Journal of the Korean Society for information Management (정보관리학회지)

Korean Society for Information Management (한국정보관리학회)
권호 표지

A study of collection evaluation using conspectus methodology

컨스펙터스방법을 이용한 장서평가연구

  • 박진희 (대한성서공회 문헌정보자료실)
  • Published : 1998.09.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

The im of the present study is to introduce and develop the concept and theory of conspectus for the first time in Korea, and to propose a new evaluation model for book collection by actually applying the developed methodology to the collection of a special library dedicated to Biblical Studies. Conspectus is a standardized and objective evaluation method that classifies the main collection according to the division, category, subject, and then gives each collection ots appropriate collection level code by analyzing the classified collection in terms of three different dimensions, which are Current Collection Level(CL), Acquisition Commitment Level(AC), and Collection Goal Level(GL). To evaluate the collection of the sample library, shelflist analysis, list checking, acquisition data in ordering process by their main subject, and survey of its users have been carried out, and all of their results ahve been indicated in terms of eleven collection level codes developed by WLN Conspectus. T e collection of sample library was evaluated as '3cW' for CL, '4W' for AC, and '4W' for GL when the Conspectus methodology was applied for evaluation. This study could be utilized as an collection evaluation model for theological libraries, and become a basis to bring about more active cooperative collection development among related libraries.

본 연구는 국내 최초로 컨스펙터스(Conspectus)에 대한 개념과 이론을 발전시키고 그 이론을 실제로 성서학 전문도서관의 장서평가에 적용함으로써 새로운 장서평가 모형을 제시할 목적으로 이루어졌다. 컨스펙터스는 도서관의 규모와 상황에 적합하게 장서를 주류, 강목, 요목별로 구분하여, 현재장서수준(CL), 수집의지수준(AC), 목표장서수준(GL)이라는 세가지 차원에서 분석 평가한 후, 각 장서에 적합한 장서수준기호를 부여하는 표준화되고 객관적인 장서평가방법이라 할 수 있다. 평가대상 도서관인 대한성서공회 성서학문헌정보자료실의 장서평가를 위하여 서가목록분석법과 목록대조법, 주문중인 자료의 주제별 수서데이터분석, 이용자설문조사방법을 이용하였으며 그 결과를 종합하여 각 주제별 장서에 미국서부지역도서관망 컨스펙터스의 장서수준기호를 부여하였다. 따라서 평가 대상도서관 장서중 성서학 강목의 현재장서수준은 '3cW', 수집의지수준은 '4W', 목표장서수준은 '4W', 목표장서수준은 '4W'였다. 본 연구는 신학도서관의 장서평가 모형으로 응용될 수 있으며, 이를 토대로 도서관간의 협동장서개발업무를 활성화시킬수 있을 것이다.

Keywords

References

  1. 국회도서관보 v.27 no.5 미국 대학도서관을 위한 기준, 1986 미국도서관협회 대학 및 연구도서관부회, 대학도서관 기준위원회(Association of College and Research Libraries, College Library Standards Committee;이병목(역)
  2. 신학인을 위한 필독서 총신대학 신학대학원 교수회
  3. 석사학위논문, 성균관대학교 대학원 학교도서관 장서중 국어과 교사용 자료의 평가연구 한윤옥
  4. Guidelines for Collection Development American Library Association, Collection Development Committee
  5. Guide to the Evaluation of Library Collections B.Lockett(ed.)
  6. Collection Description and Assessment in ARL Libraries, SPEC Kit 87
  7. Ph.D. Dissertation The University of Indiana Inventory, Overlap, and Description of Psychology Collection in Research Libraries : Study of a Conspectus Bentley,S.
  8. Collection Management v.18 no.3/4 The Conspectus Approach to Collection Evaluaiton : Panacea or False Prophet Blake,V.L.P.;Tjoumas,R.
  9. Library Trends v.22 no.3 Evaluation of the Collection Bonn,G.S.
  10. Collection Management for the 1990s Branin,J.J.(ed.)
  11. Conspectus in the British Library British Library
  12. Conspectus Assessment : A Look at the RLG Conspectus The Conspectus: Possible Process and Useful Product for The Ordinary Library Bushing,M.
  13. Australian Academic and Research Libraries v.21 no.3 Conspectus Reconsiderd Clayton,P.
  14. Conspectus Assessment : A Look at the RLG Conspectus The RLG Conspectus: What in the Number Coffey,J.
  15. Conspectus Assessment : A Look at the RLG Conspectus The RLG Conspectus : A History of It's Development and Influence and a Prognosis Coleman,J.
  16. College and Research Libraries v.49 no.2 The RLG Conspectus : Its Use and Benefits Ferguson,A.W.;Grant,J.;Rustein,J.S.
  17. An Introductory Bibliography for the Study of Scripture(3rd ed.) Fitzmyer,J.A.
  18. College and Research Libraries v.44 no.2 Coordinating Collection Development : The RLG Conspectus Gwinn,N.E.;Mosher,P.H.
  19. Qualitative Collection Analysis : The Conspectus Methodology, SPEC Kit 151 Qualitative Collection Analysis : The Conspectus Methodology Jakubs,D.
  20. Collection Management v.6 no.1/2 The RLG French Literature Collection Assessment Project Larson,J.
  21. Collection Building v.13 no.2/3 The WLN Conspectus Loken,S.
  22. WLN Participant v.14 no.4 WLN Conspectus Users Group Meets in Chicago Loken,S.
  23. College and Research Libraries News v.46 no.3 Verifying the Conspectus : Problems and Progress Lucas,T.A.
  24. Collection Management for the 1990s Overview of Collection Assessment and Evaluation McEwan,B.
  25. Library Trends v.33 no.3 Evaluation by Type of Library Magrill,R.M.
  26. Acquisitions Management and Collection Development in Libraries(2nd ed.) Magrill,R.M.;Corbin,J.
  27. Journal of Librarianship v.19 no.3 The Planning and Implementation of the Conspectus in Scotland Matheson,A.
  28. Illinois Libraries v.71 no.1 The Greater Midwest Regional Medical Library Network and Coordinated Collection Development : The RLG Conspectus and Beyond Millson-Martula,C.A.
  29. College and Research Libraries News v.46 no.7 The Nature and Uses of RLG Verification Studies Mosher,P.H.
  30. Resource Sharing and Information Networks v.2 no.2/3 A National Scheme for Collaboration in Collection Development : The RNG-NCIP Effort Mosher,P.H.
  31. Resource Sharing and Information Networks v.2 no.2/3 A National Scheme for Collaboration in Collection Development : The RLG-NCIP Effort Mosher,P.H.
  32. IFLA Journal v.16 no.3 Collaborative Interdependence : The Human Dimension of the Conspectus Mosher,P.H.
  33. College and Research Libraries v.49 no.2 Evaluating the Conspectus Approach for Smaller Library Collections Oberg,L.R.
  34. WLN Collection Assessment Manual(4th ed.) Powell,N.;Bushing,M.(ed.)
  35. Manual for the North American Inventory of Research Library Collections Reed-Scott, J.
  36. The Concise Oxford Dictionary of Current English(9th ed.) Thompson, Della(ed.)
  37. Conspectus Assessment : A Look at the RLG Conspectus A Conspectus of Conspectus Wood,R.J.
  38. Guide for Written Collection Policy Statements American Library Association, Collection Management and Development Committee