Journal of the Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture (한국조경학회지)

The Korean Institute of Landscape Architecture (한국조경학회)
권호 표지

Development of Methods to lmprove the Reliability of ELECTRE

복합기준 평가방법 ELECTRE의 신뢰도 증진을 위한 방안 연구

  • 이인성 (상명여자대학교 환경녹지학과)
  • Published : 1995.04.01
Download PDF
⟨ Previous Next ⟩

Abstract

ELEECTRE is a less demanding and potentially Bffective multiattribute evaluation method for pre-editing proeedure. The method, however, was developed based on probabilistic mathematicsand its reliability has never'been emprieally tested. This article examined the reliability of ELECTRo under various conditions of linear and non-linear utility func- tions using a Monte-Carlo shnulation, and found the method eausea a considerably high rate of error. To enhance the reliability of ELECTRE, two ways of modi(ication - adjust- ment of threshold values of concordance and discordance matrices, and adjustment of the required nunlber of probably-dominant alternatives to eliminate a probably-dominated alternative - were suggested, and their effctiveness was also tesed by a Monte-Carlo simulation. The simulation result chows that these modifications cponsiderably improve the reliability of ELECTRE, and yet maintain a reasonably high level of efficiency. Through these modifications, ELECTRE can be used as an efficient and feliable pre-editing method. Ways to implement ELECTRE in the construction of plainning decision support systens were discussed. The impli(els combination of this method and other multiattribute evaluation methods will help to create more effective decision suport systems.

Keywords

References

  1. 경희대학교 박사학위논문 중소도시의 녹지환경 특성분석에 관한 연구 이행렬
  2. European Journal of Operational Research v.26 A Comparison of the Analytic Hierarchy Process and a Simple Multi-attribute Value Function Belton, Valerie
  3. Principles of Geographical Information Systems for Land Resources Assessment Burrough,P.A.
  4. Managemant Science v.38 Multiple Criteria Decision Marking, Multiattribute Utility Theory: The Next Ten Years Dyar James S.;P.C.Fishburn;R.E.Steuer;J.Wallenius;S.Zionts
  5. GIS 개론 및 실습 IDRISI User's Guide Eastman,J.R.;연상효(편역);이상석(편역)
  6. Management Science v.28 Sources of Bias in Assessment Procedures for Utility Functions Hershey, John C.;Howard C. Kunreuther;Paul J. H. Schoemaker
  7. Water Resources Research v.28 Does Choice of Multicriteria Method Matter An Experiment in Water Resources Planning Hobbs, Banjamin F.;V.Changkong;W.Hamadeh
  8. Judgment and Choice Hogarth, Robin
  9. Report for U.S Army Construction Engineering Research Laboratory Development of Algorithms for Classification Spatial Allocation and Tradeoff Analysis for Training Landuse Management Hopkins,L.D.;Douglas Johnston;Insung Lee
  10. Multiple Attribute Decision Making Hwang Ching-Lai;Kwang-Sun Yoon
  11. Management Science v.31 Effort and Accuracy in Choice Johnson,E.J.Eric; J.W.Payne
  12. Decision Science v.13 The Relationship between the Analytic Hierarchy Process and the Additive Value Function Kamenetzky,R.D.
  13. Decision With Multiple Objective: Preferences and Value Tradeoffs Kaaney, Ralph L.;Howard Raiffa
  14. Environment and Planning B: Planning and Design v.16 The Meaning of Tradeoffs in Mutiattribute Evaluation Methods: A Comparison Lai,S.K.;L.D.Hopkins
  15. Ph.D Dissertation. Dept. of Urban and Regional Planning University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign Development of Procedural Expertise to Support Multiattribute Spatial Decision Making Lee, Insung
  16. Progress in Planning v.30 Multicritria Decision Making (MCDM) Techniques in Planning Massam, Bryan H.
  17. Analysis and Aiding Decision Processes Decision Rules and the Search for a Dominance Structure: Towards a Process Model of Decision Making Montgomery, Henry;P.C.Humphrey(ed.);O.Svenson(ed.);A.Vari(ed.)
  18. Journal of Experimental Psychology v.14 Adaptive Strategy Selection in Decision Making Payne,J.W.;J.R.Bettman;E.J.Johnson
  19. Readings in Multiple Criterial Aid The Outranking Approach and the Foundation of ELECTRE Methods Roy,B.;A.Carlos(ed.);B.Costa(ed.)
  20. The Analytic Hierarchy Process Saaty,T.L.
  21. Methodology Appraisal in Economics From Substantive to Procedural Rationality Simon, Herbert A.;Sapiro, J. Latsis(ed.)
  22. A Primer for Policy Andlysis Stokey, Edith;Richard Zeckhauser
  23. Organizational Behavior and Human Performance v.23 Process Descriptions of Decision Making Svenson,O.
  24. Behaviora Science v.25 Efficient Decision Heuristics Thorngate,W.
  25. Proceedings of the 21st Annual Hawaii International Conference on System Sciences Vol.Ⅲ. Decision Support and Knowledge Based Systems Track An Investigation of Performance, Productivity, and Rationality in Multi-criteria Decision Making Volnonino, Linda;Peter Kirs
  26. Theory of Games and Economics Behavior von Neumann, John;Oscar Morgenstern
  27. IEEE Transactions on Systems, Man and Cybernetics v.20 Descriptive and Prescriptive Models of Decision Making Weber, Elke U.;Osman Coskunoglu