Cross-National Study Kettinger, W. J.;Lee, C. C.
  32. MIS Quarterly v.21 no.2;June Pragmatic Perspectives on the Measurement Information System Service Function Kettinger, W. J.;Lee, C. C.
  33. MIS Quarterly Evaluating MIS King, W. R.;Rodriguez J. I.
  34. Service Quality : A Study of Quality Dimension Lehtinen U.;Lehtinen G.
  35. International Journal of Service Industry Management v.4 Estimating zones of tolerances in perceived service quality Liljander, V.;Strandvik, T.
  36. MIS Quarterly v.11 no.1 Measuring the effectiveness of computer-based information systems in the financial service sector Miller, J.;Doyle, B. A.
  37. Creating Customer Value Naumann, Earl.
  38. Journal of Marketing Research v.17 no.November Cognitive Model of Antecedents and Consequences of Satisfaction Decision Oliver, R. L.
  39. Advances in Services Marketing Management v.2 A Conceptual Model of Service Quality and Service Satisfaction : Compatible goals, different concept Oliver, R. L.;Swartz, A. T.(ed.);Bowen, D. E.(ed.);Brown, S. W.(ed.)
  40. Advances in Consumer Research v.21 Conceptual issues in the structural analysis of consumption emotion, satisfaction and quality : Evidence in a service setting Oliver, R. L.
  41. Journal of Retailing v.64 no.Spring SERVQUAL : A Multi-Item Scale for Measuring Consumer Perceptions of Service Quality Parasuraman, A.;Zeithaml, V. A.;Berry, L. L.
  42. Journal of Retailing v.67 no.Winter Refinement and Reassessment of the SERVQUAL Scale Parasuraman, A.;Zeithaml, V. A.;Berry, L. L.
  43. Journal of Marketing v.58 no.January Reassessment of Expectation as a Comparison Standard in Measuring Service Quality : Implications for Future Research Parasuraman, A.;Zeithaml, V. A.;Berry, L. L.
  44. MIS Quarterly v.19 no.2;June Service Quality : A Measure of Information System Effectiveness Pitt, F. L.;Watson, T. R.;Kavan, C. B.
  45. MIS Quarterly v.21 no.2;June Measuring Information System Service Quality : Concerns for a Complete Canvans Pitt F. L.;Watson T. R.;Kavan C. B.
  46. Business America Winning Strategies for Quality Improvement Reimann, C. W.
  47. Journal of MIS v.10 no.1 Perceptions of conflict and success in information system development project Robey, D.;Smith, L. A.;Vijaysarath, L. R.
  48. Service Quality : New Directions in Theory and Practice Service quality : Insights and managerial implications from the frontier Rust, R. T.;Oliver, R. L.;Rust, R.T.(ed.);Oliver, R.L.(ed.)
  49. Journal of Economic Psychology Merging service quality and service satisfaction : An empirical test of an integrative framework Ruyter, J. C.;Bloemer, J. M. A.;Peters, T.
  50. MIS Quarterly v.9 no.3 Alternative measures of system effectiveness : Association and implications Srinivasan, A.
  51. Management Science v.21 no.2;February Management information system : Appreciation and involvement Swanson, E. B.
  52. Advance in Service Marketing and Management Research and Practice Fifteen Years after Breaking Free : Servce Then, Now and Beyond Swartz, Teresa A.;Bowen, Davie E.;Brown, S. W.
  53. MIS Quarterly v.21 no.2;June Measuring Information System Service Quality Van Dyke, T. P.;Kappelman, L. A.;Prybutok, V. R.
  54. Proceedings of the 2nd International Research Seminar in Service Management Consumer satisfaction with services : Opening up the disconfirmation paradigm Wirtz, J.;Bateson, J. E. G.
  55. Know Your Customer : New Approaches to Understanding Customer Value and Satisfaction Woodruff, R. B.;Gardial, S. F.
  56. Quality Information System Zahedi, Fatemeh
  57. Journal of Marketing v.60 The Behavioral consequences of service quality Zeithaml, V. A.;Berry, L.L.;Parasuraman, A.
  58. Journal of Marketing v.52 no.July Consumer Perceptions of Price, Quality and Value : A Means-End Model and Synthesis of Evidence Zeithaml, V. A.
  59. Decision Science v.9 An Empirical Investigation of the Dimensionality of the Concept of Information Zmud, R. W.
  60. Management Science v.25 no.10 Individual difference and MIS success : A review of the empirical literature Zmud, R. W.