An analysis of th cause of passenger ship accident -from the perspestive of policy non-compliance

여객선사고의 원인분석 -정책불응의 관점을 중심으로

  • 배점모 (전북산업대학교 행정학과)
  • Published : 1997.01.01

Abstract

As passenger ship accidents so frequently have occurred, crisis consciousness is highly aroused in Korean society. Although bombastic policy guidlines were suggested in accordance with every passenger ship accident, there remains a still high possibility of such an accident reoccurring because passenger ship accidents occur from the perspective of non-compliance. The research objective of this study is to government's safety regulatory policies. Data for the analysis was collected from literature review. A Case study related to passenger ship accident is adopted for the analysis. The research methods utilized in this study consist of extensive quantitative analysis of 138 passenger ship accidents which had happened over last 10 years from 1984 to 1993 in Korea and a qualitative analysis of the passenger ship accident of the Seohae Ferry in October 1993. The results of the quantitive analysis on the 138 passenger ship accidents are as follows; Seeing the accidents yearly, the accidents which occurred by policy non-compliance are still exist, only somewhat reduced as years gone by. Seeing the accidents from the perspective of types of accident, fire accidents and death and injury accidents had more non-compliance factors than contact accidents and one-side collision accidents, etc. had. Seeing the accidents from the perspectives of types of passenger ship, large ships like car ferries and general passenger ship accidents had more non-compliance factors than any other kinds of ships had. Seeing the accidents from the perspectives of tons of passenger ships, large ships weighing more than 1, 000 tons and small ships weighing less than 50tons contained a lots of non-compliance factors. The results of the qualitative analysis of the passenger ship accident of the Seohae Ferry in Octovber 1993 are as follows; From the viewpoint of the human factor, there were non-compliance to the recruiting of required number of qualified crew members and non-compliance to the rule which prohibited them from leaving port in bad weather and high wave conditions. From the viewpoint of the ship factor, there were defects in the ship. So we might say that there was non-compliance which was aroused from the lacks of technical skills. From the viewpoint of the administrative factor, there were many non-compliance factors such as sailor education, shipping management, rescue, safety equipment. From the viewpoint of the passenger factor, there were passengers' threats which compelled the crews to leave the port under bad weather conditions. In conclusion, the principal non-compliances factors are passenger ship company did not follow safety rules such as shipping the permitted number of passengers, loading permitted tons of freight and fastening freights properly and recruiting required number of qualified crew. In order to reduce accidents, firstly we should find out the causes which play key roles in passenger ship companies' non-compliance to the government's safety regulations. Secondly we should tackle the causes.

Keywords

References

  1. 불확실성과 정책의 정당성 김영평
  2. 영남대학교 대학원 박사학위논문 정책집행과정에 있어서 정책순응에 관한 연구 나중식
  3. 정책분석론 노화준
  4. 국민과 정부관료제 이종범
  5. 정책학원론 정정길
  6. 한국행정학보 v.19 no.1 원인귀인의 형태와 상벌체계의 괴리현상에 관한 연구 조철옥
  7. 해양한국 no.4월 안전과 해난사고 최재수
  8. 선박검사 및 정비제도 개선방안 교통안전공단
  9. 해난과 방지(해난사례를 중심으로) 한국해운조합
  10. 재결서(1984년도 ~ 1993년도까지 각 년도 전부) 중앙해난심판원
  11. 재결서(1984년도 ~ 1993년도까지 각 년도 전부) 각 지방해난심판원
  12. 해난심판사례집(Ⅰ) 중앙해난심판원
  13. 위도 앞바다 서해훼리호-우리는 그 참사 이렇게 극복했다 전라북도
  14. Public Policy-Making, (3rd ed.) Anderson, J. E.
  15. Public Policy-Making, (2nd ed.) Anderson, J. E.
  16. The Functions Of Executives Barnard, Chester Ⅰ.
  17. On Organizational learning Argyris;Chris
  18. Research in Crganizational Behavior v.1 Organizational Learning : Implications For Organizational Design Duncan , R.;Weiss A.;Staw, B. M.(eds.)
  19. American scientist v.64 How do People Perceive the Cause of Behavior? Jones, E. E.
  20. Annual Review of Psychology Attribution Theory and Research Kelley, H. H.;Michela, J. L.
  21. Policy Implementation in Federal and Unitary Systems Strategic Interaction, Learning and Policy Evolution: A Synthetic Model Sabatier, P. A.;Hanf, D. K.;K.Hanf(ed);Theo A.J.Toonen(ed)
  22. Effective Policy Implementation The Implementation of Public Policy : A Framework of Analysis Sabatier, P. A.;Mazmanian, D. A.;P.A.Sabatier(ed.);D.A. Mazmanian(ed.)
  23. Policy Studies Journal v.8 no.4 The Implementation of Public Policy : A Framework of Analysis Sabatier, P.A.;Mazmanian, D. A.
  24. The Science of the Artificial Simon, Herbert A.
  25. Compliance and Public Authority: A Theory with International Applications Young, O. R.