Comparison of Performances between Brown and White Egg Layers

백색산란계와 갈색산란계의 생산성 비교

  • 이규호 (강원대학교 사료생산공학과)
  • Published : 1998.09.01

Abstract

On account of the recent improvement in performance of brown layers, the market share taken by brown layers has increased to about 50% in the world and to almost 100% in Korea. There are several other reasons why the industry has moved from white to brown, such as : brown layers are used to be more robust, more docile and easier to manage ; e brown layers are easier to sex at the hatchery ; brown layers lay less second grade eggs, due to a better shell Quality ; brown eggs seem to be more attractive than white ; and a clear consumer preference, thus a better price per egg. More recently, however, the trend towards brown eggs has been slowing down. The main reasons for this lie in that white layers can still produce an egg at a lower cost and that white eggs have better de-shelling properties, easier candling and higher yolk and solid content of the liquid egg which are benefits for egg processing industry. Although the performance of the brown layers is still improving, there are increasing opinions in the poultry industry that the market portion of white layers should be increased based on the following reasons, such as : shell color has no effect on the nutritive value of eggs ; . brown layers consume more feed ; the percentage of meat spots is significantly higher in brown eggs than in white eggs ; . brown layers are less efficient in the second cycle of production than in the first ; white layers are more resistant to the disease of fowl typhoid. In order to increase the market share of white layers in Korea, it may be needed to enlighten the consumers not to prefer the brown and large eggs and to inform the excellencies of white eggs widely.

Keywords

References

  1. North Carolina layer performance and management tests Anderson,E.A.
  2. North Carolina layer performance and management tests Carey,J.B.
  3. World Poultry Brown layers make faster progress than white Flock,D.
  4. Poultry husbandary Jull,M.A.
  5. Commercial chicken Production Mannual North,M.O.;Bell,D.D.
  6. Nutrient requirement of poultry(9th revised edition) NRC
  7. Poultry International Developments of brown egg market Peters,T.
  8. World's Poultry Sci. J. v.51 Comparison of white and brown egg shell laying stocks Shalev,B.A.
  9. Poultry science v.61 The effect of a Protoporphyrin mutant on some economic traits of the chicken Shoffner,R.N.;Shuman,R.;Otis,J.S.;Bitgood,J.J.;Garwood,V.;Lowe,P.
  10. World Poultry Misset v.11 no.6 Brown slowly but surely gained up on white still holds the lead Wieve van der Sluis
  11. 월간양계 v.98 no.3 계란유통의 흐름과 소비경향 대한양계협회
  12. 한국가금학회 한국의 양계. 6 채란양계 정일정